I have since dabbled a bit with Stephenson, and amazingly his other books fall along the same divide for me. Zodiac is amazing, the Victorian sci-fi series (Diamond Age?) are unreadable. One book, Seveneves, the first part is amazing Neal Stephenson, the second is lazy, naive and dumb Neal Stephenson. Super puzzling, almost as if he has (really bad) ghost writers.
I have since gone back to Snow Crash (could not finish it the first time), and with some overbearing, it is not entirely unlikable.
Clearly there are two styles of Stephenson books, and we like the opposite ones.
[edit]
Maybe I should try finishing Seveneves to see if I like the ending?
The Diamond Age +++
Snow Crash ++
Quicksilver/The Confusion/The System of the World ++ (I think it makes sense to rate them as a series)
Anathem +
Seveneves -
Cryptonomicon -
Reamde --
Fall, or Dodge in Hell: hate to admit it but I haven't read it yet. It's sitting right next to The Rise and Fall of DODO, which is also waiting to be read. And I should probably read Zodiac at some point, but it hasn't seemed urgent.I still think The Baroque Cycle would make a wonderful sprawling multi-series show (Jack Shaftoe being one of my favourite fictional characters).
Diamond Age is a single book, and one of the "phyles" (cultures / pseudo nation states) is called the Neo-Victorians
He got better over his career, but the short answer is yes.
I really liked Seveneves though. And The Rise and Fall of D.O.D.O. has been good so far!
Seveneves, on the other hand, I absolutely loathed in basically every regard. My loathing for it makes it memorable enough to be my most hated book (there are plenty of books out there that are 'worse', but are also unmemorable -- Seveneves is viscerally memorable)
Here's a HN comment I wrote shortly after reading it last year:
> Snow Crash is so bizarre. It launches you straight into the story with no explanation, starting off with some crazy pizza delivery man in a rocket car with swords and an electric zapper thing for people who don't pay the bill. The whole book is like that--it never explains how, why, or when, leaving you to piece it all together yourself. The entire time I was reading it, I was waiting for a 30000 feet view of the world. But then it ended, never having fully explained itself.
> I've never read anything else quite like it, and honestly don't know what I think of it. Are all of Neal Stephenson's books like that?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19704665