News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Imnimo on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:29PM (#23784791)
One thing I'm unclear about is this: "If Congress wishes to withdraw its promises, it must say so." The question in the case, as I understand it, was whether previous acts of Congress had in fact dissolved the reservation. Could Congress, if they wanted to, pass a resolution saying, "Actually, such-and-such bill from 100-some years ago dissolved the reservation." Or can they only say, "Starting today, the reservation is dissolved."

Is Congress empowered to clarify the meaning of its own past statements? Or once the text leaves Congress, only the courts can say what that text means, and if the courts disagree with Congress, then Congress can only remedy that going forward?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Gene_Parmesan on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:53PM (#23786209)
Congress writes the laws. Courts interpret them. Congress can't simply say "oh actually back then we meant this other thing," as that would be completely nullifying the power of the Courts. Yes, they can make an amendment that changes/clarifies the meaning of an existing law, and that might sound like the same thing, but doing that requires the formality of the process -- in particular, bringing it to a vote.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cheerlessbog on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:33PM (#23786882)
Aren't retroactive laws a thing?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by lwf on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:47PM (#23786967)
In the context of this case, which was over a criminal matter, they cannot pass a retroactive law. ("ex post facto")

For civil matters, yes, with a bunch of asterisks: https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-1/sec...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by arkis22 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:40PM (#23786928)
Congress is prohibited from passing ex post facto laws by clause 3 of Article I, Section 9 of the United States Constitution.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by adrr on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:57PM (#23787029)
That only applies to criminal matters and only in terms of punishment. Congress could decriminalize drugs and make it retroactive for people who have yet to be convicted or charged.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by mcny on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:26PM (#23787214)
Sorry for stupid question but I'd imagine this ruling means the State of Oklahoma (and therefore all counties and cities/towns in Oklahoma) never had the authority to bring criminal cases against those Native Americans in tribal lands?

Would action of Congress mean any such criminal convictions stand? If yes, would that be a violation of the Constitution of the United States?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by brianwawok on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:39PM (#23786924)
Like wearing white shirts is illegal, effective 2001? So anyone you can prove wore a white shirt 2001-2020 is going to jail? That would be pretty stupid.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cheerlessbog on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:22AM (#23791724)
It's possible in some jurisdictions although as you say they can very easily be unjust.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_post_facto_law

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by veridies on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:38PM (#23784896)
That's a good question. I'm not a lawyer, but I think it would be problematic if Congress could make those decisions. That would allow them to de facto create ex post facto laws by contriving "interpretations" of past laws. It might incentivize intentionally ambiguous laws that allow them flexibility in the future. At that point, the Supreme Court would be in the very odd position of deciding whether something is a plausible interpretation of a previous law.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Imnimo on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:45PM (#23784978)
Yeah, I agree. That could definitely get into some really sticky territory. I guess the other side is that a malevolent court could contrive those interpretations, and Congress would be only be able rectify the situation going forward. I don't know what the best solution is, but I guess I trust the Supreme Court more than I trust Congress. Still, it seems weird that Congress wouldn't get a say in determining what their own bills mean when there's a dispute.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by alasdair_ on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:40PM (#23785544)
>I guess I trust the Supreme Court more than I trust Congress

It's quite a damning indictment of US-style democracy that people trust a small cabal of unelected lifetime appointees without any meaningful oversight, over a larger pool of democratically elected officials.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:01PM (#23785751)
The root of the problem (and this isn't unique to US-style democracy) is that any body that has to deal with re-election every few years is going to focus more on things that get them re-elected, not necessarily things that are good or sustainable for the state as a whole. That's just human nature, and I don't think there's a way to fix that problem without fundamentally changing how with think of elections and terms in office, and I'm not sure what that would look like.

One thing that makes SCOTUS interesting is that they have no enforcement mechanism. It's mainly only tradition and respect for the institution that causes people to follow Supreme Court rulings. If the executive branch suddenly decided to do whatever it wanted, as long as they had support within their own ranks, including the military, there'd be no one to stop them.

On the flip side, this means that SCOTUS has a huge incentive to do their best to figure out what the actual right thing is, and rule that way. Because if too many people think SCOTUS is a shady group of individuals whose rulings are arbitrary and don't deserve respect, that's it for their power. And that's why even when I believe one of their rulings to be counter to my values, I can usually understand why they came to the decision they made, and at least respect the process.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by dannypgh on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:44PM (#23786128)
> One thing that makes SCOTUS interesting is that they have no enforcement mechanism. It's mainly only tradition and respect for the institution that causes people to follow Supreme Court rulings

You're underselling this, I think.

