News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by semanticist on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:55AM (#2386780)
It'd be good if Top Gear was more clearly 'labelled' as fictionalised entertainment. In the UK the brand/programme name still carries the associations of 'old' Top Gear, which was a factual motor review programme (which was cancelled, the format - but not name - sold to Channel 5, and then relaunched with the new format). Most of their challenges are staged, and I don't think they'd lose entertainment value by being clearer that it's fiction.

It'd also be good if they stopped pandering to Daily-Mail-reading-racists. The Mexican stuff in the last series was horrific. I wish BBC America had had the balls to include it in their version, if only so they'd have to deal with the enraged viewers.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by vaksel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:14AM (#2386833)
oh please...the new version of Top Gear has been out since 2002...if you haven't caught on that the new Top Gear is different from the "old Top Gear" after 9 years...then you haven't been watching
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by geoffw8 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:05AM (#2387221)
...or your work at Tesla!
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:15AM (#2386836)
They play conkers with caravans, do you think it really needs pointing out that this is an entertainment show?
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by semanticist on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:52AM (#2387155)
No, but it needs to be pointed out that it's fictional entertainment.

They have races and competitions between each other which are staged and adapted for dramatic results. The few car reviews they do are similarly dramatised. Does the viewer understand that the car didn't break down, that the person on the motorbike didn't coincidentally reach the same point as the person in the car, or whatever?

I suspect that most people don't realise that Top Gear is fictional entertainment instead of factual entertainment, because the extremely long-running brand of the show is rooted in factual entertainment.

Suing them over a fictional review is foolish, but if you were expecting an honest review of your product and got back a dramatised narrative you'd probably be pissed off too.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:27AM (#2387651)
> If you were expecting an honest review of your product and got back a dramatised narrative you'd probably be pissed off too.

We're talking about a car company here. Are you suggesting that a car company are going to not understand what Top Gear is about? The sort of show it is and the significant chance that the review will be dramatised and tongue in cheek?

If Tesla sent them a car believing that then they should fire their marketing people who should have made it absolutely clear and then resign themselves for ignoring what 15 seconds thought would have told them.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:53AM (#2387798)
I kind of agree with you but for different reasons and therefore come to a different conclusion.

I think that many viewers don't realise that TG is entertainment rather than factual because sadly most viewers have a pretty uncritical view of anything they see on TV.

And for this reason I think it could be branded entertainment, documentary, drama or children's and it wouldn't make any difference as it's all soaked up largely without question. If people aren't taking the hints from the tongue in cheek comments and the OTT stunts then I don't think a message at the front of the show or in the TV listings would make any difference.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:45AM (#2387121)
>do you think it really needs pointing out that this is an entertainment show?

I think the ancestor comment is simply saying that they need to say that they lie about the factual basis of the show. I don't think that playing conkers with caravans or driving cars of ski-jumps or whatever should allow them to make bare-faced lies about basic performance elements of cars that they review.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by protomyth on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @12:38PM (#2387972)
and try to make a space shuttle out of a car....
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by frou_dh on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:07AM (#2386980)
Personally I find the programme tiresome and don't watch it any more. So often they are pretending that events and quips are spontaneous when they are clearly heavily scripted. I'm British for what it's worth.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by ams6110 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:43AM (#2387114)
I have watched most of the series that are on Netflix, I think 2009 is the latest, and I thought it seemed to be on the decline in that series. They seem to be running out of new ideas, as happens with all long-running series.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @12:06PM (#2387848)
They've public admitted that the show (at least in it's current form) is closer to the end of it's run than the beginning and that they accept that the presenters and opinions are approaching self parody.

Personally I think that that's under stating it but to be fair to them it remains a valuable franchise and one that they're really obliged to keep going so long as it remains relatively successful.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by rvkennedy on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:49AM (#2386762)
Hmm. I don't recall what I'd call "lambasting" - most viewers came away with a very positive impression of the Tesla - especially as it outperformed the Lotus in some areas. The bit about pushing it into the garage was obviously staged, and for humorous effect.

And to claim that providing two cars to the TV crew invalidates the point about range is a little bit outrageous. It's like saying "they cheated by not letting us cheat."

