News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by __alexs on Friday July 24, 2020 @10:45AM (#23940115)
I honestly don't understand this perspective which seems central to a lot of pgs writing lately: "the customs protecting free inquiry have been weakened"

Can anyone explain it?

We are, right now, posting on the most expansive and weakly moderated communications platform humanity has ever had. You can find almost anyone opinion imaginable out there with a brief Google search and forums on which to argue every side of it with.

In what way is free inquiry meaningfully weakened? By any absolute measure it seems like it can only be the strongest it has ever been.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by neonate on Friday July 24, 2020 @03:01PM (#23943255)
It's because the pendulum has taken a noticeable swing in the reverse direction, with online mobs getting people fired because of opinions they've expressed. Extreme labels like "white supremacist" and "Nazi" are being put on people for views that deviate from approved ideology. This is creating a climate of fear in which each case of someone getting fired is enough to cow thousands if not millions of observers, who fear to lose their own jobs if they speak out or even slip up. Bogus arguments like "it doesn't count unless the government does it" are being used to dismiss free speech concerns about this. To me it seems obvious that from a free speech point of view it's fine for people to respond to each other with criticism, even if they're mean and mischaracterize each other, but getting people fired crosses an obvious line into non-speech and physical harm. It's not as harmful as physical violence or putting someone in prison for what they say, but it's on the same spectrum, and the psychology of the zealots who want to see people punished in this way is unmistakeable. That's where the comparisons to the Soviet Union, China, and so on, come in. Anyone who is familiar with the history knows the type, even if so far they are unable to do more than exert power over employment.

There's also deplatforming, which falls in between pure speech (such as criticism/debate) and physical harm (such as firing).

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by pvg on Friday July 24, 2020 @04:43PM (#23944213)
'Firing' is not a physical harm unless you mean it literally.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by neonate on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:13PM (#23944521)
It directly impacts livelihood. It's physical in the sense that it's a real world, tangible harm. This is not at all the same thing as somebody merely saying something critical on Twitter. There's a clear distinction here.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by pvg on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:39PM (#23944758)
There is a distinction but it's not the one you were originally making. Which seems important in a discussion about kinds of harms. Firing someone is not assault.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by neonate on Saturday July 25, 2020 @01:38PM (#23950983)
It's exactly the distinction I was making. That's why I said "it's not as harmful as physical violence" etc. I guess that wasn't enough to be clear.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by __alexs on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:35PM (#23944730)
These hypothetical people are getting fired because their words cause real harm to people. They encourage others to act in ways that result in (not at all hypothetical) physical, emotional and economic harm, usually to underrepresented groups who are least able to weather it.

You'd get fired if you punched a coworker, getting fired for speech that encourages others to do the punching seems like fair game. If you're in a position of influence you must measure your words carefully if you care at all about not harming people.

If you want to explore radical, potentially harmful ideas, find a safe space of like minded people to do it in rather than forcing it on random people on the internet unconsensually.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by igorstellar on Friday July 24, 2020 @06:32PM (#23945167)
> These hypothetical people are getting fired because their words cause real harm to people.

These people are not hypothetical and the statement is dehumanization. If you punch a coworker they will have a damage that could be measured and reported. On the other side you won't be able to measure how offended someone is (unless it goes against the law). Cancelling people for having their own ideas even if they are different from what is conventional transforms into a witch hunt for a "greater good".

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by oramit on Friday July 24, 2020 @12:50PM (#23941693)
Yes, this narrative about not being free to talk about "dangerous" ideas is always left intentionally vague.

We have so much free inquiry going on right now that I can't even keep track of it. If free inquiry is being eroded, one of the central claims in this essay, then that means we are coming down from a greater high. When was that high and would you prefer to go back to that time?

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by marvin on Friday July 24, 2020 @02:58PM (#23943232)
I'll hazard a guess: PG went out on a limb a few years ago, and actually published a long essay on one of the ideas that are very controversial in the sense implied in this essay. Namely, how tech tools as a primary driver for increasing wealth inequality will likely grow in importance, leading to increased wealth inequality, and that this is in itself not a problem.

This was after years of pointing out that it's not necessarily a good idea to specifically discuss controversial topics, if you want to spend your time thinking and learning instead of arguing (and, implied, deleting hate mail and death threats, etc).

This essay was met with an incredible amount of backlash that missed its point entirely, and if I was in PG's shoes, I'd probably have soured on taking that sort of discussion outside my closest circle. A big but very understandable loss.

