Re:Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image ...
by kempbellt on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:51PM
(#23333200)
What is stored in your cache was loaded from their servers when you originally visited. Also, you can clear your cache at any time you choose to re-fetch the original content from the provider.
Also, a provider uses a CDN at their discretion. Giving them the ability to invalidate or update cached records at times of their choosing. Or remove the CDN entirely if they choose to.
This is Google using their weight to be anti-competitive and fall further down the anti-trust rabbit hole.
Re:Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image ...
by regularfry on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:12AM
(#23334392)
A provider uses a CDN at their discretion, but it's totally legitimate to have a client-site cache as well. If I've got 20 users going through a squid proxy to get to the internet, that's something the provider has to live with. Not to diminish your core point, which I think is correct, but there are limits on what providers should be able to expect.
Re:Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image ...
by brokenmachine on Thursday May 28, 2020 @08:26PM
(#23344872)
I sort of agree with you, but robots.txt is a thing.
I know it seems impossible but nobody has to use Google.
Are there any copyright implications of amp? They're essentially republishing your property.
Does the original publisher get their ad revenue?
Re:Google no longer providing original URL in AMP for image ...
by Aeolun on Friday May 29, 2020 @12:38AM
(#23346308)
> It blows your mind that different people have difference opinions and values than you?
Given context and full knowledge of the issues involved? Yes, absolutely. For this particular issue anyway.
> Or maybe it’ll come from a CDN rather than origin.
That’s not a problem, since the URL and where it points to is still decided by the content owners.
What’s shown in the URL bar has long been divorced from the HTTP request(s) that are made.
> It blows my mind that anyone thinks that’s an acceptable idea
It blows your mind that different people have difference opinions and values than you?