News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by screye on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:00PM (#23384486)
This is exactly why we need LIDAR.

Tesla has been very stubborn about avoiding LIDAR and this is what happens as a consequence. The rest of the self-driving scene fundamentally relies on LIDAR to get things working. Believe me, if cameras were sufficient people wouldn't use LIDAR . LIDAR is expensive. I have spoken to quite a few people in the field and the lack of LIDAR in Tesla vehicles baffles them.

Radar is not a substitute for LIDAR. Sound is really high latency and has terrible resolution.

I would like to see how often things like these happen with Waymo.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by jturpin on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:14PM (#23384629)
Maybe, the problem right now is that there is no module that Tesla can purchase and use on their cars. All the Lidar modules currently in use are these large and more importantly expensive spinning devices mounted on top of the car. These make sense for robotaxis, where cost and unsightliness are not an issue, but not an option for Tesla right now. I believe a couple companies have made headway with cheaper, smaller (solid state?) devices that might be an option in the near future, but these are just recent developments.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by clouddrover on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:44PM (#23384942)
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by jturpin on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @02:12AM (#23388076)
That's a good point, I didn't know Audi was shipping a model with Lidar out and the price point is around where the Tesla's are. Certainly the reasons to not include Lidar are dropping.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by threeseed on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:53PM (#23385521)
This is the plan for the Cruise self driving car with LiDAR:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/22/technology/cruise-gm-self...

Doesn't look unsightly to me. Also given that every car company and self driving car uses LiDAR suggests that over time the costs will come due to economies of scale.

Also are people not forgetting that Tesla charges a massive premium for Autopilot ? People are willing to pay a lot for self driving more than enough to cover the cost of the LiDAR sensor.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by icelancer on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:35AM (#23387829)
>> Doesn't look unsightly to me. Also given that every car company and self driving car uses LiDAR suggests that over time the costs will come due to economies of scale.

This has been predicted for radar units over optical in other industries. It never happened. Optical became cheap and capable, radar stayed slow and expensive. I see no reason why this would change in car manufacturing.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by trog on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:29PM (#23384780)
How about laser rangefinders? Even one of them in the centre of the vehicle in the direction of travel would be useful for high speed impact avoidance - well, assuming they work reliably and how I think they do; I'm not a hardware guy. But would a laser rangefinder pointing forward be useful? They're not that big and bulky and should at least be useful for braking when it detects something closing too rapidly...?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by bentcorner on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:51PM (#23385512)
Just spitballing but would those have problems in rain/fog/smoke?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by sukilot on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:10PM (#23385653)
You know what a smart driver does in rain/fog/smoke? Slow down.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by bentcorner on Monday June 01, 2020 @10:35PM (#23386724)
I guess I should be more clear - I'm guessing (but I could be wrong) that a laser rangefinder would consider heavy rain/fog/smoke to be a solid barrier and wouldn't slow down, it'd stop.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by trog on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:28AM (#23387781)
That would be my guess too.. but that's probably what you want to happen if automated sensors are unable to perceive the world around them - slow and stop the car until a human takes over again...?
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by mprovost on Tuesday June 02, 2020 @01:50AM (#23387919)
Lidar is a laser rangefinder.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by habitue on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:29PM (#23384783)
> Believe me, if cameras were sufficient people wouldn't use LIDAR

I don't necessarily think LIDAR is a bad idea, but this logic seems kind of circular. Isn't the issue that nobody knows what's sufficient? At the very least the engineers at Tesla seem to think LIDAR isn't necessary (maybe not a slam-dunk argument but humans don't use LIDAR to drive, so it's at the very least plausible computer vision systems alone are sufficient)

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by lnanek2 on Monday June 01, 2020 @09:15PM (#23386116)
That's like saying humans have consciousness, so strong AI is at least very plausible. Possible, sure? Possible in the next decade? Probably not.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by Cerium on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:05PM (#23384528)
Radar is not sonar. The latency for radar is good, but the resolution is indeed poor.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by throwaway0a5e on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:33PM (#23384825)
If you're willing to spend DOD type bucks you can get some insanely good (like the old boring legacy tech will keep track of a city's worth of vehicles and dismounts without getting them all confused with each other) radar. The secret sauce is in the algorithms though and lord knows how many millions of dollars and man hours have been poured into that.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by mlyle on Monday June 01, 2020 @06:38PM (#23384868)
Limited aperture on a car means limited angular resolution even with millimeter wave. This can mean the information needed to tell whether something stationary is in your path just isn't there-- especially in the vertical direction where aperture is smaller.

A big flat surface that's not normal to you like the box truck may also not be a very large return.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by kube-system on Monday June 01, 2020 @09:26PM (#23386205)
Yeah, my 6 year old Toyota has millimeter wave radar, and so do a lot of cars, for detecting objects in front of the vehicle.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by SomewhatLikely on Monday June 01, 2020 @07:59PM (#23385578)
Doesn't seem like it was necessary here. I'm no computer vision expert, but surely parallax between multiple cameras and/or multiple time points would make detecting such a massive object simple.
Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by MauranKilom on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:03PM (#23385602)
Large uniform/featureless surfaces are the bane of stereo vision. And propagating in from the borders is extremely risky if there's any occlusion affecting the borders (read: if you get the borders wrong).

Maybe in this particular instance you could look at the data and go "yep, that white surface is indeed closing in and not just some part of the sky". But how many false positives do you allow for "there's a huge thing in my way that requires emergency braking" in interstate scenarios?

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by screye on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:17PM (#23385687)
This actually seemed like an adversarial case.

It seems like the color of the truck and that of the road were near identical to each other. Maybe no different that what it looks like when the road changes textures to a worse surface or or hits an odd pot hole.

It is likely the car alerted the owner to take over, but did not brake on its own.

The thing about LIDAR is detecting objects becomes shit easy. One thing is for sure. I can guarantee such an accident would not have happened with LIDAR.

Re:Tesla Model 3 Drives into Overturned Truck in Apparent Au... by aeternum on Monday June 01, 2020 @08:56PM (#23385984)
It's surprising they did not train for this given very similar accidents (hitting semi-trucks) in 2016 and 2019.

LIDAR isn't a surefire solve, it also has issues with large white surfaces and bright sunlight.