News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by muro on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:46PM (#23835156)
I wondered when I can buy a AMD workstation with official ECC support, looks like that will finally be possible in September. Hope the price will be OK.

There are higher base frequencies but lower turbo on the new TR Pro vs Ryzen 9:

  | name   | CPUs  | base | turbo|
  | 3955WX | 16/32 | 3900 | 4300 |
  | 3945WX | 12/24 | 4000 | 4300 |
  | 3950X  | 16/32 | 3500 | 4700 |
  | 3900XT | 12/24 | 3800 | 4700 |
Edit: the new, much higher TDP is not welcome news.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:34PM (#23835862)
> I wondered when I can buy a AMD workstation with official ECC support, looks like that will finally be possible in September. Hope the price will be OK.

You don't have to wait. The current Ryzen 3000 series processors support ECC.

ASUS, ASRock, and Gigabyte have several Ryzen 3000 motherboard options that support ECC RAM. Example: https://www.asus.com/Motherboards/Pro-WS-X570-ACE/

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by paulmd on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:54PM (#23836937)
> You don't have to wait. The current Ryzen 3000 series processors support ECC.

The post you were responding to asked when they would get official ECC support. ECC is not officially supported on Ryzen. If it works on your particular board/BIOS, great, but it's not officially validated or tested, so nobody besides you will actually be testing whether it works, and if it doesn't work in some edge case (or at all) then sucks to be you. If ECC doesn't work right on some future BIOS revision that fixes a security issue or some other critical bug, and there is never an updated version that does support ECC, sucks to be you.

That is specifically the problem that people are looking to avoid by asking for official support.

As it stands, you can probably count the number of boards that anyone would bother to validate ECC on on a single hand - Asrock Rack has two server boards, Asus has some "WS" series that might, maybe some of the high-end Asrock consumer boards. And it will never be officially supported by AMD, if there is a critical bug then welp.

As such I think "ECC is supported on AM4" is a bit of an exaggeration or a clever bit of terminology spin from some fans. If you call up AMD and ask, they will tell you they don't go out of their way to disable it (except in APUs) but it's not supported. I think "functional" or "enabled" is a better term.

(Intel validates support on their consumer processors, by the way... i3s and Pentiums officially support ECC. Supermicro/Asrock Rack/etc test those configurations and if they don't work then you can complain and they will fix them.)

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by theevilsharpie on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:23PM (#23838098)
> The post you were responding to asked when they would get official ECC support. ECC is not officially supported on Ryzen. If it works on your particular board/BIOS, great, but it's not officially validated or tested, so nobody besides you will actually be testing whether it works, and if it doesn't work in some edge case (or at all) then sucks to be you. If ECC doesn't work right on some future BIOS revision that fixes a security issue or some other critical bug, and there is never an updated version that does support ECC, sucks to be you.

ECC is officially supported on Ryzen CPUs. The feature is present in the chip, and you can RMA it if it doesn't work.

ECC support is not _validated_ on the AM4 platform. That means that a motherboard vendor can market a motherboard that lacks ECC support as being AM4-compatible, and not get a nasty letter from AMD's lawyers. By extension, it also means that ECC support becomes a feature of the motherboard, rather than something you can take for granted that the entire AM4 platform supports.

From the user perspective, it does mean that if you're looking to buy a Ryzen-based platform with ECC support, you need to check to see if the motherboard supports ECC. But once you've made that selection, you will have a fully-functional ECC-capable platform with full support.

> As it stands, you can probably count the number of boards that anyone would bother to validate ECC on on a single hand - Asrock Rack has two server boards, Asus has some "WS" series that might, maybe some of the high-end Asrock consumer boards. And it will never be officially supported by AMD, if there is a critical bug then welp.

All ASRock AM4 boards (that I'm aware of) support ECC, and most ASUS boards do. I can't speak for other brands, but ECC is pretty broadly supported (the motherboard manual will say whether it's supported it or not).

What separates the motherboards you mentioned is that ECC support is _marketed_ as being a feature.

As a data point, I'm currently running an ASRock B450M Pro4 motherboard with a Ryzen 9 3900X and 64 GB of Kingston KSM26ED8/16ME DDR4-2666 ECC DRAM, and it is working with full ECC support.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by InternetOfStuff on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:28PM (#23837393)
> ECC is not officially supported on Ryzen. If it works on your particular board/BIOS, great, but it's not officially validated or tested

The Asus Pro X570 ACE (or similar name) explicitly offers ECC support though, not just unofficially.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by paulmd on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:57PM (#23837759)
Some boards list in the specs, but that's not a guarantee that it's actually working. Previous BIOS revisions can and have silently broken the ECC part of the memory functionality, and nobody at the board companies was testing it so it went out without anybody noticing until a user started a forum thread about it. That was Asrock iirc.

In the case of MSI, those boards reportedly also don't support the ECC reporting function. They will try to correct them but they don't actually report them to the OS. MSI's answer: "wow, sucks to be you". AMD’s answer: “wow, sucks to be you”. That's what you get from "unofficial support", just a halfhearted level of effort all around.

https://hardwarecanucks.com/forum/threads/ecc-memory-amds-ry...

