Mmm...in theory this sounds good. I wonder if the people that could/cycle aren't already doing it. I have a number of colleagues who live in London. However they're just too far away from the office to be able to cycle let alone walk there. London's a big place. A lot of people use trains and buses to get from the periphery to the centre. I'm not sure cycling or walking is an option for them.
But yeah, ultimately the pre-Corona model of London commuting, with basically the entire population of the city going into and out from the centre at the start and end of the day is not going to be feasible anymore, no matter what mix of cars, public transport, walking and cycling you have. But we should still try to achieve a mix than enables the best possible quality of life for everyone.
I know plenty of people who are within cycling distance, but haven't chosen to cycle because they prefer other options for transport and fitness.
Cycling comes with certain inconveniences that it takes a certain enthusiasm to overcome. You have to own a bike you're happy to use. You have to be fit enough for the distance you need to go. You have to plan out and learn a route. You may have to be confident/experienced/macho enough to ride among traffic and navigate big multi-lane junctions. You have to be willing to shower and change at your destination, or not do so. You might need to buy lights or bags or even different clothes. You have to be willing to get wet in the rain. You may have to figure out how to store your bike at both ends.
I agree not everyone will be able to change to cycling, of course. Reading to Paddington can be done in 30 minutes by train, but takes 4 hours by bike - and some people have disabilities or other things that keep them from cycling. But I'm confident there are plenty of people who can rise to the challenge despite not having done so before.
> You may have to be confident/experienced/macho enough to ride among traffic and navigate big multi-lane junctions.
But not so much if they're closing large areas of the city to cars, right?
> You have to own a bike you're happy to use. [...] You have to plan out and learn a route. [...] You may have to figure out how to store your bike at both ends.
It occurs to me that this applies to cars too, and cars are an order of magnitude larger and more expensive. So it's mostly a cultural change.
> You have to be fit enough for the distance you need to go. [...] You have to be willing to shower and change at your destination, or not do so.
Would an electric bike help with this? Lower level of physical exertion = less sweating.
I don't think anybody is suggesting that, in fact I wonder why you even raised it.
And if I'd chosen a non-ridiculous number for my example, someone would have 'corrected' me by telling me they cycle that far. I've met Londoners who have a 2 hour cycle commute, by choice because they love cycling.
I would prefer to cycle, but don't currently. My commute (when there isn't a pandemic on, that is) goes from Vauxhall to King's Cross, which is straight through Westminster - not a great borough to cycle through.
Cycling this route is probably manageable, but it requires a lot more vigilance than I'd like to have to apply during my commute.
If this leads to a reduction in traffic I'll absolutely be cycling going forward, and I've heard the same from various colleagues.
Edit: Of course, there's also a Jay Foreman video on why Londoners don't cycle - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gohSeOYheXg
Vauxhall to Kings Cross is fine, there’s a segregated route pretty much the whole way, crossing Blackfriars bridge. The new elephant and castle roundabout is segregated too, and easy to navigate. Traffic levels won’t make all that much of a difference.
The roads are nicer anyway since the 20mph limit came in.
I accept the tube is quicker as the Victoria line is very good, but the returns from cycling make it worthwhile.
There's some bits at the start and end that are annoying to deal with, and it's slightly longer, but as a result of this it's quite likely I'll start going this way when things normalise (though I'm not expecting that to be this year).
For me, the key is to continuously try different routes. Sometimes the busier roads are safer and more pleasant to cycle. Personally once I’m on my bike the length of the route no longer matters - it’s getting on it on the first place that’s tough.
Nearly all of my journeys last year where on my bike, on a hire bike, or in a taxi. It’s wonderful leaving the tube behind.
It was an easy cycle as it’s flat yet when I did that route, there were only a handful of other cyclists. Yet the tube was packed.
There’s huge scope for getting more people onto bikes. There are still cultural challenges around cycling, which hopefully will be challenged by the lockdown.
In the Netherlands, it's not uncommon to have a cheap bike at both ends of a rail commute.
Full size bikes are sometimes allowed. For commuter trains to/from London, full size bikes are only allowed during off-peak times. On other lines, it may be necessary to reserve before travel.
https://www.thetrainline.com/trains/great-britain/bikes-on-t... , https://www.nationalrail.co.uk/stations_destinations/cyclist...
However, there's one caveat here:
> Officials said they were working with boroughs to implement similar restrictions on the minor roads they manage within the area
Some boroughs (e.g. The City) have historically been very interested in pedestrianising, but others (e.g. Westminster) have fought tooth and nail to ensure that roads are cars-first.
I would expect them to put up a fight here, too, so this is probably far from settled.