News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by swivelmaster on Friday July 04, 2008 @02:21AM (#235994)
I stopped reading after it turned into a rant about how all software should be free. While I understand and agree with some of the complaints about Microsoft, the extreme 'commercial software is bad' position is kind of ridiculous.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mattmaroon on Friday July 04, 2008 @02:45AM (#236004)
It's his religion, and no matter how mathematically intelligent he may be, he's as blind to rational thought in that area as the most zealous Imam.

There are different types of intelligences, and it seems pretty obvious that he is incredibly strong in some and weaker than the average Wal-Mart shopper in a few.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by tx on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:08AM (#236019)
He seems to dislike Gates more than you dislike him, yet he managed to avoid personal insults against Bill's intelligence, despite his own limited (according to you) mental capacity.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mattmaroon on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:56AM (#236042)
I don't dislike him at all. I consider him the computer science version of a communist. Well meaning, but misguided and suffering from a severe case of tunnel vision.

Saying he has limited mental capacity has a little different connotation than what I meant. Perhaps I didn't express it well. He would appear to be genius-level intelligent in certain regards (math/logic type) and the opposite in others (social, if his Craigslist personals and appearance are any indication). The free software thing is sort of a mixture of the two.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by asimjalis on Friday July 04, 2008 @05:47AM (#236085)
Also you managed to insult Imams and Wal-Mart shoppers for no particular reason, even though as far as I know neither takes a position on open source versus closed source software.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by bayareaguy on Friday July 04, 2008 @04:57PM (#236554)
The selection of software at Wal-Mart is probably limited to closed source.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by jrockway on Friday July 04, 2008 @07:45PM (#236664)
I don't think you understand arguments. When you are arguing for a cause, taking a "reasonable" middle ground doesn't get you anything. You have to argue for the extreme, so that the other side agrees to meet you half way. Then you get what you really want. (If they met you half way to your half way, then you'd not be satisfied.)

RMS needs to say "all non-Free software should go away" so that some of it will.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by pg on Friday July 04, 2008 @07:55PM (#236670)
Depends who your audience is. If you're trying to convince smart people, arguing for extremes will make them think you're a fool.

And incidentally, if you find yourself trying to convince audiences of stupid people, you may want to stop and ask yourself whether you want to be spending your life that way.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by logjam on Friday July 04, 2008 @02:44AM (#236003)
You must not have read very carefully, because nothing in that article said anything about "commercial" software being bad. His points about Gates and his unethical and harmful business tactics are right on the money.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by swivelmaster on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:18AM (#236026)
Okay, then it's a matter of word choice. He actually was talking about 'proprietary' software.

"But Gates didn't invent proprietary software, and thousands of other companies do the same thing. It's wrong, no matter who does it."

That is an outrageous statement.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by gwniobombux on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:28AM (#236031)
Why? Could you elaborate? Just like Stallman actually explains, why he thinks proprietary software wrong.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by KirinDave on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:44AM (#236037)
The problem with Stallman's statements here is that he makes arguments that are essentially non-sequiturs. He argues that code ought to be open because it is the best situation for all parties involved, which seems more-or-less on the money (although there are edge cases where it may not be true, as ESR pointed out).

But this leads him to a militant, legally questionable and altogether obnoxious philosophy that all code therefore must be free, because otherwise it will all collapse into some sort of dystopian future and a black hole where all information is censured and controlled.

But this wasn't the case when Stallman started his activist efforts, and it's not the case now. There is lots of free software and lots of for-pay software and some intersection of the two, and the world seems fairly happy with this situation. And there's really no evidence that the GNU approach has been solely or even significantly responsible for this state of affairs! It really seems like the market has understood the value of open source outside of Stallman's framework for it for quite some time.

From a free-market perspective, the two kinds of software fill different market requirements. Often times closed-source software pioneers an approach, makes an initial profit, and proves a demand which open source efforts then methodically fill. This makes a lot of sense, when you think about it.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mojuba on Friday July 04, 2008 @09:35AM (#236199)
code ought to be open because it is the best situation for all parties involved

He usually emphasizes that it's the best situation for users, and as far as I can tell never mentions software makers in this context.

What he says essentially is software must evolve like an academic discipline. In academia, everything is open and accessible for everyone, so that you can take any one's work, improve it and share your improvement with others in the same manner. That's the way academia worked for centuries, and in fact it worked that way in all political systems.

Note that Stallman is not pushing Computer Science as an academic discipline - not at all. Instead, he says all software must be free as in academia, as I understand it, and there is a reason for that, he says: proprietary software "divides" us like no other product or service we may buy. (Well, you'd add music, video and all kinds of copyable goods to the list of things that "divide" us, but notice that they became cheaply copyable thanks to computers and software.)

