News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by perfunctory on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:49AM (#23525256)
> The Paper later found out that many insurance companies have already fixed the loopholes that Li took advantage of to get rich.

> The ones they checked with now have a clause that says they will not be responsible for any payout should the insured, at the time of buying, already knows or reasonably deduces that the flight can be delayed anytime.

What kind of clause is that?

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by csunbird on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:36AM (#23525507)
This is extremely ambiguous, the insurance company may refuse to pay any insurer at all based on this clause.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by Majromax on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:03AM (#23526851)
> This is extremely ambiguous,

Perhaps we should not rush to finely parse language that has gone through a double translation: from legaleese to reporter and from Chinese to English.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by close04 on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:54AM (#23525995)
This may be treated as "insider knowledge" but I expect the burden is on the insurance company to prove prior knowledge.

But "reasonably deduces"... that can be used in any such case where mass payouts are a likely outcome. If I can "reasonably deduce" a payout will be needed than so can the insurance company. Under these conditions accepting my insurance purchase should be seen as the company committing fraud. They accept a payment knowing the customer can never collect.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by buran77 on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:21AM (#23527007)
Not sure why downvoted, if the clause actually reads like that it seems like insurance companies stacking the odds in their favor. Like a casino that reserves the right to kick you out if you're winning. Even if I can deduce it might be delayed, that's far from certainty. I take insurance only when I reasonably expect to encounter incidents. Does this make all my policies invalid? When the company "reasonably deduces" that there will be no delays do they give me the money back?

I hope they are reserving this clause for such obvious fraud cases where they can prove prior knowledge and intent. Like the case of this woman who even created fake identities to carry out the plan. Otherwise I see them being stuck in court forever either trying to prove that a random customer had some sort of insight that they didn't despite literally being their job and investing (tens of) millions in this. Or trying to prove that they didn't knowingly sell a policy with the expectation that they will never provide the payout, which is misrepresentation of the service at the very least.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by rswail on Monday June 15, 2020 @07:25AM (#23526191)
Note that it's "reasonably deduces" at the time of buying the insurance contract.

So it's not like the insurance company can say "you should have cancelled the night before because everyone could see the storm coming".

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by close04 on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:52AM (#23526748)
I think I addressed it pretty clearly before.

If a regular consumer can "reasonably" deduce (using logic, not some "illegal" insider knowledge) at the time of buying the insurance policy that the flight may be cancelled then the insurance company employing experts and very accurate statistical models can more than reasonably make the same deduction.

Now since we agree that both parties deduced the flight will be cancelled but the company still went ahead and took the money for the insurance contract, this can only be fraud. The company took the money under false pretenses since they implicitly know even before the transaction that the claim is null and void under the "reasonable deduction" paragraph.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by ErikVandeWater on Monday June 15, 2020 @10:07AM (#23527439)
The reason people buy flight insurance is because they reasonably deduce the flight might be cancelled.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by jacobr1 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @09:46AM (#23539051)
There is a line (fuzzy line, granted) between the general possibility and specific knowledge. An example might be: flying to the southeast coastal areas during hurricane season. There is an increased likelihood based on historical evidence of the weather canceling flights. But nothing specific. Once a storm is a named, has tracks with predicted (but still not certain) dates and locations, there is much more specific evidence. This type of situation is very difficult to write rules to handle every case, but we can create rules of thumb that the courts at least will tend to be even-handed about.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by close04 on Tuesday June 16, 2020 @11:24AM (#23540225)
There's also a clear line between specific knowledge ("I know for a fact Company X will cancel flights starting next week") and reasonable deduction ("many times it rained heavily they cancelled flights").

I get why the first one is unacceptable but the wording in their agreement fits the second one.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by WhompingWindows on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:37AM (#23526646)
Is there any legal definition/precedent of "reasonably deduces"? Have companies attempted this kind of blockage before?
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by dfxm12 on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:19AM (#23526996)
There is a definition. https://www.trans-lex.org/902000/_/standard-of-reasonablenes... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_person

That doesn't mean there's no grey area, though. Is it unreasonable to buy tickets and insurance under an assumed identity? Probably, but part of getting your day in court having the ability to suss this out.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by jopsen on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:40PM (#23532704)
Probably an unnecessary one...

Most jurisdictions won't enforce a contract entered in bad faith.

I'm no lawyer, but I would guess the hard part is detecting this behavior and/or getting the money back, not so much denying the payments. (Though flight insurances probably don't have much infrastructure for fighting fraud, as there is few ways to do insurance scams)

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by nightcracker on Monday June 15, 2020 @04:59PM (#23532903)
> Most jurisdictions won't enforce a contract entered in bad faith.

What? What exactly is bad faith here?

