News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by knowtheory on Monday March 14, 2011 @12:25PM (#2323106)
Vociferous opposition is not the same as condescension, though.

There are some people who care deeply about a subject and just lack social tact. They'll jump on you for a variety of subjects, but they don't have ill intent.

Then there are the people who are dicks and want to crush people who they disagree with. It's the point at which one starts displaying schadenfreude and denigrating others that the line has been crossed.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by AndrewDucker on Monday March 14, 2011 @12:33PM (#2323146)
People who lack social tact need to be taught it. They aren't stupid, generally, they can be taught, if it's made clear that they must.

Treating people badly is a great way to drive out those who don't have the ability to deal with flamewars and shoutiness. And many of those people have a lot to contribute.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by shaggyfrog on Monday March 14, 2011 @04:08PM (#2324182)
Have you ever heard the song Your Friend Wil by MC Frontalot, nerd rapper extraordinaire? Your post is basically a perfect two-line summary of the lyrics!

http://frontalot.com/index.php/?page=lyrics&lyricid=68

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by ahoyhere on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:12PM (#2323360)
They should learn it themselves. There are books & training courses on the subject. But people rarely seek these out because they are so defensive about their deficiencies that they turn even those into a contention -- they say "this is just the way I am, take it or leave it."
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by stcredzero on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:23PM (#2323421)
Think of it as evolution in action. (And I shall take this whole post as a call to clean up my act.)
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by danssig on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @07:00AM (#2326847)
You seem to imply that being an asshole is genetic. Surely it has a large social aspect (i.e. can't be "bread out")?
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by stcredzero on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @04:22PM (#2329199)
You seem to imply that being an asshole is genetic.

Only to people who have a shallow understanding of evolution. (Left as an exercise to student.)

(i.e. can't be "bread out")?

Unfortunately, no. [irony captioned for the impaired]

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by danssig on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @04:19AM (#2331277)
The tone of this post seems to indicate your effort to "clean up your act" isn't going very well.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by stcredzero on Saturday March 19, 2011 @07:35PM (#2345056)
Well, some cases are more difficult than others. High amounts of stupidity are more challenging.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by nerfhammer on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:47PM (#2323538)
So all we have to do it just wait a few generations, and...
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by mgns on Monday March 14, 2011 @02:26PM (#2323733)
Hopefully just one generation as being an ass may stop them from getting along with the opposite sex and reproduce...
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by cakeface on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:18PM (#2323960)
Unfortunately being an ass is frequently a great way to get laid. Nice guys finish last and all...
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by detst on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @09:22AM (#2327308)
This is such BS and makes me sigh every time I hear it.

It's not being an ass that gets them laid, it's the other characteristics that an asshole typically has that gets them laid. Things like confidence, not coming off desperate and having experience not just approaching a girl but being able to hold a conversation... and the many more things that increase attraction but these are the basics.

These characteristics in a nice guy will get him laid more than the asshole and he'll have opportunities with girls that see right through the asshole (and some would say these are the more desirable women).

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by jhamburger on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:33AM (#2327602)
I wish this were true. Well, you're not completely wrong- An outright asshole is getting by on confidence alone. But a guy who is polite but disarmingly arrogant, condescending in subtle ways, is much more desirable than a confident nice guy.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by detst on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:24AM (#2327898)
> [...] disarmingly arrogant, condescending in subtle ways [...]

Nice guy equivalent: playful teasing and flirting. Someone eavesdropping might even take it out of context and interpret it as arrogant or condescending but it's just a little game -- not in some "pick up artist" sense; it's ideally very natural. Works for me.

While we can argue all day long about what makes for the most desirable man, I still contend that you can have more (desirable) women want you than you could possibly ever get around to and be a nice guy.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by crasshopper on Monday March 14, 2011 @06:48PM (#2324871)
Sure, lots of men ('cause programmers are male, right?) get positive female attention by publicly insulting people who know less about programming and computers.

Meanness is always unattractive. Always.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by pyre on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:11PM (#2323931)
On the other hand, that may be the cause instead of a side-effect, at least in a number of cases. (e.g. "You need to get laid, bro")
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by Alex3917 on Monday March 14, 2011 @12:55PM (#2323245)
"Then there are the people who are dicks and want to crush people who they disagree with."