So, what's wrong with his point in principle?

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by Herring on Friday July 04, 2008 @09:56AM (#236212)
> There is lots of free software and lots of for-pay software and some intersection of the two, and the world seems fairly happy with this situation.

Noone was arguing that closed source isn't profitable. "Proprietary software exists" isn't an argument for it's existence & many are unhappy about it.

>

>Often times closed-source software pioneers an approach, makes an initial profit, and proves a demand which open source efforts then methodically fill.

I hope you're not saying OSS isn't innovative.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by KirinDave on Friday July 04, 2008 @04:14PM (#236513)
> Noone was arguing that closed source isn't profitable. "Proprietary software exists" isn't an argument for it's existence & many are unhappy about it.

There is definitely slippery-slope rhetoric in the GNU propaganda. Thus far, no slope has existed. That's all I meant to say.

> I hope you're not saying OSS isn't innovative.

I am not saying this, but it is historically true that lots of different fields have been pioneered by closed-source or closed-license-source and that kind of funding. It may shortly thereafter become open-sourced in some fashion, or take longer.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mojuba on Friday July 04, 2008 @07:37PM (#236660)
It is also true historically that people who innovate often are forced to close their code, which otherwise they'd quite possibly be happy to open. It's more often companies that put restrictions rather than engineers themselves.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by swivelmaster on Friday July 04, 2008 @08:01PM (#236673)
Sorry, I started to write a more details explanation of my position last night but was interrupted and closed the browser.

Stallman is suggesting that software should be free because people shouldn't have to pay for it, and so that anyone can modify it.

In theory that sounds great, but the truth is that capitalism has driven most of the software that actually enhances the lives of the majority of people who have computers. Look at the differences between Gimp and Photoshop (or even Paint Shop Pro), or between Impulse Tracker and Logic Pro. (IT wasn't free, actually, but it was really cheap!) Software that people pay for is usually better, and far more useful.

I tried using Gimp at my company for a while to save us money, and I was practically pulling my hair out after ten minutes. It sucks. It really, really sucks. It does a lot of cool things, but it's buggy and it's difficult to use.

If Adobe wasn't rich because they sell their software, their software wouldn't be nearly as good. Same with most other software companies.

Now if it wasn't proprietary, most of the advantages of being able to sell it would go out the window. If everyone had the source code to Photoshop, Photoshop would be nearly worthless. And then everyone would go off and add features when they could, and each feature would only be usable to the person who wrote it. There's no reason to make it usable if you're writing it for yourself.

And that's how Photoshop could become Gimp.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by parenthesis on Friday July 04, 2008 @08:36PM (#236686)
I think Ardour and Rosegarden would be fairer comparisons with Logic Pro. But your point still stands that it was programs like Logic, Cubase, ProTools, Studio Vision that made the market and between them figured out which features should be available and how they should be presented to the user.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by Herring on Saturday July 05, 2008 @04:34AM (#236816)
> Stallman is suggesting that software should be free because people shouldn't have to pay for it,

No.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by bayareaguy on Saturday July 05, 2008 @05:07AM (#236819)
Stallman is suggesting that software should be free because people shouldn't have to pay for it, and so that anyone can modify it.

Can you cite a source? For reference, what the FSF actually says about selling software is here - http://www.fsf.org/licensing/essays/selling.html

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mattmaroon on Friday July 04, 2008 @02:46AM (#236006)
Commercial software largely means proprietary, especially in the area of web applications. It can have APIs and interact with other programs much the way Windows does, but it is proprietary nonetheless.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by tx on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:06AM (#236017)
... which I consider a major loophole in GPL. If google is using a single line of GPL'ed software in their "Big Table" implementation, I demand to see the source, even though it's not "distributed" to my computer.

Matt, free software is the major reason why PG, YCombinator, YouTube and Google are possible: this is why starting a software company is so cheap these days. Without it you'd be paying "enterprise-grade" fees for shit like a web server, operating system, complier, editor, bug tracker and commercial libraries for reading every imaginable file format or speaking any kind of protocol, plus a thousand other software things an average business needs to exist.

Perhaps Stallman sees something you don't, partly because you take it for granted.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mattmaroon on Friday July 04, 2008 @03:52AM (#236041)
You're assuming it's an either/or proposition. I never said that. I love free software, we use it for many things at Draftmix, and I own a ton of websites myself, none of which are hosted on Windows. I think it's had a hugely positive impact on the world, and I hope that some day my startup can contribute back.

But that doesn't mean proprietary software is evil. There's a place for both, and Stallman doesn't see that. He can't because his religion blinds him to it.

