News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by philistine on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:17PM (#23478816)
With the heavy rumours of Apple moving forward with ARM chips in Macs, Intel clearly showed the plans for this chip to Apple last year, and Apple said no thank you.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by AgloeDreams on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:47PM (#23479206)
Why wouldn't they!

While Intel showed this, Apple was currently selling iPhone 11s with processors that would clearly outpace this. The A13 has two large cores and four small cores, whereas either one of the large cores outperform the comparable 'Core' core in this, and I'm betting the smaller cores do as well, possibly at less power. Supposedly their ARM< Mac CPU is a 12 core architecture, I imagine with four large cores and 8 small cores. Thats a massive hardware difference...did I mention that the 12 core CPU is supposed to be build on TSMC's 5nm? Intel is trying to get current and honestly, maybe Apple will ship a Macbook Air with it.. but probably not.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by kllrnohj on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:14PM (#23480277)
> The A13 has two large cores and four small cores, whereas either one of the large cores outperform the comparable 'Core' core in this

The evidence of this is flimsy at best. It's possible the A13's big cores are faster than Intel's Sunny Cove, but also not very likely, and certainly not established fact. The only real evidence here is Geekbench, which is a highly questionable benchmark that also has extreme OS dependencies (compare results for the same CPU on Windows & Linux, for example).

When/if an Apple releases something running MacOS with their custom ARM cores then you'd finally get a good comparison to isolate the CPU's performance by itself.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by rpiguy on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:29PM (#23481046)
This is not true we have a pretty good idea of where the A13 stands. Anandtech has run SpecInt and SpecFP on the A13 and shows it to be in the same range of performance as a Xeon Silver 4112 (2.6ghz base/3.0ghz turbo), which is a 14nm chip from 2017.

So not as fast as the latest processors on a per core basis, but still pretty damn fast.

Can't really make assumptions, but you would think with the higher thermal envelope Apple can boost clock speeds making them even more competitive.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by ksec on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:28PM (#23481045)
There are lots of other test from SPEC to Javascript benchmarks ( Using same JS Engine ) that shows what A13 is capable of. And so far results are comparable in many cases, better in some cases, and slower in other cases.

We already knew what to expect from Intel Willow Cove, we will have to wait and see what A14 has in store for us.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by rayiner on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @05:45PM (#23482507)
It’s not just geekbench. People have run SPEC on the Apple chips, which is a suite of real applications like GCC.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by kllrnohj on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:31PM (#23482946)
A12's spec results are close to Intel's single-thread performance at comparable clock speeds in SPEC, yes, but that wasn't the claim. The claim was that A12 was faster and that is what doesn't really have much evidence to support. Particularly since at comparable clock speeds is great and all, but not if your competitor can just outclock you by a landslide. The A12 can almost certainly go higher than 2.5ghz when actively cooled. But can it hit 4ghz? That's a different story.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by rayiner on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:50PM (#23483114)
On SpecInt2006, Apple is matching a 9900K and a 3900X even at a substantially lower clock speed: https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro...
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by gsnedders on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:26PM (#23490484)
>Geekbench, which is a highly questionable benchmark that also has extreme OS dependencies (compare results for the same CPU on Windows & Linux, for example)

OS and compiler dependencies, really. On the other hand, comparing macOS and iOS results may well be more meaningful (they use the same compiler and much of the OS is shared, especially at layers likely to significantly affect performance).

Geekbench (v4 especially) is definitely flawed, but the results in this case don't seem out-of-line with what we see on specINT for example.

e.g., https://browser.geekbench.com/v4/cpu/compare/15541405?baseli... comparing shows an A12X roughly matching a Sunny Cove 1060NG7 on single-thread performance (and it mostly follows where I'd expect Intel's strengths to be, with a wider vector unit and specialized instructions); in multi-thread performance the A12X unsurprisingly wins, but it also has double the number cores (okay, four of them are little, but that's still providing extra capacity to get work done).