I believe that discussing the phenomenon, rather than specific instances of it, still has great value. This points out tools that can be used to discover and handle the censorship of valuable heresy.

I'd love it even more if I had intimate access to a group of very intelligent and open-minded folks to actually discuss the heresies of today, as this is both super fascinating and a great mental stretching exercise. Sadly, doesn't look like public forums on the Internet are the most fertile arena for that kind of thing. It happens rarely, when I happen to stumble across a community that hits something like this by chance, or where one of my real-life acquaintances happens to stray outside the box in exactly the right way.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by oramit on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:14PM (#23944537)
I appreciate the response. I'm not certain which essay you are referring to so I can't comment on it or the backlash it received specifically.

In this "Quadrants" essay PG clearly aligns himself with the entrepreneurial free-thinkers, who bravely face down the mob. The problem with this though is he doesn't seem to be able to handle the criticism part. He acknowledges it is going to happen but when he gets dunked on for an essay, he takes his ball, goes home, and then complains that he can't have a real discussion.

But that's the entire point. He wrote something, people disagreed, that's the discussion. Did he take people's disagreements seriously? Did he change his mind? Was he unconvinced and pointed out why the people who disagreed were wrong? He seems to want to take on the mantle of beleaguered free-thinker while only willing to receive praise.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by pjscott on Friday July 24, 2020 @06:38PM (#23945205)
Sounds like this essay, "Economic Inequality":

http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html

And here's the HN thread from when it was first written:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10826838

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by __alexs on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:44PM (#23944804)
I've read many of his essays on inequality and generally he over simplifies the economics and social issues involved so much it's almost impossible to critcise it. His style is so vague on these matters I'm not surprised he gets so much backlash. It's not good writing to be purposefully ambiguous.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by NoodleIncident on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:04PM (#23944427)
Do you have examples of the backlash to this essay? Were there any actual consequences to expressing his opinion, or did people just express their own opinions about his?
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by sinker on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:07PM (#23946575)
I'll give it a try. At your company's next diversity seminar, why not suggest merit should be prioritized over diversity? Or that affirmative action is regressive in its effects, or that the talk of reparations is so silly as to be dismissed, or that women's unequal pay is due to factors unrelated to sexism, or that Asians are unfairly penalized in universities and the workplace, or that biological sex exists, or that trans women are not real women, or that trans women should not share a bathroom with biological women, or that white men are not oppressors, or that you don't support BLM. Whether or not these ideas are right, you clearly cannot express them. Not in the workplace and if you live in a large city, not to strangers, and sometimes not even to your friends. There's an implicit belief that if you deviate from some of these positions you must be a racist, misogynist, transphobic, alt-right, or a radical.

There are ideas you can safely express if they fall on one side of the political spectrum and there are other ideas you have to be hush about even if they are completely reasonable.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by etrautmann on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:03AM (#23940326)
I think the larger point is that it doesn't matter how easy it is to make works public if the consequences prevent you from doing so: if you can easily get fired, pushed out of a tenured position at a university, or otherwise lose your voice for making unpopular opinions public.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by __alexs on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:30AM (#23940654)
I don't buy this. There are millions of anonymous Twitter accounts and forum posters. Literal children have figured out opsec well enough to save themselves them embarrassment of having to share their love of anime with the wrong friends.

I'm sure a tenured professor is smart enough to use a different email address and profile picture when signing up to radical life extension forums if what they want to discuss is really that edgy.

We have more tools and venues to test out and refine new ideas today than we have ever before. Use them.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by jimbokun on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:57AM (#23941025)
> You can find almost anyone opinion imaginable out there with a brief Google search and forums on which to argue every side of it with.

And you can quickly get someone fired or their business boycotted or doxxed or swatted if they express an opinion you don't like.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by __alexs on Friday July 24, 2020 @12:11PM (#23941180)
Yes the world is scary, people speaking up have always put themselves at risk but we have better tools to protect ourselves and find like minded people now.

This isn't new and at worst doesn't seem that much different to how people have always acted. The argument is that things have got worse, but they just seem to be the same.

Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by M2Ys4U on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:08AM (#23940381)
It means people like him are being scrutinised like never before (absent an actual revolution) and he doesn't like it.
Re:The Four Quadrants of Conformism by BurningFrog on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:36PM (#23944732)
> Can anyone explain it?

One clue is that almost everyone here posts anonymously.

Under people's own names, many would be much more careful and conformist.