Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by davedx on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:10AM
(#23489055)
Despite the production chaos, missed deadlines, over promises and general CEO fuckwittery, Tesla is a massive success story that was in the right place at the right time and completely changed an industry. I have huge respect for everyone who worked there and helped build it.
I was a (small time) shareholder from around 2013 until last year when I happily liquidated my position and put in an order for a Model 3.
I don't think anyone can really say whether this share price is justified even with all the future growth priced in. This is a company that has been at least partly responsible for some quite fundamental changes in mobility, and they're nowhere done yet. (I'm more excited about the Semi than Cybertruck).
They've also helped drive the price/watt of batteries right down which is having a multitude of knock-on effects across many industries. Without Tesla, would we have seen battery powered airplanes starting to be built? Maybe we would, but they would probably be at the least more expensive.
I can't wait to see what the future holds for Tesla, and despite all his shortcomings, I'm happy Musk is still in charge. This all simply would not have happened without his insane drive and determination.
(Strangely, HN, that loved Apple in Steve Jobs' glory days, seems to have a lot of irrational hatred for Tesla).
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by fsloth on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:18AM
(#23489145)
"(Strangely, HN, that loved Apple in Steve Jobs' glory days, seems to have a lot of irrational hatred for Tesla)."
Jobs was vocal in public about products they have already launched. They delivered products that were obviously best at what they were intended for. Musk is vocal about - well, apparently everything - and ICE:s are still a superior option for a large category of car owners.
I think the biggest gripe is probably about overpromising autopilot capability years before it's actually production ready.
Still, Musk is up there with Ford on a list of industrialists who made a dent in the universe in my books.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by davedx on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:38AM
(#23489379)
> I think the biggest gripe is probably about overpromising autopilot capability years before it's actually production ready.
Very fair! This has been a pretty spectacular overpromise. I firmly believe FSD will get here eventually but the timeframes were ridiculously off.
What I also read is an insane amount of comment on every SpaceX and Tesla post here about how bad it is to have touchscreens in cars or spacecraft, and how huge swathes of HN commenters are absolutely convinced touchscreens are dangerous, regressive, etc. Even when professional pilots chime in about how they're used in aircraft. Even when SpaceX designed their Dragon controls in consultation with the veteran astronauts who use them, HN was convinced this was bad, and don't even mention they dared used Chromium!
(Not really a Tesla specific thing using touchscreens but seems to be a very popular complaint about them here.)
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Silhouette on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:13AM
(#23489725)
What I also read is an insane amount of comment on every SpaceX and Tesla post here about how bad it is to have touchscreens in cars or spacecraft, and how huge swathes of HN commenters are absolutely convinced touchscreens are dangerous, regressive, etc.
Even when professional pilots chime in about how they're used in aircraft.
Flying an aircraft is a very different experience to driving a car. The procedures, instruments and control systems are so different that I'm not sure there's really any meaningful comparison at all.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by xkjkls on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:14PM
(#23490987)
The timelines are ridiculously off, and they continue to release underbaked features to their beta testing customers. That's actively dangerous.
As for the touchscreens, so much of that speaks to Musk's credibility. He seems to make decisions, like with Autopilot above, more for PR than for safety. I can see why people are going to be skeptical when he claims touchscreens are best for space usage/
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by redis_mlc on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:56AM
(#23489570)
> Even when professional pilots chime in about how they're used in aircraft.
Well ... depends.
Airliner FMS systems are awesome.
Small planes usually have Garmin 430 and 530 GPS units, which are not touchscreen (they have side buttons), and have shitty UIs. And those eye-watering navigation database update prices ... thousands per year.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Traster on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:43AM
(#23489443)
Steve Jobs went on stage and announced the iPod on October 3rd 2001, they were on sale Nov 10th. He announced the iPhone Jan 2007, it was in people's hands by June. Elon Musk announced fully autonomous cars about 17 times in the last decade and sold software packages to people for it and has still hasn't delivered. I'm not sure Jobs could be any further from Musk in terms of how they manage(d)their companies.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by seesaw on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:57AM
(#23489579)
“(Strangely, HN, that loved Apple in Steve Jobs' glory days, seems to have a lot of irrational hatred for Tesla)”
You do need some with the personality of Musk to take on the current automobile industry. But this also means Musk needs to be always in the news with a lot of unfulfilled claims: https://elonmusk.today/
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:46AM
(#23489471)
They miss some deadlines, but with the Model Y they were early. That is arguable the most important part. The giga factories are making pretty fast progress as well.
I think the narrative that they are always late on everything is wrong. The set insane goals and most of the time they miss them, but they are still fast even in those cases.
I bought stocks for the first time right in the heart of the Covid-19 crisis, Tesla is riding two massive waves of change, electrification and self-driving. It will take 10-15 years to shake out completely but I think Tesla will be the big winner of this shakeout.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by TechBro8615 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:48AM
(#23489489)
The fact that the top engineers in the country want to work at Tesla should be a good sign. Any company that can hire top talent has a solid chance of outperforming its competition.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by xkjkls on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:20PM
(#23491061)
Do top engineers work for Tesla? I see them having great recruiting from the university pipeline, but fresh-faced Eng School graduates are a very different population than the best engineers. You hear so much about Tesla's work culture that seems to discourage older people or people with families from working there.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by xkjkls on Thursday June 11, 2020 @01:09PM
(#23490946)
Steve Jobs always did exactly as he said he was going to do. Musk doesn't. Self-driving, solar roofs, Semis, Robotaxis, profitability, buyouts, mars missions -- Musk has made enough false claims to write a book.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by partiallypro on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:09AM
(#23489039)
If you think this is insane, look at Nikola, an electric car company that has never produced a single vehicle...is now worth more than Ford (as of yesterday.)
