News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by loughnane on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:46AM (#23325026)
I will never again build any kind of workflow for my knowledge on top of anything that isn’t open source. 5y is a long time and 10y is an eternity for these sorts of products but its just a fraction of my working life.

My own personal setup is a bunch of markdown files and it’s great, so I like that approach, but I’m very cautious about investing time for something so important in a product i don’t control.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by heavyset_go on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:20PM (#23330147)
> I will never again build any kind of workflow for my knowledge on top of anything that isn’t open source.

100% this. The peace of mind I get knowing that all of my data is under my control is worth it, after scrambling to archive content from failed or pivoting services, removing my data from businesses that try to exploit it or trying to migrate my data from one old app to a different newer app.

There are many different open-source and self-hosted wikis, note taking apps and mind-mapping tools. Some of them are listed here[1], just Ctrl-F for "wiki", "notes" and "knowledge"

[1] https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by Eugeleo on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:00AM (#23333923)
Just a quick notw, I think everythink (need to archive content, ease of migrating data etc) is solved simply by Obsidian being offline-first and markdown-only. I.e. you don’t need the app to be open-source in the end.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by ericax on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:56AM (#23325175)
We'll likely make a formal guarantee to open source in the case of us shutting down. Didn't realize that was a possibility, thanks for the suggestion!
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by unknown2374 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:57PM (#23330583)
You may want to look into the Gitlab [1] model of open source monetization, as it has strong resemblance of what you are trying to achieve with Obsidian.

[1] https://about.gitlab.com/pricing/#self-managed

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by prepend on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @08:29PM (#23331926)
That’s pretty cool and it’s good of you to think about the scenario.

The problem is the bankruptcy court/buyer/ex-spouse/whatever may have a different preference. So you may want to set up something legally binding now when everyone is the same agreement.

Could you also solve this by GPL+Commercial license for those that pay?

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by sneak on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:12PM (#23332990)
Standard Notes is open source (and free software) today, while still in business with a business model similar to yours.

It also allows people to read, audit, and trust the crypto code, which your model does not. For people like me, that’s a hard pass.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by ken on Thursday May 28, 2020 @12:09AM (#23333301)
"Open source" is both a license and a development model. You're talking about a license, but someone interested in workflow longevity will probably not be satisfied with a source dump from a dead company. They're looking for a community which knows how to maintain it.

As JWZ once said: "You can't take a dying project, sprinkle it with the magic pixie dust of 'open source,' and have everything magically work out." Has there ever been a case where a company as its last act released their software as open-source, and a community formed and picked it up?

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by MayeulC on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:50AM (#23334631)
I can recall a few on the top of my head, but those are the exception rather than the norm: Blender & Mozilla, though that last one wasn't really a last act. I think I saw a few others, but can't recall which ones, I'd be interested in such a list.

Now, there are interesting communities that form around games, that tend to be a "dead product" after release, and for which there was a source dump (or not, actually): doom, openMW, openRA, etc.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by bmikaili on Thursday May 28, 2020 @05:08AM (#23335096)
You do realize communities can die out as well?
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by ken on Thursday May 28, 2020 @02:57PM (#23340994)
By definition, that's what happens when its developer community dies off down to size n=0. A source dump without a community is essentially fast-forwarding a (potential) developer community to its death. It should be clear why this is strictly worse.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by quickthrower2 on Thursday May 28, 2020 @07:52AM (#23336204)
Parse?
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by loughnane on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:24PM (#23326660)
that sounds good in principle but I still wouldn't feel comfortable with it unless I was aware of similar setups that worked out well for the users.

Not saying such examples aren't out there. I just am unaware of any.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by roryokane on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:43PM (#23355291)
If anyone is wonder what this comment is in reply to, this comment is a dupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23325105, replying to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23325035.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by Aeolun on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @07:40PM (#23331561)
I don’t follow. This app would work on top of your existing markdown files, and if they go out of business there is nothing preventing you from either keep using the app, or take your markdown files and take them elsewhere.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by MayeulC on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:58AM (#23334674)
That's really a nice thing, to be honest, and probably the only reason I'm somewhat interested, even though I mostly run open-source software on my computers, except when such software is a one-off comodity, like videogames.

But for something I'm going to invest some time learning, and will rely on, that's a very difficult pill to swallow. I don't want to depend on proprietary software for important parts of my workflow. What if I want to switch to a pinebook, for instance? No ARM build seems to be available yet. And that's just a single example... (a WASM/LLVM IR build could sidestep that issue).

That said, I like the idea. Is there any open-source equivalent?

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by udfalkso on Thursday May 28, 2020 @03:33PM (#23341502)
vimwiki is pretty close but this adds some nice touches on top.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by m-p-3 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @12:33PM (#23325824)
You could build a knowledge base in https://joplinapp.org/ and store/sync it the way you want.

I don't see any restrictions regarding corporate usage.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by loughnane on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @01:23PM (#23326638)
I was actually using Joplin for the past year after migrating to evernote. I really liked it but am now migrating to something with a little more flexibility around structuring.

Thinking to structure it around hugo.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by s_trumpet on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:13PM (#23330057)
I'm checking out Joplin on this suggestion. Couple of questions - In what way did you use it? And what were your problems with it?
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by loughnane on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @07:09PM (#23331290)
As the other commenter noted Joplin is a desktop application that syncs (over E2EE) if you like to other machines via gdrive/dropbox/nextcloud etc.

I was using it via nextcloud and it worked perfectly for what it was. The web clipper also did a great job of snatching simplified versions of web pages.

What killed it for me was just my expanding desires. I want to things like

- view my knowledge base from my work machine without downloading the whole knowledge base to it. - Be able to search my notes AND all the books i've read. I tried using pandoc to go epub to md but it was too clunky and the searchability within notes wasn't great.

If I was still using it as a drop in replacement for evernote I think it would be great, but to go beyond that starts to stretch the seams a bit.

I also second looking at github's awesome-selfhosted.

Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by heavyset_go on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:44PM (#23330451)
Joplin isn't like your typical web app, and you need to either carry a copy of your notes around on every device, or you need to sync them using a cloud service. For that reason, I went with other note-taking and wiki software.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by soapboxrocket on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @11:56AM (#23325184)
I'm in agreement with you on this. I've been playing with a package for Atom that would simplify a bunch of stuff in my process, but in general I don't like the risk of proprietary software/stack for my workflow.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by ThouYS on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @05:40PM (#23330401)
that’s a funny idea, putting the logic in the editor
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by Thorentis on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @08:59PM (#23332134)
Joplin is the state of the art in terms of open source note taking in my opinion. It too uses Markdown, and supports a whole heap of other features on top of it. But it's been around for a long time, has mobile apps, cloud backups, the lot - and is all open source on Github.
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by komali2 on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @06:47PM (#23331081)
This is what attracted me to org-roam
Re:Show HN: Obsidian – A knowledge base that works on local ... by ulisesrmzroche on Wednesday May 27, 2020 @03:46PM (#23328920)
What actually happened? I have a really hard time imagining