On the other hand, our paper includes one of the world's top aerosol scientists, along with top epidemiologists, biostatisticians, and other experts. https://www.preprints.org/manuscript/202004.0203/v2
The rubbish spouted by CIDRAP about masks is very obviously flawed, as you can see for example here: https://www.fast.ai/2020/04/20/skeptics-masks/#what-about-th...
Osterholm has never written any paper about community mask wearing. He is not an informed authority on this issue. The efficacy of masks has now been very clearly shown in multiple studies, e.g:
https://gh.bmj.com/content/5/5/e002794
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2...
https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2020.00818
> We are also unable to explicitly decompose physical distancing measures into constituent components, such as staying 2 m apart, increased hand washing, and face mask wearing, as the relative effectiveness of these components has not yet been estimated.
Did you post the right link?
And neither are you. Your "paper" on the subject is a joke. I've read it, and I've read the source literature you cite. It is a series of sloppy misinterpretations and mis-representations of the other papers, coupled with the results of running an ad hoc epidemiological model with questionable parameters. It is a quora post, written up like a paper, and pushed to a pre-print server.
You cite papers that are rated by Cochrane (and others) as low-quality, as if they are reliable evidence. You dismiss papers that do not support your conclusions for "lack of evidence", but deflect similar criticisms of your own conclusions with "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence". Quite simply: your analysis wouldn't pass muster at even a third-rate journal, and Osterholm has rightly called you out on it.
It's especially ironic that you say that Osterholm is not an "informed authority" -- he leads one of the country's leading research institutes on infectious disease, has a long history in epidemiology and public health, and spends the better part of an hour-long podcast specifically describing his experience and outlining areas where he has no specific expertise. Say what you want about the man, but he is rigorously honest about his experience. Yet I regularly see you cited as a "mask expert". Where did you do your research, again? Was it when you were getting a philosophy degree, or when you were at Fastmail? Maybe Kaggle has a mask competition?
As for the papers you've cited here: the first link you cite can't separate the effects of social distancing, gloves, masks, and other interventions, and finds mainly that people who take precautions against infection have better outcomes than those who don't. When they actually try to break out masks, specifically, they find that they don't have any effect after illness onset, which should make you doubt legitimacy of the results.
The second link provides no evidence for masks. It is a modeling study.
The third link has the same problem as the first, but worse: it can't possibly separate the effect of masks from everything else that was happening in the examined states at the same time. There is no control.
Maybe some studies are happening now. Even so, it probably makes more sense to encourage people to purchase more reliable masks.
Surely manufacturers and supply chains for conventional masks have caught up with the demand by now?
We have lots of evidence for all of these, and most of that evidence doesn't show any benefit for surgical masks that are not fluid resistant.
That's fine, but there are lots of plausible interventions that have little/no evidence, and we don't mandate those by law. Why this one?
For example, the Lancet study commissioned by the WHO found that eye protection is about as supported by the available literature as surgical masks. Why aren't we all required to wear goggles?
I believe that "science" should not be used to mandate actions that have no scientific data backing them.
"it probably makes more sense to encourage people to purchase more reliable masks."
The issue there is still shortages. I don't buy surgical or n95 masks, because other people need them more than I do.
Because masks are being recommended to work on outgoing virus. Unless you've evidence respiratory viruses spread significantly via jets of air emitted via your eyeballs, this is a weird argument.
If you read the Lancet paper, you'll find that they pooled papers for source control and PPE together to arrive at their conclusions. In fact, most of the papers they used in that meta-analysis were for surgical masks used as PPE (personal protective equipment) in a medical setting.
In other words, the advocates for masking are doing the same thing that you're saying is weird. If you try to break the analysis down according to specific lines of evidence (i.e. source control for the public), you quickly find that there's not enough data to draw any conclusion.
On the other hand, the argument in favor of this kind of pooling is straightforward: if your end goal is to reduce transmission of a virus, and you find that goggles are highly effective at preventing infection, then it doesn't matter very much. Tell everyone to wear goggles instead, and forget about the masks. Transmission will still be reduced.
Mask wearing for COVID is targeted at reducing likelihood of spreading to someone else.
> If you try to break the analysis down according to specific lines of evidence (i.e. source control for the public), you quickly find that there's not enough data to draw any conclusion.
We're going to get a lot of data soon, but for the time being, it's probably best to err on the side of "something that stops droplets probably helps stop a disease spread by droplets".
> Our search identified 172 observational studies across 16 countries and six continents, with no randomised controlled trials and 44 relevant comparative studies in health-care and non-health-care settings (n=25 697 patients). Transmission of viruses was lower with physical distancing of 1 m or more, compared with a distance of less than 1 m (n=10 736, pooled adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 0·18, 95% CI 0·09 to 0·38; risk difference [RD] −10·2%, 95% CI −11·5 to −7·5; moderate certainty); protection was increased as distance was lengthened (change in relative risk [RR] 2·02 per m; pinteraction=0·041; moderate certainty). Face mask use could result in a large reduction in risk of infection (n=2647; aOR 0·15, 95% CI 0·07 to 0·34, RD −14·3%, −15·9 to −10·7; low certainty), with stronger associations with N95 or similar respirators compared with disposable surgical masks or similar (eg, reusable 12–16-layer cotton masks; pinteraction=0·090; posterior probability >95%, low certainty). Eye protection also was associated with less infection (n=3713; aOR 0·22, 95% CI 0·12 to 0·39, RD −10·6%, 95% CI −12·5 to −7·7; low certainty). Unadjusted studies and subgroup and sensitivity analyses showed similar findings.