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by tenpies on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:38AM
(#23489382)
And if you want to see even more insanity, look at market cap versus profit. Tesla - who has not even made $1 BB of profit in its 15 years despite billions of government money, tax credits, regulatory credits, and untold favours - is now valued at $185 BB. Musk's bonus this year is bigger than all the profit Tesla has ever made.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by xkjkls on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:01PM
(#23491568)
You can add up every quarter they had a profit, and ignore the fact that they had losses every other quarter and it’s still not equal to his $750 million pay package
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Cthulhu_ on Friday June 12, 2020 @03:32AM
(#23496949)
Modern capitalism doesn't work with basic maths apparently; companies run off investor money for years, if not decades (AMD is one of those companies that has been running a net negative for a long time - not sure how they're doing of late though).
Personally, based on a very superficial understanding of economy, I... don't actually mind - as long as their personnel, suppliers, and taxes are paid timely and adequately, they are doing their 'contribution' to the economy.
It appears that technically, your statement is incorrect in that they've produced some prototypes. And they have orders (not sure if that counts as sales), but they've not actually delivered a production vehicle yet. Which makes their market cap seem insane, but it seems like most publicly traded companies have had insane market caps since the 90s.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:50AM
(#23489513)
The 'orders' are basically you can go to their webside and say 'I want 1000 trucks' no information, account or down-payment.
Usually public companies go threw funding rounds, this company knew they couldn't convince any real funds.
They claim to have battery technology that is way ahead of anybody else, and that just sounds like a nonsense claim. They basically do nothing inhouse, say about Tesla what you want but they have technical skills.
Seems to me Nikola is basically a scam designed to be as Tesla like as possible but with a little twist to make it seem just different enough.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by dhosek on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:06AM
(#23489661)
The wikipedia article claims Anheuser-Busch ordered 800 trucks in 2018 with a 2020 delivery target, so barring outright misinformation, that's probably a legit order. Whether the order gets filled is a different question.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Friday June 12, 2020 @05:48AM
(#23497614)
That order might be real, but of the 10 billion many are just clicks on their website. Probably Anheuser-Busch thought 'free preorder, why not' and they probably have a hand in a couple of future truck companies.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by martythemaniak on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:50AM
(#23489509)
Tesla is an industrial conglomerate that will power the 21st century. At the moment they are a small, luxury car maker, but much like Apple was a small, luxury computer maker, Tesla's ambitions are great and their stock price is a function of how much the market believes that they will be able to achieve that.
The parts of this conglomerate are:
* The vehicle manufacturing. This one is obvious - they have a big lead on other automakers in producing EVs and this lead is not closing. They will keep expanding their portfolio of models and markets until they're near the top.
* The mobility service. This will grow out of their Autopilot efforts and take on Uber et all. This will be much wider though, as it will include public transit services with the Boring Co, private cars, and even taking on rail with fleets of Semis.
* The electricity utility business. This one is simple as well - there's a ton of cheap solar and wind power. Pairing it with batteries and Tesla's management software means they'll be providing the infrastructure utilities use. They likely won't become a utility themselves, as that requires local certifications etc.
* The homes business. Your home needs a battery, a roof that makes power and a geothermal HVAC system. Tesla wants to sell them to you all tied up with great software.
* Planes. Electric flight needs the best batteries and electric motors, Tesla would be pretty crazy not to pursue this. No, they're not going to take on Boeing or Airbus, but small, regional commuter planes (range of several hundred km) are within reach in 10 years.
Anyway, it's pretty simple. If you believe the above, go long. If you think it's BS, go short. If you think this is a bit too out-there/WTF, then just sit back and enjoy the show.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by coldcode on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:07AM
(#23489021)
It has declining revenues, increasing liabilities, and sell expensive cars in a strange recessive economy. Its stock is being treated like early Facebook. Sure it might have some magical future where it dominates auto sales forever, but supporting this valuation is nuts.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by alextheparrot on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:30AM
(#23489276)
A more productive comment would’ve taken the statement at face value and tried to learn where the disconnect is.
I assume that the first sentence, including declining revenues, is in reference to the current state vs expectations. The disconnect may be in what “Declining revenues” was intended to mean, in this case it makes sense if it is against expected revenue instead of the global value.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bhupy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:26AM
(#23489233)
I think it's incorrect to say that their revenues are declining, but in this past year Ford and GM sold 60-70x more cars than Tesla did, each. Tesla would have to monopolize car production on the entire planet to justify their valuation, at least as a car company.
If you were to price this company as a combination of auto (Ford/GM) + energy (Chevron) + ridesharing? (Uber/Lyft), then you could maybe justify this valuation in the long run, but Tesla is yet to really prove any real revenue in energy and ridesharing, at scale. The current value is pure hype and expectation, and remains to be seen who ends up being correct in the long run.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by SEJeff on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:34AM
(#23489336)
at least as a car company
Is their justification justified if they are treated as more than a car company?
Tesla is a car company. Their current products are great. Their upcoming products might be industry changing. The Semi is going to lower the cost of longhaul freight, which has ripple down effects across many industries. The cybertruck is a moonshot granted, but just might hit it big. Allegedly, they have over 500,000 reservations for it which is more than the Model 3 ever had.
Tesla is a car company.
Plus a static energy provider (powerwall, powerpack, megapack).
Plus a solar provider (solar panels + solar tiles)
Plus a large refuel / recharge network provider (superchargers) who has a huge lead on literally everyone.
Plus a software company. Even if you want to joke about AP not being full self driving. Find a car you can buy right now that does all of the things that a Tesla on autopilot can do (in specific, stop lights / signs, smart summon, and navigate on autopilot). Last I checked, the closest was Mercedes's supercruise, which is very good and still doesn't have 1/2 of the functionality of Tesla. The OTA updates really are game changing. When I purchased my Model 3 in November 2018, it lacked an alarm system (Sentry Mode), dashcam (Tesla Cam), etc. I got this and a ton more functionality, for free via OTA updates. Unlike every other automotive company, I didn't have to wait for their next year's model. This is a radical rethink of the industry.