(there are really multiple levels of functionality here, "boots with ECC in non-ECC mode", "corrects ECC silently", and "behaves like a server and reports ECC to the OS or lets you reboot the system". You'll note that nobody ever commits to a particular level of support on AM4 based products...)

Furthermore, AMD doesn't support it at a processor level, so they apply no pressure to the mobo companies to actually test the features they claim they support, nor will they fix it if there is ever a critical functionality bug. An AGESA update could break or remove ECC and welp, sucks to be you, they never advertised that as an actual feature.

That is why I think it is a little ridiculous that people phrase that as "supported". Nobody is validating that it actually works, nobody at AMD will stand behind the feature, and will in fact tell you that they don't support it.

It works, probably, on certain combinations of hardware and BIOS. It is not supported by anyone other than yourself and your own time.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by Reelin on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:57PM (#23838495)
> Some boards list in the specs, but that's not a guarantee that it's actually working.

You do realize that false advertising is illegal? Of course realistically that would be a very uphill battle to pursue but that doesn't make it legal.

For example my motherboard has built in audio. The board manufacturer makes some fairly vague claims about what precisely that means but it is clear that there are ports on the board and that they will provide some base level of functionality in conjunction with a supported OS. To the best of my knowledge the CPU manufacturer makes absolutely no claims about that feature. Nonetheless, it is reasonable to expect it to work.

Of course it would be nice if AMD required ECC support as part of the platform. Then all the boards would be required to support it and I wouldn't have to bother reading their spec sheets.

> there are really multiple levels of functionality here

This is the real issue. At least historically, some boards "supported" ECC memory to the extent that they could operate with it inserted; they didn't actually do any error correcting though. Of course in the case I'm aware of (MSI) they specifically stated that. If you as a consumer glossed over their claims and missed that, legally that was on you.

Other vendors specifically stated that their boards officially supported actual ECC functionality. It's not safe to assume precisely what that means though (silent vs reported) unless the manufacturer makes an official claim.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by account42 on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:48AM (#23859525)
I don't know about AM4 but my TR4 MSI board definitely does report ECC errors (both corrected and uncorrectable).
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by marmaduke on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:05PM (#23837100)
thanks for the informative reply,

> i3s and Pentiums officially support ECC

my experience is that OEMs like Dell won't support ECC except for Xeon configurations. You can get the same machine with an i9 but not ECC memory or the Xeon and ECC.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by wtallis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:29PM (#23837416)
> You can get the same machine with an i9 but not ECC memory or the Xeon and ECC.

The desktop and workstation class Xeons are in direct competition with i9 processors in terms of raw performance, which is why Intel uses features like ECC to enforce product segmentation. This isn't the case for the low-end i3 and Pentium branded processors, because the Xeon lineup simply doesn't extend down that far. If you want to build eg. an industrial PC with ECC memory but you only need a low-end CPU, Intel's official solution is for you to get an i3 or Pentium processor because they don't have anything equivalent under the Xeon branding.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by paulmd on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:40PM (#23837546)
Well, that's a different segment, you won't find Dell selling you a 3900X and ECC in a server or workstation either.

But OEMs like SuperMicro and Asrock Rack do officially support this, and sell barebones or pre-configured systems like this.

https://www.supermicro.com/en/products/motherboard/X11SCH-LN...

https://www.supermicro.com/en/products/system/1U/5019/SYS-50...

Workstation: https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=C...

(and to be fair, Asrock Rack does have a few AM4 server boards and barebones, and these are among the few I would count on to actually validate ECC. It really just is something you have to explicitly go out of you way to find support for in the AMD ecosystem, whereas it's "free" on any C2xx server board in the Intel ecosystem, the default assumption is that it works because it's considered a supported configuration and that's not the case with AMD.)

https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=X...

https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=1...

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by burmanm on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @03:55AM (#23842441)
Dell does actually sell Pentium machines with ECC support, like the smaller Poweredge servers such as T140. They've done this for a while, I personally run T20 with ECC and G3220 (sold like this by Dell).

They do occasionally remove some features like IPMI from those cheaper processor options, but the ECC support stays.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by jmole on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:30PM (#23837424)
i9 and Xeon (officially) use a different PCH. So it's not really the same machine.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by fomine3 on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @10:53PM (#23855223)
Explaining in opposite: Pentium supports both PCH lines and supports ECC because they don't want to sell such cheap Xeon-branded CPU.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by binarycrusader on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:36PM (#23835896)
Yes, but only a limited UDIMM variant which makes it much harder to source memory for. It's gotten a little easier over the last year, but these new Pro variants will have support for RDIMM, LRDIMM, etc. DIMMs which will make it much easier to find memory at a reasonable price.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:41PM (#23835942)
16GB and 32GB ECC UDIMMs are easy to find and reasonably priced: https://www.cdw.com/product/samsung-ddr4-32-gb-dimm-288-pin-...