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by ams6110 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:57AM (#2386787)
Agreed, on balance the review was very complimentary, especially for Top Gear; they only pointed out the very real limited range that all fully electric cars have with today's battery technology. I don't see the lawsuit getting very far.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by robryan on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:57AM (#2386786)
Little weird they would be bothering, if Tesla won this case a large amount of the cars featured on the show could surely win similar cases. It's part of the show to pickup on cars flaws and over emphasise them.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by arethuza on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:31AM (#2386877)
Indeed, that Bentley they had in Albania completely put me off ever buying one!
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Andys on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:41AM (#2386919)
The fact they provided two cars says a lot about what they thought might happen to just one car.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:02AM (#2387201)
From what I recall of Top Gear this is pretty standard practice. It also presumably factors in filming issues.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by dman on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:01AM (#2386800)
An auto company targeting auto enthusiasts suing Top Gear is like a tech startup suing YCombinator. In nine cases out of ten the loss of goodwill is going to make this a losing proposition.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by vaksel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:03AM (#2386807)
agreed, Top Gear is pretty much THE car enthusiast show world wide...by suing them Tesla is pretty much attacking 80-90% of their potential customers.

This will do nothing but hurt them...especially after Top Gear retaliates.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:25AM (#2386862)
It's an electric car, I think your average Top Gear viewer is as far from a potential customer as you can get given the general stance the show takes on such matters.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bradleyland on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:43AM (#2387113)
That's entirely untrue of the new generation of gear head. I'm a gear head and what I would consider an "average" Top Gear fan. I'd love a Tesla Roadster. I also find that Clarkson's views on a car are pretty close to what I feel. Yes, the whole out of juice thing was staged, but it was based on the realities of an all-electric car. It does have less range than most petrol powered vehicles. It does take longer to recharge than it would to refuel a petrol car. These are realities, but the show dramatizes them so the viewer can relate to them. Clarkson had plenty good to say about the car too.

None of this makes me want a Tesla any less, and I'd argue that this holds true for pretty much anyone who wants to buy a Tesla. It's a $100k+ two-seater car for crying out loud. You don't buy it because it's practical, you buy it because it goes like stink and is a technological triumph. It's as fast around their track as a Porsche 911 GT3, yet it's 100% electric! I almost fell out of my chair when I first saw that.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:27AM (#2387334)
Sorry, when did I say anything about the average Top Gear fan being interested in practical cars? That was the old Top Gear (and in large part the reason that the old show had became utterly tedious and why Clarkson left it).

The editorial line on Top Gear (and Jeremy Clarkson's view in pretty much all media) has long been to mock environmentalists and their concerns. Maybe the viewers are all wildly interested in electric cars but it would be slightly odd as it would have them watching a show that spent a significant chunk of it's time mocking their beliefs.

Obviously were you to offer to give them a Tesla they'd bite your hand off - it's as close to a super car as most of them will get - but offer them any car of equivalent value and I suspect you'd find that the demand dropped to close to zero.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bradleyland on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:10AM (#2387561)
It appears we have a not-argument against a not-argument. I'm not claiming TG fans are interested in electric cars. I'm claiming that TG fans are interested in cars with awesome performance whether they're electric or not. As you correctly pointed out, most TG fans would jump at the chance to own a Tesla. The equation becomes less clear when you thrown a more traditional super car in to the mix, but that's all besides the point, because very few of these people can afford to actually buy one.

I'm rebutting this:

"I think your average Top Gear viewer is as far from a potential customer as you can get given the general stance the show takes on such matters"

Well, come to think of it, you're right in many respects. The average TG viewer simply can't afford a $110k automobile. I think you slightly misinterpret the TG editorial view though. They're not opposed to electric cars. They're opposed to slow, ugly, uninspiring cars. The net effect of environmentalism is that efficiency is put before all of these other factors. There wasn't one jab at the green aspect of the Tesla Roadster in that episode. It was all about the performance and the trade-offs.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:48AM (#2387777)
Possibly I'm making the mistake we're all accusing Tesla of here which is taking TG too seriously.

In regard to it's view of electric cars I'd say it's position is pretty much to deliberately miss the point (that is that they are practical items rather than performance ones) and to play that for comic effect.

As you say, they like attractive, fast cars (and curiously the Renault Megane which I recall Hammond liked which is neither) and electric cars are designed to be practical and functional - two things which generally are lower down the list of what they consider worthy of note.