Their current stock price seems a tad low if they're able to execute effectively in all of the markets they're in. So far, it does appear that they are.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bhupy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:45AM
(#23489465)
> Tesla is a car company. Their current products are great. Their upcoming products might be industry changing. The Semi is going to lower the cost of longhaul freight, which has ripple down effects across many industries. The cybertruck is a moonshot granted, but just might hit it big. Allegedly, they have over 500,000 reservations for it which is more than the Model 3 ever had.
I don't doubt that Tesla is a great car, I plan to buy one myself. The question is whether this justifies that kind of valuation. Cars are a commodity, and for as long as they've existed, there have always been great cars, shitty cars, and everything in between.
Re: cybertruck. Ford already has already demonstrated its F-series all electric pickup prototype. I don't doubt that the semi truck market is huge, but again I ask: what specifically does Tesla have that would make it a monopoly here? Seems like another commodity market.
> Plus a static energy provider (powerwall, powerpack, megapack).
> Plus a solar provider (solar panels + solar tiles)
In theory, yes, but in practice they haven't sold much of this at all. Remember, the current revenue growth is on the back of their car revenues. Vast majority of their opex is in car manufacturing and sales.
> Plus a large refuel / recharge network provider (superchargers) who has a huge lead on literally everyone.
This is a strong point, but I'm not sure that it's really that much of a competitive advantage. While you're right that Tesla has a huge lead on everyone, that's just because the vast majority of consumers still drive ICE cars, and get the energy for that from Chevron/Arco/Shell/BP pumps sprinkled all over the world. The world will gradually shift away from ICE -> electric, but installing electric chargers at gas pumps isn't a huge lift for your Chevrons of the world — they already have the humans, capital, and real estate.
> Their current stock price seems a tad low if they're able to execute effectively in all of the markets they're in. So far, it does appear that they are.
I don't doubt that Tesla will continue to exist and be hugely successful — I'm even rooting for Elon because he is IMO the most interesting industrialist of all time. It still doesn't necessarily mean that they are worth $200B+.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:05AM
(#23489652)
Its a question of margins. Take a look at the new Ford EV (Mustang) that competes Model Y. That care has the same amount of miles and yet has 2x the battery. That means that car is flat not making money.
Tesla has demonstrated 25% margin, and their Model 3 is still a nightmare to manufacture. The Cybertruck promised to get there too. The Model Y based on breakdowns is pretty well designed to make good margin.
One argument one has to make is not why is Tesla so high, but why are the others so low. They have gigantic capital stock that is dropping in value like a stone, the used car market will be fludded with insane amounts of old ICEs. These companies have thin margins already, and they will need to make huge investments in batteries and new product lines to compete. All of that with a stock market that doesn't make it easy for them to raise money.
We saw this during Covid, companies like Ford and GM start dropping 10s of billions as soon as their margins slide.
Even given all of those good things, Tesla is still high. For me, the only thing that can make it worth it, is the taxi fleet idea. If you don't believe in that, then the evaluation is way to high.
I bought my stock at basically the lowest point in Covid, but I think I'm gone hold it longer. Just because even if you don't believe in the fundamentals, I think the hype cycle is at a peak yet.
And I think I believe in the taxi idea, simply because whatever people think Elon knows about the potential profit and is doing everything he can to get there. Others simply don't have that conviction and drive.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bhupy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:32AM
(#23489927)
> They have gigantic capital stock that is dropping in value like a stone, the used car market will be fludded with insane amounts of old ICEs. These companies have thin margins already, and they will need to make huge investments in batteries and new product lines to compete. All of that with a stock market that doesn't make it easy for them to raise money.
Just want to point out that Toyota Motor Company's gross profit has been at about $50 billion per year. That's their profit.
Honda's gross profit has been about $30 billion per year.
Ford's annual gross profit has been teetering $20-25B per year.
Tesla's gross profit is $4B (and increasing).
This isn't to knock Tesla, I just want to make sure you're not under-estimating the competition. I think it's too early to say for sure who is going to win the electric automobile market.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 11, 2020 @03:03PM
(#23492239)
Yes, I really think this headline is less about Tesla and more about the other car companies. Ford's stock price is teetering close to 10% of it's peak value. The fed is injecting huge liquidity into the stock market and it's going into TSLA and not into Ford etc.
I'm fairly confident that some car companies will make it through the transition to electric, and that some won't, but I have no idea which. Tesla is going to be one of them, but that upside is already priced in. VW is investing tens of billions, maybe they'll be OK? OTOH Toyota's conservative strategy may be best -- I'm sure they'll introduce electric cars when there is a solid market for them. Perhaps being last to the party just means that it'll be cheaper for them to transition.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Friday June 12, 2020 @05:44AM
(#23497593)
I think Toyota should be higher then Tesla. The only reason for me why I'm a bit iffy on them is that they still going after hydrogen and there electrification strategy is pretty wrong. They seem to have partly realized that but still not totally convinced by their new strategy. They will defently survive and thrive, but I don't think they can dominate more then they do now.
Ford has been problematic and their balance sheet is not that great, their margin are very thin and they totally relay on high margin trucks and SUV. Their electrification plans seem pretty terrible, so I would not bet on them at all.
Betting on Tesla is betting on the other car makers having trouble doing the transition and making profits at the same time. Tesla ability to continuation to execute year after year. And to justify the super high evaluations, bringing self driving to market.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Retric on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:41AM
(#23489409)
Basically, comparing Apple and Samsung based on number of phones sold is a poor metric. The same applies to Tesla and GM.
Vertical integration is a huge difference between Tesla and other car companies. GM and Ford outsource a significantly higher percentage of their cars than Tesla. On top of this their an automotive dealer which captures more revenue and by making cars on demand has lower capital costs.
