News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ikeyany on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:16PM (#23421915)
> fragile ... the word is fragile. We've built an insanely fragile economy. Take a look. There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there. We've lost about 100k people, which is horrific but in the scheme of things at "USA" scale, and with the skewed demographics, not much of a hit to the economy.

And yet the economy is staggering and it's likely to get worse. Why? Because people have stopped doing things

We've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do. In and of itself, that's not so bad, but we've also built an economy with so little resilience, so much fragility, so little spare capacity that the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff has the potential to cause complete economic disaster for, what 15-20M Americans?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23328234

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by crazygringo on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:55PM (#23422380)
> We've built an insanely fragile economy.

Citation needed. Things seem to be functioning pretty well, all things considered. I can still buy virtually everything I need from the local grocery store and Amazon.

I've lived in third-world countries where regular products would be out of stock for months at a time under normal circumstances.

To me, the economy looks insanely resilient in a global pandemic.

> the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff has the potential to cause complete economic disaster for, what 15-20M Americans?

That's just how it works, if people stop buying the stuff that 20M people produce, the work for those jobs stop existing for the moment. That's neither good nor bad, it just is. There's literally no way around it.

The problem isn't fragility or doing unnecessary things. You just need a social safety net, which Europe has been better at providing than the US, but the US could easily provide if it wanted.

If you want to have a conversation, the one to have is about social safety nets, not an "economic resilience" bogeyman.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by tonyedgecombe on Friday June 05, 2020 @08:00AM (#23427497)
> To me, the economy looks insanely resilient in a global pandemic.

It does seem having a large part of the economy focussed on frivolous endeavours has given us a fairly big buffer. We have seen formula one teams making medical equipment, supermarkets hiring restaurant staff, hospitals hiring air stewards (after the opposite in recent years).

It looks to me like the developed world will cope with this (some countries better than others of course).

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by save_ferris on Thursday June 04, 2020 @09:45PM (#23424183)
> To me, the economy looks insanely resilient in a global pandemic.

We’re still in the early days of this pandemic, as it usually takes many months for the upfront shocks to fully process through the economy. Numerous reports detail a potential collapse of the commercial real estate market, the government is signaling that it is going to hand out any more stimulus money, and health experts are warning about a second wave. Economists aren’t ruling out 40% unemployment down the road, which puts us firmly in depression territory.

I have no idea where you live, but I live in Austin, TX, a fairly affluent city, and the changes to the city have been dramatic and very visible. So much retail is still closed, and many thousands are out of work with little opportunity to renter the workforce and likely without future stimulus.

Just look at the George Floyd protests, there’s an inherent economic component to American racism and Covid provided a lot of fuel that the senseless killing of Floyd ignited. Those events did not occur in a vacuum, which is partially why we’re seeing unrest that we haven’t witnessed in 60 years.

Not to mention that millions never recovered from the last major crisis while politicians and big business pretended like everything was back to normal after the big market rallies.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by RhysU on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:13PM (#23424711)
Austin, despite the government and technology economy narrative, has been in a service economy bubble for some time as local businesses capture dollars arriving from elsewhere in the form of brunch costs.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by bsder on Thursday June 04, 2020 @09:59PM (#23424254)
> Numerous reports detail a potential collapse of the commercial real estate market

While I'm happy to bail out workers, can we please simply bust out the overleveraged on assets for once?

Part of the reason why the economy has no resilience is that we keep bailing out the irresponsible so there is no incentive to be responsible. Why keep inventory and cash reserves when you can go into 3x debt and get bailed out? Why be responsible when your competitor is basically going to get loan forgiveness instead of going bankrupt and you being able to buy them?

How about some "trickle up"? Bail out the individuals who are basically unleveraged and let the leveraged compete to try to stay afloat or go bankrupt and release the assets to those less leveraged. The real estate doesn't suddenly lose it's value because the owner got busted out.