Free software is often better for a given task, and would still be preferable if it were equal. But I like Photoshop a hell of a lot better than GIMP and Windows or OSX (for my laptop anyway, not so much for servers) much better than Linux. Free software still clearly lags behind proprietary in some cases, and always will.

There's plenty of room for both. And it's quite a large error on your part to assume I take it for granted.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by galactus on Friday July 04, 2008 @06:40AM (#236113)
"Free software still clearly lags behind proprietary in some cases, and always will."

For Stallman it is not a question of quality of software but of ethics. And he explains his views without resorting to religion or calling people idiots.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mattmaroon on Friday July 04, 2008 @02:49PM (#236421)
His views are a religion, and he essentially calls Bill Gates something worse than an idiot: evil.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by tx on Friday July 04, 2008 @04:28PM (#236523)
I honestly don't understand your "religion" line towards Stallman's position. Yes, he's been consistent and kept saying the same thing for years, that's the only grounds you can base your analogy on.

Free software is a wonderful thing and keeping a source code "secret" or patenting stupid shit like "single click buy" is indeed evil, what else you want to call it when closed-source systems are forcing the entire world to reverse-engineer their file formats, communication protocols, etc. How many programmer-hours have been wasted re-implementing JPEG compression, TCP/IP stack, XML parsing, etc etc etc?

Tell me, how is it NOT evil to hold font-rendering patents forcing the entire non-Windows (or OSX) world to stare at fucked-up unreadable fonts? ... and at the same time borrowing anything they want from OSS community when they feel like it (look! there is "etc" folder in windows/system/drivers!) How is it possible to look into SCO vs Linux case and not call Microsoft's envolvement "evil"? If not evil, what is it then?

Moreover, the modern history of computing is actually proving that Stallman's views make perfect sense, even from commercial perspective: look at Adobe, who's actually being forced to open-source because they suddenly realized that this gives them an edge over Silverlight. Just compare that to Macromedia's not so distant dreams of selling crazy ass expensive "Flex servers". Or look at poor Opera fighting against the whole world's efforts of improving FF.

Even your own examples of better software don't apply. On features and flexibility alone, OSX can't hold a candle to even (!) Gnome and wins user's hearts purely on looks. What's more important, however, is that OSX itself is a giant example of open source (BSD) taking over commercial (Windows) with a for-profit company cashing out in the background - I still don't understand why OSS community lets Apple to get away with it: they took all they wanted and haven't given much of their own stuff back. Majority of code you get installed with OSX isn't written by Apple, yet they get to charge you for it. So don't use OSX as an example of successful closed-source product because it isn't.

Also, look back in time: open source systems have been innovating and are responsible for nearly everything we see around ourselves: languages, compilers, internet itself, the list is huge: commercial and closed-loop development hasn't produced anything with an impact, merely playing "catch-up -> copy -> resell" game.

You're an intelligent guy, you like to speak your mind directly and I enjoy your blog. There is probably something in your argument that you just can't get across.

Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by bayareaguy on Friday July 04, 2008 @05:12AM (#236070)
It's ironic that the biggest obstacle to Stallman's idea of free software is his own stupid use of the word "free", so I feel I have to ask but do you mean free as in "without charge" or free as in "unencumbered"? Given that this is Hacker News, it's perhaps important to keep in mind that Stallman has nothing against commercial software. The whole "free" issue for him has to do with restrictions on the right of people to hack and redistribute their hacks.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by krschultz on Friday July 04, 2008 @08:52AM (#236179)
No, the issue for Stallman is for the software to be open and stay open. There are many places where the GPL put limitations on what YOU CAN DO with the software. His whole "rights for the people" is a side effect of "rights for the software". By free he means the SOFTWARE is free, not the people using it are free to do what they want. There is a reason the BSD people complain like hell about GNU and the GPL. In my view, the BSD is 'free' software i.e. you can do what you want with it, and the GPL is 'shared' or 'collective' software i.e. you can change it, but you have to share all your changes.
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by HansF on Friday July 04, 2008 @11:27AM (#236266)
You USE (do) the software anywa. The gpl only limits distribution
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by juanpablo on Friday July 04, 2008 @10:40AM (#236232)
How much you can do with an EULA covered software?
Re:Richard Stallman on Bill Gates: "It's not the Gates, it's... by mynameishere on Friday July 04, 2008 @01:59PM (#236377)
free software is the major reason why PG, YCombinator, YouTube and Google are possible

This is not the argument that Stallman is making, and if he could fully grok the simple fact that business and not mankind is that which has benefited from free software, he'd probably go hang himself in despair.

Windows + IIS + VS + SQL Server is not that expensive. Altogether, it's still much cheaper than starting a lawn-care business.