Bosch, Denso, Magna, Continental and ZF Friedrichshafen so more than just make auto parts, but still end up as huge players in the automotive industry.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:53AM
(#23489535)
They have not made money as a a ride-sharing company as they have not tried this. The point is that when it comes online, they will have a huge fleet. That means extra profit with very little investing.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bhupy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:57AM
(#23489578)
> The point is that when it comes online, they will have a huge fleet.
This might be correct in a world with full-self-driving, though as others might point out, we're quite far away from that. Waymo is probably closer to full-self-driving than Tesla is [1].
If you're talking about just raw Tesla car ownership, then ride-sharing operations still requires a human being to be sitting in the driver's seat that expects to be fairly compensated, at which point you have the same supply growth problem that Uber/Lyft have.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by xkjkls on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:06PM
(#23491612)
There’s nothing to indicate that ML learning with only cameras is the best way to achieve FSD features though. And many Tesla autopilot mishaps indicate the opposite.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Silhouette on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:20AM
(#23489167)
The problem is that, as every investment firm reminds us, past performance is not a guarantee of future returns. This year is not going to look like last year, for just about anyone in business.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by u10 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:14AM
(#23489084)
The world has gone insane... treating a manufacturing company like it's a tech company and applying the "appropriate" multiples. People are going to lose their shirts on this one.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by jeffreyrogers on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:49AM
(#23489502)
The more things I've seen like this, the more I realize the wisdom of Keyne's quote, "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent", or something to that effect. There have been a number of publicly traded companies I've seen with outrageous valuations, that've shocked me by how long they've maintained them. I've probably been right about the eventual outcome about 70% of the time, but I would have lost a ton of money trying to bet against them.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by alextheparrot on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:38AM
(#23489375)
Couldn’t you apply this same principle to Apple from ~2000 until current? It seems, at least in some pocket markets, there exists an intersection where manufacturing and technology combine to be highly profitable.
Maybe car manufacturing isn’t one of those places, but I feel like that’s more difficult to dismiss as flippantly.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by u10 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:57AM
(#23489580)
Not really, for one Apple outsources their manufacturing to various companies (TSMC, Foxconn, AMD, Intel, etc). This allows Apple to focus on design and software (ie, the hardware design follows the software, unlike Tesla where the software follows the hardware, so to speak), and not get bogged down in the manufacturing process. Apple handles the design and software, not the manufacturing.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Lazare on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:35AM
(#23489350)
"Realistic"? Shorting a stock is not a pure mathematical bet that a stock will, in the fullness of time, be viewed as overvalued, it's a concrete bet about prices in the near term. :)
Plenty of people called the 90s dot com bubble, shorted tech stocks, then lost everything because the bubble kept going until they ran out of cash to make short bets. Same with the housing market more recently.
If you could magically know that Company X's stock is overvalued, and that it WILL collapse at some point, but you couldn't figure out when, just a vague "sometime in the next 10 years", going long would be a good way to lose money (it will collapse eventually), but going short would also be a good way to lose money. Timing matters just as much as direction.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by CrazyStat on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:16AM
(#23489115)
A recognition that the market may continue to be irrational for a long time, so even if you believe a company to be extremely overvalued it may be unwise to short it unless you have infinitely deep pockets.
If you insist on a single word, may I suggest "experience."
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by gpm on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:19AM
(#23489151)
And even if you have infinite money, a short squeeze in the meantime can mean that you permanently lose money on shorting the stock before it goes down.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by ABeeSea on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:15AM
(#23489107)
The one where shorting requires debt and a massive risk premium on the time value of money. Not to mention the unlimited risk piece. The two bets aren’t symmetric
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by tibbydudeza on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:10AM
(#23489056)
Talk to me again when they make something for the common folk like the Toyota Corolla or VW Golf ... sure they will become an important player but it will be like Volvo.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by AlanSE on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:17AM
(#23489127)
The valuation basically assumes that the Corolla of Tesla will come around sometime in the next 10 years, otherwise volume won't be enough. But not before they run out of all the most profitable markets. Thus the consumer-level truck.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by fomine3 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:36PM
(#23495431)
As an outside of US person, I won't expect US car manufacturer going to record top sales on all over the world. In EV era, I expect Tesla would get BMW position but not Volkswagen/Toyota.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:23AM
(#23489194)
I want to love Tesla, but between messing with car setup OTA, issues with getting parts and basically treating car like a software release, it is difficult for me to consider it for purchase ( and I do want an EV ). Eh, I really hope other manufacturers deliver.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by zaroth on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:24AM
(#23489211)
Most of all it’s important to understand the headline is totally false. The “value” of a company is not represented in its equity market cap.
Other car companies finance their operations through debt instead of equity. It directly effects their market cap. It doesn’t directly effect their “value”.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by syllable_studio on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:12AM
(#23489072)
People will never understand Tesla's value if they don't understand that Tesla is more than just a car company. (But no comment on the current stock value.)
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by jariel on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:18AM
(#23489133)
Actually, really the opposite.
People will never understand Tesla unless they understand it really is just a car company.
There is no magic leap here. Cars are becoming smarter, and more electric and car manufacturers have been adjusting all along.
Most car buyers are not caught up in the heady-dreamspace that the Tesla brand is built on - they will just by what they perceive to be value at price.
What is 'amazing' is that someone was able to actually break into making cars in the 21st century! That's a hell of an achievement.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by klmadfejno on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:27AM
(#23489241)
People treat 'tech' as a type of company. It should really be a modifier. It's still noteworthy though. The advantages of being tech literate and building your processes from the ground up with software in mind cuts out enormous swaths of labor costs and decision making tedium. It's not something that legacy companies of any industry are often successful at reshaping towards.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Shivetya on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:22AM
(#23489181)
True; disclaimer I own a 3. When talking to coworkers if not friends when most of them state they want an EV they mean a Tesla.