It's what capitalism is supposed to be--risks are supposed to get upside AND downside.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by dvtrn on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:08PM (#23422558)
If you want to have a conversation, the one to have is about social safety nets, not an "economic resilience" bogeyman.

Porque no los dos? You say you've lived in third-world countries, surely you can see the utility in a conversation on both and how much overlap there is between the two hemispheres of that particular socio-economic Venn Diagram..I'd hope?

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by nikofeyn on Thursday June 04, 2020 @11:31PM (#23424824)
> Things seem to be functioning pretty well

citation needed.

100,000+ people have died because our country is fragile. unemployment is somewhere between 15-25%. a virus is about the dumbest enemy we could ever hope to face, and we've failed.

the u.s. is in massive debt, the highest in the world. the u.s. has no socioeconomic safety net, and i question your claim that the u.s. could easily provide one if it wanted. the existing "safety nets", such as social security and taxes, are so abused and misused that they serve as explicit counter examples to your claim. roads and infrastructure in the u.s. are falling apart.

in no household would it be advisable to have massive debt upon debt while the house is falling apart and you're living paycheck to paycheck. and yet, that is exactly what the u.s. is doing.

in many respects, the response to the virus has been both the u.s. didn't want to react to it and that the u.s. couldn't react to it. the u.s. does not have the organizational capacity to handle it.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by rurp on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:43PM (#23422239)
Well said. People often forget that optimizing for efficiency isn't free, it has a cost in flexibility. The modern economy is heavily optimized which, yes, can produce enormous profits, but it also makes the economy extremely brittle.

Approaches like just-in-time manufacturing or loading up on debt in a good economy to expand faster work out great... until they don't. And when things go bad, they can go bad quickly.

I've heard a number of people referring to COVID-19 as a black swan event, but it's really not. Pandemics are a known risk that have happened many times in the past and will happen many more times in the future. The fact that such an unsurprising disaster has stressed modern economies so tremendously makes me really pessimistic for our society's long term prospects.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by chkaloon on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:49PM (#23422308)
Yes! That is an astute point. Corporate farms are efficient. Monoculture forests are efficient, etc. But they are fragile. Unions and income transfers cause inefficiencies, but without them, society becomes fragile.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ethbro on Thursday June 04, 2020 @07:03PM (#23423016)
Efficiency has to be integrated over a timespan.

Despite all the disruption, I'd be surprised if it were on the whole more efficient for companies to optimize for resiliency... for an event that happens once in 100 years.

Rather than fall back on central banks & governments, and expect them to throw everything and the kitchen sink at it.

Ideally, though, what the government will and won't do should have been communicated well in advance of a pandemic, so that everyone had an even investment playing field. Piecemeal bailouts are asking for insider trading.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by mikekchar on Thursday June 04, 2020 @09:16PM (#23424027)
According to Wikipedia, the original author does not consider COVID-19 a black swan event, so I think you must be right. However, while we know a pandemic will occur, we don't know when. Neither do we necessarily know ahead of time what measures are appropriate to take to mitigate the risk.

The aspect of the Black Swan theory where you point to the data after the fact and say, "We should have known" is very similar. For example, countries that experienced SARS and MERS where very much more prepared for COVID-19. Other countries which didn't have many problems did not prepare. This is because they didn't realise that they should prepare. For them COVID-19 was out of the blue -- a complete shock. Of course, we should have looked at the original data and if we had, we could have improved the outcomes. But we didn't have that experience and we didn't know when to expect a large problem.

The Tohoku earthquake in Japan in 2011 was similar. Earthquakes of that size hit Japan about once in 1000 years. We know it will happen. We don't know when. We don't know if it will happen in our generation. Should we prepare for it. In hindsight, yes, of course. At the time, it was a shock.

Is that a black swan event? I don't know. However, I don't think we need to have much of a distinction. Even if we should know, the fact that we don't know is all that matters. It is still a surprise.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by pragmatic on Thursday June 04, 2020 @07:44PM (#23423369)
Yes. Hospitals in particular.

