A conversation I had with a person yesterday. Him: My older coworkers asked me if I use all the new apps like Tik-Tok and Robinhood. Me: With everybody being free now, theres no real reason to start with robinhood. Him: "But is it as easy. If not, dont care."
My counterargument was customer service, but was not persuasive. He has no intention of ever picking up a phone or asking for help. He wants a toy to play with, while he and his friends cant be at the casino. The majority of his money is at Vanguard, hes not moving it to robinhood. It's just something to look at everyday for some entertainment value. Its the same mindset where "I made x today (or at the casino)" but ignore the losses or how much they put in. This is the same group of friends that are excited their $75 in dogecoin is up 50% today, or who are playing with options against Draftkings for the thrill of it. Gambling on gambling. Fun. Games. Thrill.
I can't say with a straight face that the Schwab or Fidelity have mobile apps that are as simple to pick up or navigate. They involve more clicks, and buried options. Free gave robinhood publicity and got people to give it a try. UX keeps them around. If Schwab, Fidelity, Merril, Goldman Sachs/Marcus want to compete in this space, they need lite versions of their platforms that are true mobile first apps AND some kind of value add above Robinhood to lure people to try it and convert. Maybe these arent the customers they are looking for, some of them at least.
I tried placing an option trade on Fidelity web version on desktop. It took me forever to figure out how, and even if I memorized the flow, it would still be much much slower and annoying than on RH. And that's on web, I don't even want to mention how bad it is on their mobile app.
I get that Fidelity operates on "if it ain't broken, don't fix it" principle, but sorry, UX matters a lot to users. And when a vastly superior in UX alternative appears, you cannot just sit and do nothing.
Due to all of that, Fidelity has been designated to be used solely for 401k management for me (which is almost automatic anyway).
After the outages, I don't see why a sophisticated trader who's doing option trading would trust Robinhood. I trade at IB and am very happy there. Just my 2 cents.
Why do you like IB? Genuine question, because that's the one I've never tried, but now I am curious to try it out, so I want to know what the major things that drew you to it are.
0. https://www.barrons.com/articles/robinhood-trading-app-has-o...
This stock market upheaval some other brokers are trying to have competitive margin rates, but in the past downturn when I was broker shopping, IB was blowing others away with ~2% rates while everyone was at ~7%.
IB is very much targeting advanced consumers all the way up to small funds and trading shops, so you can do a lot on their platform if you're interested.
I really appreciate this perspective. I am way more into options trading, while keeping my savings in regular stocks, so I don't manually trade stocks much. But it is still good info to know, in case I change my mind on it later.
I don't know that good UX is a positive for society in this scenario.
I should be the only person to decide that, already there are strict regulations about day trading, volume of trades on a mobile platform, access to margins and access to after hours trading.
Robinhood adheres to all these regulations and doesn't easily dole out features to anyone.
You losing all your money impacts you. You and millions of other people losing all their money at the same time impacts society; they can't pay bills to their creditors, then those creditors can't pay, and soon enough we're talking bank runs and financial collapse.
If I want to gamble away a windfall $200K inheritance, I can easily and legally go to Vegas and have my loss "impact society." Why shouldn't I instead be allowed to invest that in a startup?
The entire country is in the stock market (401k and pensions, etc.) so gambling with valuations has real impact on things that aren't just you, and the blast radius of harm is so much larger. We already saw this happen in the Great Depression; bank runs, sudden, massive tightening of liquidity that screwed over creditors and suppliers in a cascading fashion, etc.
The real fundamental issue is that QE as the overwhelming response to 2007 mostly just massively inflated stocks and other rich people assets without meaningfully improving the financial prospects of middle and working class people, so now everyone is clamoring at the gates to be let in at the stock market. Look at how quickly BTC became a numbers game rather than the actual useful intrinsic value, with people who couldn't give two shits about the blockchain.
I am not against regulations, I think all existing regulations are perfectly adequate to protect inexperienced investors from themselves.
If I lose ALL my investments, it doesn't change my way of life or status in society. I have no dependents or collateral.
On the other hand, if my investments pay off, I have a real shot of upward social mobility within 5 years, instead of 5 decades.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/why-free-trading-on-robinhood-i...
After that come back and see how the WSJ article is just a poorly written hit piece on RH.
So I read Patrick's article and now I'm back. You're wrong.
