School for me was a special sort of hell where I was able to read at a 12th grade level in 3rd grade, and yet a decade later was in class with people who could not yet read. I would stare at the clock and switch between sleeping and being insanely bored.
I'm 31 years old now and I feel I have enough life experience to call it what it was: Neglect. I was left in a corner to rot in child jail for a over a decade, during some of the most important years of my life, and constantly punished for the crime of being a bored young person whose time is being wasted.
And let me add to "child jail": not only was I sent somewhere to be bored for several hours a day, I was drug out of bed far before my body wanted to be awake to be sent there.
Thankfully I was still able to pull myself out and try to repair the family as an adult. And I like the person I am now, with the experience and relationships I have, so I don't need the past to change, but things could have turned for the worse just as well. I am fighting negative/destructive thoughts (as in "oh if you did this to me I would beat you SO HARD", not suicidal) to this day.
My children will never go near a school.
(Edit: I really wonder who and why downvotes this)
* majority that's absolutely horrible at their job, whose only goal is to average all the children. Hammer down nails that stick out, and artificially inflate grades of struggling children without helping them at all.
* few great motivated teachers, who are genuinely great.
Usually the latter ones were part of protests, or some anti communist movement. at least in my experience.
Supposedly all communist countries had gifted programs, but those were stripped/forgotten in transitional era(at least over here).
Small observation: i haven't met any PE teacher that was part of the second group, nor any of my friends(and their friends) ever did.
I am very sure that I would do something really bad to the school and teachers if I didn't meet the school's IT teacher, who pulled me out of some of the really bad lessons to work on computers with him, and was the only person who viewed me positively and treated me like a human. I am still coming back to visit him.
He just asked us at the beginning of the year what we wanted to do, we all replied that we wanted to do 5-a-side football indoors so he organized that.
I read the story of Thomas Edison and think what would have happened to him in our time. He would have been medicated up the wazoo until he finally became a quiet, docile little boy who sat in class and did as he was told. I doubt he would have however turned in the massively productive revolutionary inventor (with apologies to Tesla of course) that he did.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/thomas-edisons-mom-lied-ab...
> One day I overheard the teacher tell the inspector that I was “addled” and it would not be worthwhile keeping me in school any longer. I was so hurt by this last straw that I burst out crying and went home and told my mother about it. Then I found out what a good thing a good mother is. She came out as my strong defender. Mother love was aroused, mother pride wounded to the quick. She brought me back to the school and angrily told the teacher that he didn’t know what he was talking about, that I had more brains than he himself, and a lot more talk like that. In fact, she was the most enthusiastic champion a boy ever had, and I determined right then that I would be worthy of her and show her that her confidence was not misplaced.
According to the snopes page, he was taught by his mother until age 16
partial /s
I think you have crystallized the essence of much of our educational system. A sort of daycare/prison that also selects winners and losers (usually somewhat capriciously or even maliciously), with large rewards and punishments.
In 6mths of her giving up her lunch hour to teach me I'd caught up, In a year I'd passed everyone else, once I realised I could teach myself the things I was interested in (computers and science) there was no stopping me, I lived in the local library and read 2-3 fiction books and at least one factual book a week for the next couple of decades.
School after that was easy, I'd just go get a book and teach myself because the pace at school was too slow.
It's a habit that served me well, the first thing I do when approaching anything new is track down the perceived best book and devour it.
I came from a pretty shitty background (poor and parents with mental health issues) but I ended up with a good career because of Mrs Speck and the thousands of books.
I remember actually saying something along the lines of, if they had asked me any time earlier, I'd've gone for it, but I didn't want to leave the friends I'd made that year.
This set the tone for a large chunk of my schooling: When given the choice, I always ended up choosing the middle path so I wouldn't stand out, even though every time I quickly got to the point where I'd've done fine in the more advanced path. It wasn't until the year before highschool, when a bureaucratic mixup ended up with me skipping a year of math (pre-algebra, which was a full year in my district - jumped straight into algebra), that I realized what I was missing. Then in highschool, the accelerated program only accepted freshman and lasted all four years, so I decided to go for it. Ended up just on the edge of being accepted, but didn't get in because of affirmative action.
Oh, and that group of friends I didn't want to leave way back in elementary school? I drifted away from them barely a year later. I've regretted not just going for the more advanced path ever since.
Eventually, I began to do math at an accelerated pace, and it was wonderful to be with a group of older students closer to my ability level then.
I spent some very unhappy years between ~15 and 24. I wish I'd had the chance for a different youth.
EDIT: unhappy, not happy
I think this is the real issue, irrespective of 'gifted' status. I failed the 11+ in the UK but spent my entire teenage years bored out of my mind and in fear for my physical safety. At 16 I switched to a school where classes were less chaotic and thrived. I graduated with a high 2:1 from Cambridge, so although I'm not 'gifted' in any precocious sense, and probably wouldn't have been picked up by these programmes, I was capable of some kind of academic achievement.