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by pradn on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:41PM (#23480574)
IMHO, Apple's phones were considered fantastic for a few reasons, in order: brand (perceived quality, luxury status, pricing, "Apple"), software lock-in (iMessage, iCloud), and privacy (also a branding thing since they still use Google for Safari search). The hardware and camera were usually matched or exceeded by top-tier Android manufacturers. Now, Apple-designed CPUs are leaving their competitors in the dust, and provide, perhaps for the first time in a long time, hardware superiority. I don't think consumers quite understand the actual performance gap yet. But once it gets out, it's probably going to be second or third in the list for why people buy iPhones.

I'm going to switch from a Pixel to an iPhone this year. The CPU is just clearly better, and seems to actually matter for taking photos and web browsing. (The Pixel still takes like 5 seconds to post-process a photo. iPhones do it instantly.)

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by SomeHacker44 on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @08:03PM (#23483637)
I switched for the opposite reason. Phone hardware is plenty fast for anything I want to do, but Apple's really restrictive closed software ecosystem and lack of hardware variety drove me to Android last year after being on Apple since iPhone 3G.

I just wanted a touch ID, notcheless, fast and current phone, and Apple did not offer one until recently.

I am not going back, and I am also now seeing the same thing with their laptops. Crappy keyboards, non optional and useless touch bars, low performance per dollar and software that gets in your way. No thanks. Windows 10, WSL, Surface Book/Go/Alienware, wow. Just good, open, usable stuff.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by Havoc on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:49AM (#23488827)
I'd do the same if I wasn't concerned about Android privacy. My pi-hole is blocking literally 10x as much phoning home stuff on the Android device I've got vs iPhone. And that is with the iPhone having way more crap installed on it.

Literally phoning home every 2 mins:

https://i.imgur.com/VJH8Yqa.png

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by delfinom on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:38PM (#23483013)
Pixel 2 and newer have a completely independent processor for photo processing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pixel_Visual_Core

It also includes :AI:

The Pixel 4 has renamed it the "Pixel Neural Core" and has given it even more machine learning tasks and offloading such as Google Assistant and face unlock.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by pradn on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:04PM (#23493769)
That's true, but I meant the general-purpose CPU.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by harpratap on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:02PM (#23480784)
the Pixel 4 has dedicated Visual cores based on their TPUs they developed inhouse. All my Pixel 4 photo processing is near instant.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by oehtXRwMkIs on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:03PM (#23480790)
What are your sources for the claim that the hardware superiority actually matters in real life? Every once in a while when I'm looking to buy a phone, I like to check out videos that do real life speed tests (mainly opening apps but other tasks as well) and iPhones have never been on top. Curious to see if that has changed recently.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by acdha on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:57PM (#23481336)
You're asking for sources and then citing unnamed “real life speed test” videos without any way for people to see what they're measuring or how solid their methodology was?

The main area where normal people notice this is in web usage, where Mobile Safari has handily outpaced Android browsing for many years — see e.g. https://discuss.emberjs.com/t/why-was-ember-3x-5x-slower-on-... from 2014. How much that matters depends on how much a particular website is limited by single-core JavaScript performance — well-engineered sites probably don't have a huge impact but it's quite noticeable on anything which has a bloated SPA and the web has been moving in the latter direction for years.

Gaming is the other area where this is fairly noticeable but that varies both in where the bottlenecks are (CPU vs. GPU), how prominent the effect is, and the relative quality of the ports so it's harder to do a fair comparison.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by oehtXRwMkIs on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @05:56PM (#23482614)
Burden of proof is on the one who makes the claim. I'm just asking for some links and I explained why I doubted the claim.

I appreciate your effort with giving more background, although I think 2014 is a bit dated with Firefox Quantumn becoming more of a thing on Android. Can't remember if the Preview has it yet or not.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by saagarjha on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:54PM (#23481309)
> I like to check out videos that do real life speed tests (mainly opening apps but other tasks as well)

Those "tests" almost invariably suck at measuring anything useful or being accurate.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by oehtXRwMkIs on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @05:58PM (#23482631)
They are certainly better than synthetic benchmarks however. If you know of anything better let us know.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by nojito on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:20PM (#23478851)
It doesn’t matter what Intel shows Apple.

Intel can’t meet deadlines which forces Apple to restructure their plans constantly.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by fermienrico on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:41PM (#23479106)
Just to add color to that - Apple doesn't want external control of their semiconductors. They want to do their own thing starting with the mobile SOCs, then the secure enclave, then the M2 chip, and the GPU, and now mainstream high power processor. What Intel offers is orthogonal.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:50PM (#23479962)
What Intel offers they still have to compete with.

