News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by nikivi on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:03PM (#23728380)
Nathan made a thread as a reply to this piece on him

https://twitter.com/NathanTankus/status/1278777095670370304

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by hardwaregeek on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:49PM (#23728688)
I've been thinking about this exact issue with respect to my accomplishments. How much benefit have I drawn from looking like a programmer? I'm an Asian American male with glasses. I fit the part. Looking back, people gave me respect and their ear far before I deserved it. Would I have gotten the same level of encouragement if I were Black? Would I have gotten the same level of respect if I were a woman? Probably not.

Any social engineer can tell you that appearances are half the battle. A white male in a hardhat with a clipboard could get into most construction sites. A white male in a suit could probably get into most office buildings.

There's some rather vehement responses in this thread. I wonder how many people are threatened by the idea that their accomplishments are partially due to them "looking the part" and not just their work and skill.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by ColanR on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:00PM (#23728759)
> Any social engineer

From my readings of pentesters doing social engineering, female pentesters have the vast advantage when trying to gain building access.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by usaar333 on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:28PM (#23728914)
> How much benefit have I drawn from looking like a programmer

On the other hand, our profession does have the benefit of being able to be done with zero knowledge of appearance. In fact, I credit that fact to enabling smart teenagers to make key contributions to open source they otherwise would be excluded from due to assumptions coming from age.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:30PM (#23728925)
On the internet, nobody knows you are a dog.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_...

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by BoiledCabbage on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:51PM (#23729045)
It's a great point you raise, and something that we all should think about.

> There's some rather vehement responses in this thread. I wonder how many people are threatened by the idea that their accomplishments are partially due to them "looking the part" and not just their work and skill.

Additionally I think a lot of people understand the concept of probability and likelihoods, but when it comes to this topic people get very uncomfortable thinking that where they are today is partially due to luck but as well due to structural factors that benefited them unrelated to any active actions they took.

And usually the emotional response is either doubling down on the parts they did control (completely ignoring the fact that plenty of other people put in more effort or did better at those same parts and didn't get as far as they did), or claiming that yes the problem does exist but "not in my area, because no-one actively does anything bad like that", or the other "my intuition says it's a minor issue or an already resolved issue therefore that's true" - which goes against the research that says - no it is a problem.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by CerealFounder on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:32PM (#23728939)
Im a white man who looks like a wrestler, while also the CEO and founder of a pair of very well known companies and I without fail will get "bro" talked to upon first meeting by other guys in all contexts.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by chrisco255 on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:02PM (#23728774)
Dressing for success is not exactly some secret of influence. A black guy in a suit in 2020 is going to be able to get into any office building as well. A black guy with a hard hat is not exactly unheard of on construction sites. It's quite common.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:01PM (#23728767)
> A white male in a suit could probably get into most office buildings.

A woman is going to have a far easier time getting into an office building.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by _hardwaregeek on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:26PM (#23728895)
I appreciate the correction, but frankly this isn't what I hoped people would take away from my comment. My point was that race/gender/appearance plays a large role in gaining access to normally stratified resources
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by M5x7wI3CmbEem10 on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:08PM (#23728796)
aren’t Asian-Americans dominant in every high-paying profession? doctor, engineer, consultant, banker, etc.

I just haven’t seen very many in industries such as education or government

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:11PM (#23728436)
Wow, what a thoughtful way to respond. That level of character is something you certainly can't get with a degree.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by arkis22 on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:07PM (#23728793)
There are quite a few people in the world with a high level of character and no degree
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by fzeroracer on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:50PM (#23729041)
It's unfortunate to see other HN commentators here seeing someone be humble and recognize that their success is the result of a number of different criteria as being an example of 'PC culture gone mad' or that he's just lying to avoid the mob or as a personal attack on them.