It is "respect for the institution" why the military accepts the civilian authority of the POTUS as commander in chief. If we are only considering the ability to use violence to enforce one's position as legitimate, it's the military and police forces who rule. Once you factor in laws, the SCOTUS is authoritative as to how the laws can be legally interpreted.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cconstantine on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:23PM (#23787190)
This very much reminds me of the riddle in Game of Thrones:

"In a room sit three great men, a king, a priest, and a rich man with his gold. Between them stands a sellsword, a little man of common birth and no great mind. Each of the great ones bids him slay the other two. ‘Do it,’ says the king, ‘for I am your lawful ruler.’ ‘Do it,’ says the priest, ‘for I command you in the name of the gods.’ ‘Do it,’ says the rich man, ‘and all this gold shall be yours.’ So tell me – who lives and who dies?”

The more interesting question to me than "who lives and who dies?" is "who holds the most power?" The three great men have enormous resources to influence the sellsword, but in this situation isn't it the sellsword ultimately making the decision and being the agent of change? Does the military let POTUS pretend he has ultimate power, or does "respect for the institution" really overpower the military?

I really hope "respect for institution" is more powerful than our military. I think so far we've seen that it is, but the current administration seems to be attacking our institutions pretty aggressivly.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by alasdair_ on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:58AM (#23788594)
>Does the military let POTUS pretend he has ultimate power, or does "respect for the institution" really overpower the military?

A huge portion of the military really comes down to who has money to keep paying the soldiers, fueling the bombers etc. If the military revolts but no one ends up paid, a problem ensues.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by dannypgh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:27AM (#23802052)
I think in the scenarios where the military decides to no longer respect civilian rule (a coup), it's not particularly hard to occupy the Treasury and the mint.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by tigen on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:46PM (#23786963)
A potential improvement might to split the scope of duties across more independent government entities. It's actually similar to how corporate management tends to plan management roles: things like end-to-end ownership of clear (and relatively limited) responsibilities. These days, the federal government's scope is massively larger than when the constitution was created.

One approach to splitting things might look something like this:

government A: education, taxes, social services, abortion, immigration, ...

government B: electoral issues, telecom/internet, mail, privacy, utilities, workplace regulations, ... basically, mundane areas that are more about boring competence and finding smart solutions. Or at the very least, serving the public will more directly.

This way, the boring yet important stuff can be done by B without being drowned out by the divisive stuff in A, where people become polarized into thinking they just need to vote against particular issues and there's no real accountability for the rest of it.

You might think that state-level government provides more accountability by being smaller, and this is true in some way, but for the most part I see the exact same thing happening where state government elections are mostly not providing much accountability in a lot of government domains because they aren't contentious enough to be the deciding factors in elections. But they are still important nevertheless.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by sjy on Friday July 10, 2020 @06:42AM (#23790085)
Doesn’t the system already work like this? The federal government is responsible for the things enumerated in the Constitution (accepting, as you say, that the scope of these powers has become wider in practice over time). The states are responsible for everything else. The “boring yet important” decisions are made by unelected bureaucrats rather than politicians.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by shliachtx on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:16PM (#23786384)
This (to my understanding) was the purpose of the Senate originally. Appointed by the states (however they choose), for terms of 6 years. This means they represent the interest of the state as a whole, not of the individual voters.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:51AM (#23788253)
Yeah. And I was about to say something to the effect that this plan was a bad idea, because then you end up with out-of-touch political elites in the Senate. But then I thought about the current makeup of the Senate...
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by rgbrgb on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:15PM (#23785881)
Very interesting points regarding enforcement mechanism.

> I'm not sure what that would look like.

Just iterating a few possibilities:

1) Lifetime terms (like Roman senate or SCOTUS)

2) Term limits (like US Pres)

Honestly really naive about political theory and I wonder what the case is for each and what the process for changing would look like (guessing it is something congress would have to do, so hard to do).

