News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:10PM (#23728428)
Thank you for linking this. Arguments will be made that Nathan is politicizing his spotlight, but he's simply seizing the moment to cast light on a dark and apolitical truth most of us take for granted.

I hope HNers can take the time to read this with an open and introspective heart and mind. Unrolled: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1278777095670370304.html

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by roenxi on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:32PM (#23728582)
He's literally just some dude; he isn't even claiming credentialism. Anyone who complains about him politicising something is looking very hard for reasons to complain.

If making political statements is the reward he wants for doing the legwork to document what the Fed is doing, he can have it.

[dead]
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by danbolt on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:42PM (#23728647)
I think "cis" is a topic related to gender, rather than sex. The term is short for "cisgender". For example, "cis man" and "trans man" are both subsets of men.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by dragonwriter on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:45PM (#23728657)
> I think "cis" is a topic related to gender, rather than sex.

Cisgender and transgender have to do with both sex and gender. Specifically with whether they have the stereotypical or antistereotypical relation.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by danbolt on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:47PM (#23728674)
You're totally right! I probably should have referenced the relationship between the two in my post.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by dkdk8283 on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:12PM (#23728442)
It absolutely is politicized and I find this to minimize his accomplishments.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by bdibs on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:26PM (#23728533)
I don't like this new trend where some people believe certain facts are political. A fact is a fact, no matter which "side" you're on.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:34PM (#23728594)
It is hardly factual that he was only allowed into conferences for being white.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:49PM (#23728682)
Do you think it's factual that it's easier to blend in if you look like everyone else?
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aliante on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:51PM (#23728697)
That is factual. That would be relevant if conference entry were being managed by snipers searching crowds.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by aahhahahaaa on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:58PM (#23728742)
Or if you're attending without a badge, which is what Nathan was doing. As someone who's done the same thing... they definitely check at a lot of conferences.

One of the few times I was caught was at a psychoanalysis conference where I stood out for being roughly 20 years younger than most attendees. I wish I had a badge in that case because I was very obviously called out due to my age alone.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by zarathustreal on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:33PM (#23728591)
A parroted opinion, presented without evidence and rigorous scientific research, on the other hand, can very well be just a political statement. Especially the kind of opinion that is given in a context completely unrelated and to an audience of people that never asked to hear it. Regardless of whether being white is a statistical indicator of likeliness to have something meaningful to say, we need to first establish that the consequences of such a thing are negative in the first place. “White privilege” does not exclude others from the same “privilege” - it’s entirely possible for any other attribute-based demographic to accumulate a statistic average as well.
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:13PM (#23728450)
Can you help me understand why you believe that highlighting privilege arising from one's innate characteristics is political?
Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by smeeth on Friday July 03, 2020 @07:24PM (#23728519)
Not OP but I’d be curious to hear why you think it isn’t.

As best I can tell the distinguishing characteristic between people who believe in the existence of white/male privilege and those who do not is political affiliation.

Re:A 28-year-old with no degree becomes a must read on the e... by eganist on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:57PM (#23729676)
> As best I can tell the distinguishing characteristic between people who believe in the existence of white/male privilege and those who do not is political affiliation.

The people who are not white, not cis-male, or not straight are the people who have encountered consistent barriers as a result of these negations.

These are all immutable parameters, not political affiliations. No one chooses to be white (or not). No one chooses to be male (or not). No one chooses to be straight (or not).

Women? Barriers.

Trans? Barriers.

Black? Barriers.

Middle Eastern? Even though we're classified as white by tax code? Barriers.

Gay? Barriers.

Jewish? Muslim? Even Catholic? (Considering the mental trauma that often arises with rapid disillusionment from religion, this is largely considered immutable) Barriers.

Hispanic? Asian? Aboriginal? Native American? Barriers.

I get that it's uncomfortable to hackernews because we like to think that every startup operates in a meritocratic manner, but that's been consistently proven false just with the sheer volume of white straight cis-men managing and leading companies in the US, Australia, the EU, wherever you look.

tl;dr: it's not political because the people who understand that it's an issue overwhelmingly tend to be the victims, and the people who don't understand that it's an issue mostly tend not to be victims, and the victims tend to be victimized because of immutable traits rather than ideologies.