i feel like a lot of people are ignoring that a ton of people have relocated outside of NYC. i don't think the 25% antibody positive study in nyc is accounting for that
When you combine this 10x increase of the IFR along with the 5x-8x increase in suspected attack rate of flu, one would have to quite ignorant of reality, and perhaps an unknowing tool of others, to somehow look at the NYC study and think that it supports the silly "flu" conflation.
(And for that matter, flu kills a ton of people every year, are we going to add another flu to the world without fighting back at all? What sort of wimpy, defeatist person looks at the world that way?)
I actually agree that most parts of the US should carefully open up - the lockdowns have a significant portion of the population in dire straights. Our society can't survive a long-term lockdown intact, I'm convinced.
But that doesn't mean the virus isn't extremely dangerous. It's far worse than the flu. It's irresponsible for folks on social media to insinuate that it's "not even has bad as the flu" based on a few memes they've read.
We have to take great care, or more areas will end up like the Tri-state area. As the GP pointed out, the viral load is extremely important in determining mortality among the younger ages. If there is tons of the virus everywhere, the < 60 mortality rate will increase, possibly dramatically.
Glad to be on HN where most people understand things like CFR vs IFR (as opposed to a vague "death rate" most of social media talks about) along with issues of bias, etc that can affect any of these studies.
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav...
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/10/upshot/corona...
I feel like they're realistic limits. People are not gears and you cannot turn humanity off like batteries. There is unrest in Ecuador when cities began running out of morgue space. There's unrest in parts of the world where people haven't seen paychecks for two months. Most high income countries have been overproducing food for years, but we're still losing a lot of food quickly. We're depending on that overproduction slack to hold.
Combined with the difficultly of creating coronavirus vaccines. I've read people attribute the lack of a good SARS1 vaccine due to the economics/capitalism, but there seems there more to it. Animal and human trials have produced vaccines that may not provide long lasting immunity and have dangerous side-effects:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3335060/
A vaccine in less that 5 years feels very unrealistic, not for a safe one. I have a feeling humanity may need to come to the realization that our life expectancy may have been significantly lowered for the next several years, if not decades.
Yes. The reason there is no SARS1 vaccine is because SARS1 burned out after a year:
"The SARS global outbreak was contained in July 2003. Since 2004, there have not been any known cases of SARS reported anywhere in the world." [0]
[0] SARS (10 Years After) [2016] - https://www.cdc.gov/dotw/sars/index.html
There is no need for a SARS1 vaccine because that virus disappeared before the vaccines became available.
https://www.sportschau.de/weitere/allgemein/corona-lungen-sc... (I did not found an english link)
https://www.lung.org/lung-health-diseases/lung-disease-looku...
Other fibrosis can be chirgurgically removed (happened to a semi-pro i know of), but this is not possible for the lungs.
So yeah a virus can do more harm than you can see from the outside. It is not just a cough. You don't know what else is going on.
The point of flattening the curve is to keep the healthcare system from being overwhelmed, in order to avoid a catastrophic death rate.
With a vaccine still 18-24 months away, we're all going to get infected sooner or later no matter what we do.
If we can keep this thing suppressed for another month summer might provide us with a bit of breathing room to figure out what works and stockpile supplies. But even if not I'd rather get this thing with the medical state of the art a month from now.
The Chinese doctor who blew the whistle on covid-19 died from it, and I believe he was an otherwise healthy 30-something.
It's not really clear at the moment but it could be due amount of dose (more virus particles, faster replication) and where the virus makes contact with the body (if you are unlucky you are breathing a high dose directly into your lungs i.e. coughing patients in a hospital) - your immune system does not know the virus and it takes a while until it's able to fight it off and if the virus is directly in the lungs or you've got a high dose it has less time to do so. If you have it only in the throat it takes a lot of time, like multiple days until it goes into the lungs (if at all, this is also not clear when and when not this happens) and he suspected that in this time period you already have a better immune response.
Besides that (not from the podcast) I've read that the virus can induce inflammation that can can cause blood clots and other nasty things - so you may die from stroke or heart problems and not pneunomia.
There was also a paper that hypothesized that the virus can either replicate in the throat and go the lungs but it's probably also possible for the virus to use the nervous system to reach the brain via the olfactory bulb.
China did isolate ill patients from their families and it was hypothesized that sharing a bed/room with a sick person is a bad idea because the virus is in high doses in the air. So you can read that you should keep fresh air flowing in and possible avoid too much direct contact.
1: https://www.ndr.de/nachrichten/info/podcast4684.html (only in german)
Making strong guarantees that people will become immune and won't be infected is part of what makes coming up with a vaccine hard. It's apparently pretty easy and quick to come up with vaccine candidates.
Yes. In some cases, the wrong kind of immune response can cause antibody-dependent enhancement (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibody-dependent_enhancement), where the immune reaction enhances the severity of the virus.
This is not terribly common, but alas this exact mechanism has been seen in earlier work on SARS.
Nurses and doctors work in close proximity to people who are sick. So 50 cm compared to 2 meters.
This is why their viral load would be more.
Given a default R of 2 to 2.5 what model are you implying makes this worse in terms of viral load given a reduced R? How would this work?
This bit need explaining because it sounds like you are implying with a R of 2 to 2.5 then the average person might get a higher viral load than if R was .9 lets say.
If 20 people spend a day in a room and 10 of them have mild cases maybe you now have 10 mild and up to 10 severe cases.
In order to be in a situation with many mild or pre-symptomatic cases in the same room the disease must spread fast through society.
So this needs to be modelled realistically.
I think there's a small chance one person in the room has it for R0 = 2.5 compared with a not quite as small chance one person in the room has it for a lesser R.
Also I also don't think being in a room with multiple people effects load.
I think it's distance. A cough from a person within 50cm is far far worse than 2 people breathing.
So this is my junk science claim, this needs to be backed with numbers. It's not logical R effects load exposure to me, where is this evidence from?
Else this is dangerous information, exactly the same as saying it's just the flu.
One thing I'm looking at is the excess mortality in a country like Sweden, which had an outbreak (in the top 25 countries by cases) but has not done any lockdown.
https://www.euromomo.eu/graphs-and-maps/
It's flat.
> In practice, however, this strategy, which was rejected in the United Kingdom, is leading to a much higher death rate in Sweden than in other Nordic countries.
and they cite a CNN source. But then I look at this data plotted on a log chart and it appears they're leveling out:
https://covidly.com/graph?country=Sweden#growth
I think it's way too early to make any inferences about which method is working better. There is a lot of noise in all the data.
I don't think the mutation rate of this particular virus is very high, though, so this situation doesn't seem as likely here.
My understanding is that viruses don't have replication machinery at all - it's one of the defining features of viruses. Their host cells are essentially tricked into producing copies of the virus.
Some people are looking at antibody studies that show that large parts of the population are somehow affected and then doing back of the napkin math and deciding that this is really not worse than the flu in terms of death rate. They are further encouraged by the fact that people that die tend to be older and with pre-existing conditions. Then they say we should open everything up and get everything "back to normal", and sometimes they add that this is just a way to winnow out the old and the weak.
As problematic as the latter statement is, the above thinking is actually dangerously optimistic. Experience shows us that in specific situations with prolonged/repeated exposure, the death rates are much higher. Also young and healthy people may get seriously sick and die due to high level of exposure.
This has already been happening in hospitals that did not have sufficient protective equipment/procedures.
If we open everything up and get into a situation where the virus is all over the place we can get into a horrible spiral of increased exposure and increased death rates etc.