Where I have trouble (and I'm running the risk of contradicting things I've said elsewhere in this thread) is that while the presenters and programme makers exaggerate this for entertainment value, I'm not so convinced that it isn't a more accurate representation of the opinions of many of the shows viewers who do have an overly negative view of electric cars.

But maybe that's just me being biased against how I perceive a "typical" TG viewer (to be clear I do watch it, though not always and I'm really not typical in that I don't really care about cars, I just find it amusing).

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by dman on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:28AM (#2386869)
Tesla isnt your typical cookie cutter electric car. Theres a reason the Top Gear folks compared it to the Lotus.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by kerryfalk on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:53AM (#2387164)
The chassis is built/designed by Lotus.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bmelton on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:28AM (#2387050)
It's a Lotus Elise that outperforms the Lotus Elise on straightaways. Faults or not, I have a hard time believing that they're aren't going to sell cars based on that fact alone.

That they got covered on Top Gear is the car equivalent of a startup getting featured on TechCrunch -- good or bad, they got a LOT of eyeballs on the car, and while the review wasn't 100% positive, it wasn't entirely negative either.

The flip side of the equation is whether or not TopGear actually exerts any purchasing influence whatsoever. Since most of their reviews are of Aston Martins, Lamborghinis, Ferraris, etc., do people buying cars at that caliber actually buy based on practical reviews? I'm guessing not.

The Murcielago is a very impractical car, and I doubt anyone who was interested in buying a Lambo has changed their mind because TopGear exposed that its windshield wipers make noise over 100 miles per hour.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by rythie on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:08AM (#2387229)
The point of a Lotus Elise is that it has excellent handling, you don't buy it for straight line speed.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by chadgeidel on Thursday March 31, 2011 @04:10PM (#2393437)
Wil Shipley sold his Elise SC (supercharged - about 250 HP in a ~2100 pound package) because the Tesla roadster was faster around an autocross track. http://wilshipley.com/blog/2008/09/tesla-v-supercharged-lotu...
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bmelton on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:11AM (#2387246)
Traditionally, that is true. But this isn't a Lotus Elise, it's an electric. Many people will buy Hybrids/Eco-cars to make a statement, and if it happens to smoke your gas-guzzler in a drag race, all the better.

The point is that the Tesla Roadster has selling points that aren't invalidated by a negative review on Top Gear and that, even if it were, they did a good job of making it look like a ton of fun, if not entirely practical.

People paying 6 figures for cars are seldom looking for practicality in the same sense that most people do -- they're looking for something special, and there's no denying that the Tesla has that in spades.

Edit: Swapped 'hybrid' for 'electric'.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by unwind on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:28AM (#2387341)
A hybrid between what and what, exactly?

The Tesla Roadster is 100% electric, there's no hybrid technology involved.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bmelton on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:47AM (#2387438)
I was apparently editing that right as you made that remark. You are of course correct.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by rythie on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:15AM (#2387269)
My comment was a direct response to "It's a Lotus Elise that outperforms the Lotus Elise on straightaways. Faults or not, I have a hard time believing that they're aren't going to sell cars based on that fact alone."
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bmelton on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:56AM (#2387486)
Then you are correct.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by vaksel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:39AM (#2386911)
Top Gear is the #1 car show in the world...so there has to be a segment that would be interested in a Tesla.

Sure it's electric, but it's still a sports car of sorts.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by sp332 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:57AM (#2386951)
That's not really true. Toy Story 3 was the highest-grossing film of 2010... so there has to be a segment that would be interested in live-action movies. :)

Basically, Top Gear is popular because it isn't all those other car shows. It's mainstream by popularity, but it's not mainstream in terms of typical car enthusiasts.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by protomyth on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @12:41PM (#2387992)
I think the "average" viewer of any show is far from a potential customer. It is a $100K sports car with a range that limits it to commuting (not travel) distances.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by _phred on Friday April 01, 2011 @01:06AM (#2395031)
I highly doubt that the "average" viewer of Top Gear could afford a $100k car of any make or model. Honestly, it's fun to watch the hosts blaze around the track in hideously expensive super cars, but the law of averages says that not more than a small proportion of the audience could actually afford those cars. So it's hard to quantify Tesla's claimed reputation damage as the people who buy Tesla cars likely don't care one whit what Top Gear has to say about the Tesla roadster, especially given the show's strong anti-environmental pro-speed hi-octane pro petroleum bent.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bigohms on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:32AM (#2386882)
This suit has parallels to Dan Snyder (NFL team owner - Washngton Redskins) suing a local city paper for a rather humorous (and factual) A-Z account of his mismanagement. The original post: http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/articles/40063/the-cranky...