How is buying insurance on things you expect to fail any different than, say, buying options on the stock market, or some other form of intelligent betting?

You have expectation X, you find a third party that disagrees and has expectation Y, and agree to make a bet on the outcome with odds relative to X:Y. If your assessment of the situation was closer to the truth than the other party, you can stand to make money.

The assumptions of the insurance company is that they have superior models and can amortize losses among many people and thus charge only a small margin. They don't always have the best models though, and I really don't see how calling them on it is 'bad faith'.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by second--shift on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:56PM (#23533507)
> How is buying insurance on things you expect to fail any different than, say, buying options on the stock market, or some other form of intelligent betting?

Insurance, unlike options on equity stock or indexes, require an insurable interest. The pricing of insurance assumes that the buyer of insurance would rather not use the insurance policy; the options contract on stock makes no such stipulation. They are a bit similar in practice but both are structured, regulated contracts and are defined differently.

This lady did not have an "insurable interest" in the flights she was purchasing insurance on, since she did not actually intend to go on on the flight (she bought the insurance to profit from the insurance). Had she bought an "option" and not "insurance" on the flight, fraud maybe would not be in play. However, expect an "option" to be priced differently.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by rictic on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @04:53PM (#23556607)
That's interesting. My personal reasoning has been that insurance is a bad deal unless either:

1. you believe you are at higher risk than the typical person buying the insurance (or more practically, that [cost of insurance] < [payout amount] * [likely of payout]).

2. the outcome you're insuring against would otherwise be financially ruinous (e.g. life insurance on family breadwinner, homeowners' insurance on expensive house)

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by cellar_door on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:13PM (#23533683)
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by VectorLock on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:58PM (#23533532)
Not to defend the insurance companies, but I think it is bad faith because the intention of the insurance is to protect the insured from risk from an unforeseen situation, not to attempt to gamble or arbitrage against the insurance company.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by kebman on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @07:17AM (#23550107)
I've come to the conclusion that the "protection" most insurance companies offer, are scams. Hear me out. While there are one-off insurances, most insurance is monthly or annually. So each year you pay a set amount. Now, consider saving that money instead. Usually, if you can go only a few years without an accident, you would have saved up more than enough to cover that incident yourself with your insurance savings. On top of that, you'd most likely save yourself the hassle of going to court if the insurance company for some reason or another contests your claim, and let's face it, they often do. So not only is the saving a great alternative, but it also insures a payout. The only instance where insurance might be good, is if the amount covered is far larger than you could ever hope to afford yoruself. In this case it might be smart to sign up to an insurance, if there is a high enough risk that you might need it. Even then, simply saving the insurance fee might be a better option, becuause you then have the option to draw interest on it (if it's high enough), or even invest it.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by VectorLock on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:30AM (#23551846)
I agree with you. Its not in the insurance companies best interests to pay out when they can, they have no incentive to "help" you. Sometimes I wonder if home insurance is even worth it. Barring the house burning down from a lightning strike they'll try to clause their way out of almost every situation and even if they can't paying the deductible and insurance increases aren't even worth it except in the most extreme cases.

I pretty much pay them just so I don't have to experience the social ramifications of telling people I didn't have home insurance if something did happen.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by kebman on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @09:29PM (#23558838)
Have you ever calculated how much you've paid in insurance fees over the years, and the interest you'd earn if you simply saved the money?
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by patrickmcmanus on Wednesday June 17, 2020 @10:27AM (#23551816)
protecting against the zero-bound is the value - that's not a scam. As the ratio of potential loss to net worth drops, that's less interesting and so is the insurance.

Varying levels of deductible choices hard code this notion even further into the system. If you're farther from zero-bound worries you can essentially buy less insurance with a high deductible.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by zoomablemind on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:13PM (#23530883)
I think the main point is about risk distribution. In a normal insurance contract the main risk of an uncertain event (the damage) is assumed by the insurer, while the policy holder's risk is tied to losing the paid premium.

When such a contract is made in advance knowledge of likely occurrence of the event, the risk is fully shifted over to the insurer. Thus in absence of shared risk this subverts the contract into an unequivalent monetary transaction, which reasonably amounts to fraud.

Similarly, if there's an advanced knowledge from the insurer on almost certain unlikelyhood of the event, then it's defrauding the policy holder of their premium.

So the insurers must pay off time to time to maintain the perceived fairness of contracts. Meanwhile doing their best to balance their share of the risk... and most importantly price in the 'administrative overhead'.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by ashtonkem on Monday June 15, 2020 @07:00AM (#23526034)
One that is extremely narrow in scope.

In this case, continual purchasing of insurance on the flights likely to be delayed would be evidence you knew it was going to be delayed.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by fendy3002 on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:18AM (#23526521)
IMO, the problem is how to prove / what is the condition.

