Single payer means everyone has a health card entitling them to spend tax money on their own healthcare how they want (within certain parameters, of course). This means health insurance companies don't get to act as cartels, limiting (patient) access to care, and, crucially, limiting provider access to patients & patient dollars. If I want to see a doctor in Toronto, I don't go to the doctor "in my network", probably at a big practice that has some convoluted agreement (or not!) with my particular insurance provider. If I want to see a doctor in Toronto, I can basically go to any available doctor who is taking new patients.
Imagine literally everyone has a health-care budget to spend, regardless of how rich poor they are. Can you imagine the type of competition & innovation this creates for those health-care dollars? Pharmacists remember my name & ask whether the meds worked as expected, doctors will visit me at my house (this has been cut back by the latest provincial government), I can check wait times at drop-in clinics online & book an appointment, see a doctor same day, even within a couple hours. Try that in the USA without going to the ER, and even then I'd be surprised if you see a doc in less than a few hours.
I was amazed to see the competition and market innovation in healthcare in Canada when I arrived here. You might be amazed as well.
Either way, we pay a lot more for a very subpar health ecosystem compared to the rest of the world.
The argument for single-payer hinges on the theory that the profit motive is incompatible with the very idea of insurance (that is, as long as denying services is more profitable than providing them, an insurance market is an inefficient way to provide said services).
1) "Single payer" is not the only way to deliver universal healthcare. Germany, Switzerland, Netherlands, Singapore all have thriving multi-payer systems. In Switzerland and the Netherlands, ALL insurance is private. In Singapore, while the government covers catastrophic care, 70% of total health expenditures are private.
2) The biggest problem in the US is that healthcare is just more expensive, and American insurers end up having to pay more. An example: doctors in America earn more (PPP adjusted) than in any other country. MRI's in America cost more (even on the Medicare fee schedule) than almost any other country. A lot of this is actually caused by a series of well-intentioned policies passed over the last half century.
3) In the US, for-profit insurance profit margins are a pretty meagre 5%, which doesn't really make a dent in costs. Also, some of the biggest insurance providers are non-profits (Blue Cross Blue Shield, Kaiser)
4) Medicare fee schedules aren't that much better, in fact the part of Medicare that's actually working the best is Medicare Part C (Medicare Advantage), which relies on private payers.
Source: I work at a claims adjuster
Or if that's too ambitious, how about just knowing that insurance isn't going to deny coverage just because I went to the wrong clinic/hospital? Nevermind that if I've been in an accident I'm not exactly going to be able to choose where I go.
Yeah this is definitely a worthwhile policy solution. Universal catastrophic coverage would also be a pretty solid compromise, especially since that would essentially be "single payer" for financially ruinous treatments. Ambulance ride costs are indeed insane, and something that even municipal cities can (and should) operate for free just like fire departments.
> Or if that's too ambitious, how about just knowing that insurance isn't going to deny coverage just because I went to the wrong clinic/hospital? Nevermind that if I've been in an accident I'm not exactly going to be able to choose where I go.
Yup, also a great solution. I work at a claims processor and have processed claims myself — the current system is asinine. Simply ensuring that all providers charge the same rate to all patients, and for that charge to be transparent upfront can probably go a long way to improving the status quo.
Additionally, providers themselves are starting to charge out-of-network rates that are LOWER than Medicare fee schedules. For example, Wal-Mart has launched healthcare in Georgia, charging $25 for a cleaning[1], which is significantly lower than the amount for a cleaning (procedure code D1110) set by Medicare/Medicaid. You can look it up yourself by visiting the FAIR Health code lookup tool (https://www.fairhealthconsumer.org/dental/results), and setting the ZIP code to that of Carlton, GA (location of the Wal-Mart clinic), 30627. The average allowed amount is $64.
Finally, the US government has historically been pretty bad at setting prices, as a monopsony buyer. The US military spends more per capita on the military largely because it pays more per-soldier, per-fighter jet, etc than any other nation on the planet. You would think that, as the sole buyer of US defense sector fighter jets, it could negotiate better rates. The F-35 is expected to cost $1.5 trillion (!!) over its lifetime, and the US enjooys monopoly/legislative powers over that cost.
Another example: NASA's planned SLS moon mission is a bit of a disaster — way over budget and way behind schedule. Because the boosters aren't reusable, each launch is expected to cost $1B (with a B) dollars — EACH launch! Meanwhile SpaceX's target cost-per-launch is $50M.
So while you're right that, in theory, a monopsony can extract the lowest possible price, there's absolutely no guarantee of this, indeed American empirical evidence has at times proven otherwise.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-02-25/walmart-t...
I can tell you ALL about M4A vs private insurance, I currently work at a claims adjuster, and adjust claims myself.