> You may have to be confident/experienced/macho enough to ride among traffic and navigate big multi-lane junctions.
But not so much if they're closing large areas of the city to cars, right?
> You have to own a bike you're happy to use. [...] You have to plan out and learn a route. [...] You may have to figure out how to store your bike at both ends.
It occurs to me that this applies to cars too, and cars are an order of magnitude larger and more expensive. So it's mostly a cultural change.
> You have to be fit enough for the distance you need to go. [...] You have to be willing to shower and change at your destination, or not do so.
Would an electric bike help with this? Lower level of physical exertion = less sweating.
I don't think anybody is suggesting that, in fact I wonder why you even raised it.
And if I'd chosen a non-ridiculous number for my example, someone would have 'corrected' me by telling me they cycle that far. I've met Londoners who have a 2 hour cycle commute, by choice because they love cycling.
I know plenty of people who are within cycling distance, but haven't chosen to cycle because they prefer other options for transport and fitness.
Cycling comes with certain inconveniences that it takes a certain enthusiasm to overcome. You have to own a bike you're happy to use. You have to be fit enough for the distance you need to go. You have to plan out and learn a route. You may have to be confident/experienced/macho enough to ride among traffic and navigate big multi-lane junctions. You have to be willing to shower and change at your destination, or not do so. You might need to buy lights or bags or even different clothes. You have to be willing to get wet in the rain. You may have to figure out how to store your bike at both ends.
I agree not everyone will be able to change to cycling, of course. Reading to Paddington can be done in 30 minutes by train, but takes 4 hours by bike - and some people have disabilities or other things that keep them from cycling. But I'm confident there are plenty of people who can rise to the challenge despite not having done so before.