News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by joelhaasnoot on Saturday March 05, 2011 @08:31AM (#2291446)
If Facebook is "a company that makes most of its revenues from advertising", and Google is stealing their revenue according to them, they need to work on their Ad Platform. As a small startup, we did some ads on Facebook with 500,000 displays but only 13 or so clicks (but then again, the ads were cheap to run). Nobody cares about Facebook ads and no one clicks on them, I know I very rarely do.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by tluyben2 on Saturday March 05, 2011 @09:43AM (#2291524)
Exactly; I click on Adsense ads often and I bought stuff I wanted via those ads. They are often good for my purpose. I made quite a bit of money with Adsense as well. Facebook ads are quite the opposite; I have seriously never clicked on one, because, even though I spend time on Facebook, I never saw even one that looked remotely interesting to me. I hear the same thing from all my friends and read this on most forums/sites I frequent. They have power in numbers, but besides that a lot needs to happen.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by jayzee on Saturday March 05, 2011 @10:11AM (#2291573)
Well isn't it basically because when you are on Google you often have the intent to buy something say plan a trip, rent a car or find a restaurant or whatever.

On facebook you are checking out your friends and the adds are not immediately relevant to the reason why you are on facebook. makes a huge difference.

Facebook needs to build a search engine and the social graph should be a subset of the results like Google categorizes images, videos, maps etc on the top/left.

Once fb builds buys a real search engine (blekko) the game could change very very suddenly

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by lallysingh on Saturday March 05, 2011 @11:15AM (#2291681)
Nope. I'm often on gmail and am looking at an email from a (non-technical) friend of mine, when a little text ad for a nice little 1U opteron machine shows up top. I click, because I'm interested.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by jayzee on Saturday March 05, 2011 @12:58PM (#2291910)
Yeah... such curiosity clicking costs advertisers. Conversions on the fb platform are abysmal.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by esmevane on Saturday March 05, 2011 @12:27PM (#2291833)
This is just evidence of the failure of the Facebook ad platform. With the sheer abundance of data that Facebook commands, this should not be the case.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by lallysingh on Saturday March 05, 2011 @01:41PM (#2291999)
I donno. I was looking for opteron serversm (still am, actually). I don't think there's anywhere that facebook would actually know that. I'd ignore any intel boxes, so they'd have to be pretty accurate to get something that I'd click on.

If I was facebook, I'd focus on social activities that I'd be interested in while interacting with my friends. Ski trips, wii games, etc.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by Lookinggood on Monday March 07, 2011 @07:50AM (#2296946)
I think FB adds will get to revolve around "performance based advertising" (targeting users) on a global scale. Google will then find its way 'in' via it's Invite Media. Facebook will help provide the Data, as will Google et al ...Data is the 'key', I feel...

http://seekingalpha.com/user/36191/instablog/search?terms=Pe...

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by socialmediaking on Saturday March 05, 2011 @05:19PM (#2292627)
If you ran ads with 500,000 displays and only 13 or so clicks, you did something horribly wrong. Facebook ads have a value because they can be ultra targeted. There are many ways ways you could have made a mistake, for instance, demographics that were too unspecific, bad images, not enough variations (i use 10+ sometimes), bad copy, etc.

I like to look at the comparison of google ads vs facebook ads as such: If you want to provide a service/product to people who are seeking that solution, use Google ads. And if you want to go to the targeted demographic directly and present your solution/product/message, use Facebook.

An example would be if you sold wedding services in miami. You could go on facebook and target women 25-35 who are engaged and live in miami. The ads would display only for the targeted demographic and would likely have a good click-through rate. Or you could go into google adwords and buy terms related to wedding services miami or zipcode+wedding service. The differences here are that a woman in the younger demographic is much more likely to be spending hours on facebook and only minutes on a google search.

In addition, google also has incredibly high competition for some of the more lucrative keywords and it is getting increasingly more competitive in local search, now requiring a top 7 ranking to really matter in the local listings.

Also, never underestimate the cpm (cost per thousand) displays of facebook ads to the targeted demographic. They work great for events like concerts and other events when simple awareness is key. A good image also helps a lot, as I run ads with the same text and different images and see dramatic differences in the number of clicks.

