News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by jokoon on Thursday May 14, 2020 @05:34AM (#23177425)
One thing I constantly realize is that commenting is broken on reddit, for one simple reason. Once a thread is popular enough, and reaches a high amount of comments, any new comment is going to be drowned by upvoted ones.

The algorithm should decrease the value of old comments even more. There's already a formula, something like

position_score = score/(age^2)

Unfortunately the more a comment is upvoted, the more it's visible, so it's snowballing upvotes faster than the 1/age^2 can decrease its position.

Also the more a thread is popular, the sooner it should be locked.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by hombre_fatal on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:01AM (#23177597)
I think a big upgrade for both HN and Reddit would be so simply collapse all child comments by default and only show top-level comments. That way every person doesn't have to scroll past the first thread to find the second top-level discussion.

I don't think threads should be locked, though. There is nothing on Reddit more annoying than not being able to reply to someone because of an arbitrary decision (like a mod locking the entire submission). There are better solutions. But it just seems silly to shut down discussion when people want to have it on a social site.

Even sinking a thread to the bottom is better than locking it.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by apexalpha on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:38AM (#23177845)
One website that I think has nailed comment moderation is the website Tweakers.net. A Dutch tech website and forum.

On Tweakers you (as a user) can apply for mod rights and it allows you to rate each comment from -1 to +3.

+3 = must-read

+2 = informative

+1 = on-topic

0 = off topic

-1 = spam / insult

There's an alogrithm that gives your rating more weight if they (retroactively) allign with what the supermods (employees of the site) rate comments.

On Tweakers you almost never read insults and "and my axe" repititive comments because they are hidden by default, and the +2 and +3 comments automatically get places at the top.

This has so much over a simple +1 / -1 system. I wish more website would think about their comments systems and how they can achieve a good incentive and moderation structure for informative comments to be lifted up and unwanted ones down.

Tweakers is Dutch but to get an idea here's a news thread with a lot of comments:

https://tweakers.net/nieuws/166988/

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by Angostura on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:57AM (#23178405)
Similar to the excellent Slashdot moderation system. Moreover on Slashdot you couldn't just moderate at will, occasionally you would find yourself with 5 moderation points to spend upvoting or downvoting 5 comments.

Even more occasionally you would find yourself with some 'meta-moderation' points - where it displays some moderation decisions and asks whether you agree/disagree that this was good moderation

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by jon-wood on Thursday May 14, 2020 @08:22AM (#23178571)
Slashdot's moderation has still yet to be beaten IMO, when up/downvoting a post you had to specify why you were doing so from a defined list, including things like Funny, Informative, Flamebait, and Trolling. Then as mentioned meta-moderation would occasionally ask a user to review those votes, asking the question "Was this post funny" for example. User's who's moderation points were upheld in meta-moderation would be more likely to get given more than someone who flung them out at random.

The real genius of the system though was the amount of configurability attached to those topics. Each user could define what those categories meant to them, so if you only wanted the serious stuff you could say Funny didn't get a +1 boost when displaying comments, and give it a -1 instead. Or -5 if you really hated Slashdot humour. In the other direction lovers of a good flame war could boost comments flagged as flamebait up in the sorting order. This also extended to relationships, where you could flag people as either friends or foes, allowing you to make sure you always saw comments from people who's comments you enjoyed, and squash anything by people you just didn't like.

All of that was an absolute nightmare for performance I'm sure, which is probably why we don't see it these days, but it was a thing of beauty.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by uabstraction on Wednesday May 20, 2020 @06:50PM (#23252928)
Another great thing about the Slashdot moderation system was the "overrated" and "underrated" tags. A comment could get moderated as "-1 Flamebait" then get moderated as "+1 Underrated" all the way up to "+5 Flamebait". My personal favourite quirk of the system.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by dredmorbius on Thursday May 14, 2020 @02:55PM (#23183789)
Slashdot's mod system was ... reasonably good at deprecating garbage. It did poorly at elevating true quality, however. The mod activity was too thin and non-convergent (each moderation moved. by a full point on a +5 -- (-2) scale).

I'd been on the site since before registration and moderation existed, and had a very low UID, back when that ... still really didn't matter.

Kuro5hin's "mean of moderation" system converged (within a five point scale, much like Amazon star ratings), though in practice people vastly overaward high scores.

Explicit scoring systems are difficult to design. They also leak insane amounts of personal information.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by y7 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @08:08AM (#23178477)
While the Tweakers system might be nicer in some ways, I think the problem of new comments having no visibility still applies to the site in practice. Maybe that's less of an issue because it's a news site, but still.

Sidenote: what's ironic in your linked post is that the only comment with a +3 rating is factually incorrect. The author claims that there is no currently known quantum algorithm that breaks ECDSA.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by asplake on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:27AM (#23178190)
I think Slashdot works something like that (or at least did, haven’t been there in a while)
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by blaser-waffle on Thursday May 14, 2020 @09:18AM (#23179098)
It did, but it gained enough traction and turned into something that could be gamed. Reddit is going that way, too.

HN is my replacement for /.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by asplake on Thursday May 14, 2020 @12:09PM (#23181234)
Yes. Mine too. Interesting to consider what a less gameable version might look like
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by hnick on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:50AM (#23178357)
It did but Funny often floated to the top... same old jokes. Very Reddity before Reddit was a thing.

I think you could filter though to hide all 'Funny' and only show 'Informative' or something like that. Never did make an account.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by koheripbal on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:04AM (#23178019)
I think the actual values of the upvotes should be hidden, but the different upvote types should just be names - informative vs funny, vs analytic, etc...

I enjoyed the say Slashdot did it.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by skilesare on Thursday May 14, 2020 @04:53PM (#23185276)
I really like https://shacknews.com/chatty. I've been going there for years.