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by foota on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:24PM (#23786436)
The typical argument I've heard against term limits is that you limit the experience your lawmakers have.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cheerlessbog on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:34PM (#23786888)
And they have an incentive to angle for their next job. Like congress people walking into a lobbying job on the other side of the desk. Conflict of interest
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Firehawke on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:56PM (#23787027)
Which is why the FCC is a complete mess of regulatory capture: it's a revolving door between FCC positions and big money telecom positions.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:45AM (#23788232)
This already happens, though, without term limits, so is it really that big a worry?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by webmaven on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:35PM (#23786511)
3) Randomly selecting citizens to serve (like jury duty).
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cheerlessbog on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:35PM (#23786891)
Rotate randomly selected federal judges through the job.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by graycat on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:01PM (#23786271)
deleted
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by usefulcat on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:20PM (#23786410)
Even if you could somehow “fix” the press, you’d still be left with the problem of individuals favoring those elements of the press that reinforce their existing beliefs. It’s not a lack of information that’s the problem; the problem is that people self-select news sources that reinforce their existing beliefs. In fact one could argue that the present abundance of “information” is a primary enabler of such bubbles.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by graycat on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:12PM (#23786765)
deleted
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by alasdair_ on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:37PM (#23786907)
>long ago I concluded that quite broadly, astoundingly, that the media doesn't know how to draw a graph!

I'm almost certain most people doing these graphics know exactly how to draw a graph, it's just that their audience has made it clear that they like incorrect graphs, so long as they reinforce existing beliefs.

Someone, somewhere, has almost certainly done an A/B test of "correct graph" versus "misleading graph" and learned that the latter produces more clicks, shares and revenue.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by graycat on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:03PM (#23787069)
deleted
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by alasdair_ on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:08PM (#23786322)
>For SCOTUS rulings and the law more generally, there is an "enforcement mechanism": Bring a legal case.

Who would hear a legal case against the SCOTUS?

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by graycat on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:42PM (#23786559)
deleted
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by alasdair_ on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:34PM (#23786884)
Sorry, I conflated my mention of SCOTUS existing "without any meaningful oversight" with your mention of "enforcement mechanism" - I missed that you were replying to someone who replied to me, not directly to me!
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by exclusiv on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:06PM (#23785801)
From my perspective, I would simply restate it as such:

"It's quite a damning indictment of US-style democracy that people distrust a larger pool of democratically elected officials over a small cabal of unelected lifetime appointees without any meaningful oversight"

You're framing it like Congress is elected by the people and are thus more worthy of their trust and the fact that doesn't happen is the damning part. But that's one-sided.

In reality there's a TON of special interests driving who gets in front of the population to even be elected to Congress and then what the agenda is for them after being elected. That erodes the public's trust, not to mention all the Congressional scandals over the years and the cutthroat tactics politicians will do to simply get re-elected.

So I see the same conclusion as you but in reverse.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by astrange on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:26AM (#23789359)
> In reality there's a TON of special interests driving who gets in front of the population to even be elected to Congress and then what the agenda is for them after being elected.

There aren't really. In other countries yes, the party can kick you out if they don't like you. In the US the parties don't really exist, there are just people.

There have been tons of primary upsets just this week and none of them are because of "special interests". No elite wants Jamaal Bowman or Lauren Boebert elected, but they'll be on the ballot.

Afterwards the control is mostly because we don't fund elections properly, so everyone except AOC has to spend all day calling donors.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by sjy on Friday July 10, 2020 @06:47AM (#23790117)
Needing to spend all day calling donors in order to stay in office sounds a lot like “special interests driving ... what the agenda is” to me.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by exclusiv on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:28PM (#23793194)
Precisely. Big donors provide money to get a return. In fact, its one of the best investments you can make.

"Corporations Lobbying Government Reap 76,000% Return On Investment. Between 2007 and 2012, 200 of America’s most politically active corporations spent a combined $5.8 billion on federal lobbying and campaign contributions." [1]

"How The Fortune 100 Turned $2 Billion in Lobbying Spend Into $400 Billion of Taxpayer Cash" [2]

[1] https://www.mintpressnews.com/corporations-lobbying-governme...

[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2019/05/14/how...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by exclusiv on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:23PM (#23793132)
I'll just disagree because I think your statement is highly inaccurate.

Regarding who gets on the ballot - yes there are a special interests that fund their candidate. We generally get whomever has a larger budget, not who the best candidate might be. Special interests also drive the ballot measures too.

> In the US the parties don't really exist, there are just people.

This makes no sense. Just recently (2016) the Dems showed clear bias against Bernie in the leaks. The Chair resigned. The party always has a platform, a brand, an agenda and big budgets. Also third parties have almost zero shot because the 2 major parties conspire to keep them out. It's not just "people". The Ds have their consistent supporters and the Rs have theirs. That includes corporations, special interest groups and more.