It's difficult for me to believe that "nobody cares about Facebook ads and no one clicks on them" because Facebook Ads (and Google Adwords/Adsense) operate as markets, with a bidding system on price. I almost don't want to post this because the more people who know about and use facebook ads, the higher the price rises. Their prices have been steadily rising over the last year as more and more business try them out. They do work, but not for every product and not for every demographic. But people wonder how facebook can have such a high valuation, because they underestimate the amount of direct access and data Facebook has to over 500 million people.

The ads do work, but to create a good campaign requires knowledge of the platform, and experience in marketing, advertising, and copywriting. Laypeople assume they don't need marketers and can do buys themselves, and more cheaply, but usually end up spending more. The true gold in online advertising though, comes from what happens after the person clicks.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by tomkarlo on Saturday March 05, 2011 @05:54PM (#2292729)
I don't disagree that Facebook ads might work for certain product ("Check your IQ online!") but for a lot of product, they are never going to match up to search-linked advertising. Facebook can target ad by demographic (you're a teenager, you like skateboarding) whereas Google can target an active buying moment (you're searching for a new helmet.) The former is more similar to the old paradigm of television advertising at target demos than the new world of targeting actual purchasing behavior as it happens.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by joe_the_user on Saturday March 05, 2011 @07:35PM (#2292982)
Hmm,

You could go on facebook and target women 25-35 who are engaged and live in miami. If Facebook's booster can't find a different glittering hypothetical, they are going to be in trouble... What about "barbers in St. Louis"? Uh wait, barbers in St. Louis actually need almost exactly what barbers in Houston need. The virtue of online business isn't "targeting" but finding something lots of people need.

Engaged? I think I remember friends talking what it's like having your Facebook profile say "engaged". Boy, that's one status that every retailer thinks they can exploit.

It's difficult for me to believe that "nobody cares about Facebook ads and no one clicks on them" because Facebook Ads (and Google Adwords/Adsense) operate as markets, with a bidding system on price.

If your reasoning was correct, nothing sold at an auction would ever be a bad deal.

But given that Facebook is seen as the next platform, every minute one has to presume that a new-customer appears to try and take advantage of this great platform. But frequency of these customers appearing doesn't prove that they are getting a deal that works for them.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by whatusername on Sunday March 06, 2011 @02:58AM (#2293751)
Cleaning services in st louise don't want to target barbers in Houston. Not everyone is selling a web app.

Agreed about "engaged" status though

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by joe_the_user on Sunday March 06, 2011 @02:00PM (#2294722)
Yes, but a cleaning service in St Louis can't afford to only target barbers.

My point is that the number of business that actually engage in very-narrow-targeting are small. And the target groups tend be overwhelmed by this token. What percentage of the population makes major purchases very specific to their demographic? Is it not high (weddings, college, funerals? Anniversaries? You start to run out after a short time). The rich can also be target and are targeted and you are again back in the "not-a-slam-dunk" range.

A San Francisco dominatrix still buys a car and a washing machine in the same fashion as a mid-western minister.

If you look at the idea behind Facebook advertising, you'll see it's actually the old model of brand advertising - somehow injecting an irrational connection between the customer and the product. It's just that brand advertising rightly imagine they can get more traction if they know the exact demographic someone is one. They might indeed do so but it's still in the same realm. The goal is to sway someone's purchase decision when that someone is at a store and has to decide ten different otherwise identical whats-its. The smallest prejudice you can insert will be worth a lot to you here.

But the Google model is the opposite - informational advertising. The model of offering an honest argument for a product that the person is actively seeking.

A Facebook ad is essentially about hijacking attention. Hoping you'll get some free-floating interest from someone who isn't otherwise thinking about your offer.

A web page gets you the chance to make your case to those who are interested in your case. What objectively makes your service better.

Does a cleaning service want barbers? It wants customer in the million-person city of St. Louis but that's a big group. It mostly wants anyone who actually needs a cleaning service. And then there are a lot of things to say but this basic is pretty simple.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by jedberg on Sunday March 06, 2011 @12:37PM (#2294544)
> The differences here are that a woman in the younger demographic is much more likely to be spending hours on facebook and only minutes on a google search.