Some of this is from the simple fact they are first and their offerings are very unlike traditional manufacturers. Most competing offerings are forever denoted with the asterisk of coming in 2022 or later. There should be more offerings this year to include Ford's Mach E but the real test here isn't that the public wants it, the real test is will Ford increase supply if demand is there. I don't feel like Chevrolet/GM has done that. VW is the real contender if they hold to their statements of how many cars they intend to push
Still Tesla needs to get their act together. Customer service is a sore spot and getting in contact with levels higher than local service centers is far too difficult. They also have reduced content in the 3 and Y instead of increasing it; no default homelink and remove auto dimming mirrors. They seem to was to pass off games and features while parked as more content instead of what improves QOL of living with a vehicle.
Long term we need Tesla so that manufacturers don't try to force us into settling for ranges of 250miles/400km which a lot of future offerings are. Just like they would not make EVs over 100/160 until Tesla forced their hand they won't be pushing 300/500 unless pushed.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by mschuster91 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:24AM
(#23489207)
A software company (where they are lightyears ahead of everyone else), an AI company (they've got far more real world training data than everyone else) and a battery management tech company (again, they have the most experience). The fusion of these three strong parts and their car knowledge (where their advantage over the competition is not the experience but the agility) is what drives the valuation.
Tesla only has to solve scale (which they're beginning to do) and spare parts availability (which is going to solve itself but it needs time to build out a network) to utterly dominate the car market of the future.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by Traster on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:51AM
(#23489521)
Huh? Tesla has to actually solve self-driving to justify their valuation. All the things you've listed might put them at an advantage solving that problem, but what their software does today doesn't justify the valuation. If it turns out that Tesla are probably 1 or 2 steps ahead of most fo the competition towards self-driving. It may turn out that we're a thousand steps away from self-driving, in which case their AI and software advantages simply aren't going to map to massive profits.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by u10 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:28AM
(#23489259)
They don't sell software though... they sell cars augmented with software. If they don't have cars to sell they don't have any software to sell. Sure, one could argue the valuation is pricing in the value of the patents but that doesn't mean that Tesla is not overvalued.
Not to mention most of their RnD and their capex goes towards manufacturing cars.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:17AM
(#23489118)
That there is so much tech conservatism on Hacker News is quite baffling. The idea that self driving cars will not exist is just nonsense, and Tesla is best place to exploit it.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by marvin on Thursday June 11, 2020 @02:33PM
(#23491901)
Because self-driving is a strategically critical element of any car company that wants to survive once it becomes obvious how to do it.
This means that anyone doing self-driving needs to be a manufacturer in order to avoid getting squeezed on terms and profitability. And vice versa. A partnership won’t cut it; one company of the partnership will get screwed and the thing will go nowhere.
That’s why having both is critical, and I think this point is not fullt appreaciated.
Waymo is the strong party in a negotation with any manufacturer, and the manufacturers know this.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by mucle6 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:44AM
(#23489452)
I've heard that whenever someone uses autopilot on a Telsa, if they override the autopilot, it sends the car's video and commands from before, and uses the override as the "correct" decision.
If Tesla has every one of their cars feeding their models more data, it does feel like a natural conclusion that they will be able to overtake waymo.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by sixQuarks on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:35AM
(#23489343)
billions of miles of real-world driving data from a million and growing fleet of vehicles.
Tesla has built their own chip optimized fully for self-driving.
all-in on vision based full self-driving, which seems to be the only way to solve all the edge cases. Even if google accomplishes self driving with lidar, lidar will never be able to compensate for all edge cases. Human vision already compensates for all edge cases, thus the case for vision based self driving.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by bhupy on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:49AM
(#23489506)
Waymo also appears to have real-world driving data from their fleet of cars, and also appears to have an operational ridesharing pilot with no driver in the front-seat.
Another way of asking this question: how many "millions" of miles is sufficient, and at what point are there diminishing returns?
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by nickik on Friday June 12, 2020 @05:54AM
(#23497646)
They have a partially driverless service in one small city where conditions are mostly perfect and traffic is light.
The problem is slogging threw millions and millions of corner cases in the real world. A trillion miles on the highway are quite pointless, a trillion miles in one Arizona city will also not get you there.
You need millions of miles in all driving conditions and train the car to always figure out 100s of details. Look at the Tesla presentation where just recognizing a 'Stop' is incredibly difficult. Working threw all these problems requires having 10000s of cars with real sensors sourcing data from you.
The advantage Tesla has is that they can do this with zero capital, while Waymo needs to have a expensive cars (100 to 1000s) with a payed driver, go threw every location and create a HD maps.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by jcranmer on Thursday June 11, 2020 @10:48AM
(#23489495)
It's been such a long time since I've heard someone trot out the "Tesla has the best raw data" canard that I thought it had finally died off for real.
For starters, Tesla still seems to have this annoying habit of not detecting large, white trucks that are stopped in the middle of the highway, and will happily drive into them at full speed. This isn't exactly an "edge case" issue here.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by sixQuarks on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:04PM
(#23490259)
I didn't say best raw data. Lidar obviously produces better raw data on an individual basis. Tesla has more real-world driving data overall. Nevertheless, it doesn't matter. Tesla is the only one going all-in on vision based self driving. That's the key thing that's going to get us to full self driving. Everyone will eventually need to do this.
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by jcranmer on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:51PM
(#23490758)
> I didn't say best raw data. Lidar obviously produces better raw data on an individual basis. Tesla has more real-world driving data overall.
The "real-world driving data" is what I'm calling the "raw data" here, as it's the raw data from the standpoint of the (perceived) AI algorithms driving self-driving cars.
> Tesla is the only one going all-in on vision based self driving. That's the key thing that's going to get us to full self driving.
Why is it the key thing? Why should worsening the quality of your input data improve the results?
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by jcranmer on Thursday June 11, 2020 @04:05PM
(#23492827)
The hardware necessary to emulate our brain capabilities with neural nets is several orders of magnitude more expensive than lidar.