The suit: http://www.tbd.com/articles/2011/02/dan-snyder-lawsuit-a-com...

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by eli on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:19AM (#2387020)
Except all the stuff about Dan Snyder was AFAIK true. While it's entirely possible that the Top Gear guys, ahem, exaggerated some of Tesla's failings.

Edit: Still, it seems rather boneheaded to try to solve a minor PR problem from two years ago with a lawsuit that is certain to be very public.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:52AM (#2387153)
>Edit: Still, it seems rather boneheaded to try to solve a minor PR problem from two years ago with a lawsuit that is certain to be very public.

Actually, I don't think this is boneheaded.

Tesla are probably finding no-one is touching them because somehow, ahem Top Gear, everyone has the impression that the car will run for 50miles and then pack in and your only option will be to tow it home and charge it for 16hours to get another 50miles.

This suit will at the very least raise the point that Top Gear misrepresented the mileage that one can expect to get and that they failed to mention fast-charging schemes. It's likely to get mentioned on Top Gear and in just about every motoring magazine and on every tech site everywhere. I think even a few million on the suit would be better spent than trying to reverse this perception through advertising.

If I were in Tesla's target population then learning that Top Gear lied and that the mileage is actually a lot better than it appeared would probably put me back on track for a sale whilst learning that Tesla is suing Top Gear wouldn't negatively affect my purchase decision.

TL;DR I think this is a win for Tesla overall.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by eli on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:56AM (#2387174)
I understand what you're saying but IMHO a two year old episode of Top Gear is has literally no effect on any sales problems Tesla may or may not be having.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:58AM (#2387496)
You're almost certainly right, now. But for the last two years, one of the biggest voices and possibly the only popular UK TV show to focus on "supercars"/"performance cars" ... if there has been no effect I'd be a little surprised.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by dhimes on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:59AM (#2386954)
Hadn't seen this- and I am definitely a cranky fan.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by quicksilver03 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:07AM (#2387545)
A better analogy would be a tech startup suing TechCrunch, except that Top Gear is infinitely better.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by RiderOfGiraffes on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:11AM (#2386827)
Surely they are deliberately going for the Streisand effect, to raise awareness of their existence by doing something the show's enthusiasts will always remember them for and getting wider publicity into the bargain.

ADDED IN EDIT: Is someone going around downvoting all my comments? This is really strange. Please, if you downvoted this let me know why so I can adjust my actions accordingly.

<FX: retreats, shaking head in confusion>

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by vaksel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:22AM (#2386857)
So does that mean you own a Morris Marina?
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by vaksel on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @07:54AM (#2386778)
wow these guys are such whiners.

Top Gear makes fun of everyone...and it's not like they hinted at something that would never happen

Other manufacturers are mature enough to understand that TG is a comedy show about cars, and their stunts are covered by satire.

And of course Top Gear will retaliate...they always do in cases like this.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by kristofferR on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:09AM (#2386984)
It's one thing to make fun of it in a humourous way, it's another thing to write a script (and follow through with it) claiming it broke down, overheated and ran out of gas before they had even driven the car.

"But in the real world, it doesn't seem to work" was already decided before the cars were even delivered. It's cool to make fun of flaws, it's not cool for something percieved as a review show to decide something is flawed and write the script about how flawed it is before they have even tested it.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by fossuser on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:27AM (#2387336)
Especially considering the amount of viewers and sway Top Gear has and how young Tesla was as a company at the time, that press could have destroyed them and there was no truth to it.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by eftpotrm on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:25AM (#2387040)
Yes, but....

The show's main presenter has been well known as having politically conservative views for many, many years. If you watch, the vast bulk of his output is joking in that general direction when it's joking. Frankly, if I were Tesla, I wouldn't have let my car appear; it smacked of a set-up against the green bogeyman who was trying to stop their fun.