Without clear condition / clauses, it is possible that they'll deny valid claims by saying that the insured has already know beforehand. Maybe there are more specific information?

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by vkou on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:34AM (#23525488)
It's a bit like the clause about how you shouldn't be buying fire insurance for a house that is already in the process of burning down.

It's not an unreasonable one.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by greatpatton on Monday June 15, 2020 @05:49AM (#23525586)
You analogy is incorrect as it would mean that she would buy the insurance when the flight is officially delayed. Here she is making a prediction, which may or may not be correct. It is exactly the same as when you are buying option or contract on the stock market. Here the issue is that the insurance company has a fixed premium which not based on the likelihood of delay. This is completely on the insurance side. Otherwise the stock market will have big issue if you apply the same analogy. This new clause is in effect a blanket one to not pay anything... if you pay for an insurance you have the conviction that the flight might be delayed... otherwise there would be no point to buy it....
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by unishark on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:10AM (#23525729)
I'm guessing you don't have this woman's inside knowledge of the airline system in China. You're assuming here that a person can't reasonably know or deduce a flight will be delayed, but her track record says different.

Sometimes, often in fact, it becomes pretty obvious a flight will be delayed but they just haven't bothered to officially announce the fact yet. Such as if the plane isn't even there because they are delayed on the previous leg, and boarding time is about to start. Or when the airport cancels all flights for an indeterminate time due to incoming bad weather and the airlines wait to update times because they don't know what to say yet.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by inimino on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:16AM (#23525758)
A certain flight out of a certain airport (I won't say which one) was routinely delayed to the point that passengers waiting for the inevitable compounding series of delay announcements (always after the predicted departure time had passed, and before the plane had showed up much less been boarded) would make small talk about it. Predicting that these flights would be delayed every. damn. time. was not difficult. However, if the insurance companies eliminate this face-saving measure for airlines then they may be forced to be realistic rather than maximally optimist in their departure estimates in the future (or simply be blacklisted by these kinds of insurance).
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by greatpatton on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:45AM (#23526692)
Yes I do know by experience that it is very easy to deduce if a flight will be delayed. By experience in Europe, last leg of the day of an Easyjet flight -> 75% chance that your flight will be delayed. Snow during the night (look at the forecast) -> 90% your morning flight will be delayed etc. etc. No need for an advance ML model. Of course what she did was more like insider trading, but I'm pretty sure that you don't even need that.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by user5994461 on Monday June 15, 2020 @02:01PM (#23530707)
The difficulty to make money out of this might be to determine the delay with some accuracy, not just that there will be some delays. Flight are routinely delayed by tens of minutes (has a low-cost flight ever left on time?) and that won't award compensation.

European laws define mandatory compensations when a flight is delayed or cancelled. This starts after 30 minutes if I remember well and depends how long the delay is and how long (distance) the flight is.

Also, delay is measured on arrival time, not on departure time. Planes frequently depart late then arrive on time, because they fly faster to catch up.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by ProZsolt on Monday June 15, 2020 @07:58PM (#23534466)
It was 2 hours, but recently they changed to 3

https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/travel/passenger-right...

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by notahacker on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:51AM (#23526732)
There's a big difference between buying a flight ticket and insuring it because of the possibility of its delay increasing your costs which you want to avoid and buying a flight ticket and insuring it because of the probability of its delay earning you a reward which you are actively seeking out in your choice of flights

It's the difference between buying flood disruption insurance because you operate in an occasionally flooded area, and moving your stock to wherever there's a flood warning. Particularly in this case, where the woman cancelled her expected on-time tickets because the tickets had no value to her except as a source of insurance payouts.

Consumer insurance is not exactly the same as stock options: it's not supposed to be a perfectly efficient market. Insurers are often operating under rules which prevent them from denying or repricing insurance due to relevant risk factors and likewise premium holders are usually bound by far more terms and conditions preventing them from taking actions which might change the value of their policy than stocks or futures markets.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by quietbritishjim on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:10AM (#23525727)
Perhaps it's more likely getting life insurance when you know you have a disease that is likely to be fatal (but not 100% guaranteed). Most life insurance policies would disallow that. At the very least they require you to disclose it, and if they still agree to insure you the premium would be much higher.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by roenxi on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:18AM (#23525774)
The insurance company isn't a math problem; they are offering an explicitly bad deal. They are offering insurance on the basis that they will make a profit. Making that explicit in the contact is reasonable.