One I'm familiar with moved to a LEAN system where they did not keep large inventory of supplies. There was some protest about not keeping essential supplies on hand for the lab etc.

And now we see the problem with this. Profit margin over safety.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ojnabieoot on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:05PM (#23422522)
> Why? Because people have stopped doing things

> We've built an entire economy around people doing things they don't really need to do.

Even hunter-gatherers spend a great deal of hard-earned resources on things "they don't need to do," such as art, music, parties, luxury foods and jewelry, and so on. This is human nature. It has nothing to do with how the economy is structured. The stuff we're not doing that "we don't need to do" is not economically redundant make-work symptomatic of an inefficient economy. It's symptomatic of us being a species that prefers nicer digs to "a cave with access to rice and beans."

In any economy, activity shuts down if individuals fear an active plague. Human nature also entails people being scared of choking to death on their own lungs.

The last paragraph here is trying to sound profound but it's really just catastrophically stupid. There's really no such thing as an economy that has the "spare capacity" to offset 25% of the workforce being furloughed. There are political economies that can adequately respond to this shock - perhaps with a large Keynesian stimulus - but that's very different from having an economy that's somehow structurally immune to the impact of widespread inactivity.

Unless its author means "give people free money until the crisis passes", the comment you're approvingly citing badly misunderstands what an economy actually is.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by uoaei on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:12PM (#23422596)
I think you missed the point. If I understood GP correctly, the "things they don't really need to do" are the modern-day pencil pushers and middlemen who exist in industries that are basically modernized rent-seeking. Health insurance is an obvious example but we can also take it to the extreme and point out that there are sometimes (not often) 3 people at some grocery checkout counters: the cashier, the bagger, and the person who takes the bags and puts them in the basket.

The latter two aren't really necessary, but we gave them jobs because it looks good when you report the quarterly unemployment stats. Think about who would be the first to be let go in the case of any economic disruption that impacted that grocery store.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ojnabieoot on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:30PM (#23422763)
Although I agree with the rent-seeker problem I really don’t think that’s what he was saying - for starters, the pencil pushers are much more likely to be at work (from home) than the food/entertainment/etc people I mentioned, and much more likely to keep their jobs during the pandemic. If your argument is what OP meant then I was giving them too much credit.

> The latter two aren't really necessary, but we gave them jobs because it looks good when you report the quarterly unemployment stats.

I don’t even know where to start with this. Clearly you have never worked in a grocery store. Beyond that - why would private businesses agree to hire unnecessary workers to juke unemployment stats? This entire argument makes zero sense.

It seems like you have some strong views about the economy but they are disconnected from the facts.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by brewdad on Thursday June 04, 2020 @07:30PM (#23423253)
I see it as a bit of both. I don't see myself going to a movie theater anytime soon even if they are allowed to open. Our restaurant spending is 1/3 what it used to be. A tank of gas lasts almost a month rather than a week. I used to go grocery shopping every week with at least one additional trip to grab one thing I needed. Now I go every 2 weeks and don't make a special trip unless we absolutely can't make anything without that missing ingredient.

All kinds of jobs are at risk in this type of environment. Service will be hit hardest but there are ripple effects that will impact pretty much everyone to some degree.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ikeyany on Thursday June 04, 2020 @08:01PM (#23423500)
I was referring to the notion of "bullshit jobs", optimizing for leanness, and neglecting societal safety nets.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by uoaei on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:38PM (#23422819)
Have you ever been in a grocery store outside the US? Am I really the one disconnected?

The grocery stores obviously don't care about unemployment stats, but federal government incentivizing "job creation" without getting into specifics about the utility, necessity, etc. of those jobs is a real problem. Everyone who drives for Uber has a "job" but that is hardly anything to survive on.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by nopzor on Friday June 05, 2020 @04:48AM (#23426371)
your example is really not appropriate. a grocery store (big or small) will not hire additional checkout staff "because it looks good when you report the quarterly unemployment stats".

private businesses really couldn't care less about those stats. they will hire the minimum number of people necessary to perform their service, at the minimum cost that they can.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by MattGaiser on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:39PM (#23422189)
> There's been no war. 100% of the (not so great) US infrastructure that was there before SARS-COV-2 is still there.

