News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by sillysaurusx on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @08:54PM (#23696591)
Am I the only one who uses piracy to explore new technologies? For example, I pirated ZBrush and spent about a month learning it. At that point I felt I had invested enough time / gained enough skills to justify buying a full license, if I ever need to do more 3D modeling.

I had the same experience with Visual Studio back in the day (aka Visual C++ 6.0; fond memories...), and of course photoshop.

It’s a stupid game, but quite a personal growth vector.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by tomc1985 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:02PM (#23696638)
This is why a lot of software houses don't come down too hard on individual pirates -- they often become your fans and they might result in business in the future. It's like selling concerts and merch as a musician.

Since software dev isn't the domain of lifelong nerds anymore I don't think most folk are as understanding or knowledgeable about the positives of piracy (or related issues around software freedom or the economic properties of digital data), hence your unfortunate downvotes.

It's a shame... there are many of us who would not be where we are today, as productive, value-creating citizens, without having learned our trade with pirated software.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by sillysaurusx on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:11PM (#23696679)
Exactly. I remember begging my mom for Visual C++ 6.0 from eBay for $60 whole dollars when I was like 12, because I had heard that’s what real gamedevs use, and I was determined to become a real gamedev. It’s weird... you can trace that moment to present, and her saying “yes” or “no” would have dramatically changed my economic outcome.

Piracy is a wonderful equalizer in that regard. Companies have every right to come down on piracy, but it often works against you if your software is a tool.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by asciident on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:28PM (#23696762)
What did she say? Don't leave us hanging...
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by sillysaurusx on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @09:45PM (#23696837)
She said yes :) I owe a lot to that decision. It's also helped me understand what "privilege" is – many, many parents would have been like "no, now go do your homework." (I wasn't a very good student.)

But, for example, Visual Studio 2003 Architect Edition was so expensive that I think it was a few thousand dollars at the time. Piracy enabled me to learn that, too. And surprise surprise, when I got into the gamedev industry, that was what they used.

From Microsoft's standpoint, it was nothing but benefit: in addition to adding +1 productive programmer to the world, the piracy also caused me to become something of a Microsoft evangelist, similar to Carmack. It helped me appreciate a good IDE back before Webstorm made it a reality for Javascript.

Of course, that eventually led to discovering Emacs (or rather being forced to learn it due to a twist of fortune) and then evolving into my bearded open-source devil form... Now if only there were an Emacs equivalent for 3D modeling and music, I'd be happy as a clam. Blender is great, but it just can't compete with ZBrush.

EDIT: By the way, I was delighted to discover that Photopea (https://www.photopea.com/) is a completely free, browser-based alternative to Photoshop. It has almost an identical UI, and it does 100% of what I need out of photoshop. We've been paying the $35/mo creative suite license, but I imagine lots of people still pirate it.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by jackson1442 on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:00PM (#23697306)
If you're wanting desktop software, Affinity[0] sells one-time-purchase licenses for their Photo, Designer, and Publisher software. I've never used Photoshop/Illustrator and generally do rather light work when I do need to edit/design, but I've been very happy with my purchase. Each license is $50, and the recently went on sale for $25 (but that's over now).

[0]: https://affinity.serif.com

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by culturestate on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:58PM (#23697620)
I can't speak for the Photoshop -> Photo transition since that's never really been my thing, but if you've been using CS professionally for any length of time then going from Illustrator + InDesign to Designer + Publisher take some significant muscle memory retraining. I've been gradually switching over for the last ~6 months but I still have to reach for Ai or Id if there's a really time-sensitive task.

The amount of subconscious automation that goes into making you really proficient at using some tool becomes very obvious when you try to use a different one.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by saagarjha on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:35AM (#23699261)
(I cracked those back in high school and then purchased them because they were so good…)
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by jackson1442 on Friday July 03, 2020 @02:34AM (#23721574)
Exactly what I did.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by jbverschoor on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:27AM (#23698381)
I got Borland c from a friend. Later on I got watcom c from crazybytes. And then visual C++.