The focus on one end of the bell curve who visibly suffer more than others in the middle obscures the real problem: public schools are underfunded and understaffed. There's a reason why private education provides class sizes of 10-15: At that level teachers are _able_ to respond to the individual needs of all children.
Hiving off <5% into special classes for gifted might be good for those children, but it is socially regressive and ignores the problem for those who remain in sink schools.
My parents were modest and didn't pursue this, nevertheless, everything was easy until it wasn't. The part I never learned properly was effort=reward. I was also diagnosed with ADHD and was on ritalin for several years.
Later school years were bad for me because it involved a lot of rote learning. I did not have the discipline to do this and my grades slipped back to mediocre. University was better and I did very well again. I've done moderately well in my career, top few % of earners but I am unable to break higher because I'm constantly distracted and struggling to complete mundane work tasks which prevents me from getting to the top where my ego says I belong.
I take full acknowledgement of issues, I know it is my own doing. I don't know if it is too late for me to change but I'm slowly (because even here I lack the focus) trying to learn technique to change my entire approach. I've recently started looking at the power of habit forming as a means to improve discipline. I think I could benefit from a very tightly structured day where one thing naturally leads to another. Otherwise I tend to drift in and out of tasks and end of up the web, like now.
Who wants leadership that’s “too good for this shit”
I feel you though, ego is the enemy, though it’s also the engine.
Similar experience for me (apart from the social distancing - never an issue for me) - being told how clever I was by parents, relatives, teachers, class-mates etc from ages 5 or 6 up to early-/mid-teens. It soaks into you and you end up becoming a bit arrogant about things.
For me I had a rude-awakening during my late teens when we did our first "real" exams and I assumed that what with me being so clever, these exams that everyone had to do must be pretty simple. After all, if non-clever people had to sit the same standard exams as someone clever like me, then they must be a walk in a park, right? No need to study or revise! Everyone has been telling me I am so smart for as long as I can remember, so no need to put any effort in - my natural smarts will carry me through! Hurrah!
...the outcome was predictable - I got pretty middling grades of mostly "B"s.
For some I accept that "straight Bs" would be a great outcome, but it was more or less the first time in my life where I had to face up to the fact that I wasn't guaranteed academic success, celebration and congratulations for being so smart from everyone. Instead everyone - myself included - was slightly disappointed in my performance.
Lesson learnt.
Now I have my own kids and wondering what to do if they are smart. I heard someone say something along the lines of "never tell your kids they are smart - instead congratulate them on how well/how hard they worked on something".
Also add ,the only person in my life whom i hate, absolutely inept math teacher in primary school. She managed to strip my ability to do calculations in head, and quite literally failed me for being too good at mental calculations as i must've been cheating.. despite solving it at blackboard standing next to her.
I was fortunate, my elementary was a magnet that did all kinds of experimental learning. I had to bus all the way across town (small town) to go there, but for my parents it was worth it.
Some experiments were elementary went to 6th grade, we learned french, and 2nd and 3rd grade were combined for awhile montessori style. However, even at the magnet, in 5th grade three of us were far enough ahead that they gave us an algebra book (9th grade) and had us self teach. But at least there were 3 of us, and Im still friends with them 40 years later.
For high school I went to a university affiliated magnet high school which ran 5 years starting at 7th and was created to serve the children of professors at the university. I didnt want to attend but my parents essentially coerced me.
I was reasonably challenged the whole time and it was a safe place to be a nerd. The school let you start taking community college and university classes when you were ready. The classes werent designated as AP classes, but they still prepared students for the AP. My sophomore high school chemistry textbook ended up being my university chemistry textbook.
I would say the school worked. Around half the class of 40 are professors. My kids are not really gifted so I wont push them in that direction, but where I live now has a very good set of magnet middle/high schools.
I agree that the pacing is slow in public schools. Kids probably only get 2-3 hours of actual learning each day. Our kids go to a spanish immersion private school that also teaches chinese. They typically are a year ahead of public school. For example my first grader started multiplication and fractions by the end of the year. However with us all being home due to covid we have moved him even faster than the accelerated curriculum and are pretty much done with the second grade curriculum this summer. I would not even classify him as gifted so more kids can probably go faster than the typical public school curriculum.
Ultimately in bigger cities the options exist via private schools, charter schools, and magnet schools but a lot depends on the parents' motivation and knowledge. I think for all the bad rap public schools get, they do a decent job of teaching the bulk of kids.
From the very beginning, I entered kindergarten as the only one in my class able to read. The teacher, doing her best, sent me off to read by myself in the corner as she taught the rest of the class. In the years where your brain is programmed to adapt itself to the environment it expects for the rest of life, I only ever had to do things which were to me trivially easy. There was this constant social distance and having to put on a sort of mask in order to interact with my "peers". At the same time everyone around me was always telling me how smart I was.
Everything was easy until it wasn't and my subconscious was simply unprepared to cope with not everything being trivial and socially making it very hard to actually be myself around people because of this very strongly built in assumption that nobody cares about what I think in conversation (amongst other things) so that I simply couldn't think of anything to say.
The struggle is real and never really has gone away.