News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by arcticbull on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @12:01AM (#23972160)
Deindustrialization is great, most industrial jobs are the worst. To the extent other countries want to take them on, it puts America at a huge advantage. Once robotization and full automation happen, there will be no reason to build in one place over another, and all the assembly work will return (as not having to expend energy moving final products from their assembly location to their final destinations will represent an advantage).

The jobs never will though, nor do we actually want them to. This is why we need UBI.

Seriously, why would we want, in the future, to pay people to smack metal with a hammer? Let's get the jobs elsewhere ASAP, unless you can tell me with a straight face the future will involve more humans in the manufacture of goods -- in which case we should be getting a head start. Nobody will say that though because it's crazy.

Trying to add humans back to the manufacturing process, who don't need to be there, amounts to a regressive make-work project we're engaging in, intentionally adding inefficiency, instead of actually changing society and positioning ourselves for the inescapable future of humanity. In my opinion, America is squandering a huge lead by glamorizing crap jobs nobody actually needs to do, let alone wants. Like coal mining.

What's next, a return to whale oil?

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by CMay on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @02:18AM (#23972831)
You are making a very large assumption about what types of work people are willing to do and dangerously that losing these opportunities is predetermined as an advantage for the US. Making strong statements like that and then ridiculing any opposition in advance of a reply is antithetical to reasonable debate.

Automation takes time to develop and can leave you inflexible depending on the task even with the wide variety of programmable robotics. Some products may not have profit margins, expected sales or complexity high enough where automation is worth investing in. You don't want to be in a situation where you need 300,000 of something in 3 weeks and the only way to get them is from a country that isn't an ally or refuses to trade with you.

Humans can easily do some things immediately and machines can easily do other things immediately. The more universally applicable a machine is, the more expensive it may be and possibly even priced against the highest value tasks it can do.

Universal Basic Income has many problems that aren't solved and there are many potential negative side effects, so it's premature to promote it confidently.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by runeks on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @05:19AM (#23973887)
> Automation takes time to develop […]

And capital! The human beings who spend their time developing new technology need to be fed, which requires consuming someone’s savings.

Whether automation makes sense always depends on its benefit versus the cost of development. E.g. if we spend money on feeding 100 engineers for 10 years while they develop a technology that increases the efficiency of producing something by X% is it worth it?

We always need to make this calculation because the amount of savings is finite, so we have an interest in spending it in a way that creates the most gain.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by adwn on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @03:39AM (#23973315)
> The more universally applicable a machine is, the more expensive it may be and possibly even priced against the highest value tasks it can do.

It's even worse: The more universally applicable a machine is, the more expensive its outputs are, because it is less efficient. Have you seen an aluminum can lid stamping machine? [1] It can only produce one thing, but that thing is incredibly cheap on account of the machine producing tens of thousands of items per hour.

[1] That's probably not its official name...

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by m-ee on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @01:00AM (#23972423)
You're ignoring the rest of the supply chain and localization of talent. If I run out of a chip in the states it might be a week or two of the line being down, in Shenzen I can have more that day. Similarly if I need to have a test fixture made or modified on short notice where do you think the talent is? Even if a US shop could do it better, which is a big if, can they do it faster? Cheaper? And why wouldn't I want engineers located near my assembly line close to the previously mentioned chips for the install? There's quite a few steps between design and final assembly, and for a lot of products assembly is much more than smacking something with a hammer.

EDIT- I'd add that this isn't just about China or moving manufacturing to the cheapest location. Let's say I need a specialty injection molded part with tough requirements for med device. The best shop might be in the US, or maybe Germany, or maybe Mexicali. Automation isn't going to change that.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by zackees on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @04:35AM (#23973653)
3D print it.

Yes automation solves it.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by varjag on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @06:10AM (#23974146)
Very few useful tools or machines are 3d-printable, due to tolerance and strength constraints.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by m-ee on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @01:18PM (#23978200)
Not trying to be rude here, but have you designed a plastic part for production? This isn't remotely practical for many if not most applications that I have seen. Cost, tolerance, surface finish, yield are all major issues. It's also far less automatable than injection molding. Post processing an SLA part for example is very manual, injection molded parts come out of the tool ready for use. What do you think is going to change about that?
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @07:00AM (#23974407)
It is not a universal solution, both because it's slow, and because of various limitations and faults it introduces. There are dozens of manufacturing processes, some of them fairly new and modern, that will never go away.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by lenkite on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @02:56AM (#23973056)
Why do you say that people don't want to work on Industrial jobs and they are the "worst"? I see this point of view regularly regurgitated on HN and I am genuinely puzzled.