The problem is that when people start mouthing off about factual issues they don't know anything about they can cause a lot of damage, so crushing them is often a necessity.

When you're in a situation where there is a lot of potential for damage and the other person isn't willing to have an intellectually honest debate about the facts then there isn't really much choice but to make them look like a moron.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by nhangen on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:18PM (#2323394)
That comment:

"The problem is that when people start mouthing off about factual issues they don't know anything about they can cause a lot of damage, so crushing them is often a necessity."

Is exactly the type of thing that comes from the hive mind, and is why it's impossible to be a dissenter. It's usually "you don't know what you are talking about," followed by bashing until the person takes their ball and goes home.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by Alex3917 on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:48PM (#2323540)
"...bashing until the person takes their ball and goes home."

And that's often a good outcome. Consider for example this article published recently by a Connecticut state senator on why she wants to put people in jail for having 'fake weed'.

http://newcanaan.patch.com/articles/fake-pot-a-new-threat-to...

The entire article was riddled with sloppy thinking, and thoroughly plagiarized, so I got all of reddit to utterly destroy her until she deleted all of her comments and wrote a followup stating that the issue was no longer a top priority of hers. I tried to engage her respectfully first, but since she wasn't willing to engage in an intellectually honest debate then going out and fucking up her day seemed like the second best option. Overall I'd consider it a win. Sure it would have been better to get her to change her opinion, but once it becomes clear that no amount of facts or logic her will persuade her then embarrassing her until she shuts the fuck up becomes the best option left on the table.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by nhangen on Monday March 14, 2011 @08:19PM (#2325165)
Since when does being wrong revoke someone's right to express said wrong opinion?

This: "I got all of reddit to utterly destroy her" is the exact type of mentality that myself, and as I estimate, the OP, have a problem with.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by Alex3917 on Monday March 14, 2011 @09:59PM (#2325476)
"Since when does being wrong revoke someone's right to express said wrong opinion?"

No one's revoking her right to express an opinion, we're just revoking her right to make shit up. If she was familiar with the facts and she was still against marijuana reform then no one would begrudge her of that, but she doesn't get a free pass to lie to the public.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by nmaio on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:17PM (#2323955)
I'm probably in the minority with this, but...

If someone's ignorance cannot be altered or at least reasonably discussed, I think that's perfectly okay. That just means it's time for me to move on.

I don't see how attacking or embarrassing someone would make you feel better about your side of things. I'd much rather let that person enjoy their own ignorance.

Note: I tend to lack/block out very strong emotions

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by khafra on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:27PM (#2323997)
Non-infectious ignorance can be left alone. A state senator with a PR platform, using it to spread ignorance of a sort that ruins millions of lives, cannot be left alone in good conscience.

You have a moral obligation to be less wrong: http://www.wrongbot.com/2011/02/27/stop-being-wrong-a-moral-...

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by nmaio on Monday March 14, 2011 @04:02PM (#2324157)
Regardless of reach, I still don't believe attacking or embarrassing someone is the answer.

My conscience is better off letting someone have a right to their own opinion (albeit a poor one), rather than attacking them for it.

In other words, I'd rather choose to understand where their point of view is coming from and accept it, than to try and change it.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by Dylanlacey on Monday March 14, 2011 @07:51PM (#2325079)
But unfortunately points of view aren't innocent things that everyone is entitled to. They can cause SERIOUS damage to the lives of other people.

If I have a point of view that binder clips should be made illegal because they're hideous, and manage to make that a law, then A: My point of view is making regular stationers criminals, and B: I might have put people who make binder clips out of work.

Everyone has a point of view, but not all of them are reasonable, and simply having them can screw other people up.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by danparsonson on Monday March 14, 2011 @04:54PM (#2324401)
I agree with you in the sense of allowing people the space to disagree, but in this particular case, someone's bad opinion, if left unchallenged, could result in other people going to jail. It's the principle of reciprocity.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by kwantam on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @12:19PM (#2328141)
Think of it this way: he's not attacking the politician for her opinion. He's attacking her for attempting to make her stupid opinion into a matter of public policy.