Both articles are saying that Robinhood makes much more money from order flow than other brokerages. The WSJ is saying that this is because Robinhood takes the market makers' price improvements to itself instead of passing it on to their clients. Patrick is saying that Robinhood makes more money off of order flow because options trading (which Robinhood does a lot of) is much more profitable for the market makers. Now both hypotheses might be true. Robinhood could be offering their clients worse prices and at the same time get paid more by the market makers because of lots of options trading. I don't see anything in Patrick's article that contradicts the WSJ's explanation.
And given the following quote, I think the WSJ's analysis is pretty convincing:
One executive with a high-speed trading firm that executes orders for Robinhood said its price improvement is much worse than that of competing brokers.
tl;dr you're not getting screwed by Robinhood selling your order flow, you're getting a benefit.
It gives people a similar experience to buying a Total Stock Market ETF, but still lets them have some runway to be foolish. The 30% nanny state of investing software.
I have plenty of experience in this, both my own behavior and that of many people I know.
This doesnt make sense, either you have more money and can retire earlier, or you dont.
1. I prefer passive investing. I already have one job.
2. More risk = more reward. I've purposely chosen this as my risk level.
3. Regardless of whether I'm smart or not, I'm not going to consistently beat the guy who eats-sleeps-and-drinks investing. Oh, and there are millions of him.
4. I believe it WILL allow me to retire earlier (given the power of compound interest and time).
If you like picking stocks and are demonstrably good at it, why are you messing around with doing it on your own instead of starting a hedge fund and having other people pay you for the privilege?
Active investors, who are professionals, that manage less than 50 million see extremely high returns. Commonly over 100%. When you get into the billions, you cannot make the same trades, and your clients DO NOT want you to loose their money. It is more so about simple wealth preservation.
Raising capital to start your own fund is extremely difficult, expensive, has extensive legal bookkeeping, and requires an immaculate pedigree. I work for FAANG and aggressively invest my money, will be retired before 40.
Source is I used to work at a hedge fund
Active investors, who are professionals, that manage less than 50 million see extremely high returns. When you get into the billions, you cannot make the same trades, and your clients DO NOT want you to loose their money. It is more so about simple wealth preservation.
I could go on and on. But I'm busy.
Source is I used to work at a hedge fund
Robinhood actually sent me an email and follow-up on outages, even though it didn't affect me one bit.
Robinhood actually gives tools and resources to explore and learn about investing, instead of it being "experts" only.
Every software platform has bugs and user issues but that risk is far outweighed by the services provided.
(None of this makes Robinhood good; it's just that PFOF doesn't explain why they're bad).
> the cost basis of trading with you is lower than with trading with the broader market
But this is exactly why Robinhood is bad. Trading with you (a retail investor) has a lower cost basis because retail investors are reliably less sophisticated than institutional investors. Therefore: an institution will pay to take the other side of a series of trades with you because it knows you aren't sophisticated, so it's likely to win in the long run.
From there, follow the incentives: Robinhood is incentivized to sell more order flow; which it does by increasing its trading volume; which it does by making trades easier. Robinhood is also incentivized to increase its net revenue per trade; which it does by increasing the price at which it can sell a given volume of order flow to institutions; which it does by making its average trade less sophisticated.
In summary: The most obvious way for Robinhood to optimize its revenue is to get its investors to make lots of bad trades.
It's not about winning or losing, it's about getting "run over" by massive momentum. Retail investors move less volume and randomly take both sides of trades, so it's much less risky to trade with them. Conversely, large players can dump so much volume that they move the price against a market maker and decimate their revenue from whatever very small spread they usually collect.
> The most obvious way for Robinhood to optimize its revenue is to get its investors to make lots of bad trades.
Robinhood doesn't care whether trades are good or bad. A discount brokerage is a moving business, not a storage business (unless you count interest on cash balances, which Robinhood doesn't make much from). They make money from retail investors doing a lot of trades. Arguably that's against the interest of the investors because retail investors tend to make bad trades, but there's no malice on the part of Robinhood there. If all their clients made a lot of money presumably they'd use it to make more trades and make Robinhood more money.
The money they're making is just the spread. They can safely quote better spreads to retail investors than they can to execution firms trading for giant funds.
That concern might exist because I'm selling a big position and my order is the tip of that iceberg, as you say; but it could also exist because I'm trading on news that hasn't yet been incorporated into the share price, and my order will be followed by many other people selling once they learn that news themselves.