The important bit here (for everyone saying we have great evidence that masks work) is that "low certainty" bit. That's GRADE, and it means "low certainty (our confidence in the effect estimate is limited; the true effect could be substantially different from the estimate of the effect);" So, maybe masks are substantially less, or more, protective.
Last time it was pointed out "low certainty" doesn't mean what you imply it does (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23434344) you let it sail on by.
Just so we're clear: you've never linked to research to support any of your points, because you're not able to, are you?
I did. 28 days ago.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23434255
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23434053
> Here's what low certainty grade results mean: "low certainty (our confidence in the effect estimate is limited; the true effect could be substantially different from the estimate of the effect);".
You're acting like its definition is "it's probably the opposite, and thus is evidence for my argument".
Here's someone explaining what GRADE means:
https://twitter.com/dnunan79/status/1269014574478626819
"I teach GRADE
If something has “low quality” evidence, it means the observed estimate is highly likely to be different from the truth.
Face masks = low quality evidence.
So what’s the point of GRADE if we can conclude “evidence shows”?"
EDIT: Your link even says this
> Further high-quality research, including randomised trials of the optimum physical distance and the effectiveness of different types of masks in the general population and for health-care workers' protection, is urgently needed
I agree that the rush to penalize people is unfortunate. On the other hand, I'm not sure what we can do (short of a national response) that would be more effective. Making these kinds of policy decisions strikes me as pretty out there for your town council person or even a state level legislator.
If we can't have a rational scientific discussion about facts, we're back to the dark ages.
We're rapidly heading that way. Masks are a political discussion now, not a scientific one. Most other aspects of COVID are the same way. You cannot criticize anything non-politically these days. Even saying "this data is entirely inconclusive" or "the first-order effects of doing this are positive but there are negative second-order effects" is a problem.
I don't have a solution, but I feel your pain.
But, as the article says, when we study this we find a bunch of other things happening that are probably more important. These include symptomatic people self isolating; people more willing to comply with social distancing; better hand washing; earlier close-down; etc.
And this matters because in the US and an a number of other countries, a large proportion of people refuse to wear face masks, and the government doesn't mandate them, and that is bad. And the people who refuse to wear face masks usually also refuse to follow some or all of the other measures. We are talking about a whole bundle of measures here.
>and the virus has exploded
Yes the virus has exploded but not worth going into lockdown, most people are asymptomatic or have mild symptom.
This is not like Ebola where you most likely going to die if u get infected.
In the countries that have had a strong lockdown and other measures, within a few months they had the disease halted and beaten back, and could go back to mostly normal. I think that is vastly better.
If we use ifr 1% then there would be 3 million american which is not bad.
> And the hospitals would be vastly overwhelmed
Only small percentage of hospital has this issue, even then the solution should be to increase hospital capacity.
>And many millions would suffer severe diseases, like for weeks
No different with any other diseases, common cold could make people suffer for weeks too.
> and with many of them there would be strong aftereffects lasting for months
There is no conclusive evidence about the severity and how many are affected.
>In the countries that have had a strong lockdown and other measures, within a few months they had the disease halted
The disease may halt temporarily but the economic cost are enormous then when you reopen the infection come back.
California and Washington both have mask laws and their infection rates have skyrocketed.
But tell me, what do you think the policies should be, for masks and everything else?
"""In one group there have been a strong set of policies to fight the virus, and it includes face masks, and in this group the virus has been beaten back."""
Because you're making it sound much more conclusive than what I've been seeing.
I think you are playing dumb.
Also I explained your description of the policies in California was a gross misrepresentation. Will you agree you got it wrong?
And let me ask you yet again, what policies are you for? That's why this whole argument matters.
There's conclusive evidence that masks help on a micro level by stopping droplets.
It's possible that masks also increase aggregate infection rate by requiring a population uneducated in mask usage to apply a potential plague vector directly to their faces.
It will be shocking if science does come back in the future and indicates that mask usage reduces the chance of spreading covid BUT INCREASES ones chance of contracting it.
Mask usage is important and many people don't know how to use a mask properly. If someone puts a cloth mask on backwards they're inhaling a virus that stays on surfaces for days.
Masks may also increase the chance of infection by causing people to put their hands near their face more often to adjust or don the mask.
Even in the most recent World Health Organization report:
"At the present time, the widespread use of masks by healthy people in the community setting is not yet supported by high quality or direct scientific evidence and there are potential benefits and harms to consider "
Additionally Sweden had no mask laws and its infection rate has stabilized while place with mask laws like Cali and Washington have skyrocketing rates of infection.
Masks have become a religious war and most people accept it without question and have never looked a single shred of research from legitimate sources that aren't news media based.
I personally think it gives people the feeling of power over a powerless situation.
I just hate to see laws forcing people to do something backed by weak science and I hope this isn't like Thalidomide or Lead paint where experts validated something based on weak science that turned out to be wrong.
If there's SARS-CoV-2 on your mask, there'd be SARS-CoV-2 on your unmasked face if you weren't wearing one. Right?
Michael Osterholm of CIDRAP has written a rather scathing summary of the data for cloth masks, and the political and social machinations that have gotten us where we are. He calls out Jeremy Howard as a particularly vocal spreader of scientific misinformation on the topic:
https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/covid-19/podcasts-webinars/specia...
(edit: how can you possibly downvote a link to a factual source that is cited in the article? Consider your bias.)