News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by gambiting on Sunday July 05, 2020 @09:54AM (#23738652)
100% with you. I absolutely hate the material design, it's the least intuitive way to use a computer. Paired with touch-first interfaces it's one of the worst thing to happen to computers.
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by jeroenhd on Sunday July 05, 2020 @01:23PM (#23740286)
I don't hate material design itself, because there's plenty of guidelines for condensed content. It's just that web designers and app artists don't seem to understand that not everything needs whitespace for miles.

A condensed table in material design strikes a nice balance between whitespace and information density in my opinion. It's just sad that nobody uses it.

I'm also that person that has their DPI set to "small" on my phone though. I bought a phone with nearly 6 inches of screen diagonal and I could barely see any more information on it then on my old 3.5" phone from almost a decade ago. Cranked it down in the setting to just above the point where apps start displaying tablet UI on my phone and I've been very happy with it.

We need to take away design from artists and hand it back to specialised UI designers in my opinion. It'd make phones a lot easier to use.

The problem I see with abolishing material design is that a whole range of elderly people have now gotten used to it. Changing all the layouts for apps and websites would quickly lead to a disaster on the scale of Windows 8 for those who can barely grasp technology as it is. I'd much rather keep the waste of whitespace if I couldn't chat with my grandma otherwise.

Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by harrygeez on Sunday July 05, 2020 @10:37AM (#23738992)
Not saying material design is great, but it's a great step up from Holo UI and anything before that in Android.

I just dislike that it became so ubiquitous now and it's a train wreck on desktop

Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by Lammy on Sunday July 05, 2020 @12:48PM (#23740016)
Personally I went through the opposite process. I was a huge fan of Android up to and including KitKat, and I thought Holo was great. My enthusiasm for the entire platform disappeared as soon as Lollipop came out with the dreadful new Material UI. Even with themes I just hated using it on every level and eventually switched to an iPhone.
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by harrygeez on Sunday July 05, 2020 @03:27PM (#23741180)
Material UI and iOS both look more similar than ever. I'm not sure if aesthetic would be the reason to go for an iPhone
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by Lammy on Sunday July 05, 2020 @03:49PM (#23741356)
It was a lot of things around that release. The look, the feel of the "cards" everywhere, the deprecation of power-user features in the name of security (like full SD card read/write access for apps). Totally the right trade for a dumbed-down-but-safe mass-market OS, but that's not why I liked Android. When presented a wannabe iPhone I prefer the real thing :p
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by harrygeez on Sunday July 05, 2020 @11:44PM (#23744490)
I didn't feel that way then but lately I actually felt the same :)
Re:The Comeback of Fun in Visual Design by dagmx on Sunday July 05, 2020 @11:24AM (#23739363)
The original material design spec was a lot more layered than what it’s turned into.