News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by yunruse on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:35AM (#24027966)
This feels like sensationalism. You could make the exact same argument for music, books, films or TV - it is an artistic medium. A game can be a complete waste of time, and equally it can be an enriching and educational experience. Blindly sticking them all into one category is naive.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by hombre_fatal on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:51AM (#24028064)
Sure, more can be said about it than "games = bad".

But at the same time, the difference between the things you list is the level of fulfillment. Or, in other words, how you feel about your time spent doing that thing 5 or 10 years later.

Even though I have good memories in some games, I don't look back on my time in World of Warcraft and think "yeah, that's definitely how I'd spend that time if I had a do-over." Meanwhile, my time spent learning language, meeting up with friends, and writing short stories are expenditures of time that I'm proud of.

Games usually suffer from two things:

1) Games tend to be cheap entertainment on the Netflix and Twitter and heroin side of the fulfillment continuum.

2) It's too easy to sink a lot of time in games, and they tend to dominate your mind when you're in them. You mention music, but people aren't just sitting at their desk from 6pm to 4am listening to music. Most hobbies don't grip you like that. It makes it easy to neglect other things in ways that, say, an addiction to hiking does not.

As a former big gamer myself, I think most people are stuck in the trap of games and only a small fraction of people are doing something particularly fulfilling with them. But my point wouldn't be that games = bad, but rather: beware.

For example, on the other hand, there was a time when I was only gaming to play online with my best friend who had moved across the country. That was some fulfilling gaming. But I wouldn't be surprised if most people were like me and found it very hard to strike a healthy balance.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by timkam on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:50AM (#24028058)
Most people who like books, films and TV, consume these media types passively, i.e., they are less immersive and hence perhaps less dangerous. With _creating_ music, I'd argue the situation is similar to martial arts: it requires discipline, and actually social skills if you want to be relevant. The same is true for many "e-sports". However, I agree with Rogan more or less, because there are just too many games that are too dull and too many young males who waste their time with them. Based on my personal experience, I would say most of my time spent gaming as a teenager was wasted, but playing music actually taught me important lessons for life. For me the social aspects, as well as the "mastery" aspects of gaming were just too simple, too simulated.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by formerly_proven on Sunday August 02, 2020 @11:31AM (#24029292)
> The same is true for many "e-sports".

Just like in "real" sports, many personalities in "e-sports" make a point of being douchebags. Some make a point of being a nice person.

> For me the social aspects, as well as the "mastery" aspects of gaming were just too simple, too simulated.

I agree, in multiplayer games "mastery" relates to improving mechanical skill, i.e. getting better at mashing specific button sequences as fast as possible or getting better at flickshots. These take a lot of time to get marginal improvements (e.g. improving your aim just a little bit beyond your personal baseline can take thousands of hours). In singleplayer and RPG games, "mastery" happens on the character and doesn't require anything from the player beyond either repeating some action a large number of times (e.g. picking locks to improve lockpicking skill) or simply allocating "skill points" awarded by advancing the game.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by panopticon on Sunday August 02, 2020 @01:31PM (#24030050)
> I agree, in multiplayer games "mastery" relates to improving mechanical skill, i.e. getting better at mashing specific button sequences as fast as possible or getting better at flickshots.

This is an incredibly shallow analysis. Most competitive multiplayer games have important strategic elements too. Positioning, knowing when to engage, effective team communication, countering opponent strategies, etc.

Don't mistake this for defending video games, but you can't expect a productive discussion when the strawmen stood up are so absurd.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by formerly_proven on Sunday August 02, 2020 @02:25PM (#24030425)
Well, yes, obviously, but I'd counter-argue that the training regimes used for these games tend to focus on the mechanical side, while tactics and strategy are improved through playing matches. And even that part is called "The Grind" for a reason.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by panopticon on Sunday August 02, 2020 @03:26PM (#24030947)
What do you think NBA players are doing? Lots of individual training with a few 5-on-5 matches sprinkled in. Muscle memory is extremely important for being effective at all kinds of sports and activities, so most training regimes incorporate rote drills to build and maintain a solid foundation.

Unless you're making a critique against games at large (physical and video), I'm not sure what you're getting at.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by formerly_proven on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:39PM (#24039950)
> What do you think NBA players are doing?

It's their job, which they get handsomely compensated for. Wasting away thousands of hours grinding Dota or CS:GO is the job of very few people, while the grand majority of gaming addicts are simply wasting a significant chunk of their life.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by irvtivitbibgbog on Sunday August 02, 2020 @10:56AM (#24029078)
What sort of "lessons for life" did playing music teach you?
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by timkam on Sunday August 02, 2020 @12:01PM (#24029461)
These insights may be trivial, but still important to experience first hand and early in life (let me highlight that I was never an excellent or successful musician, though):

* Having solid basic skills in a profession is crucial; in contrast, almost nobody really needs a virtuoso. Practically, nobody needs a rock star or diva.

* Always be reliable, even if others are not (don't pay back unreliability by being not reliable yourself). Be the one who is on time and does his homework. (In contrast, in school I learned that what technicality qualifies as homework often does not pay off.)

* Continuity is key to get a decent chance to succeed (again, in contrast school taught me that you can make things up as you go along, as long as you are somewhat talented).

To relate to the topic: the problem with many video games is that reliability and continuity come effortless. You simply need to go online and play. In contrast, as an amateur musician, I had to make sure I have the right gear, plan the transport without owning a car, make sure I can get into a rehearsal room regularly, find the right people to play with (the ones who have the connections that are needed to actually get a gig) et cetera.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by apatters on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:47AM (#24028038)
If digitally induced dopamine spikes are a concern, why isn't porn at the forefront of the discussion? Erectile dysfunction has roughly doubled in young men over the past decade and some research attributes it to online porn. https://www.yourbrainonporn.com/
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by NeverFade on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:24AM (#24028233)
The article focuses on "fake fitness": the false sense held by gamers that their gaming activities promote fitness and success in the real world.