That might be true for HN (folks who prefer working at a desk) but that is NOT true for a vast majority of people.

I have both friends and family who love to work on the factory floor/shop - it is more varied and interesting for them. More interaction, more visible output of labour and they don't need to join a Gym as they get enough physical movement in their daily job. They despise the idea of sitting at a desk the whole day.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by 0-O-0 on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @11:44AM (#23976953)
A lack of visible output bothered me so much that I had to compensate with hobbies.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by theflyinghorse on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @11:50AM (#23977009)
> That might be true for HN (folks who prefer working at a desk)

I think it's more so people who never worked a physical job and imagine those to be just the worst.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by titzer on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @02:01AM (#23972748)
Except those robotic factories are going to spring up right next to, and in place of, the existing factories and will plug right into the distribution infrastructure that already exists. The path of least resistance is not to bootstrap a completely new manufacturing and distribution system in a completely different place (the US). No matter how tempting it seems from your efficiency point of view, things sprout from existing buds. America chopped off all its buds and is left languishing at the mercy of its suppliers. That was a huge strategic mistake.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by jeffreygoesto on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @02:01AM (#23972746)
Is that an attitude of an over-privileged, pampered SV person? Because it certainly has nothing to do with reality. Maybe you should go traveling for some time and meet people who live in the real world, not a bubble.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by arcticbull on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @02:03AM (#23972757)
Not at all, I think those people should be paid, but I think their jobs should be automated. Whether it's true today, or in the near future, we can all agree: those jobs are better done by robots. Those people deserve to live happy lives, and so we should pay them out accordingly, but we don't need to introduce the inefficiency to do so.

Even Walmart is looking at replacing all their cashiers with robots. [1] Do you think assembly workers are immune for some reason? We need to skate to where the puck is going to be, not where its was 30 years ago.

I find the idea of my comment coming from a "pampered, privileged tech worker" perspective interesting, as I'm offering a part of my pay so that the folks doing the mundane, back-breaking work inefficiently, today, could be paid to stay home and look after their families or pursue self-actualization.

[1] https://bgr.com/2020/06/17/walmart-self-checkout-no-cashiers...

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by luxory on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @10:31AM (#23976178)
>Whether it's true today, or in the near future, we can all agree: those jobs are better done by robots.

It's already been done, except replace the "robot" meme with "industrial engineering" reality. instead of iRobot it's the machine that welds cars or makes pringles. It was done 30+ years ago. This world is distinct from the robot replacement headline clickbait we've been reading our whole lives.

>Even Walmart is looking at replacing all their cashiers with robots.

The technology for this has existed for 20+ years but it's always being "explored", that should tell you something. That's a distraction though. We're talking about chip fab, then you started talking about assembly line workers (which has zero meaning - can you think of a single assembly function that hasn't been automated 20 years ago?). Factory work today is skilled work, industrial engineering hasn't stood still.

>I'm offering a part of my pay so that the folks doing the mundane, back-breaking work inefficiently, today, could be paid to stay home and look after their families or pursue self-actualization.

you're getting ripped off. Modern factory jobs are pretty good. Self Actualization is a meme.

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by dpc_pw on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @04:37AM (#23973664)
Your comment got downvoted because there's a lot truth in it. :D

Manual jobs will be getting automated, and countries relying on manufacturing will be hit by that process the hardest.

Like in Factorio - first you're resources bound, than you are labor bound, and finally you're design-bound.

Modern economy is design-bound. USA being de-industrialized developed economy offers good quality of life and opportunity for intellectual workers, and attracts a lot of talent. Most HN readers is Americans, so they love to complain about USA, but "grass is always greener on the other side". As much as there are messed up things in USA, there's also plenty of things that are working really well.

The main problem is the gap between people who benefit from the post-industrial economy, and those who do not. I also don't see a better way out of it than just some well-designed form of UBI. And considering all the COVID stimulus, the USG is already paving the way...

Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by awakeasleep on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @12:24AM (#23972252)
Yeah it'll be great once the countries that manufacture things starts producing multifunction robots that build their own supply chain and automatically revert to US control.
Re:Intel ousts its chief engineer, shakes up technical group... by arcticbull on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @12:29AM (#23972271)
You don't need to do the assembly to design and take delivery of multifunction robots. Just ask ABB [1]. The IP, the design, and the schematics are the valuable part, the assembly is totally and utterly commodity. A 3D printer, a diffuser, etc, is equally effective in any country it happens to be located, and UPS is happy to meet you there for pickup.

We've started to see this return already, with Foxconn and TSMC setting up factories in the US (with no people in them of course -- because why would they put people in them?).

[1] https://new.abb.com/products/robotics