Running with a more responsible hardware stack means the software has to be more cleverly designed, and that design is mostly not in the just-throw-data-at-a-neural-net stage. Building your visible-light-only driving system is going to cause you to struggle a lot harder at getting a good subroutine for "how far away is that object?" while providing you no benefit to solving the harder problem of "what will that object react to my coming nearer to it?"
Re:Tesla is close to becoming the most valuable car company
by OldHand2018 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:07AM
(#23489665)
> For starters, Tesla still seems to have this annoying habit of not detecting large, white trucks that are stopped in the middle of the highway, and will happily drive into them at full speed. This isn't exactly an "edge case" issue here.
<joke>To be fair, it was an edge case until Tesla started selling cars.</joke>
I was a (small time) shareholder from around 2013 until last year when I happily liquidated my position and put in an order for a Model 3.
I don't think anyone can really say whether this share price is justified even with all the future growth priced in. This is a company that has been at least partly responsible for some quite fundamental changes in mobility, and they're nowhere done yet. (I'm more excited about the Semi than Cybertruck).
They've also helped drive the price/watt of batteries right down which is having a multitude of knock-on effects across many industries. Without Tesla, would we have seen battery powered airplanes starting to be built? Maybe we would, but they would probably be at the least more expensive.
I can't wait to see what the future holds for Tesla, and despite all his shortcomings, I'm happy Musk is still in charge. This all simply would not have happened without his insane drive and determination.
(Strangely, HN, that loved Apple in Steve Jobs' glory days, seems to have a lot of irrational hatred for Tesla).
Jobs was vocal in public about products they have already launched. They delivered products that were obviously best at what they were intended for. Musk is vocal about - well, apparently everything - and ICE:s are still a superior option for a large category of car owners.
I think the biggest gripe is probably about overpromising autopilot capability years before it's actually production ready.
Still, Musk is up there with Ford on a list of industrialists who made a dent in the universe in my books.
Very fair! This has been a pretty spectacular overpromise. I firmly believe FSD will get here eventually but the timeframes were ridiculously off.
What I also read is an insane amount of comment on every SpaceX and Tesla post here about how bad it is to have touchscreens in cars or spacecraft, and how huge swathes of HN commenters are absolutely convinced touchscreens are dangerous, regressive, etc. Even when professional pilots chime in about how they're used in aircraft. Even when SpaceX designed their Dragon controls in consultation with the veteran astronauts who use them, HN was convinced this was bad, and don't even mention they dared used Chromium!
(Not really a Tesla specific thing using touchscreens but seems to be a very popular complaint about them here.)
https://trl.co.uk/reports/interacting-android-auto-and-apple...
Even when professional pilots chime in about how they're used in aircraft.
Flying an aircraft is a very different experience to driving a car. The procedures, instruments and control systems are so different that I'm not sure there's really any meaningful comparison at all.
As for the touchscreens, so much of that speaks to Musk's credibility. He seems to make decisions, like with Autopilot above, more for PR than for safety. I can see why people are going to be skeptical when he claims touchscreens are best for space usage/
Well ... depends.
Airliner FMS systems are awesome.
Small planes usually have Garmin 430 and 530 GPS units, which are not touchscreen (they have side buttons), and have shitty UIs. And those eye-watering navigation database update prices ... thousands per year.
You do need some with the personality of Musk to take on the current automobile industry. But this also means Musk needs to be always in the news with a lot of unfulfilled claims: https://elonmusk.today/
I think the narrative that they are always late on everything is wrong. The set insane goals and most of the time they miss them, but they are still fast even in those cases.
I bought stocks for the first time right in the heart of the Covid-19 crisis, Tesla is riding two massive waves of change, electrification and self-driving. It will take 10-15 years to shake out completely but I think Tesla will be the big winner of this shakeout.
It is absolute insanity.
Personally, based on a very superficial understanding of economy, I... don't actually mind - as long as their personnel, suppliers, and taxes are paid timely and adequately, they are doing their 'contribution' to the economy.
It appears that technically, your statement is incorrect in that they've produced some prototypes. And they have orders (not sure if that counts as sales), but they've not actually delivered a production vehicle yet. Which makes their market cap seem insane, but it seems like most publicly traded companies have had insane market caps since the 90s.
Usually public companies go threw funding rounds, this company knew they couldn't convince any real funds.
They claim to have battery technology that is way ahead of anybody else, and that just sounds like a nonsense claim. They basically do nothing inhouse, say about Tesla what you want but they have technical skills.
Seems to me Nikola is basically a scam designed to be as Tesla like as possible but with a little twist to make it seem just different enough.
The parts of this conglomerate are:
* The vehicle manufacturing. This one is obvious - they have a big lead on other automakers in producing EVs and this lead is not closing. They will keep expanding their portfolio of models and markets until they're near the top.
* The mobility service. This will grow out of their Autopilot efforts and take on Uber et all. This will be much wider though, as it will include public transit services with the Boring Co, private cars, and even taking on rail with fleets of Semis.
* The electricity utility business. This one is simple as well - there's a ton of cheap solar and wind power. Pairing it with batteries and Tesla's management software means they'll be providing the infrastructure utilities use. They likely won't become a utility themselves, as that requires local certifications etc.
* The homes business. Your home needs a battery, a roof that makes power and a geothermal HVAC system. Tesla wants to sell them to you all tied up with great software.
* Planes. Electric flight needs the best batteries and electric motors, Tesla would be pretty crazy not to pursue this. No, they're not going to take on Boeing or Airbus, but small, regional commuter planes (range of several hundred km) are within reach in 10 years.
Anyway, it's pretty simple. If you believe the above, go long. If you think it's BS, go short. If you think this is a bit too out-there/WTF, then just sit back and enjoy the show.
I assume that the first sentence, including declining revenues, is in reference to the current state vs expectations. The disconnect may be in what “Declining revenues” was intended to mean, in this case it makes sense if it is against expected revenue instead of the global value.