You have non-citizens driving these politicians. Big donors, some unions (like police), special interest groups. Health care, gun lobbyists, etc.

"Analyst James A. Thurber estimated that the actual number of working lobbyists was close to 100,000 and that the industry brings in $9 billion annually.[6] Wall Street spent a record $2 billion trying to influence the 2016 United States presidential election." [1]

"Who got special deals in the stimulus and why they got them. In the $2 trillion package, senators took care of their home state industries and pet projects." [2]

Casinos and airlines, among others, flexed their clout in that stimulus.

From the homepage today: "AP: Catholic Church lobbied for taxpayer funds, got $1.4B" [4]

Even more damning:

"We looked for legislation that was written by special interests. We found it in all 50 states. When legislators propose new laws, they don’t always write the bills themselves. Corporations, interest groups or their lobbyists often write fill-in-the-blank documents then shop them to state lawmakers."

"These copy-and-paste bills are commonly known as model legislation. More than 2,100 of these bills have been signed into law in the last eight years." [3]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lobbying_in_the_United_States

[2] https://www.politico.com/news/2020/03/26/stimulus-coronaviru...

[3] https://www.usatoday.com/pages/interactives/asbestos-sharia-...

[4] https://apnews.com/dab8261c68c93f24c0bfc1876518b3f6

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by astrange on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:42AM (#23800572)
> Regarding who gets on the ballot - yes there are a special interests that fund their candidate. We generally get whomever has a larger budget, not who the best candidate might be. Special interests also drive the ballot measures too.

I mean, evidence suggests this is not true because of the small-donor revolution. Like I said above, there were left and right primary upsets this week, and now senior House members will probably be replaced by a socialist high school teacher and a Qanon conspiracy theorist.

Meanwhile in the presidential race, Bernie raised the most with only small donors, two billionaires outspent everyone and failed, and Biden is winning despite hardly fundraising or advertising the whole primary.

Another new case is in Seattle, where Amazon tried to spend their way into controlling the city council to get rid of a tax, but only proved they had no power and everyone hated them: https://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2020/07/jumpstart-seatt...

The less popular congresspeople who don't have as many small donors do spend too much time calling for donations, so reform is still needed, but AOC and co really do seem to not have this problem.

> This makes no sense. Just recently (2016) the Dems showed clear bias against Bernie in the leaks. The Chair resigned. The party always has a platform, a brand, an agenda and big budgets.

And in 2020 because Bernie had such a strong youth vote (even though he ran a kind of bad campaign this time), Biden moved to the left after winning and put his people on the policy team. Probably the reason he didn't win is that old people who own homes are the most reliable voters - they're the real interest behind everything in the US.

> "Who got special deals in the stimulus and why they got them. In the $2 trillion package, senators took care of their home state industries and pet projects." [2]

I read this article and idk, seems fine to me. It would be quite bad if the airlines went out of business; they have some of the largest union contracts in the US and those would not survive bankruptcy.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by exclusiv on Monday July 13, 2020 @02:20PM (#23823847)
> I mean, evidence suggests this is not true because of the small-donor revolution

You're trying to make a case based on just a handful of candidates.

You missed the whole point on Bernie - which was that the party showed clear bias.

What about the model legislation I linked to? Special interests and corporations creating thousands of bills.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by dTal on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:49PM (#23785640)
Not just US-style. The House of Lords in the UK, a cabal of unelected lifetime appointees without any meaningful oversight, is consistently saner than its elected counterpart. Political parties, and being constantly afraid for one's job, seemingly have quite the detrimental effect.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by mcv on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:08PM (#23785825)
The House of Lords sane? I admit I don't really follow it in any detail, but my impression from various reports was that it was a mess of scandals and corruption. Though I admit that being saner than the House of Commons sounds like a fairly low bar.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by tialaramex on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:18PM (#23786397)
The Lords are a mix of:

* Inherited peers who were supposed to be abolished or at least phased out but then weren't either, just statistically they'll tend to be older and have also inherited riches so while a few are knowledgeable and add value most aren't even decorative. Some of these are just a drain on the purse, they show up to collect "expenses" but don't actually do anything whatsoever. But others insist on having their say even if they nothing to offer.