A lot of my learning (game dev) was of course the demo scene, and x2ftp from Oulu in Finland.

Another huge step was me going to the bookstore, secretively reading game programming books, and copying code on a piece of paper. Those books were unaffordable for me at the time, and the store guy told me to stop a few times.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by Marsymars on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:03AM (#23697918)
My parents had stable jobs, but weren't super well off when I was a kid; but one thing that I only really appreciated in retrospect was that they gave me an effectively unlimited budget for books. They'd give me suggestions and buy me books that they thought would be worthwhile reads, but they'd also buy whatever fantasy/sci-fi books I asked for. Thankfully for my parents' wallets, I did spend a lot of time at our town library.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by ImprobableTruth on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:27AM (#23701054)
>Blender is great, but it just can't compete with ZBrush

Could you elaborate on that? I assume you're more on the 'dabbles in it for fun' side, but I can't think of any missing features for that kind of usage besides polypainting which is available as a WIP patch.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by imtringued on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @05:26AM (#23699577)
There are lots of free software alternatives to commercial tools. They are usually worse but not by that much. The difficulty of learning them is actually a nice challenge.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by megablast on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:22AM (#23698361)
Why did you need the architect edition though?
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by Intermernet on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @08:25AM (#23700592)
Probably didn't, but most pirated software includes the highest end options. The last pirated version of CS6 I saw was the ultimate edition (or some such), and the last pirated version of ableton I saw was the full suite.

Note: I use Affinity instead of photoshop, and I've had an ableton license since v6, but I keep an occasional eye on the pirate scene. I owe many of my skills to pirated software, and could therefore afford to buy software when I became a professional.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by chaos_a on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:43PM (#23697194)
This is why free student packs are super valuable. Students typically have little to no money and can't afford to buy expensive software. So the company gives you a temporary free copy so that once you have a job in the field your learning you can afford actually afford to buy it.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by the_af on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:09PM (#23696970)
> [...] there are many of us who would not be where we are today, as productive, value-creating citizens, without having learned our trade with pirated software.

Agreed. I learned to program with GW-BASIC which if I remember correctly was included in a (pirated) copy of MS-DOS. Then I graduated to pirated Turbo C and Borland C++, and (I think) only then to the genuinely free DJGPP (a port of GCC for DOS).

If it weren't for pirated software, I wouldn't be a programmer today.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by Hamuko on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:29AM (#23697752)
>It's a shame... there are many of us who would not be where we are today, as productive, value-creating citizens, without having learned our trade with pirated software.

I imagine Adobe has managed to keep a lot of mindshare for Photoshop simply by how widely it is pirated. If pirating Photoshop was absolutely impossible, there'd probably be a lot more Gimp users in this world.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by rorykoehler on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:23AM (#23697717)
That's one of the benefits of the subscription model that gets a lot of hate on here. You can try things easily without pirating and exposing yourself to malware.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by PragmaticPulp on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:06PM (#23696948)
Piracy is still piracy, regardless of your personal feelings about the value of your own use case. You’re taking something that is not yours for taking.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by jacobolus on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @11:44PM (#23697542)
If we are clear about terminology it’s less misleading. Unauthorized use of software downloaded from the internet is copyright infringement, not “piracy”.

It is similar to making a xerox copy of a book obtained from the library, recording a rented video on a new videocassette tape, making an unauthorized recording at a music concert, or typing code you found in Numerical Recipes into your own open source project.