There was an example a while ago of the issues black CEOs face in SV [1] and it's just something you'll never see as a cis white man. I've certainly never encountered any issues relating to my race or my gender or how I present myself, but if you're a black man you're already used to dressing a different way to prevent being perceived as a threat [2].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23540162

[2] https://mashable.com/2015/08/08/black-men-dressing-up-police...

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:10PM (#23728428)
Thank you for linking this. Arguments will be made that Nathan is politicizing his spotlight, but he's simply seizing the moment to cast light on a dark and apolitical truth most of us take for granted.

I hope HNers can take the time to read this with an open and introspective heart and mind. Unrolled: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1278777095670370304.html

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by roenxi on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:32PM (#23728582)
He's literally just some dude; he isn't even claiming credentialism. Anyone who complains about him politicising something is looking very hard for reasons to complain.

If making political statements is the reward he wants for doing the legwork to document what the Fed is doing, he can have it.

[dead]
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by danbolt on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:42PM (#23728647)
I think "cis" is a topic related to gender, rather than sex. The term is short for "cisgender". For example, "cis man" and "trans man" are both subsets of men.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by dragonwriter on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:45PM (#23728657)
> I think "cis" is a topic related to gender, rather than sex.

Cisgender and transgender have to do with both sex and gender. Specifically with whether they have the stereotypical or antistereotypical relation.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by danbolt on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:47PM (#23728674)
You're totally right! I probably should have referenced the relationship between the two in my post.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by dkdk8283 on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:12PM (#23728442)
It absolutely is politicized and I find this to minimize his accomplishments.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by bdibs on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:26PM (#23728533)
I don't like this new trend where some people believe certain facts are political. A fact is a fact, no matter which "side" you're on.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:34PM (#23728594)
It is hardly factual that he was only allowed into conferences for being white.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:49PM (#23728682)
Do you think it's factual that it's easier to blend in if you look like everyone else?
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:51PM (#23728697)
That is factual. That would be relevant if conference entry were being managed by snipers searching crowds.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:58PM (#23728742)
Or if you're attending without a badge, which is what Nathan was doing. As someone who's done the same thing... they definitely check at a lot of conferences.

One of the few times I was caught was at a psychoanalysis conference where I stood out for being roughly 20 years younger than most attendees. I wish I had a badge in that case because I was very obviously called out due to my age alone.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by zarathustreal on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:33PM (#23728591)
A parroted opinion, presented without evidence and rigorous scientific research, on the other hand, can very well be just a political statement. Especially the kind of opinion that is given in a context completely unrelated and to an audience of people that never asked to hear it. Regardless of whether being white is a statistical indicator of likeliness to have something meaningful to say, we need to first establish that the consequences of such a thing are negative in the first place. “White privilege” does not exclude others from the same “privilege” - it’s entirely possible for any other attribute-based demographic to accumulate a statistic average as well.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:13PM (#23728450)
Can you help me understand why you believe that highlighting privilege arising from one's innate characteristics is political?
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by smeeth on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:24PM (#23728519)
Not OP but I’d be curious to hear why you think it isn’t.

As best I can tell the distinguishing characteristic between people who believe in the existence of white/male privilege and those who do not is political affiliation.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:57PM (#23729676)
> As best I can tell the distinguishing characteristic between people who believe in the existence of white/male privilege and those who do not is political affiliation.

The people who are not white, not cis-male, or not straight are the people who have encountered consistent barriers as a result of these negations.

These are all immutable parameters, not political affiliations. No one chooses to be white (or not). No one chooses to be male (or not). No one chooses to be straight (or not).

Women? Barriers.

Trans? Barriers.

Black? Barriers.

Middle Eastern? Even though we're classified as white by tax code? Barriers.

Gay? Barriers.

Jewish? Muslim? Even Catholic? (Considering the mental trauma that often arises with rapid disillusionment from religion, this is largely considered immutable) Barriers.

Hispanic? Asian? Aboriginal? Native American? Barriers.