* Politicians sent there. No better than they were when (or if, some had previously been in high ranking unelected positions) elected. Some of these serve as Ministers. Unlike the US the British cabinet must be selected from Parliament, all the Great Offices (most important) must by tradition comes from the Commons and thus elected MPs. But it's normal (and when your talent pool is a bit empty necessary) to have a bunch of Cabinet Ministers from the Lords. You can deliberately "elevate" people there because you want them for this purpose but as it's a lifetime deal they are still there until they die. The alternative, if someone seems electable, is to "parachute them in" to replace a retiring or dead MP from your party in a by-election, but this is a less certain way and usually much slower.

* Rich people who thought this sounded interesting. In principle you can't buy a place in the Lords. In practice if you are rich enough it's definitely possible though you may look very desperate in the process, particularly if you're in such a hurry that you must be lobby different groups as power shifts from one year to the next.

* Do Gooders. These people at least didn't really set out to be in the Lords and thus could be the voice of the ordinary person. Except they tend to be pretty exceptional - for example the 1980s children's TV presenter Floella Benjamin was made a Baroness, but that's after not only being probably one of the few black women lots of very white children in England saw (on TV) from one week to the next in their childhood but also a lifetime of charitable work.

The best of the Lords are when some expert (say, a person who worked as a General Practitioner seeing NHS patients for four decades before arriving in the Lords) tells the rest of the Lords how things are, and they realise they've just been schooled and vote accordingly. Lords are not required to have a party affiliation (technically neither are the Commons but you're basically useless without one there). So-called "Cross benchers" are common, and relatively powerful.

* A bunch of actual Bishops. They probably shouldn't be there these days, and they mostly stay out of the way because they know that too, but for now they still are. When the Lords was created it made sense to have Bishops. There also used to be Judges, but those are now across the road in the independent Supreme Court.

The Lords often end up doing a lot of the "good" stuff you see the Senate doing. Dragging powerful people in to explain themselves on camera; actually reading the paperwork that the Commons was in too much of a hurry to get out the door and noticing all the horrible technical mistakes. "Did you mean to miss six year olds out for some reason? Or is this age mismatch between paragraphs 16b and 16c a typo?". That sort of thing.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Imnimo on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:00PM (#23786691)
Yeah, but on the other hand, Congress voted to confirm those Supreme Court justices, so maybe I trust Congress more than I think!

Really what I meant was that I trust the supreme court more specifically on the question of whether a body might use a loophole to achieve a political end. I trust Congress less on that because they're a political body and so will naturally pursue political ends. The Supreme Court is at least nominally apolitical, so I trust them to have a bit more restraint on that particular front. The job of a Congressperson is to fight for what they believe should be the law, and I trust them to do that. But that also means I don't trust them to avoid using a loophole to win that fight.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by lr4444lr on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:42PM (#23786562)
The court is supposed to be exactly as you describe as a counterweight to legislators affected by vicissitudes of an electorate every 2 or 6 years. This is a feature, not a bug, of the American republic.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Bud on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:28PM (#23786462)
A "cabal" is by definition a secret political clique or faction which is unknown to the outside world.

It's therefore a big reach to call the Supreme Court a "cabal".

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by labster on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:34PM (#23786500)
Public knowledge of doesn't define a cabal, only the secrecy of its decisions and who it benefits. The Supreme Court hears arguments with no recordings allowed, then makes its decisions in secret. What do they have to hide? And the only thing we ever get from the Court is the hundreds of pages in reasoning as to why they made the decision.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by cvoss on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:08PM (#23787104)
> The Supreme Court hears arguments with no recordings allowed

This could not be further from the truth. Complete audio recordings and transcripts dating back to 1955 are available on oyez.org, the more recent of which are likewise available on the Court's own website. During non-pandemic operation, the Court hearings are open to the public. For the cases argued during the pandemic shutdown, the hearings were, in fact, livestreamed.

You can hear the justices trying on different lines of reasoning for size during these arguments. So in a very real sense, we get to see a lot of their decision-making process.

Yes, they hold a private conference at which some discussion and the vote takes place. I wouldn't have it any other way. I don't want any of the justices to face social pressure in that moment.

> hundreds of pages in reasoning as to why they made the decision

This reads as an argument against the position that the Court is secretive.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by arkis22 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:42PM (#23786941)
The court is actually meant to be more trusted than congress. They don't pass laws, they just interpret them. That's why there's only 9 members and why supreme court appointments are taken so seriously.

There was a contentious period during the great depression where FDR threatened to pack the court. A serious infringement on what is supposed to be an impartial court.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:52PM (#23785664)
> Still, it seems weird that Congress wouldn't get a say in determining what their own bills mean when there's a dispute.