The infrastructure may not be physically destroyed, but it is effectively out of commission. Same with everything from warehouses to meat cutting plants. You could make the same argument if a gas attack were used on a factory instead of a bomb.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:58PM (#23422422)
Are you actually seeing out of commission infrastructure in your city or your business?

I’ve seen virtually no impact on the services I depend on locally (except toilet paper for a few weeks). Some supply chain delays on the business side, but it’s delays due to temporary shutdowns rather than permanent factory closures. The orders are still coming through a few weeks later than expected.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by pjc50 on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:49PM (#23422303)
This was Keynes' point: the productive capacity is there, it's the question of putting it to work somehow.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by aSplash0fDerp on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:18PM (#23422647)
The service economy will continue to be fragile for years.

The resilient parts of the economy are already planning for EMP protection from disruption and developing space exploration economies.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:55PM (#23422388)
Obviously, companies that depend on crowds and foot traffic are seriously hurting right now.

However, many other industries are still business as usual. E-commerce businesses might actually be doing better than ever.

I tried to schedule a few contractors to get work done recently, thinking they’d have additional openings with the slowdown. Turns out, they’re booked farther out than ever. Everyone else working at home had the same idea to schedule that work.

This will clearly shake a lot of businesses, but the real question now is which ones survive and which ones can’t come back. I suspect a lot of the businesses that don’t make it were nearing the end of their viability anyway.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by IAmGraydon on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:58PM (#23422972)
As one data point, I run small online retail business and saw sales utterly rocket worldwide during this event. At the peak of the lockdowns, I saw a 200% increase in sales. I’m in the musical instrument accessories business. My wife has a retail business as well (photography accessories) which also saw large gains. In the last week or so, things have nearly normalized.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by closeparen on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:52PM (#23422342)
Fragile compared to what? Which economies can comfortably absorb the indefinite suspension of nearly all activity?
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by vkou on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:38PM (#23422817)
I'm not sure what country you live in, but here in the US, the overwhelming majority of activity was not suspended.

My city has been in lockdown for two months, yet I look out my window, and see a full freeway of people going to work, going from work, transporting goods, transporting themselves...

Look through the list of essential activities in your local shutdown orders. By the time you get through all the pages of it, you'll be wondering what the hell is left that's non-essential.

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by xvedejas on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:03PM (#23422494)
Fully automated ones, I'd guess.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by vondur on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:02PM (#23422480)
I'm going to say most of the businesses at the smaller end of the scale would never have enough money to continue paying employee's without any income coming in. I think everyone kinda knew that shutting down the economy was going to be bad, unless it was only done for a very brief period. If the government can get no strings attached money to companies to pay their employees and get them to open as fast as possible we may come out of it.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by ed on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:44PM (#23422255)
> the mere fact of people stopping doing a bunch of stuff

Lol this is condescending, this isn’t due to millennials forgoing their avocado toast

Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by freehunter on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:49PM (#23422310)
No, it’s due to people not going to movie theaters and not going to Home Depot and not going out to eat at restaurants. You know, things they would normally do but haven’t been doing because it’s not essential.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by pgodzin on Thursday June 04, 2020 @05:53PM (#23422365)
They are definitely still going to Home Depot
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by StillBored on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:03PM (#23422497)
Yah, I should take my own advise here and buy HD, I'm pretty regular at the one near my house. I don't think i've ever seen HD as busy as its been recently. I guess instead of going to restaurants people are fixing all the little things wrong in their houses.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by karatestomp on Thursday June 04, 2020 @07:05PM (#23423028)
Everyone who's still got stable employment used that stimulus check to DIY-reno their kitchen, I think.
Re:More than half of American retailers didn't pay their ren... by grogenaut on Thursday June 04, 2020 @06:02PM (#23422485)
Agreed, home depot is hopping