I get that it's uncomfortable to hackernews because we like to think that every startup operates in a meritocratic manner, but that's been consistently proven false just with the sheer volume of white straight cis-men managing and leading companies in the US, Australia, the EU, wherever you look.

tl;dr: it's not political because the people who understand that it's an issue overwhelmingly tend to be the victims, and the people who don't understand that it's an issue mostly tend not to be victims, and the victims tend to be victimized because of immutable traits rather than ideologies.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by Thorentis on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:33PM (#23728943)
Point out your "flaw" before the mob does. Classic tactic. I can't even tell if people are sincere any more, that's how far the PC culture has gone. Nathan now gets a free ride since he has acknowledged his privilege, and has now unlocked new avenues to market his work. Maybe he can get a job as an economic diversity consultant to ensure a perfect racial balance is admitted to conference from now on, given how self-aware he is.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by jlawson on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:32PM (#23728574)
"That I'm a white cis male who dresses in dress shirts and dress slacks(and have done so since I was 19)has given me a passport into conferences,events and more.I crashed conferences without paying during high school that I would have been barred from if I looked any other way"

How does he know? Is there any evidence for this? Were women or blacks 'barred'? Because if so, I would expect someone to sue and win easily.

The rest of the tweets are a stream of similar and all-unsubstantiated accusations. But we can't dispute any of what he said, because he made his accusations without enough specificity for them to be checked in any way. He chose not to name the 2010 conference.

There's nothing trifling about such accusations. Just because nobody is in a position to respond doesn't mean you're not hurting people. Whether the accusations are made against individuals, specific groups, or a whole ethnic group. If you're gonna slag someone you should have evidence, and you should be specific.

In any case, he chose a good strategy to maximize his personal outcomes. He'll benefit greatly from this. D on fairness and principle, A on strategy.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:46PM (#23728667)
It's outrageously easier to fly under the radar if you're white. If you want to look at it in a ridiculously objective way just consider being a black rock on a white sand beach. Even without the concept of racial bias, which is absolutely at play in these situations, you'll be subject to more scrutiny just by not being the norm.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by partiallypro on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:26PM (#23728894)
It's easier to fly under the radar when you act to blend in with your environment. If you went to an economics conference in cargo shorts, you are going to stand out. I am pretty sure that a lot of biases are towards how people dress and act rather than skin color, in this given situation. I've snuck into conferences before, generally there are so many people that as long as you are dressed the part and act appropriately you will not even be noticed. Many of the most prestigious economists in the world are people of color, so I have to say what he's saying is largely nonsense.

Anyhow, MMT is a very popular thing right now, so it's obvious he would get attention regardless of his age, gender or race.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by cbzoiav on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:13PM (#23728824)
On the flip side there are positive racial biases.

i.e. if you're the only non-white but otherwise fit the part / especially if dressed on the smarter end some people are less likely to question you because they don't want to be seen applying a bias. Actively questioning the one black guy is a lot more obvious than actively not questioning him.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:06PM (#23729410)
> less likely to question you because they don't want to be seen applying a bias

Many people aren't immediately conscious of their biases. This isn't the same situation, but I thought this article about being a black CEO was illuminating. I've seen the similar bias-exposing mistakes happen to women.

https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/06/16/for-black-ceos-in-sil...

They're easy mistakes to make (I made an similar mistake by assuming a young woman was a nurse and not a doctor), but the most important bit is to learn and be aware.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by kojeovo on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:18PM (#23728849)
lucky them not being treated like anyone else
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by jlawson on Monday July 06, 2020 @02:42PM (#23751238)
He didn't say it was 'easier to fly under the radar'.

He made a vastly more hurtful claim - that everyone else was 'barred'.

You're simply not responding to the charge that's been made, you've chosen to try to argue a far weaker claim (which is trivially true) instead in the hopes that nobody notices the difference.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by Aloha on Friday July 03, 2020 @08:13PM (#23728827)
It's outrageous to fly under the radar if you look like you're supposed to be there. Being white makes it easier in most cases, but it was not required.