That's an interesting point that has me thinking.

My feeling on this is that this is actually as designed. Congress' job is to pass laws after writing them in whatever way they deem prudent. But Congress doesn't really have an interest in the enforcement of those laws, up until the point their constituents come to them and say "hey, this law y'all passed, it isn't really working out... do something to make it better". And if there's a dispute as to the enforcement of those laws, an independent third party (the judiciary) mediates and decides, as seems appropriate. But, again, Congress doesn't get involved there, because it's the executive's job to actually apply the law.

If Congress does get a say in interpretation, that means they could change their minds on existing law as political winds change, without going through the proper process of passing new legislation. They shouldn't get to do that, especially not for laws that are already on the books. That would amount to the power to write ex post facto laws, which are considered such a bad idea that they're expressly forbidden by the US Constitution. I think the risk of passing a law that gets interpreted in a wildly different way than Congress' intent isn't that high, and in cases where it does happen, it's usually because culture has fundamentally changed over time. Congress' remedy of passing a new law, but one that will only cover future cases, is a fair trade off, I think. And in cases where there's a big screw-up, I'd expect it would get noticed fairly quickly once cases start hitting the courts, so Congress would have the opportunity to fix things, but only have a short window of time where unintended consequences happen.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by FactolSarin on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:17PM (#23786389)
It actually depends on the judge whether the lawmaker has a say in it. Traditionally, most judges looked to the legislature for this kind of thing, but that type of judge has been in rapid decline over the last few decades.

Let's take an example. Imagine a municipality wanted to pass an anti-electric scooter law. So they pass a law that bans "electric scooters, electric bicycles, and other such electric motor powered conveyances not generally used by handicapped people" from city sidewalks.

Then one day someone gets arrested for driving a mobility scooter on the sidewalk (like, the three-wheeled things in Wal-Mart, not a Bird). Is this covered by the law? On one hand, it explicitly bans "scooters" and this is a scooter. On the other hand, it says it doesn't target conveyances generally used by the handicapped.

So the court takes it up. Traditionally, a judge might look a the transcripts of the city council as evidence, and find that the line about handicapped vehicles was inserted by a city councilman who said he specifically wanted to allow mobility scooters. When he said this to the rest of the council, they unanimously agreed to add the exemption. So with this very clear evidence of legislative intent, the judge rules that mobility scooters are fine.

Another judge is a textualist. This is an increasingly popular way to look at laws in judicial circles right now. A textualist doesn't care about what the city council meant only what the law says. The text of the law is the text of the law, period.

Which sounds convincing, but the problem with that is two people can look at a law that's a bit vague or seems to conflict in two places, and come up with different readings. One textualist might say, sorry, mobility scooters are banned. Hell, the law is called the "Get Scooters Off Our Sidewalks Act." It's a dumb law, the judge says, but that's what it says.

Another textualist looks at the same law and says, of course it doesn't mean mobility scooters. Any idiot can see that!

The great thing about textualism to a judge is it basically boils down to "the law is what I think it is." And they can ignore the legislature's opinion. It gives judges much more power. Which is why it's popular with the kind of judges that like to overturn precedent like Scalia was.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:55AM (#23788277)
I think there's a difference, though. I'm fine with (and agree with) the idea of your example of looking back at the city council transcripts and finding that the intent was obvious, and going with that. But I think at least some of this thread is about the idea that the legislature could have some sort of effective litigation or consultation power at the time a law is disputed.

At that point, it might be many years since the law was passed; its original authors could be retired or even dead. In that case, I don't think it's fair to allow the (current) legislative body a seat at the table, because they don't have the context to provide input on the original meaning, and would likely ignore that anyway and try to push their personal agenda.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by michaelt on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:10PM (#23785838)
> Still, it seems weird that Congress wouldn't get a say in determining what their own bills mean when there's a dispute.

Ah yes, rule by Humpty Dumpty, where you don't know what the words they used mean until they tell you, and words mean what they choose them to mean, neither more nor less.

If it were a law passed by the current congress, then maybe they would have some insight into their own intentions. But I don't see that the congress of 2020 is any better informed about what the congress of 1909 intended than you or I.

And even under the same congress the idea a law could have a secret meaning, passed by congress but defined only in their minds and unknowable to those under their rule, seems completely contrary to the idea of the rule of law.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by veridies on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:49PM (#23785635)
> Still, it seems weird that Congress wouldn't get a say in determining what their own bills mean when there's a dispute.