Yes, but here is the key. It's all about attitude when presented with the ad. Those few minutes on Google are being spent actively seeking information about that particular topic. The hours on Facebook are about find out what friends are up to, with little thought about finding information.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by icefox on Saturday March 05, 2011 @11:50PM (#2293493)
Case in point: the only ad I have ever clicked on purpose was on Facebook. highly targeted: It was for a class on buying a house later that week in the town I live in (I was just starting to look into buying a house).
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by swombat on Saturday March 05, 2011 @08:41AM (#2291461)
I'm sure that's true and they're no doubt aware of it.

But just because your revenue model needs work doesn't mean you should leave the door wide open to your largest competitor to steal your customers who are building apps on your very own platform!

Facebook's move makes perfect sense. I'm surprised they didn't do it sooner.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by AlexC04 on Saturday March 05, 2011 @10:11AM (#2291575)
Maybe they should start making their own adsense then. Allow publishers to put ad units on their own websites out in the wild.

The ads would be of various standard banner sizes

Placed via iFrame so they were contextually relevant to the page you were on, but also socially tied back to the person doing the viewing - cookie tracking the user.

Self management system through facebook gets an option for placement on the "extended network"

I bet facebook clickrates would go WAY up because the ads would be everywhere.

What's even better is people who get "BANNED FROM ADSENSE" would have a real viable alternative.

It's not a small task - but - seems the way to go. Facebook Adsense

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by tlack on Saturday March 05, 2011 @11:36PM (#2293474)
I think this is what they're planning. I note that they have made very slow progress on their on-site platform bits (and actually hurt them in many ways by reducing virality) but are constantly improving their off-site stuff, like Like stream stories, the share widgets, and the FB Comments widget. This makes me think their medium to long term strategy is to convert the entire web into a sellable FB ad unit, rather then get everyone to spend their time on FB directly. I know the logic is a bit strange here but I can't find any other reasoning for their actions.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by notintokyo on Saturday March 05, 2011 @02:09PM (#2292061)
Could this be what Facebook is planning? They have all the like info from users and plenty of more data beyond that, plus tons of business and developer contacts for leads.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by blueben on Saturday March 05, 2011 @03:37PM (#2292341)
A small correction. These are Google's customers. Facebook is the one trying to steal them away.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by esmevane on Saturday March 05, 2011 @12:25PM (#2291824)
Do you mean, because they have no ability to compete, they should have made a move to eradicate superior platforms before it became obvious that their ad product is a waste of money?
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by sdizdar on Saturday March 05, 2011 @01:01PM (#2291916)
We did some market research using Facebook ads and we were super satisfied. In this particular case, we were interested in a specific customer segment (what they like, location, status, etc.) and Facebook ads did a great job. Google ads and other services were useless.

If other words, it is mistake to equate Google AdWords with Facebook Ads platform. They should be used differently.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by davidu on Saturday March 05, 2011 @01:05PM (#2291923)
I've been exceptionally pleased with Facebook advertising -- I find it has had far higher conversions than Google advertising has.

So as with most things, your blanket statement doesn't ring true to others; and ymmv.

Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by qq66 on Saturday March 05, 2011 @02:48PM (#2292169)
for what type of product/service?
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by bane on Saturday March 05, 2011 @10:10AM (#2291572)
I'm always curious where these mysterious "ads" are in Facebook. I have yet to see a single one in my profile (and yes even with adblock turned off). Do people really find their profiles plastered with advertising?
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by sorbus on Saturday March 05, 2011 @10:15AM (#2291583)
They occasionally show up in one of the columns on the homepage, next to the news feed. They're quite small, and very easily ignorable. Facebook even lets you close them, and after you do so enough times it seems to stop showing them to you.
Re:Facebook bans Adsense in all applications, driving Google... by phlux on Saturday March 05, 2011 @01:27PM (#2291965)
Based on your comment, you might like this article:

http://techcrunch.com/2010/10/16/why-twitter-is-massively-un...

There - Don't say I've never curated content for you :)