It is not at all similar to boarding a ship and robbing the passengers.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by whakim on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:52AM (#23698533)
That may be the case, but much of the "piracy is justified" crowd seems to rely on an "ends-justify-the-means" approach to suggest that piracy is great. If everyone pirated software (or if even a significant portion of people did), it'd be much harder to make money off of building software. I say this as someone who has pirated plenty of software in my life. I just didn't delude myself into thinking that I wasn't doing something wrong.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by imtringued on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @05:28AM (#23699594)
I'm having a dejavu but literally everyone who justifies piracy does it for the benefit of those who are dependent on it. People who have money don't care and just use the most convenient option.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by kaibee on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:13PM (#23696995)
This analogy really doesn't work, because taking something deprives someone of something they would've otherwise had. If you have the means to buy a piece of software and pirate instead to save money, then sure, I think you can make a case that it is 'taking'. When you're pirating something that you would've never been able to buy, who are you depriving of anything? I guess you're depriving those who have the means to buy that software of the exclusivity of their position, but is that something that they get to 'own'?
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by nitrogen on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @01:37AM (#23698104)
depriving those who have the means to buy that software of the exclusivity of their position

I'm gradually realizing that this probably plays a larger effect in society than we think. Like the ancient parable of the prodigal son, whose faithful brother was jealous that the rebel was celebrated in the end. Maybe it also plays out in lifelong CS devotees vs. CS-for- the-money people -- the nerds might feel that they have "earned" CS more, and the dayjob folks might not appreciate the depth of understanding that comes from the dedication of the lifelong devotees?

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by Groxx on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:26PM (#23697078)
At a moral absolutist standpoint: yea, absolutely. Whether it's harmful or not, the intent is still to avoid paying for what you got, which is pretty straightforward.

For almost any other positions: it's murkier. If you take a berry off a bush on public property... what's the morality? Or growing from private property overhanging public that's just dropping fruit and the owners are either not present or clearly allowing fruit to drop? It's theirs, they absolutely could harvest it, but they're not and it's clearly implied that is not going to change. Now what?

Yes that's still further towards harmless than you can likely argue software piracy is (... ignoring the network effects of everyone knowing how to use X because everyone pirated it, or I could probably come up with others), but my point is that strict black and white separations have dividing lines and breaking points. Whether there is black or white somewhere isn't really useful to anyone, it's where you draw the line.

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by fortran77 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:16AM (#23697689)
You are exactly right. And I'm surprised people are talking about it here cavalierly. I wouldn't hire someone who brags openly on forums about stealing software.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by zucker42 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:23AM (#23697721)
Copyright infringement isn't the same as stealing. I'm saying this as someone who can't recall ever using unlicensed software.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by benhurmarcel on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @07:23AM (#23700254)
Ask your colleagues. If you work around computers chances are that piracy is how a lot of them was able to start using them.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by fortran77 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @09:22AM (#23701013)
Here's the difference: People who stole software, but agree it's wrong have a moral compass. Those who try to rationalize it don't.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by pjmlp on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:57AM (#23698560)
As developer myself, I rather use demo versions when available.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by fearface on Tuesday June 30, 2020 @10:11PM (#23696980)
ZBrush is $40/month. Makes me sad you can’t afford that.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by zucker42 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:28AM (#23697747)
$500/year is a nontrivial amount of money anywhere, but especially in many countries outside the U.S.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by ajzinsbwbs on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:41AM (#23698465)
In this thread though we are talking about someone’s experience using piracy to spend a month learning something. $40 seems like a reasonable alternative to that.
Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by sillysaurusx on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:43AM (#23697812)
Oh, thank goodness! You're right, it's $40/mo now for ZBrush 2020. ZBrush 3 and earlier was $895 with no monthly option, which is great for CAD professionals but out of reach of hobbyists. I'm glad they have an option now; thanks for pointing this out.

(I'm surprised you're getting beat up for this sentiment. $40 is definitely below the threshold of "purchase on a whim and try to learn it for a month." FL Studio was another great one at $99. Still, I'm sympathetic to people who simply can't afford it – children especially.)

Re:New Mac ransomware spreading through piracy by tpush on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @03:09AM (#23698633)
40 bucks a month is a huge amount of money for most of the world's population.