News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by gexla on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:39AM (#23667295)
What model? A monthly fee?

As opposed to what? Free? Getting investors who will pay for development while the service monetizes the users? It's unfortunate that this is what users have come to expect. That we feel should be getting free usage of a service when the developers have bills to pay just like everyone else, in addition to the cloud usage costs.

The people complaining about monthly fee in that three are target users for nobody but Facebook, Twitter, etc.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by kshatrea on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:57AM (#23667357)
I personally like the JetBrains model where one can pay yearly and get updates but if you have to stop paying due to some reason you can still use the version you originally paid for.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by drannex on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:02AM (#23667375)
I miss this model of releasing products, it was the defacto standard for the first 40 years of software development and I shall weep for it's return.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by gexla on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:43AM (#23667522)
Right, for much of that time we didn't have digital distribution. 40 years ago we were buying vinyl records (probably superior products) and cassette tapes. 10 years ago, selling subs were a pain because we didn't have providers such as Stripe to make it easy.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by input_sh on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:38AM (#23667502)
I'm all for a premium, but $15/month is a bit too much. Almost all their competitors are half the price. Here's the pricing of their competitors I can think of on top of my head:

Evernote: €7/month

Notion: $4/month

Ulysses: $5.49/month

Standard Notes: $9.99/month

OneNote (+ the entire Office 365): $9.99/month

Inkdrop: $4.99/month

Bear: $1.49/month ($14.99 per year!)

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by criddell on Sunday June 28, 2020 @12:21PM (#23669832)
You're not the type of user they want:

> We don't want fuckin tire kickers who don't take thinking tools seriously.

> You don't think it's worth the money, that's cool - gtfo.

> You're actually poor -- we'll help you out.

https://www.reddit.com/r/RoamResearch/comments/ep2vy6/how_mu...

That thread on Reddit really soured me on Roam. I'm glad to see alternatives like Foam pop up because there are some interesting ideas there.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by zomglings on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:12PM (#23673433)
Their big mistake was so abrasively describing their product development strategy.

Their core strategy is sound - to develop, at an early stage, for a passionate group of users (even if the group is small).

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by nika1975 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:19AM (#23667627)
If you do not get a value of $15/month from using Roam then it simply is not the right tool for you. Roam makes it easy for me to explore connections between ideas. It has a user interface that fits my way of thinking. I'm also a Office 365 subscriber but OneNote cannot replace Roam for me.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by edjrage on Sunday June 28, 2020 @08:15AM (#23668236)
Honestly, it's not that hard to implement something like Roam compared to the aforementioned competitors. The value is in the idea, and even that isn't novel. It really is a mystery to me why an open source alternative doesn't exist / isn't more popular.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by theon144 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @09:09AM (#23668476)
>Honestly, it's not that hard to implement something like Roam compared to the aforementioned competitors.

Getting hard "Dropbox is trivial to implement with FTP, curlftpfs and CVS" vibes from this kind of thinking.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by edjrage on Sunday June 28, 2020 @02:52PM (#23671108)
Come on, that's the opposite of my “vibe”. The commenter you refer to didn't believe there was any value in the existence of such a product, while I see so much value in this that it's puzzling to me how we still don't have an open source alternative. I didn't say it's trivial, but I bet it's simpler than that for the likes of Notion (and we do have alternatives to those).
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by theon144 on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @04:17AM (#23699146)
Damn, sorry, honestly misread your comment. Yeah I actually do agree completely.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by Aeolun on Sunday June 28, 2020 @08:34AM (#23668310)
I think Roam can be successful because they are charging $15. It gives them a completely different customer base (among other things, probably one that doesn’t see cost as a relevant factor in deciding which note taking app to use).
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by greyman on Sunday June 28, 2020 @11:32AM (#23669436)
From this list, I am familiar with Evernote and Notion, but IMHO they are not Roam competition, since Roam is too different from them.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by gexla on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:47AM (#23667537)
Same response as I gave to another comment.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23667492

Why are we talking about Roam rather than those services then? Why don't we just "find and replace Roam with Bear?" (anyone know the Regex for that?)

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by bhl on Sunday June 28, 2020 @11:01PM (#23673959)
Notion is mostly free now since they seem to target companies more than personal plans: https://www.notion.so/pricing.
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by inakarmacoma on Sunday June 28, 2020 @12:15PM (#23669791)
I'd add DynaList to the list, too
Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by healsjnr1 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @03:57AM (#23667359)
Whether we agree with it or not, I think what is strange is how subscriptions models have become the norm.

There _is_ an alternative that isn't free and that is one off payments (rember when we used to buy software?). I happily pay in the order of $50 to $120 for one off payments, often locked to a version.

In many cases this is _more_ than I've ended up paying for subscriptions I've used, then abandoned after 6-12 months.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by Tehnix on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:36AM (#23667498)
The only model where a one-off payment really makes sense is for products that have zero cost for the developer to keep alive. For example an SQL Client doesn’t need a cloud component.

The difference here is, Roam and similar services run on servers that cost money monthly. The service is almost worthless without it. Ultimately someone needs to pay for this.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by healsjnr1 on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:52AM (#23667729)
Thing is, at their heart, these are document editing tools. They don't actually need an on ongoing operational cost (yes, maintenance, but as a number of people point out you can take the jet brains approach and lock to versions).

The supposed benefit of my data being hosted is not a benefit to everyone. I already have multiple solutions to backup and sharing, I don't need another silo where my data lives. I don't need another vendor hosting arbitrary data which means I now can't use the product because the megacorp I work for won't let that through their legal.

Key point I was making above was that one off payment is an option and can be successful, we don't need to fall straight into the free vs subscription dichotomy.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by bosie on Sunday June 28, 2020 @10:20AM (#23668862)
> The difference here is, Roam and similar services run on servers that cost money monthly. The service is almost worthless without it. Ultimately someone needs to pay for this.

that is also a downside though. which side of the coin wins depends on the customer. I rather use icloud/dropbox and apps then an unencrypted web version. Roam decided to implement a web app, the actual use case does not require a server or monthly maintanance costs.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by d4rti on Sunday June 28, 2020 @05:43AM (#23667699)
These products will still require maintenance with changes in drivers and suchlike.

No software is really finished.

Re:Foam – A Roam Research alternative with VSCode, Markdown ... by dageshi on Sunday June 28, 2020 @04:24AM (#23667452)
Regular, predictable monthly income is just a better model for businesses than irregular large one off purchases.

Customers generally don't mind so long as they can cancel easily if they find they don't need or want the product.

Plus, you can't really buy a "web app" with a one off purchase and much more software is developed as web apps nowadays.