If you were to price this company as a combination of auto (Ford/GM) + energy (Chevron) + ridesharing? (Uber/Lyft), then you could maybe justify this valuation in the long run, but Tesla is yet to really prove any real revenue in energy and ridesharing, at scale. The current value is pure hype and expectation, and remains to be seen who ends up being correct in the long run.
Tesla is a car company. Their current products are great. Their upcoming products might be industry changing. The Semi is going to lower the cost of longhaul freight, which has ripple down effects across many industries. The cybertruck is a moonshot granted, but just might hit it big. Allegedly, they have over 500,000 reservations for it which is more than the Model 3 ever had.
Tesla is a car company.
Plus a static energy provider (powerwall, powerpack, megapack).
Plus a solar provider (solar panels + solar tiles)
Plus a large refuel / recharge network provider (superchargers) who has a huge lead on literally everyone.
Plus a software company. Even if you want to joke about AP not being full self driving. Find a car you can buy right now that does all of the things that a Tesla on autopilot can do (in specific, stop lights / signs, smart summon, and navigate on autopilot). Last I checked, the closest was Mercedes's supercruise, which is very good and still doesn't have 1/2 of the functionality of Tesla. The OTA updates really are game changing. When I purchased my Model 3 in November 2018, it lacked an alarm system (Sentry Mode), dashcam (Tesla Cam), etc. I got this and a ton more functionality, for free via OTA updates. Unlike every other automotive company, I didn't have to wait for their next year's model. This is a radical rethink of the industry.
Their current stock price seems a tad low if they're able to execute effectively in all of the markets they're in. So far, it does appear that they are.
I don't doubt that Tesla is a great car, I plan to buy one myself. The question is whether this justifies that kind of valuation. Cars are a commodity, and for as long as they've existed, there have always been great cars, shitty cars, and everything in between.
Re: cybertruck. Ford already has already demonstrated its F-series all electric pickup prototype. I don't doubt that the semi truck market is huge, but again I ask: what specifically does Tesla have that would make it a monopoly here? Seems like another commodity market.
> Plus a static energy provider (powerwall, powerpack, megapack).
> Plus a solar provider (solar panels + solar tiles)
In theory, yes, but in practice they haven't sold much of this at all. Remember, the current revenue growth is on the back of their car revenues. Vast majority of their opex is in car manufacturing and sales.
> Plus a large refuel / recharge network provider (superchargers) who has a huge lead on literally everyone.
This is a strong point, but I'm not sure that it's really that much of a competitive advantage. While you're right that Tesla has a huge lead on everyone, that's just because the vast majority of consumers still drive ICE cars, and get the energy for that from Chevron/Arco/Shell/BP pumps sprinkled all over the world. The world will gradually shift away from ICE -> electric, but installing electric chargers at gas pumps isn't a huge lift for your Chevrons of the world — they already have the humans, capital, and real estate.
> Their current stock price seems a tad low if they're able to execute effectively in all of the markets they're in. So far, it does appear that they are.
I don't doubt that Tesla will continue to exist and be hugely successful — I'm even rooting for Elon because he is IMO the most interesting industrialist of all time. It still doesn't necessarily mean that they are worth $200B+.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAlIfWcCJdI
Tesla has demonstrated 25% margin, and their Model 3 is still a nightmare to manufacture. The Cybertruck promised to get there too. The Model Y based on breakdowns is pretty well designed to make good margin.
One argument one has to make is not why is Tesla so high, but why are the others so low. They have gigantic capital stock that is dropping in value like a stone, the used car market will be fludded with insane amounts of old ICEs. These companies have thin margins already, and they will need to make huge investments in batteries and new product lines to compete. All of that with a stock market that doesn't make it easy for them to raise money.
We saw this during Covid, companies like Ford and GM start dropping 10s of billions as soon as their margins slide.
Even given all of those good things, Tesla is still high. For me, the only thing that can make it worth it, is the taxi fleet idea. If you don't believe in that, then the evaluation is way to high.
I bought my stock at basically the lowest point in Covid, but I think I'm gone hold it longer. Just because even if you don't believe in the fundamentals, I think the hype cycle is at a peak yet.
And I think I believe in the taxi idea, simply because whatever people think Elon knows about the potential profit and is doing everything he can to get there. Others simply don't have that conviction and drive.
Just want to point out that Toyota Motor Company's gross profit has been at about $50 billion per year. That's their profit.
Honda's gross profit has been about $30 billion per year.
Ford's annual gross profit has been teetering $20-25B per year.
Tesla's gross profit is $4B (and increasing).
This isn't to knock Tesla, I just want to make sure you're not under-estimating the competition. I think it's too early to say for sure who is going to win the electric automobile market.
I'm fairly confident that some car companies will make it through the transition to electric, and that some won't, but I have no idea which. Tesla is going to be one of them, but that upside is already priced in. VW is investing tens of billions, maybe they'll be OK? OTOH Toyota's conservative strategy may be best -- I'm sure they'll introduce electric cars when there is a solid market for them. Perhaps being last to the party just means that it'll be cheaper for them to transition.
Ford has been problematic and their balance sheet is not that great, their margin are very thin and they totally relay on high margin trucks and SUV. Their electrification plans seem pretty terrible, so I would not bet on them at all.
Betting on Tesla is betting on the other car makers having trouble doing the transition and making profits at the same time. Tesla ability to continuation to execute year after year. And to justify the super high evaluations, bringing self driving to market.
Vertical integration is a huge difference between Tesla and other car companies. GM and Ford outsource a significantly higher percentage of their cars than Tesla. On top of this their an automotive dealer which captures more revenue and by making cars on demand has lower capital costs.
Bosch, Denso, Magna, Continental and ZF Friedrichshafen so more than just make auto parts, but still end up as huge players in the automotive industry.
This might be correct in a world with full-self-driving, though as others might point out, we're quite far away from that. Waymo is probably closer to full-self-driving than Tesla is [1].
