News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:46AM (#24047020)
> The cheapest grid "battery" is minute-by-minute pricing of electricity.

This works to the extent that it works. But one of the big applications for a sufficiently cheap grid battery would be to store generation from solar to be used at night.

A large fraction of the nighttime load is for heat and light, because night is when it's cold and dark. It can't really be shifted into the daytime.

And another obvious use for a grid battery is to take advantage of that same demand pricing by buying power when it's cheap and selling when it's not.

Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @02:02AM (#24047105)
> It can't really be shifted into the daytime.

The heat can be. Heat can be stored in the thermal mass of the house itself, and thermal mass can be added in the form of rocks.

With the advent of LED lights, the lighting bill isn't that much anymore.

Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by nicolaslem on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @11:47AM (#24051110)
This concept was widely deployed in certain regions with "storage heaters": very heavy (~40 Kg) electric heaters that would accumulate heat during the night when electricity is cheap and release it throughout the day.

They felt out of fashion because apparently they were hard to use as you cannot control how the heat is released. Charge them too much and you will have to open windows the next day wasting energy, charge them too little and you will have to turn them on during the day when the electricity is expensive.

Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by Gibbon1 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:48AM (#24048625)
> And another obvious use for a grid battery is to take advantage of that same demand pricing by buying power when it's cheap and selling when it's not.

Far as I get the actual price of electricity varies a lot, so there potentially a lot of arbitrage to exploit. There's a dozen ways to store energy with varying amount of round trip efficiency, capital costs, and operating costs. Some set of technologies will win out in that space.

I suspect one reason these technologies aren't well developed is because historically the cheapest is baseload power produced by coal and nuke plants. Economically the price is actually subsidized. So utilities did not want knuckleheads buying their cheap power at night and selling it during the day.

Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by grandinj on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @04:31AM (#24047865)
You heat up a big block of concrete during the day. Insulated of course. Then at night you run water through it, and pipe that (now hot) water to radiator around your house. Already being deployed in Germany.
Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by dmurray on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:02AM (#24048383)
What's the advantage of using the block of concrete instead of directly heating water? Water has a 4x higher specific heat capacity by mass, or 2x higher by volume.
Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by grandinj on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:06AM (#24048409)
I could be entirely wrong as to the substance(s) involved :-)

I'm quoting from a memory of an article I read about 6 months ago, sorry.

googling for "specific heat high energy storage material" seems to indicate that rock-type materials are used where air heat is required.

Re:Court ruling clears way for energy storage on the grid by dmurray on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:17AM (#24048455)
They definitely are used in some circumstances. For example, a sauna uses heated rocks. This allows you to control the humidity separately and not have the water evaporate. I guess it would work just as well with sealed metal tanks of water, but rocks are cheaper and more traditionally available. And they can't leak.

So I'm not doubting you, just wondering why an intermediary heat storage medium is preferred in practice. Maybe for some of the same reasons as the sauna.