Disclaimer: A Mooney owner myself.
(I have a turbo and TKS on my A36. Almost never need the TKS.)
Having TKS (or boots) is definitely a safety benefit in case you end up in inadvertent icing, but remember that the system can still get overwhelmed.
Avoiding icing conditions is still a good idea, even with TKS. :)
In reality most people who can afford to run a piston twin are moving down to a Cirrus or moving up to a turbine single.
Turbines give you much higher power reserves at low altitude, so they are better in icing on departure and approach, but that difference doesn't come up nearly as often as generalized maintenance issues. (Owning a 1976 piston twin was an overall negative experience. I loved the airplane, but it was a maintenance hog, mostly aging systems and aging design philosophy related.)
I agree 100% that the piston twin is a dying breed, but I think it's almost never to do with FIKI (flight-into-known-icing) issues.
That said I've heard anecdotally a 172/182 can carry ice better than a lot of other aircraft (I've only been iced up in a 172, never on a Mooney). That shouldn't matter anyways since you should avoid ice as much as possible.
I'd take a Commache 260 over a Mooney any day of the week. Not quite as fast/economical, but much more comfortable, cheaper, and easier to work on.
I owned a Twin Commache and it was a thing of beauty... but a different animal to the singles.
I would guess safety standards are much higher too, but I generally don't understand why they're so expensive.
I guess the piston engines are very different from the ones you find in cars.
As I understand it, the most lenient certification to allow someone to sell planes to masses in USA is the (special) Primary Category¹, for the General Aviation, which Cessna's two-seat 152 model seems to be in. Cessna's four-seat model 172, however, is on another category, the so-called "Utility Aircraft", which required the more costly Standard Certification². With a broader (legally permitted) use, it's kind of natural to expect an appropriate price difference.
¹ https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/airworthiness_certific...
² https://www.faa.gov/aircraft/air_cert/airworthiness_certific...
Edit: probably the manufacturer could always be sued, but the change made it easier. I can't remember the specifics.
but i think the 172 does have some upsides:
- docile handling
- availability to rent, pretty much globally
- availability of a&p who are super familiar with it
- low insurance rates and superior safety record
- landing gear can take a lot of abuse
[1] https://airfactsjournal.com/2016/08/whats-right-cirrus-pilot...
There was a huge difference in trying (and often failing) to stay ahead of the plane even moving from a 172 to a 182.
I get that there's more things involved for a practical implementation (weight, reliability, added complexity) but still... What am I missing?
As mentioned there are alarms already, but you can drown it out if sufficiently overloaded. Its best to recognize overload, take a deep breath and go back when calm.
Pilots still land gear up, even with the alarm sounding. There is (or at least was) even a public (YouTube) video of this happening from a passenger filming.
Landing a plane is not difficult (source: I’m a pilot) but there’s a lot going on. This is clearly a UI/UX issue but innovation is relatively slow in the certified market.
And yeah, before anyone says "but the beeping!" - yup, people are fallible. I've managed to scratch a car in a similar but far cheaper setting: start up...set navigation...go into reverse...think about the traffic announcement...think about garage keys...hear parking sensors beeping...beeping intensifies...CRUNCH...facepalm, dammit I was supposed to brake! In my case, this was a low-speed, low-energy collision, so just a tiny scratch on plastic, but I can definitely see how a minor distraction can turn into a major accident.
In 1994, Congress passed GARA[1], and two years later Cessna began producing new aircraft again. But having been out of the industry for a decade, Cessna lacked some combination of the means and confidence to bring back its entire fleet; so it focused on the 172 for the training market and abandoned the 152, which never saw production again.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Aviation_Revitalizatio...
My wife got her PPL and all the sudden had an opinion on what to buy. :) She's now a CFII so her opinion matters.
I still would be into getting one if my wife was sold on home built.
Plus the freedom to modify. In a Cessna, you can’t so much as run a USB charger out to the panel without the FAA coming down on you like a ton of bricks. On an experimental, if you want the latest electronics or if you want to swap in a different engine, go right ahead, sparky!
(Disclaimer: I’m 3.5 years into a RV-7 build so I’m biased)
You're not kidding. I think the cheapest annual inspection I've ever seen was around $2,000 for an old, clean 172 that needed zero actual work. More typical is ~$4,000-$10,000 for a modern-ish 4 seater, depending on what they need to do. Throw in $20,000 every several years for an engine overhaul. If you have a G1000 and they need to touch it, it's going to cost you at least half a car.
What does turbo-normalised mean in this context?
His is one of the reasons why turbodiesels are valued for hauling. They can still make (near) rated power across the Rockies, where an NA engine might be down 30-40%
I own a Mooney, which burns 10 GPH and does 160kts. Fits two people just fine and three if you sacrifice fuel. A good trade off over all. Definitely think the 172 is the least badass plane with almost no upsides other than being a good trainer.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beechcraft_Bonanza
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mooney_M20
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancair_IV
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pilatus_PC-12