If somebody thinks they are making money out of their insurance contract it is probably fraud or very close to.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by rswail on Monday June 15, 2020 @07:31AM (#23526223)
My understanding is that insurance companies operate on pricing the contracts to cover their potential losses while making profit on investing the insurance premiums.
Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by Cogito on Monday June 15, 2020 @07:19PM (#23534221)
Insurance companies, depending on the company and the line of business, will aim to make both an underwriting profit and an investment profit.

If it is a particularly high premium line, and especially if there is a lot of competition, it's more likely that the underwriting profit will be kept minimal or even negative, as the investment profit is so much more lucrative. This is common in the car insurance lines of business, for example.

For retail insurers there are a lot of moving parts here, and they will often not hold much of the final risk, so can't make money from investment anyway. For example, the retailer (sometimes an underwriting agency) may be underwritten by some bigger insurer.

That insurer may have a quota share arrangement with another insurer (I'll take 10% of the risk, you take 90%) with a corresponding premium share.

At each level reinsurance is bought, sometimes on the whole portfolio of risks and sometimes on particular classes of risk or specifc policies, and the costs associated with the reinsurance are priced into the retail premium.

Additionally, when working in an intermediated market with brokers, there are often credit terms of up to 90 days where no payments are made. Anecdotally, it does seem like some brokers do make a large amount of their money on this float.

Adding it all together, there are two main numbers to track from an underwriting profit point of view - your loss ratio (claims incurred / earned premiums, often extended to include projections for future claims and premium for future insured periods) and your combined operating ratio (COR) which includes expenses.

There will be a loss ratio at which a line of business becomes profitable, and final premiums are often calculated by taking the expected losses and grossing up by this loss ratio. For individual accounts it might literally be that simple - "over the last 5 years this account has averaged claims of $100,000 a year, we need a 60% loss ratio so the premium should be $166,667." If there are extra reinsurance costs you might add those, and you might also add a loading for large infrequent losses that aren't captured in your underlying loss ratio (and another loading for catastrophes, a level above that).

The combined ratio needs to be under 100% to be 'underwriting profitable'. I've seen CORs as high as 105-110%, but typically those portfolios were being very closely monitored/remediated/exited. If there is a strong market the COR is allowed to drift higher, but when the market tightens so does the COR.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by wastedhours on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:09AM (#23526461)
More like buying fire insurance for a house as you see an arsonist walking slowly toward it.

You know what the expected outcome is going to be and are securing an agreement deliberately in bad faith. That's not to say insurance companies are always good faith actors (oftentimes not), but it's a very one-sided information flow.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by SkyBelow on Monday June 15, 2020 @09:07AM (#23526885)
If there has been a rise in arson cases in my city that finally convinces me to get fire insurance, is that in bad faith? I have a reason to believe my house is now more at risk of burning down, so I'm buying insurance. It seems a much more realistic scenario than the one of having a arsonist slowly approaching a house (and even then, arsonist in general do not burn down most the buildings they approach throughout their lifetime, and even more so when you could individual approaches that result in arson).

What about someone who notices that they are getting older and are starting to develop aches and pains and decides to start buying health insurance that they had avoided when they were younger because they seemed to have been made out of rubber back then?

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by webmaven on Monday June 15, 2020 @10:28AM (#23527690)
> What about someone who notices that they are getting older and are starting to develop aches and pains and decides to start buying health insurance that they had avoided when they were younger because they seemed to have been made out of rubber back then?

That's exactly the reason the ACA made health insurance mandatory, to avoid that scenario which would require insurance companies to make the policies more expensive in order to compensate for the higher average age and worsening average health of the insured pool, which further incentivizes the avoidance, and so on, until we're right back in the same situation with a high-risk pool and unaffordable premiums.

Incidentally, that doesn't mean that avoiding health insurance if you are young and healthy with no dependents is actually a good idea at the outset, since many common health conditions like injuries from car accidents don't particularly discriminate by age.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by wastedhours on Monday June 15, 2020 @10:06AM (#23527431)
The fact there's so many ifs and buts shows this can't be a clear line. In the eyes of the law, it's about the intent of the action - which is why the ambiguity at the Terms and Conditions level is probably for the best.

Yeah, your first argument makes a lot more sense to normal situations, but mine was aimed at being an analogy to the example at hand from the article.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by franciscop on Monday June 15, 2020 @06:06AM (#23525700)
As the sibling said "it would mean that she would buy the insurance when the flight is officially delayed"

I think it's more like, you shouldn't buy fire insurance if you are having a bbq or similar. Or at least somewhere in the middle of these two statements.

Re:Woman makes $420k by buying insurance on flights she pred... by Cthulhu_ on Monday June 15, 2020 @08:08AM (#23526453)
You shouldn't be buying fire insurance if someone has said they were going to burn your house down.

Or well you should, but if you wilfully had your house burn down anyway to get insurance money, that's insurance fraud.