It always seems like a good idea to do your own thing when your supplier is stumbling. The problem then is you're on your own. If they find their footing you're in trouble -- either you've blown a huge pile of money developing something which you then don't use because the competition has something better, or you use it anyway and get to relive the final days of Sun Microsystems.

And the same thing happens if anybody can beat you. If Intel can't but AMD does, you lose. If AMD can't but Qualcomm does, you lose.

Worse, success precipitates failure. If you make an in-house processor which is only a couple of percent faster, that's boring. You spend a lot for a little. If you make one which is more than a couple of percent faster, that's war. Intel can't have that. Google can't have that. Samsung can't have that. Microsoft can't have that. Even if you're bigger than any of them, you're not bigger than all of them. So they double their R&D, combine their resources, whatever it takes, and soon you're Sun Microsystems again.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by jsnell on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:21PM (#23480343)
When was the last time that a commodity mobile phone soc was even remotely competitive with Apple's latest? 2012? That seems like rather strong evidence against your theory.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:36PM (#23480521)
https://benchmarks.ul.com/compare/best-smartphones

https://www.gsmarena.com/benchmark-test.php3

I see a lot of Android devices at the top of those lists.

Apple likes to cherry pick. For example, they require everything on iOS to use their browser engine, then they spend a lot of time optimizing their browser engine for their CPUs. But that's not superior hardware performance, it's software optimization, which they could do with whichever commodity CPU they chose as well.

Intel does the same thing. They spend resources optimizing popular software for their CPUs. Qualcomm not so much.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by mrkstu on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:29PM (#23480444)
Agreed- all those competitors have been shown up by Apple for years. They've had to take it because they haven't been able to come up with a technical response- even those using the same foundries...
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by Jhsto on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:33PM (#23479771)
And don't forget the modem! Apple recently dumped Intel LTE modems as well.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by williadc on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:52PM (#23479992)
... and then acquired the team that made those modems.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by clairity on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:01PM (#23480099)
no, it's not purely about control. apple wants reliability and (predictable) advancement in it's supply chain. if intel had delivered on that by meeting it's own roadmap, apple probably wouldn't be looking to move away from them.

it's not apple simply being control freaks (although they are and can afford to be), it's intel shooting it's own foot.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by robbyt on Thursday June 11, 2020 @06:11AM (#23487134)
Please stop using the phrase "add color to". You're adding details, not color.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by feteru on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:22PM (#23478886)
Do you have a link with more info on this?
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by dpacmittal on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:27PM (#23478946)
Haven't they been trying 10nm for years? It was supposed to come out by 2015.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by benologist on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:31PM (#23480468)
Even when Intel started recycling 14nm why would Apple actually care? Some of their computers have gone years without updates despite newer processors being available, it doesn't seem like an important feature of most of their computers.

In 2008 Apple bought PA Semi to design processors for iOS, make processors for Macs is likely something they've been working on since way before Intel was late on 10nm.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by dannyw on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:25PM (#23478921)
I have only seen a sentence or two mentioned in Bloomberg, etc. But it’s widely known that Intel haven’t delivered a true generational upgrade since Skylake.

We are on 14nm+++++ or something?