There seems to be a growing tendency at the moment in the UK at least for people with politically conservative views to express these loudly, prominently and repeatedly in a more forceful tone than they could otherwise use, with an I'm only having a bit of fun, it's just a joke, can't you just grow up and take it? tacked on to the end, trying to belittle those who might take offence at their assertions. If these people want to express their views from such a platform (by which I mean a prominent one, the fact of this being on the BBC isn't an issue for me), they should have the nerve to stand behind it.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by philjackson on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:03AM (#2387203)
"they should have the nerve to stand behind it"

So summarise, are you saying Jeremy Clarkson doesn't stand behind his political statements? That's simply not true, have you never seen his columns in the Times? Clarkson gets a terribly hard time for his views and he doesn't waver a bit, whether you agree with him or not, you have to give him some credit.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by eftpotrm on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:44AM (#2387429)
I agree, I've seen his columns and he's firmly standing behind his ill-informed bigotry. A pity, because if you see some of his writing as a younger man 25 years ago he was interesting, funny and observant while still demonstrably holding the same political views; now far more he's a frustrated bigot railing against the modern world.

Watch Top Gear though (which I do and largely enjoy), and there's a relatively regular stream of reactionary material with a 'boys will be boys' tongue in cheek. The problem is, it's consistently in the same direction and at the same targets; it's using a cover of comedy and his TV persona to make attacks he couldn't otherwise make in such a platform. Jeremy Clarkson the newspaper columnist stands behind his positions, I agree; Jeremy Clarkson the TV character often tries to make much the same attacks while laughing them off as 'just a bit of fun'. That isn't intellectually honest.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by philjackson on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:59AM (#2387822)
"Jeremy Clarkson the TV character often tries to make much the same attacks while laughing them off as 'just a bit of fun'. That isn't intellectually honest."

Are you talking about the more extreme rubbish like "all lorry drivers are prostitute murderers"? His genuine political opinions like the ones he has on bendy buses, speed cameras, the M4 bus lane etc. strike me as genuine and not veiled in the 'boys will be boys' disguise you talk of.

I should probably bail from this conversation lest people mistake me as a JC supporter, I just think you're being a little unfair.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by antihero on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:31AM (#2387065)
People still use it as basis for forming their opinions. If they staged the Tesla going into the garage, then it undermines every bit of work engineers have done to make sure that would ever happen, and undermines the hard work engineers have done to get electric cars into the mainstream.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by nhebb on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:36AM (#2386900)
I don't want to dog pile on them because Tesla seems like such a promising company, and despite this PR disaster, I hope they pull through to profitability. They're trying to push the technology for electric vehicles forward, and they're going to use the vacated NUMMI plant in Freemont, which is commendable. So I'll cut them some slack. A lot of slack.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by watchandwait on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:39AM (#2387103)
The Freemont plant is part of the crony deal they struck with then Speaker-Pelosi and the unions in exchange for their massive government subsidy.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by ams6110 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:52AM (#2387154)
Sorry to rain on your parade but battery-only powered electric cars still have too limited a range and take too long to recharge to be practical for most people. They may find a niche with people who can afford to have a separate car for a modest daily commute, but most people don't have the cash to tie up in an extra car just to be "green" (which electric cars aren't, really).
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by whatusername on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:34AM (#2387371)
Have you seen www.betterplace.com

They have an answer for the range/recharge complaints (switching stations)

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by nickbp on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:25AM (#2387638)
(nitpick: Fremont)
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:20AM (#2386852)
As an aside under the proposed new English libel laws this case couldn't be bought as they've waited two years from first publication (the new laws place a limit of a year).
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by dmazin on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:09AM (#2387234)
I'm not sure what's wrong with this really. Top Gear (pretends to be) is a car reviewer, and they made false claims in a car review. They are surely a comedy show but that segment was just astonishing.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by watchandwait on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:36AM (#2387090)
Normally Tesla's lawyers are busy in Washington, D.C., fleecing U.S. taxpayers for handouts. The company is one of the biggest welfare queens in America, they have almost no revenue and yet the government has given them hundreds of millions in unsecured loans.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by api on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:40AM (#2387105)
BP got far more in government handouts to pay for their Gulf oil rig blowout disaster. In a free market, BP would now be bankrupt as it would have had to pay for the cleanup of hundreds and hundreds of miles of damaged coastal property as well as compensating fishermen for millions (or billions?) in lost revenue.

