Re:92 of top 500 subreddits controlled by same 5 people
by dredmorbius on Thursday May 14, 2020 @02:55PM
(#23183789)
Slashdot's mod system was ... reasonably good at deprecating garbage. It did poorly at elevating true quality, however. The mod activity was too thin and non-convergent (each moderation moved. by a full point on a +5 -- (-2) scale).
I'd been on the site since before registration and moderation existed, and had a very low UID, back when that ... still really didn't matter.
Kuro5hin's "mean of moderation" system converged (within a five point scale, much like Amazon star ratings), though in practice people vastly overaward high scores.
Explicit scoring systems are difficult to design. They also leak insane amounts of personal information.
I'd been on the site since before registration and moderation existed, and had a very low UID, back when that ... still really didn't matter.
Kuro5hin's "mean of moderation" system converged (within a five point scale, much like Amazon star ratings), though in practice people vastly overaward high scores.
Explicit scoring systems are difficult to design. They also leak insane amounts of personal information.