If you're talking about just raw Tesla car ownership, then ride-sharing operations still requires a human being to be sitting in the driver's seat that expects to be fairly compensated, at which point you have the same supply growth problem that Uber/Lyft have.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaOB-ErYq6Y
Maybe car manufacturing isn’t one of those places, but I feel like that’s more difficult to dismiss as flippantly.
"There's too much risk either direction, stay away from it" sounds pretty sane to me.
Plenty of people called the 90s dot com bubble, shorted tech stocks, then lost everything because the bubble kept going until they ran out of cash to make short bets. Same with the housing market more recently.
If you could magically know that Company X's stock is overvalued, and that it WILL collapse at some point, but you couldn't figure out when, just a vague "sometime in the next 10 years", going long would be a good way to lose money (it will collapse eventually), but going short would also be a good way to lose money. Timing matters just as much as direction.
If you insist on a single word, may I suggest "experience."
Other car companies finance their operations through debt instead of equity. It directly effects their market cap. It doesn’t directly effect their “value”.
Toyota enterprise value: $325B
Tesla enterprise value: $200B
https://ycharts.com/companies/TM/enterprise_value https://ycharts.com/companies/TSLA/enterprise_value
People will never understand Tesla unless they understand it really is just a car company.
There is no magic leap here. Cars are becoming smarter, and more electric and car manufacturers have been adjusting all along.
Most car buyers are not caught up in the heady-dreamspace that the Tesla brand is built on - they will just by what they perceive to be value at price.
What is 'amazing' is that someone was able to actually break into making cars in the 21st century! That's a hell of an achievement.
But it's just a car.
Although there may be a Magic Leap here:
https://techcrunch.com/2020/04/26/tragic-leap/
Some of this is from the simple fact they are first and their offerings are very unlike traditional manufacturers. Most competing offerings are forever denoted with the asterisk of coming in 2022 or later. There should be more offerings this year to include Ford's Mach E but the real test here isn't that the public wants it, the real test is will Ford increase supply if demand is there. I don't feel like Chevrolet/GM has done that. VW is the real contender if they hold to their statements of how many cars they intend to push
Still Tesla needs to get their act together. Customer service is a sore spot and getting in contact with levels higher than local service centers is far too difficult. They also have reduced content in the 3 and Y instead of increasing it; no default homelink and remove auto dimming mirrors. They seem to was to pass off games and features while parked as more content instead of what improves QOL of living with a vehicle.
Long term we need Tesla so that manufacturers don't try to force us into settling for ranges of 250miles/400km which a lot of future offerings are. Just like they would not make EVs over 100/160 until Tesla forced their hand they won't be pushing 300/500 unless pushed.
Tesla only has to solve scale (which they're beginning to do) and spare parts availability (which is going to solve itself but it needs time to build out a network) to utterly dominate the car market of the future.
Not to mention most of their RnD and their capex goes towards manufacturing cars.
Is Tesla just a car company? No.
Does Tesla still have an exponential growth outlook? Yes.
Has Tesla been able to meet their stated goals in the 1st 10 years? Yes.
Do you think Tesla will meet their stated goals for the next 10 years? Probably
This is why Tesla market cap is nearly 200 billion.
Where is the full self driving car? They are selling a feature that most likely will never exist.
https://www.tesla.com/blog/secret-tesla-motors-master-plan-j...
This means that anyone doing self-driving needs to be a manufacturer in order to avoid getting squeezed on terms and profitability. And vice versa. A partnership won’t cut it; one company of the partnership will get screwed and the thing will go nowhere.
That’s why having both is critical, and I think this point is not fullt appreaciated.
Waymo is the strong party in a negotation with any manufacturer, and the manufacturers know this.
If Tesla has every one of their cars feeding their models more data, it does feel like a natural conclusion that they will be able to overtake waymo.
*Disclaimer: I'm not an expert in ML
Tesla has built their own chip optimized fully for self-driving.
all-in on vision based full self-driving, which seems to be the only way to solve all the edge cases. Even if google accomplishes self driving with lidar, lidar will never be able to compensate for all edge cases. Human vision already compensates for all edge cases, thus the case for vision based self driving.
Another way of asking this question: how many "millions" of miles is sufficient, and at what point are there diminishing returns?
The problem is slogging threw millions and millions of corner cases in the real world. A trillion miles on the highway are quite pointless, a trillion miles in one Arizona city will also not get you there.
You need millions of miles in all driving conditions and train the car to always figure out 100s of details. Look at the Tesla presentation where just recognizing a 'Stop' is incredibly difficult. Working threw all these problems requires having 10000s of cars with real sensors sourcing data from you.
The advantage Tesla has is that they can do this with zero capital, while Waymo needs to have a expensive cars (100 to 1000s) with a payed driver, go threw every location and create a HD maps.
For starters, Tesla still seems to have this annoying habit of not detecting large, white trucks that are stopped in the middle of the highway, and will happily drive into them at full speed. This isn't exactly an "edge case" issue here.
The "real-world driving data" is what I'm calling the "raw data" here, as it's the raw data from the standpoint of the (perceived) AI algorithms driving self-driving cars.
> Tesla is the only one going all-in on vision based self driving. That's the key thing that's going to get us to full self driving.
Why is it the key thing? Why should worsening the quality of your input data improve the results?
Our eyes get worse data than lidar, yet our brains are able to process this data more effectively.
Also, lidar is super expensive. It will take much longer to get affordable lidar into everyday vehicles.
Running with a more responsible hardware stack means the software has to be more cleverly designed, and that design is mostly not in the just-throw-data-at-a-neural-net stage. Building your visible-light-only driving system is going to cause you to struggle a lot harder at getting a good subroutine for "how far away is that object?" while providing you no benefit to solving the harder problem of "what will that object react to my coming nearer to it?"
<joke>To be fair, it was an edge case until Tesla started selling cars.</joke>