Just to give one example. Just saying.

We live in a welfare state. Criticizing people for accepting welfare in a welfare state is like criticizing people for speeding at Nascar. Everybody does it. Every major corporation has lawyers and lobbyists in Washington to get as much pork as they possibly can.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by anamax on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:56AM (#2387487)
> Criticizing people for accepting welfare in a welfare state is like criticizing people for speeding at Nascar. Everybody does it.

Actually, "everybody" doesn't do it. You can't subsidize everyone because you run out of money long before that. The vast majority of us don't get subsidies.

Two wrongs don't make a right.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by fleitz on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @08:04AM (#2386809)
You can't drop lithium ion batteries much below 25% charge or they start to die. If you fully discharge a lithium ion battery it's dead forever. That's how the Tesla engineers knew it didn't drop below 25% charge because otherwise the car would be undrivable. Why is it unbelievable that a car with a normal range of 200 miles would only get 55 on a track? If your car normally gets 400 miles to a tank it would not be unreasonable to expect 100 miles during a track day.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by po on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:14AM (#2387002)
That's also why lithium batteries include circuitry to shut down when they get to x%. When they say they are at 25% then they are really at 25% of what is "safe" for the technology. It's not like if your laptop drops to 0% you can't boot it again. Don't you think that when they say it had 25% charge they are talking about what the battery was reporting?
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by JshWright on Thursday March 31, 2011 @02:34PM (#2392967)
I had a MacBook battery that dropped to 0% and wouldn't charge after that...
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by fleitz on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:30AM (#2387056)
Knowing lawyers, probably not. Look at the crap SCEA is putting infront of the court against an 18 year old kid. Also, 25% is known as a quarter tank where people who don't like to run out of gas decide that it's time to fill up, since you can't 'fill up' a Tesla, that means you have to go home. It also means that if you drive your car 55 miles away from home in track like conditions you'll be pushing your car home.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:58AM (#2387182)
>It also means that if you drive your car 55 miles away from home in track like conditions you'll be pushing your car home.

In the UK you'd probably have been stopped by the police and have several speeding tickets if you were lucky enough to do the 55 miles on public roads at track speeds (0-60mph in 3.7s, limiter hits at 125mph) without killing anyone or wrecking the car.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by bradleyland on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:52AM (#2387156)
It's worth noting that the Ford GT actually ran out of gas on the Top Gear track while Clarkson was driving it, and they put it in the show. They got something ridiculous like 6 miles to the gallon and made a point of it.
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by Nelson69 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:14AM (#2387259)
It seems reasonable to me.. I vaguely remember the car actually breaking in some way, maybe even a couple times.

I can't say I was in the market for a Tesla, but the range wasn't what sounded bad to me, I was left under the impression that it just didn't have the quality yet.

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by geoffw8 on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:07AM (#2387224)
Its such a PR flop. The thing I can't understand is why they'd want to draw attention to the fact a very well read/watched/trusted program wrote a very poor review of your product.

Why on earth would you give it a second life?

Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by raarky on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @09:07AM (#2386979)
here's hoping they do nice segment tearing tesla apart in their usual witty style :)
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @10:04AM (#2387208)
Yeah they can go all out on how it's got a far better range than Top Gear presented it having and how it can be charge under best conditions in 4 hours. Tesla will cry all the way to the bank ...
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by nickbp on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @11:29AM (#2387661)
More like "oh, you've got a Tesla? Isn't that the car company that sued Top Gear? Hahaha!"
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:33PM (#2388802)
[possible response] "Yeah, it's the one that whipped the Lotus' ass so bad that Jeremy got scared and had to lie to make it look crippled. Apparently the BBC still haven’t learnt about not lying on public funds ... Hey ho, wanna race?".
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by guscost on Thursday March 31, 2011 @06:16PM (#2393960)
"Sure. My pit crew will use a gas pump, yours will use a charging station."
Re:Tesla loses plot, sues Top Gear by nickbp on Friday April 01, 2011 @02:30PM (#2397407)
"I would but you'd sue me if you lost."