That's true, although you might argue that Congress should be clearer when they write their laws to begin with.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by smegger001 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:52PM (#23786203)
Require simple easily parsable English and as little ambiguity as possible. and then well define every term and phrase. include commenting much like code in the law it self. Along with a version history and changelog for with reasons given for each change.

But we live a the world of common law tradition in the US. and law unfortunately or not does not behave like code.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by lilott8 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:16PM (#23785897)
To ruminate about this a bit, let's assume our Congress critters never change. So Congress passes law "X" during Congress "Y". It is now 50 years in the future. Who do we ask about the intent of the law? Do we ask the initiators, cosigners, committee, do we take a survey of the entire congress? I'm not trying to prove any point -- I'm genuinely interested in understanding how this could play out!
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by SamReidHughes on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:55PM (#23785098)
Congress isn't the same Congress that passed the bills.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Imnimo on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:04PM (#23785210)
That's a good point. I don't really have a sense for whether the legal system makes any differentiation between different sessions of Congress, or whether it's just viewed as one continuously-operating entity. Like would Congress be able to retroactively-clarify their intent if the law was very recent and the same Congress was still in session?
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by pdonis on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:08PM (#23785818)
> I don't really have a sense for whether the legal system makes any differentiation between different sessions of Congress, or whether it's just viewed as one continuously-operating entity.

Congress as an institution is one continuously operating entity. But the important question legally is not what Congress is, but what the actual text of the statute passed by Congress and signed by the President is. That is the law. In other words, the Constitution does not say "whatever Congress says is the law". It lays out a specific process by which laws get passed, and says what the limitations of that process are (no ex post facto laws, which means Congress can't pass a law that says some previous law meant something different, and have that retroactively apply).

> would Congress be able to retroactively-clarify their intent if the law was very recent and the same Congress was still in session?

No, but they could pass a new statute repealing the old one, or replacing it with new language, which would limit the time the old statute was in effect.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by kelnos on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:08PM (#23785821)
Congress has no ability to do this, period. If they screw up and pass something ambiguous that gets interpreted contrary to their desires, their only remedy is to pass a new law to fix the problems. That will only -- by design -- cover new cases, as they are constitutionally barred from passing legislation that takes retroactive effect.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by jacobwilliamroy on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:06PM (#23785797)
Congress controls the reservation system. It's not real sovereignty. That's one of many reasons why there is such large debate over accepting federal recognition among Kanaka specifically. At that point the federal government controls the land, distributes it, decides who is and is not eligible to use the land. The government literally stole my friend's house just by revising the definition of "hawaiian" and telling her she was not eligible.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by lostcolony on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:48PM (#23785012)
I'm not sure it matters. Whether Congress creates a new law overwriting the old, or passes one that tries to explain the old differently than it was executed on, if anyone doesn't object it's moot, and if anyone does, it will end up in the courts.

Particular to this case, Congress could do either, and either way the courts will have to decide whether it's fair to do. But, also particular to this case, Congress has done neither, so the courts were left with interpreting what Congress last decided.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by charwalker on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:40PM (#23785547)
I think they could, but even if it matched the SCoutUS decision it could only apply going forward or it would be unconstitutional via Section 9.3 on barring ex post facto laws. Now if Congress were to pass a law saying not that something 100 years ago meant XYZ but that as of the sign date the reservation no longer exists, that might pass 9.3 but if that bill hits the courts, lower courts would need to reference this case and probably conclude that it isn't a correct application and ax it.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by thefounder on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:35PM (#23784861)
I believe the Congress can simply enact a new law and say there is no such thing as a reservation and the law would he constitutional. That being said it would be similar with China's latest laws on HK if not worse.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Jabbles on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:11PM (#23786349)
I believe the answer is here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ex_post_facto_law#United_State...

Congress is prohibited from passing ex post facto laws by clause 3 of Article I, Section 9 of the United States Constitution.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by anthonygd on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:41PM (#23784933)
No. Congress writes laws but they're supposed to be careful because the Supreme Court interprets.

They'll essentially have to create a new bill (or tack this on to something else going through) and go through the full process, i.e. get senate approval and the presidential signature.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by pdonis on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:05PM (#23785784)
> Is Congress empowered to clarify the meaning of its own past statements?

