News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gig workers are organising in tech-savvy ways by karpierz on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:23PM (#23109068)
The public option isn't supposed to replicate private insurance. Monopolistic/legislative powers allow the public option to set market rates.
Re:Gig workers are organising in tech-savvy ways by bhupy on Thursday May 07, 2020 @06:41PM (#23109210)
That's true, in theory, but in practice Medicare fee schedules aren't that much better than private insurers.

Additionally, providers themselves are starting to charge out-of-network rates that are LOWER than Medicare fee schedules. For example, Wal-Mart has launched healthcare in Georgia, charging $25 for a cleaning[1], which is significantly lower than the amount for a cleaning (procedure code D1110) set by Medicare/Medicaid. You can look it up yourself by visiting the FAIR Health code lookup tool (https://www.fairhealthconsumer.org/dental/results), and setting the ZIP code to that of Carlton, GA (location of the Wal-Mart clinic), 30627. The average allowed amount is $64.

Finally, the US government has historically been pretty bad at setting prices, as a monopsony buyer. The US military spends more per capita on the military largely because it pays more per-soldier, per-fighter jet, etc than any other nation on the planet. You would think that, as the sole buyer of US defense sector fighter jets, it could negotiate better rates. The F-35 is expected to cost $1.5 trillion (!!) over its lifetime, and the US enjooys monopoly/legislative powers over that cost.

Another example: NASA's planned SLS moon mission is a bit of a disaster — way over budget and way behind schedule. Because the boosters aren't reusable, each launch is expected to cost $1B (with a B) dollars — EACH launch! Meanwhile SpaceX's target cost-per-launch is $50M.

So while you're right that, in theory, a monopsony can extract the lowest possible price, there's absolutely no guarantee of this, indeed American empirical evidence has at times proven otherwise.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-02-25/walmart-t...