Everyone is welcome to have their opinions. When one attempts to act on those opinions in a way that's harmful to other people, one cannot but expect others to oppose.

Let's say I believe that three-year-olds can fly if only they're forced into a situation where they must do so in order to save their lives. It's a stupid opinion, but it's harmless if it's just a thought sitting in my head.

Now let's say I decide that I need to teach a bunch of three-year-olds to tap their innate flying ability by throwing them off a bridge. Is stopping me from doing so disrespectful of my opinion? Would that actually give you pause in stopping me?

Respecting someone's opinion is fine and dandy, but your inalienable right to your opinion stops when it starts motivating action involving others; at that point, the general rules regarding your rights when interacting with other people apply.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by ominous_prime on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:43PM (#2323511)
The "hive mind" works both ways though. You can find examples of posts with a correct position being bullied and forced out by a mass of self-confirming, yet incorrect posts. "Geeks", who often can't let inaccurate statements stand unchallenged for fear of it self perpetuating in this manner, will fight back in kind. Public forums are often very democratic, in that the majority wins even when the majority is ill-informed. (I'm not justifying the behavior, just proposing a theory as to why this seems perfectly acceptable to many "geeks")
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by derleth on Monday March 14, 2011 @02:11PM (#2323660)
> It's usually "you don't know what you are talking about," followed by bashing until the person takes their ball and goes home.

I agree that if it's just that kind of content-free junk, it's pointless.

However, if the beatdown comes with a factual and logical refutation of the idiot's points, or at least a link to a site that has such a refutation, then it performs the inestimable service of educating the lurkers.

For example, let's say we had an anti-vaccinationist come here and start spreading lies about vaccines. We would, rightly, be dismayed at such utter lunacy at work in our forum, and we would (hopefully) post multiple refutations of that dangerous nonsense. Ideally, the lunatic would find that we are not amenable to that kind of idiocy and would leave, sadly uneducated (most likely) but at least doing less damage. The real benefit to such actions may come months later, when someone unsure of the facts about vaccines discovers a dead thread that has all of this wonderful information we used to refute the idiot.

(And, heck, we might even convince the anti-vaxxer. It could happen.)

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by loup-vaillant on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @10:54AM (#2327721)
> And, heck, we might even convince the anti-vaxxer. It could happen.

To do so, make sure you only crush the the mistake, without beating the person down. Not easy to do without de-emphasising your point though:

"You say that 2+2=5, but I think you might be misinformed…" The more direct "No, 2+2=4. II+II=IIII. 1,2,3,4." might be perceived as too blunt, especially if the context is emotional (children, programming languages…).

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by erikpukinskis on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:03PM (#2323893)
The problem is you can only do that if the categories "What you think you know/What you think you don't know" overlap exactly with the categories "What you actually know/What you actually don't know". And they often don't.

So, doubtless you're laying down the hammer of knowledge in some cases where you think you know something, but you don't. Which means it's not the hammer of knowledge you're dealing, it's just a hammer.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by scott_s on Monday March 14, 2011 @02:48PM (#2323831)
My problem with that attitude is that it's not humble. Not in a false, pretending-to-not-be-good way, but systematically not acknowledging that you may be wrong. Say what you think is correct, but always conduct yourself knowing you may be wrong.
Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by loup-vaillant on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @11:15AM (#2327841)
There are degrees of certainties. If for instance one of your beliefs is based on crushing evidence, then changing your mind on that matter will require super-crushing evidence. If someone comes and assert the contrary of your belief without presenting evidence, you should believe the other person is wrong.

Wrong beliefs are often dangerous (an extreme case would be believing that prayers are better than western medicine at curing most illnesses). So your duty is to convince the other person, or at least control the damage.

Now of course, if you do see that super-crushing evidence against your previously strongly held belief, then your duty is to change your mind. The most difficult part here is correctly assessing the weight of each piece evidence, and how they interact.

Re:My fellow geeks, we need to have a talk. by jsmcgd on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:51PM (#2323558)
Making someone look like a moron can be done with tact :) I would say that this is essential and more effective. Doing it without tact makes everything you say easier to dismiss.