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by whynotminot on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:39PM (#23479079)
10nm Icelake in the new 13" MBP is looking like the first solid generational upgrade in recent memory, but yeah, one qualified success in the last 4ish years does not a roadmap make.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by thought_alarm on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:03PM (#23479422)
Intel is hardly to blame for Apple's bungled MacBook lineup of the last 4+ years.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by rbanffy on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:22PM (#23479649)
That the latest and greatest MacBook Pros use 14nm processors is entirely Intel's fault.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by fomine3 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:21PM (#23494659)
Partially due to Apple because they don't prepare for adopt AMD processors (like lack of AMD's instruction like AMD-V support).
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by thought_alarm on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:31PM (#23479748)
That's not the reason why the 2015-2019 MacBooks are such duds.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by catalogia on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @02:33PM (#23480482)
It's one of a few reasons. Macs have worse thermal characteristics than they should; part of that is Apple's fault for making such thin computers with poor ventilation, but part of that is Intel's fault for making such shitty hot chips. Of course there are other matters that can't be laid on Intel, like the keyboard fiasco, but that's beyond the point I think.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by philistine on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:55PM (#23481315)
The keyboards are. Fair is fair.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by deathanatos on Thursday June 11, 2020 @12:15AM (#23485140)
The display cables fraying "Flexgate"[1], the numerous battery recalls[2][3], that the iPhone and the MBP, as shipped, could not be connected to each other (the MBP came with USB-C to USB-C; the iPhone with USB-A to Lightning; the magic trackpads also suffered this)[4], the kernel panics with USB-C until they finally got patched, that the flagship monitor (admittedly an LG device, but advertised on Apple's website at the time) had issues with … Wi-Fi (just being near it, from improper shielding), that same display also had huge issues with disconnecting peripherals (you would connect to the display and get picture/power, but no peripherals), the crappy noisey RSI-inducing redesign of the already poor keyboard (admittedly subjective except for the objective pain in my wrist, but, e.g., [5]¹), the poor design of the device s.t. any breakage in a component results in the complete waste of the remaining good hardware as nothing is independently replaceable/servicable, routinely receiving a score of 1 out of 10 by iFixit, Apple fighting right to repair[6], … oh, and the keyboards breaking the entire laptop from a single grain of sand, the terrible suspend/resume times, … and I haven't upgraded to Catalina yet. I hear that's gone so well for so many.

Yeah, Intel's chips are not the biggest fish in the Apple fish fry.

I'm not even an Apple customer, I'm just forced to use them by my employer. (And it feels like most employers nowadays.)

[1]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/3/5/18251264/macbook-pro-2018-...

[2]: https://support.apple.com/15-inch-macbook-pro-battery-recall

[3]: https://support.apple.com/13inch-macbookpro-battery-replacem...

[4]: https://thenextweb.com/apple/2016/10/27/cant-connect-new-mac...

[5]: https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/01/an-ode-to-apples-awful-mac...

[6]: https://www.vox.com/the-goods/2019/7/3/18761691/right-to-rep...

¹I now limit my use of Apple keyboards to an absolute minimum.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by ksec on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:30PM (#23479733)
>Intel clearly showed the plans for this chip to Apple last year,

Lakefield, Foveros, 10nm were suppose to arrive in 2018. And Apple would likely have known about this roadmap before that time.

Looks like there will be lots to unpack in WWDC, unfortunately it wont be a staged keynote like it used to.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by williadc on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @01:55PM (#23480019)
From what I heard when I worked there, Lakefield was purpose-built for this new Microsoft platform, so it's possible that they would not have showed this to Apple until after some time.

*Edit: I wanted to add that I left about 2 years ago, and thought the project had been cancelled, along with so many other 10nm products.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by ksec on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @03:33PM (#23481091)
So that was before Bob Swan became the new CEO?

Why left? If you dont mind sharing :)

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by williadc on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @09:26PM (#23484296)
> So that was before Bob Swan became the new CEO?

Yes, BK was fired right around the time I gave my notice.

> Why left?

A lot of reasons that would sound like griping. I was recruited by Google for a similar job, but with a chance to build something from the ground up. That sounded like the adventure I was looking for, so I took the offer. I must say, it's been an adventure!

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by ksec on Thursday June 11, 2020 @03:44AM (#23486188)
>A lot of reasons that would sound like griping

Thanks. I guess that does sums it up and align with lots of other similar sentiments I heard over the years.

Off Topic: I think we live in a world where we put too much emphasis on the positives and neglect any negativities. So we end up having any valid complains to be viewed as moaning or griping. I wish as a society there are better ways to handle these rather than simply ignoring it, which would leads to all sort of bad things happening as we seen in the world today.

Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by chongli on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:47PM (#23479200)
Last year would already have been too late. These transitions take at least 5 years. So of course Apple said no thank you.
Re:Intel Discloses Lakefield CPUs Specifications by fomine3 on Thursday June 11, 2020 @08:19PM (#23494650)
When Kaby Lake-G (Intel CPU with RADEON iGPU) is released, I thought that it's for Apple devices but Apple doesn't released devices that use it. I'm curious what's purpose.