I even 'rebuilt' it tried to sell it as a service once (http://xcursi.com - warning, the cert is expired and I've been too lazy to replace it).

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by raverbashing on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:49AM (#23177930)
Well that famous tech website had a similar, more granular way of voting (which made sense I guess 10 years ago), but I think I like this way better
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by Bedon292 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#23179057)
Not sure it should be all children. But maybe 2 deep or something. For instance your comment would be unseen if it was collapsed at the top level, but yours is what sparked my reply. It does get weird though, because then people would just be incentivised to reply at the top level. And end up a longer thread there. I guess if its not completely collapsed there is always going to be some attempt to reply in the right place because you will get more views there instead of a top level comment.

Also curious about being able to make a web extension that collapses at a certain configurable level. Or even reordering. Not that it helps most users. But would be interesting.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by MaxBarraclough on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:18AM (#23177700)
Interesting idea. If the reply chain is expanded by default, whichever top-level comment rises to the top tends to steer the direction of the discussion. This is especially troublesome on Slashdot where comments are shown in chronological order, regardless of score.

> But it just seems silly to shut down discussion when people want to have it on a social site.

Locking is meant to be used when a thread is filling with toxic bile and there's little chance of things improving. I don't think it's always wrong for mods to lock a thread.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by omniscient_oce on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:34AM (#23189541)
They have some form of that already as it is, but I'm not 100% sure how it works. Some comment replies have the first few replies and then it shows a 'Show 43 more comments' button to expand that depth level, but some comments go 3,4,5 levels deep.

Maybe if it was more predictable and shallower it would be good, the problem is its annoying to keep clicking show replies to load more levels

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by amiga_500 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @08:40AM (#23178720)
Hacker news does the opposite. It's hard to collapse child comments thanks to the absurdly small collapse button.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by jokoon on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:23AM (#23177731)
you can still answer in PM
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by evgen on Thursday May 14, 2020 @10:44AM (#23180150)
Such a bad idea. A set of comment threads is going to be a tree of some type and you need to decide if it will be deep or wide. This promotes wide with very little justification beyond 'I didnt get in early on the discussion but still want a high-ranked comment' while the idea of allowing people to necro old threads is so bad it does not even merit discussion (seriously, go try out some forum that allows this and it will take you no time at all to realize that this is a phenomenally bad idea.)
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by Hnrobert42 on Thursday May 14, 2020 @05:04PM (#23185421)
I think both ideas are good, and I don’t find your dismissive objection persuasive. The point of hiding all but top-level posts wasn’t about making comments.

It was about reading them. Specifically that with fully expanded comments, users have to scroll past even downvoted, flagged responses to the top comment before seeing the second-highest voted top-level response.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by someguyorother on Thursday May 14, 2020 @06:15AM (#23177686)
One thing I'd like to see would be a comment section that uses a multi-armed bandit algorithm based on upvotes, or by something like Thompson sampling. So each time you refresh, comments that have more upvotes tend to be shown earlier, but the fewer votes in total they have, the more it's up to chance where they appear.

If it uses a deterministic MAB algorithm, it would put unvoted posts at the very top. The MAB algorithm is constructed to find the best choices (here, most liked posts), and it can't know what the true score of a comment is if nobody has voted on it yet. Thus the need for exploration would push those posts/comments very high.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by NoodleIncident on Thursday May 14, 2020 @07:00PM (#23186646)
This is way less of a problem than you'd think, as long as the default "best" sort is used. Also, I don't think age is taken in to account on reddit, are you thinking of this site instead?

https://redditblog.com/2009/10/15/reddits-new-comment-sortin...

As someone who browses both reddit and hacker news (obviously), I'm regularly frustrated by the way this site hijacks your attention to ask you to judge some recent comment, rather than showing you the ones worth reading at the top. It's still never going to get enough votes to keep that position, and it makes more sense to ask people who've scrolled to the bottom to judge comments with few votes, once they've already read the current frontrunners.

When you see big subs with old comments with a lot of votes at the top on reddit, it's probably because there's nothing else worth showing towards the bottom. I scroll further than I probably should, and the more the subreddit appears to have the early-replier problem, the less I care how those comments are ordered.

Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by rightbyte on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:31AM (#23190097)
I would like an option of defaulting subreddits for all users to chronological order and bumping threads to front page as soon as someone posts in it. Reddit is really bad for actual discussions. It was designed for link sharing not a forum and incidently algorithmic feeds have since becoume standard due to advertising for some reason.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by colinmhayes on Thursday May 14, 2020 @12:03PM (#23181143)
Reddit has a feature called contest mode which orders comments randomly for the first few hours or so.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by OGWhales on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:09AM (#23188807)
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by blackearl on Thursday May 14, 2020 @10:24AM (#23179893)
There also seems to be an uptick in threads being locked, usually with some lame excuse like "you people can't behave" but is more likely that the mod doesn't agree.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by bitxbitxbitcoin on Thursday May 14, 2020 @11:22AM (#23180625)
Some subreddits (certainly not any of the popular ones) set their comment threads to sort by new to combat this.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by nialv7 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:54PM (#23195147)
score = upvotes/view_count is probably a good metrics that takes popularity into account. But there is certainly some statistically trickery needed to compare a popular post with lower score and a less popular post with higher score.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by guerrilla on Thursday May 14, 2020 @10:50AM (#23180216)
So, another instance of "rich get richer." I wonder if your fix or something like it would work in other systems like twitter (e.g. the more followers you have, the less I hear from you), in science (see Sabine Hossenfelder's critique of voluntary peer review), traditional media and even capitalism itself.
Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people by saadalem on Thursday May 14, 2020 @08:18AM (#23178542)
What about medium comments then xD