What? What exactly is bad faith here?
How is buying insurance on things you expect to fail any different than, say, buying options on the stock market, or some other form of intelligent betting?
You have expectation X, you find a third party that disagrees and has expectation Y, and agree to make a bet on the outcome with odds relative to X:Y. If your assessment of the situation was closer to the truth than the other party, you can stand to make money.
The assumptions of the insurance company is that they have superior models and can amortize losses among many people and thus charge only a small margin. They don't always have the best models though, and I really don't see how calling them on it is 'bad faith'.
Insurance, unlike options on equity stock or indexes, require an insurable interest. The pricing of insurance assumes that the buyer of insurance would rather not use the insurance policy; the options contract on stock makes no such stipulation. They are a bit similar in practice but both are structured, regulated contracts and are defined differently.
This lady did not have an "insurable interest" in the flights she was purchasing insurance on, since she did not actually intend to go on on the flight (she bought the insurance to profit from the insurance). Had she bought an "option" and not "insurance" on the flight, fraud maybe would not be in play. However, expect an "option" to be priced differently.
1. you believe you are at higher risk than the typical person buying the insurance (or more practically, that [cost of insurance] < [payout amount] * [likely of payout]).
2. the outcome you're insuring against would otherwise be financially ruinous (e.g. life insurance on family breadwinner, homeowners' insurance on expensive house)
I pretty much pay them just so I don't have to experience the social ramifications of telling people I didn't have home insurance if something did happen.
Varying levels of deductible choices hard code this notion even further into the system. If you're farther from zero-bound worries you can essentially buy less insurance with a high deductible.
Most jurisdictions won't enforce a contract entered in bad faith.
I'm no lawyer, but I would guess the hard part is detecting this behavior and/or getting the money back, not so much denying the payments. (Though flight insurances probably don't have much infrastructure for fighting fraud, as there is few ways to do insurance scams)