Re:Academic acceleration in gifted youth: a 35-year longitud...
by phkahler on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:50AM
(#23759232)
Same thing regarding kids. I like to split it and attribute their success to effort and a bit of inherent awesomeness. I think it's good to build self-worth while also sending the message that you have to make the effort to get good results. Failures are simply due to not putting in enough practice right?
Re:Academic acceleration in gifted youth: a 35-year longitud...
by mattlondon on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:13AM
(#23759476)
Hmmm I like the idea of "awesomeness" - really positive thing to say, but also whimsical and flimsy enough to not really carry any actual concrete meaning with regards to academic skills etc. Nice.
Similar experience for me (apart from the social distancing - never an issue for me) - being told how clever I was by parents, relatives, teachers, class-mates etc from ages 5 or 6 up to early-/mid-teens. It soaks into you and you end up becoming a bit arrogant about things.
For me I had a rude-awakening during my late teens when we did our first "real" exams and I assumed that what with me being so clever, these exams that everyone had to do must be pretty simple. After all, if non-clever people had to sit the same standard exams as someone clever like me, then they must be a walk in a park, right? No need to study or revise! Everyone has been telling me I am so smart for as long as I can remember, so no need to put any effort in - my natural smarts will carry me through! Hurrah!
...the outcome was predictable - I got pretty middling grades of mostly "B"s.
For some I accept that "straight Bs" would be a great outcome, but it was more or less the first time in my life where I had to face up to the fact that I wasn't guaranteed academic success, celebration and congratulations for being so smart from everyone. Instead everyone - myself included - was slightly disappointed in my performance.
Lesson learnt.
Now I have my own kids and wondering what to do if they are smart. I heard someone say something along the lines of "never tell your kids they are smart - instead congratulate them on how well/how hard they worked on something".