News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by onion2k on Monday June 08, 2020 @08:21AM (#23455868)
Alternatively, just work with a designer. There are thousands of them out there who want to build tech stuff but don't have the skills. They want developers to collaborate with. Reach out to some on social media and you might be surprised how receptive they are.

You don't have to do everything on your own, and you definitely shouldn't compromise on design if you want your project to succeed.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by BiteCode_dev on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:01AM (#23456528)
- you may not have the budget for that (small company, student, open source project, side project...)

- you may not be able to find the talent where you are (good designers are not uniformly distributed, and remote may not be possible for you. Source: lived in Africa)

- you may want/need to know the basics to evaluate the work of a designer, hire one or just communicate efficiently with one

- you may just be curious, and want to learn that for you. Or transition to be, you know, a designer :)

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by eitland on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:14AM (#23456190)
Isn't this for people who cannot afford to have a graphic designer?

Unless it is an open source project I feel it would be rude to ask someone to work for free on it.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by onion2k on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:30AM (#23456311)
Unless it is an open source project I feel it would be rude to ask someone to work for free on it.

I said work with a designer, as in a collaboration. As in bring them onboard as a co-founder, give them equity, have an agreement to share profits. Pay them if you can. Share skills by getting them to do design work on your side project in return for coding their side project. There are lots of ways to work with people.

I am absolutely not suggesting anyone asks someone to work for free. That's exploiting people. Don't do that.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by duxup on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:40AM (#23456376)
Are designers usually co-founders?
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by onion2k on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:08AM (#23456579)
Two of YouTube's founders, Chad Hurley and Christina Brodbeck, were designers. Charles Adler who started KickStarter is a designer. It does happen.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by duxup on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:51AM (#23456975)
I think probably how it sounded to me was "Need a designer, get a designer as a co-founder." and I was thinking of random designer drone and not sure how that plays out as a skillet works out as a founder (I consider myself a programmer drone equally likely or not likely to be qualified to be a founder).
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by felideon on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:08AM (#23456583)
Perhaps not typically, as tech startup founders tend to skew on the engineering side (outside of your traditionally MBA-founded startups).

But I believe a UX designer would make a great co-founder if they focus on user research, information architecture, and interaction design.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by meristem on Monday June 08, 2020 @11:04AM (#23457110)
UX designers also have built in product management skills.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by duxup on Monday June 08, 2020 @11:54AM (#23457684)
I mean this sincerely, they do?

I don't know much about UX designers jobs, do they deal with project management often?

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by felideon on Monday June 08, 2020 @01:48PM (#23458824)
Not all of them have the same product sense of a good product manager[1]. However, as far as I can tell, the lines do get pretty blurry the more senior you become as a designer. You shift from tactical work to strategic work which can have a huge influence on the product.

[1] Conversely, a lot of product managers do not have the same UX sense of a good designer. My favorite PMs are ones that have a solid UX background.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by meristem on Monday June 08, 2020 @01:58PM (#23458935)
Yeah, true. Lucky for everyone both UX skills and product skills can be taught. Otherwise we'd have no hope and a sea of disjointed unusable products.

Product management and UX get pretty blurry (positively) when product management wants to generate value to customers by listening to them/distilling what users want into a good strategy that meshes with the business.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by meristem on Monday June 08, 2020 @01:52PM (#23458865)
Product, not project or program management.

Project and program management are detached from the skill set of both product manager and UX experts. One can have the skills, but it is not because they know product or UX.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by TomMarius on Monday June 08, 2020 @12:13PM (#23457867)
They said product management, IMHO an important distinction. Project management is managing the work, product management is shaping the product - again, IMHO.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by meristem on Monday June 08, 2020 @01:53PM (#23458868)
Exactly.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by divbzero on Monday June 08, 2020 @06:39PM (#23461581)
Airbnb. [1] [2]

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Chesky

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joe_Gebbia

That’s 2 out of 3 co-founders.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by divbzero on Monday June 08, 2020 @06:44PM (#23461616)
Airbnb is also a great example of gdub’s comment that “design isn’t all about the way it looks, it’s about the way it works”. [1] This applies not just to the website or the app, but to the entire user experience.

[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23456898

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by mellosouls on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:06AM (#23456573)
Any reason they shouldn't be? Steve Jobs...
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by duxup on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:20AM (#23456682)
I don't think of Steve's skill set as 'designer' alone.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by 411111111111111 on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:26AM (#23456745)
If we put numbers on his talents, I'd wager his marketing skills would be higher then his design ability.

They'd both be high though, that's for sure.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by eitland on Monday June 08, 2020 @12:54PM (#23458282)
Ok, thanks, I misunderstood you. It was absolutely not intentional.

That said wouldn't it be risky to bring someone you hardly know on as cofounder?

Does anyone here have good experience with that?

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by cj on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:26AM (#23456278)
> I feel it would be rude to ask someone to work for free

Presumably you'd exchange % of future revenue / profit share, or an equity split if it's a company.

