News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by randyrand on Monday April 27, 2020 @03:07AM (#22993592)
The Beatles are sounds more correct to me.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by INTPenis on Monday April 27, 2020 @03:14AM (#22993622)
What about Nirvana? Or Metallica? I think in the case of "The Beatles" it's clear cut because it sounds like you're talking about insects. But in other cases I think both sound ok because you could either be talking about a group of people, or a movement or a brand.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by rukuu001 on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:25AM (#22994274)
What happens in my brain:

- "The Beatles are..." This means we're talking about those 4 guys in The Beatles

- "Metallica is..." Means we're talking about the band, not the 4 dudes.

And when that change happens (inferring the band vs inferring the band members) it doesn't change the meaning of the sentence, so nothing else matters.

Re:Lamest Edit Wars by KMag on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:59AM (#22994429)
> Metallica ... nothing else matters

I see what you did there.

Re:Lamest Edit Wars by nfg on Monday April 27, 2020 @03:39AM (#22993752)
All I can say as a speaker of non-US English is that “Metallica is” and “Nirvana is” still sound completely wrong to my ear.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by vanderZwan on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:00AM (#22994702)
As non-native speaker I think I'd intuitively go with “Metallica is” and “Nirvana is”, but “The Beatles are”. I guess my brain is more wired towards whether the name itself is plural or not.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by roelschroeven on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:04AM (#22995420)
What about "Dire Straits"? Also plural, but grammatically completely different from "The Beatles" (by which I mean: you could say that John Lennon was a Beatle, but you can't refer to Mark Knopfler as a Dire Strait)
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by willyt on Monday April 27, 2020 @10:10AM (#22995960)
Dire Straits is something that happens to you, it would be used in this context, 'He was in dire straits' meaning, in big trouble of some kind. The straits in question are not a plural of an individual living thing like a Beatle. So I would say 'Dire Straits is a band'. I'm a native British English speaker, that sounds right to me, but my generation weren't formally taught grammar at school so I can't back that up with any fancy grammar words!
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by ajuc on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:45AM (#22994900)
Same, but I realized I'm just going with my native language rules on that one.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by TulliusCicero on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:46AM (#22994904)
Congrats, you're American.
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by waylandsmithers on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:13AM (#22995478)
Wait wait but what if Nirvana was a one-person band? OR what if you don't know?
Re:Lamest Edit Wars by phreack on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:37AM (#22994034)
Since there appear to be no right answers and I love this topic, I feel the band's name should play a big role in its plurality. I would never say that 'Queen are a band' but I would also not feel like 'The Beatles is a band'. At gun point though, I'd choose the latter.