The real advantage of the PRO processors is that they support 8-channel memory and have more PCIe lanes. The higher TDP spec might allow for higher all-core turbo, too.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by binarycrusader on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:31PM (#23836626)
Yes, some DIMM configurations are easier to find now, but when Threadripper was first released they were all but impossible to source.

However, even if 16GB and 32GB are easy to find, that won't let you get anywhere near the 1TB limit of the first systems to ship or the technical limit of 2TB as other posters pointed out.

It's just not realistic to equate the two as equal -- these new systems are definitely going to unlock use cases that aren't possible with the regular Threadripper.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by amarshall on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:50PM (#23838413)
> that won't let you get anywhere near the 1TB limit of the first systems to ship or the technical limit of 2TB as other posters pointed out.

The limit of TRX40 is 256 GB max, 32 GB individual, and WRX80 supports RDIMMs, so finding larger UDIMMs is pointless, anyway.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by binarycrusader on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @12:44AM (#23841414)
Early on there were claims from some that 64GB UDIMMs would work when they existed or would be supported when they did. But yes, I agree otherwise. I seem to recall spotting some special order 64GB UDIMMs recently (for sampling only at OEM level).
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by kllrnohj on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:45PM (#23835985)
> The higher TDP spec might allow for higher all-core turbo, too.

Same TDP spec as the existing non-pro threadrippers - 280W.

> The real advantage of the PRO processors is that they support 8-channel memory and have more PCIe lanes.

Those are advantages yes but the other DIMM types means you can also actually exceed 256GB of RAM, which with 64-cores is definitely also a bottleneck on the existing Threadripper lineup

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by leoc on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:55PM (#23836128)
256 GiB is also supposedly a bit of a low ceiling for serious 4K video work, never mind 8K (please forgive the not-prestigious source): https://youtu.be/1LaKH5etJoE?t=926 I wouldn’t be astonished (not an expert) if unhappiness from video professionals was an important reason behind the release of the Pro.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:49PM (#23836036)
> Same TDP spec as the existing non-pro threadrippers - 280W.

The current 280W TDP Threadrippers are 24, 32, or 64 core.

These new Threadripper PRO parts have 280W TDP even down to 16 and 12 core parts.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by gruez on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:52PM (#23836915)
>The higher TDP spec might allow for higher all-core turbo, too.

Is there a difference in silicon quality, or is it essentially PBO[1] being preapplied? In other words, can you get the same effect by getting the non-pro part and going into your mobo setting and setting the power limit higher yourself?

[1] https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/amd/pbo

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by rbanffy on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:49PM (#23836866)
Sourcing memory is not something we need to do regularly. Unless it's something nearly impossible to find, it's a very minor nuisance.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by muro on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:53PM (#23836087)
They claim to support, yet noone will guarantee it actually works. And no (big) OEM sells one. I don't mind waiting for official support from an OEM.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by init on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:00PM (#23836185)
I picked this exact same motherboard for my custom built worstation with ECC RAM and a Ryzen 3k series processor.

It was impossible to find an OEM workstation with those specs so I ended up building it and it's been working with no hassles.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by DCKing on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @04:05PM (#23837098)
Regular non-pro Threadripper has officially supported ECC from the start: https://www.amd.com/en/products/ryzen-threadripper

The usual distinction is that Threadripper regular takes unbuffered ECC, whereas Threadripper Pro and Epyc take buffered ECC. But they're both ECC.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by tiffanyh on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:30PM (#23835814)
I firmly believe that TR (with their higher base freq) + ECC would be the ultimate SERVER.

The TR 3970x in particular is amazing for a server. It's 32 core, all running at a base freq of 3.7Ghz. It's amazing to have that kind of high clock with so many cores.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:26PM (#23836553)
People typically run EPYC's at 4 sockets per U of rack space (2p-2u4n: 4 dual processor nodes in 2U). With these, you'd be lucky to get 1/4 of the density, more likely 1/8. Any savings on chips would be more than eaten up by rack fees.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by neurotixz on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:54PM (#23836105)
This is probably part of the reason why it's OEM-only. That way AMD can control where it's used, avoiding it competing with it's own EPYC server chips.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by wmf on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @05:00PM (#23837795)
It's probably the same price or more expensive than EPYC anyway so AMD doesn't care which one you buy.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by fomine3 on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @10:53PM (#23855229)
It's good point but sad for DIY.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by lliamander on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @08:23PM (#23839793)
> the new, much higher TDP is not welcome news.

The TDP is (in part) because the Epyc IO die consumes roughly 100W by itself. You can still cool a Threadripper on air though.

Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by parsimo2010 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:17PM (#23836437)
You can already buy workstations with Epyc CPUs and have been able to for a while. ECC memory and more of it, plus extra PCI-E lanes.
Re:AMD Announces Ryzen Threadripper Pro: Workstation Parts f... by muro on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:44PM (#23836793)
Not from big OEMs, unfortunately.