So, let's say you are trading 1000 shares. Normally, you might pay around $10 for that with a real broker. Now you execute that same trade at RH (or some other zero-commission broker), and let's say your average price is just 2c worse than what the other broker would get you. Well, now you just paid $20 for your "free" trade. And this gets worse for odd-lot orders (those that are not multiples of 100 shares). Because with those the MM is not bound to the NBBO, and can give you an even worse fill. Given that a lot of these RH accounts are presumably rather small, that likely applies to a decent amount of orders executed.
> the cost basis of trading with you is lower than with trading with the broader market
These are market makers; they don't take directional bets, hence this is irrelevant, as they only trade in a reactive way while trying to maintain a neutral book. What you are presumably talking about is toxic (i.e. informed) vs non-toxic order flow. Having a big player, who knows more than the MM, is what they are afraid off, because they can lose a lot of money by being on the wrong side of the market. They know that retail traders are unlikely to be informed traders, hence their order flow is less risky. However, the volume retail traders are moving is a drop in the bucket compared to what instis do.
I'd love to know how that split gets decided. I guess it's "as much as possible to the brokerage without looking so lopsided that someone writes an article about it", except at brokerages like IB that publish data on execution quality and try to market based on that? Do the contracts between the brokerages and the market makers specify the quality of execution in any detail, or is that just a long-term reputational thing?
HFTs like retail orders because they don’t move the market, so you can collect some of the spread without worrying about getting run over by an informed institutional player.
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2018-10-16/carl-i...
Is this actually true? If so it blows me away this this is not illegal, or that the press hasn't destroyed them for it.
RobinHood is has one of the most ridiculous branding efforts ever: 'borne of the Occupy Wall Street' movement, the idea was to empower Millennials to 'break the system' ... by 'buying into the system'??? It's like the perfect script written by a NY agency for a bank to re-position the exact same financial products under the banner of a ridiculous 'empowerment branding', like Exxon creating a hipster brand to sell 'clean oil'.
"Robinhood Raises $323M to Democratize Finance For All" [1].
"Trading app tries to fix a 'rigged' financial system" [2] from CNN.
How does a startup get major news agencies to consistently promote their narratives unchallenged, especially when they're so ridiculous? We saw this a lot with WeWork as well.
I can't figure out is how the press, particularly CNN bought into hook-line and sinker especially early on. They've been consistently promoting Robin Hood and their 'empowering message' with fluff stories, not remotely critical of the materiality of the business. Have a look [3]
Recently, they've started to question some things, and perhaps the press will fall out of love with them and it'll be narrative in the other direction.
There is absolutely something amiss here, if anyone with deep relationships in the PR and story placement care to comment, it would be enlightening as I think that's a big part of the underlying story.
Edit: another great example of the press point-blank driving RH's branding, in this case 'intergenerational' [4]. What kind of agency can get this kind of coverage?
[1] https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2019/7/21/robinhood-raises-3...
[2] https://www.cnn.com/videos/business/2018/09/21/robinhood-fou...
[3] https://money.cnn.com/2017/09/08/investing/robinhood-baiju-b...
[4] https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/robinhood-and-merry-millen...
"Schwab earned 1.4% of revenue from payment for order flow, TD Ameritrade about 8.4%, and E*TRADE about 6.1%. Interactive Brokers has historically been quite reticent about participating in internalization, because it doesn’t play well with their sophisticated clients; they earn about 1.1% from it."
Scroll down to "payment for order flow" https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/6/26/how-brokerages-make-mone...
Schwab sells theirs as a feature/benefit. https://www.schwab.com/public/schwab/active_trader/trading_t...
"Why Robinhood earns more than the discount brokerages for order flow is readily apparent: their product encourages options trading. This is bad for customers, principally because the supermajority of Robinhood customers do not understand options trading and the risk/reward calculus for them is even more borked than it is for the vast majority of people who engage in it. The options trades they engage in are also less liquid, and so have higher spreads, and so are more lucrative for marketmakers, "
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_best_bid_and_offer
[2] https://www.investopedia.com/robinhood-hit-with-usd1-25-mill...
I would hope that most people left their platform after they had those major outages during volatile trading days a few months ago. Any place that has outages lasting that long without properly explaining what happened shouldn't be licensed to deal in securities.
Now they're just preying on people that aren't knowledgeable in the financial markets by showing them how "easy" it is to trade. I have studied and worked in finance, and I'll be the first person to tell you, trading isn't the least bit "easy" and shouldn't be portrayed as such.