I don't think so. The statute is the actual text that is passed by both houses of Congress and signed by the President. Congress does not have the power to "interpret". It only has the power to pass a new statute, which can only be in effect as of the date of its passage (when the President signs it). Anything Congress says or does that does not follow the process given in the Constitution for passing a law is not a law and does not have the force of law.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by R0b0t1 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:11PM (#23785841)
But what if the court were being intentionally obtuse and kept interpreting laws in face of the facts and the intent of congress? You need to consider this as something less brazen could be used to undermine congress' authority.

The judicial branch de facto has the most power of any branch in the US. The positions are not elected.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by learnstats2 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:50PM (#23786605)
> But what if the court were being intentionally obtuse and kept interpreting laws in face of the facts and the intent of congress?

This would apply for whichever organisation is responsible for interpreting the existing law: there has to be some such organisation, with significant political power: especially where this power is centralised as in the US Supreme Court, rather than distributed.

Giving the executive this power, of unlimited re-interpretation the words of its previous incarnations, seems unwise and worse. Should congress be able to say about the negotations of its predecessors, "ah, in retrospect the previous session didn't mean it like that"?

This is recognised as judicial independence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judicial_independence#Theory_o...

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by pdonis on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:24PM (#23787200)
> Giving the executive this power

I think you mean the legislative branch, since you say "Congress".

Although the way most "law" is made now, Congress delegates so much of the details to executive agencies that the executive arguably does have the de facto power to re-interpret the laws passed by Congress.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by learnstats2 on Friday July 10, 2020 @06:21AM (#23789940)
Thanks for the correction :)
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by pdonis on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:27PM (#23786456)
> what if the court were being intentionally obtuse and kept interpreting laws in face of the facts and the intent of congress?

Arguably the court has been doing that in many cases for a long time. But I don't think the court was doing that in this particular case.

The only recourse is to change, over time, who sits on the court.

> The judicial branch de facto has the most power of any branch in the US.

Yes, agreed.

Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by rileymat2 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:36PM (#23786516)
If there was something like that, congress can impeach judges.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by astura on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:49PM (#23786599)
Federal judges can be impeached
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by goodluckchuck on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:48PM (#23786978)
No, it doesn’t mean Congress has that power. That question hasn’t been decided. That question would be raised if congress attempts to change the law. Until then, a Congress is bound by the Court’s interpretation of what the law is/was/means. In short, Congress lack the authority to tell the courts what a prior law meant. If they’re not happy with the interpretation then. Ingress has to change the words of the statute / treaty.
Re:U.S. Supreme Court deems half of Oklahoma a Native Americ... by Laremere on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:47PM (#23787322)
If your interested in this kind of stuff, I highly recommend the podcast "What Trump Can Teach Us About Con Law". It's a podcast focused on constitution law rulings made by the supreme court. Often looking at a current court ruling, giving historical context with historical cases that laid down precedent. The political disdain for Trump comes through the hosts a little bit, but I think it's fairly neutral in it's evaluation of the cases, and very educational.

As I understand it: The court's job is to interpret the law under specific circumstances.

As a stupid example, lets say that congress makes a law that you can't have those fake flamingos on your lawn, else you'll go to jail. Fred ignores the law and puts some fake flamingos on their lawn. The executive branch enforces the laws, so the police arrest Fred. The courts rule that you violated the law, so to jail you go.

Bob is rebellious, so he paints his fake flamingos with orange spray paint. The police arrest Bob under that law, and in court he argues a core characteristic of Flamingos is that they're pink. So really he just has decorative orange birds in his lawn. If the court agrees with his argument, then he goes free. This sets a precedent: The judicial branch didn't really make any laws here, but they kind of did. Courts don't have the power to make laws and decide on a case by case basis what's legal or not. So they take breaking precedent as a really, really big deal.

Now what congress can do is go back and make any birds in the form of flamingos illegal, no matter the color. Now that the law has changed, the courts will use a new interpretation, and Bob could now be arrested if he doesn't take down his "decorative orange birds".

However, he could make another argument in court: That he has the first amendment right to have orange flamingos because that's freedom of speech. The courts (possibly up to the supreme court) can rule that he is indeed protected by the first amendment, and nullify congress's law.

Of course, the constitution can be amended. So if people really hated fake lawn flamingos, they could go through that process and remove the first amendment's protection in this case. The bar for changing the constition is so high that it basically doesn't happen for anything political.

This is why the supreme court's rulings can be so politicized, against the court's wishes. The courts aren't political because they don't make laws, and are intended to be impartial interpreters of it. However a 5-4 split supreme court ruling today is basically law until there's a super-super-majority of people who want to change it.