The article aims to show that this sense is indeed false.

Porn consumers don't generally share a sense that porn consumption improves their real-world fitness and success. You could make a separate argument against porn consumption, but the "fake fitness" argument the article makes doesn't apply to porn addiction.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by dgellow on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:22AM (#24028223)
Are you sure it isn't actually at the forefront of the discussion? Because I remember reading quite a lot of stuff during the past 2-3 years on the effects of porn on young adults.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by waihtis on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:56AM (#24028086)
Difficult conversation topic for many, I suppose
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by daenz on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:46AM (#24028030)
The difference between games and everything else you listed is that games are interactive. This has a huge impact on how powerful the psychological rewards are. The point is that games offer simulated experiences that give a false sense of accomplishment.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by D13Fd on Sunday August 02, 2020 @11:02AM (#24029119)
On the other hand, maybe the interactivity of games means that you are using more of your brain than you would be in passive consumption.

I tend to think that, say, a month spent in competitive gaming at night is better For your mind than a month spent binge watching Seinfeld at night for the second time.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by waihtis on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:42AM (#24027999)
Agree partially - however, comparing games to books is really apples to oranges. Games are a high degree more addictive, and the major problem are not the artistic story-driven games but the engineered-to-addict AAA’s.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by jedimastert on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:45AM (#24028022)
As a counter-argument, have you seen come people's romance novel collection? They can be absolutely addicting as well; fulfilling an instinctual need.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by waihtis on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:46AM (#24028034)
Unfortunately I have not. But makes sense, I suppose both serve as a strong mechanism of escape to their respective core audiences.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by quantified on Sunday August 02, 2020 @11:19AM (#24029232)
Not an addiction widespread enough to care about. Unless it’s all free/stolen, limited by their economic capacity as well.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by watwut on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:10AM (#24028167)
I can honestly say I never met anyone like that. Romance readers I know are less focused on it then Sci-find readers I know.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by NeverFade on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:52AM (#24028068)
> A game can be a complete waste of time, and equally it can be an enriching and educational experience.

There are a few exceptional games that encourage creativity and arguably provide some education. However, the majority of gamers have been playing roughly the same FPS that provides the same basic violent catharsis since Doom came out 27 years ago.

For this vast majority of gamers, games are just mindless fun which neither aims for, nor achieves, any sort of meaningful self-improvement.

> You could make the exact same argument for music, books, films or TV - it is an artistic medium.

Most popular entertainment, just like the aforementioned FPS, is just mindless diversion catering (or if you will, exploiting) our baser instincts and propensity for addiction. That applies to all forms of popular entertainment: games, TV, films, and even books.

The point of the article is that games - unlike films or TV for example - promote a sense "fake fitness". Nobody believes that they acquire some valuable fitness by binge-watching Friends on Netflix. However, gamers do tend to hold a false belief that they are gaining some valuable skills out of the huge amounts of time they spend playing popular video games.

RPGs for example directly exploit this delusion: your character gains many valuable skills, and by falsely identifying with them, you feel a sense of accomplishment even though all you did was mindlessly grind some braindead "quests" and your odds of surviving in a real combat situation are just as bad as before - worse, probably, because your fitness has deteriorated from so many more hours of sitting on your couch mashing buttons.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by partyboat1586 on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:18AM (#24028208)
The sad part about it is many of the people who naturally achieve stuff in videogames could also be successful in life with a little therapy to overcome their avoidant personalities.

I know people who were heavy into WOW and decided to make life the real grind. They have done very well for themselves.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by NeverFade on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:34AM (#24028299)
Yes, the basic traits that lead to video game addiction are actually beneficial in most real-world scenarios:

Identifying challenges, focusing on them, engaging in behavior that overcomes them, persisting in that behaviors until signs of success manifest, and then feeling rewarded by these signs of success.

These are all traits that really do tend to lead to skill-building, self-improvement, and success when applied in REAL contexts.

The problem with video games is that they create an ARTIFICIAL context to exploit these traits. It's not you who improved your fighting skills by mindlessly mashing that button 20,000 times - it's your avatar, a fictitious being. But games are set up so that you will feel the sense of accomplishment.

Games is conditioning our generation to gain the rewarding sensations of fitness, self-improvement, and survival success from trivial activities that are merely dressed up to appear challenging and "masculine".

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by mrob on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:01AM (#24028121)
Doom is one of those exceptional games that encourages creativity. Doom was the game that popularized modding, and people are still making new maps for it today.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by NeverFade on Sunday August 02, 2020 @08:09AM (#24028158)
Let's not kid ourselves: the vast majority of people who play highly popular FPS games are not modders. They just play the game.

This is especially true for the current generation of gamers who are often playing on consoles lacking any modding capabilities.

Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games? by Barrin92 on Sunday August 02, 2020 @07:42AM (#24028005)
for certain kinds of TV the analogy might hold, for film or reading it's harder to see.

As the article points out games fit very well into what it calls 'limbic capitalism', using reward mechanisms of the brain to keep people engaged in repetitive tasks. If you go through the list of the most popular games, very few are artistic in nature.

This isn't really true for reading. Okay, sure you can write erotica or fan-fiction, but culturally everyone knows that this is garbage essentialy. Going and picking up a (challenging) novel is relatively hard work, which is why reading that kind of fiction is on continuous decline.