Or if it's not a revenue-generating project, there might still be people who would help you out in order to build their portfolio.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by brudgers on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:29AM (#23456775)
Will you build a mobile app for me? It will build your portfolio.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by _qulr on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:29AM (#23456306)
Maybe, but I find their slogan "Join the movement" to be very strange. That makes it sound like "No Design" is a goal rather than just a fallback.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by brudgers on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:27AM (#23456749)
Asking a designer to work on your open source project for free is like asking the local pizza parlor to feed your open source project for free. Unless your open source project is something that benefits designers it doesn't...well it doesn't benefit designers. The open source model is mostly developers building things that serve their own interests and the interests of other developers. On top of that developers tend to be paid better than designers and designers get lots of offers to work for free.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by Matumio on Monday June 08, 2020 @11:33AM (#23457406)
If you build a tool for coders, you will most likely find coders who are willing to help. And if you build an (open source) tool for graphics, you will have no problem finding designers who are willing to help for free (speaking from experience).
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by brudgers on Monday June 08, 2020 @12:02PM (#23457756)
Sorry for not being clear. I don’t disagree. An open source tool for designers would probably attract designers’ contributions. Very few open source projects are tools for designers. Most projects looking for free design contributions are not for designers. The ideas of giving back or what comes around goes around don’t apply because the the interests of most projects do not include benefits for designers.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by itsoktocry on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:00AM (#23456524)
>Alternatively, just work with a designer.

How can a person with minimal design skills (ie. me) tell if a designer is any good? I know when I like something, but I can't trust my own taste.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by Minor49er on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:10AM (#23456600)
Check out the designer's portfolio first. If you like what you see, hire them to work with you on a small piece of the project (if possible) and negotiate how you want to handle any modifications to their designs. If it doesn't work out, you can stop working with them.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by enhdless on Monday June 08, 2020 @01:40PM (#23458741)
> There are thousands of them out there who want to build tech stuff but don't have the skills.

This sounds like a pretty cynical take. I know plenty of designers who want to design for tech, not because they "don't have the skills" to "build tech stuff" but because they have different skills, aka design skills (user research methods, applying UX best practices, visual design, the list goes on). Although many design departments may have originally started under engineering, I like to think that designers have much more to contribute than being developer-wannabes that your comment might imply.

That said, I agree with the rest of what you said! There are lots of designers out there who want a chance to practice their skills, and I encourage everyone to at least get your project design critiqued!

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by schwartzworld on Monday June 08, 2020 @10:54AM (#23456994)
I think most of these resources are for devs who just need something to look good enough. if I'm building a UI for a small project, or even something for my own use, I'm not going to spend money on a designer. I just want a website to tell me two fonts that look nice together.
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by thestepafter on Monday June 08, 2020 @12:24PM (#23457983)
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by berkes on Monday June 08, 2020 @08:44AM (#23455998)
Good advice, and I wholly agree: design is important and deserves an expert.

> Reach out to some on social media

Any tips on how, or where?

My experience with fiverr is very much "hit or miss" and getting designers interested for a startup in very early phase is hard in my experience.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by RobertKerans on Monday June 08, 2020 @08:54AM (#23456050)
As in Dribbble or Behance for example, or Twitter (et al). Or look for large designer communities on Slack or Discord etc (or FB)

fiverr (or Upwork etc) are just meat markets and a race to the bottom, being hit or miss should be expected from those platforms: if you try to buy things on the [extreme end of] cheap, then often the end product is not going to be particularly good.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by zerkten on Monday June 08, 2020 @09:54AM (#23456481)
> My experience with fiverr is very much "hit or miss" and getting designers interested for a startup in very early phase is hard in my experience.

How are you paying them? Fiverr is a low-price marketplace and not where I'd try to find the best talent. Getting good Fiverr designs requires a lot of work and some understanding of design. The latter seems to run counter to this thread. Ultimately, you won't get great design on the cheap.

My personal experience is the lowest cost option for really great design is having a couple of thousand dollars on retainer with a contract designer, or small design agency. Go through your working prototype and see how they can uplift the existing design within your budget. If you can come inside budget then get the same designers back later for more bits and pieces. This is how you build up a relationship and they might cut you some slack, such as doing an updated email template, or some other one-offs.

Using bootstrap, or another standard framework is a potential win. They may be able to provide customizations for you directly. If you have a completely custom frontend, or something that's highly engineered, then it's harder and more expensive for developers to work with you.

It goes without saying that you need to own the copyrights on the assets they create for you. The other part is that you need things in the right formats. If they created illustrations, then get the original AI files, not only the exported image files. If you have the source files, then you can make your own tweaks later. So many people forget to think about this. I've had to make tweaks 100% of the time. Copyright issues will come up much later and hinder you when you are successful, but it's easy to deal with those initially.

If you don't have a couple of thousand to budget toward design then you should stick to generic templates because designers don't work for free. They generally don't win from startup success because of the bias towards engineers, so don't expect them to keen to work based on some promise of success and payment later.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by berkes on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @05:53AM (#23465193)
Thanks for the advice.

I am well aware of fiverr being the low-end of the spectrum, which is why I used that as example. As opposed to "finding a designer", which is costly.

I was not trying to argue that I want to hire a designer for a fiverr-price. Slavery has been abolished in Europe and I would not like to bring it back, thank you very much.

The advise to move forward with commonly known frameworks such as Bootstrap is a good one. As it allows to bring in (and properly pay!) designers when you can afford it.

Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by uvic on Monday June 08, 2020 @12:09PM (#23457822)
Hi, I agree with you.. but I think there needs to be something to get you started...watching other websites can intimidating sometimes especially when your just working on a side project....
Re:NoDesign.dev – Tools and resources for non-artistic devel... by jakearmitage on Monday June 08, 2020 @11:18AM (#23457232)
I'm dying to do a side project, but I'm a code guy. I have zero talent for business, design or product. Wish I could easily find a partner that is the opposite of me.