Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games?
by panopticon on Sunday August 02, 2020 @01:31PM
(#24030050)
> I agree, in multiplayer games "mastery" relates to improving mechanical skill, i.e. getting better at mashing specific button sequences as fast as possible or getting better at flickshots.
This is an incredibly shallow analysis. Most competitive multiplayer games have important strategic elements too. Positioning, knowing when to engage, effective team communication, countering opponent strategies, etc.
Don't mistake this for defending video games, but you can't expect a productive discussion when the strawmen stood up are so absurd.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games?
by formerly_proven on Sunday August 02, 2020 @02:25PM
(#24030425)
Well, yes, obviously, but I'd counter-argue that the training regimes used for these games tend to focus on the mechanical side, while tactics and strategy are improved through playing matches. And even that part is called "The Grind" for a reason.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games?
by panopticon on Sunday August 02, 2020 @03:26PM
(#24030947)
What do you think NBA players are doing? Lots of individual training with a few 5-on-5 matches sprinkled in. Muscle memory is extremely important for being effective at all kinds of sports and activities, so most training regimes incorporate rote drills to build and maintain a solid foundation.
Unless you're making a critique against games at large (physical and video), I'm not sure what you're getting at.
Re:Is Joe Rogan right about young men and video games?
by formerly_proven on Monday August 03, 2020 @12:39PM
(#24039950)
> What do you think NBA players are doing?
It's their job, which they get handsomely compensated for. Wasting away thousands of hours grinding Dota or CS:GO is the job of very few people, while the grand majority of gaming addicts are simply wasting a significant chunk of their life.
Just like in "real" sports, many personalities in "e-sports" make a point of being douchebags. Some make a point of being a nice person.
> For me the social aspects, as well as the "mastery" aspects of gaming were just too simple, too simulated.
I agree, in multiplayer games "mastery" relates to improving mechanical skill, i.e. getting better at mashing specific button sequences as fast as possible or getting better at flickshots. These take a lot of time to get marginal improvements (e.g. improving your aim just a little bit beyond your personal baseline can take thousands of hours). In singleplayer and RPG games, "mastery" happens on the character and doesn't require anything from the player beyond either repeating some action a large number of times (e.g. picking locks to improve lockpicking skill) or simply allocating "skill points" awarded by advancing the game.