News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by anticensor on Thursday April 16, 2020 @04:43PM (#22893347)
AFAIK Nitrogen in the initial atmosphere rules this out.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by perl4ever on Thursday April 16, 2020 @04:53PM (#22893426)
Is there a succinct explanation of why some terrestial bodies in the solar system (Earth, Titan, Triton, Pluto) have mostly nitrogen atmospheres, but others (Mars, Venus) are mostly carbon dioxide instead?

I mean, aside from specifics about each, what's the pattern that you would apply to an arbitrary planet?

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by pdonis on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:08PM (#22894516)
> Is there a succinct explanation of why some terrestial bodies in the solar system (Earth, Titan, Triton, Pluto) have mostly nitrogen atmospheres, but others (Mars, Venus) are mostly carbon dioxide instead?

For Earth, the answer is simple: life. In the absence of life, a nitrogen-oxygen atmosphere is thermodynamically unstable. Our best current understanding is that the atmosphere of the early Earth, before life developed, was mostly methane and ammonia, which are commonly observed in the atmospheres of the outer planets and their satellites. Once life developed, the methane and ammonia were gradually chemically converted by life to water and nitrogen.

For the others you mention, oxygen is not present, and the nitrogen is combined with methane (plus traces of carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide). I have not seen detailed thermodynamic calculations, but if there are very few oxygen atoms present, nitrogen plus methane should be thermodynamically stable. The unique feature of Earth as compared with these others would be the presence of a sufficient quantity of oxygen atoms to oxidize the nitrogen to ammonia in the early atmosphere before life developed.

For Mars, it is close enough to the Sun and small enough to make its temperature too high for it to retain significant amounts of nitrogen or methane (it has traces of both, IIRC), so CO2, which is significantly heavier, is the only significant component left.

For Venus, a significant amount of nitrogen gas is present (about four times as much as in Earth's atmosphere--Venus is significantly larger than Mars so its gravity can keep the nitrogen from escaping), but this is masked by the enormous amount of CO2 present (about 95 atmospheres worth), which AFAIK is believed to be due to all of the calcium carbonate in the surface rocks having been driven into the atmosphere due to a runaway greenhouse effect raising the temperature.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by neuronic on Friday April 17, 2020 @04:49AM (#22897315)
When solar system planets formed from stellar dust, do we assume that said dust was uniform in composition and merely position, solar dynamics and interplanetary dynamics such as collisions (formation of Moon) led to the differences in chemical composition?

For example, it's the outer planets that are gas giants. Venus composition doesn't seem too different from Earth but it's much closer to Sol, so it's more exposed with much more energy absorbed etc.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by pdonis on Friday April 17, 2020 @10:14AM (#22899123)
> When solar system planets formed from stellar dust, do we assume that said dust was uniform in composition and merely position, solar dynamics and interplanetary dynamics such as collisions (formation of Moon) led to the differences in chemical composition?

That's the simplest assumption.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by elihu on Thursday April 16, 2020 @05:41PM (#22893862)
According to wikipedia, Venus' atmosphere is about 3.5% nitrogen and its pressure is about 91 atmospheres. So, technically Venus doesn't have a lack of nitrogen (it appears to have about 3 times as much as Earth), it has an extreme abundance of carbon dioxide.

Something interesting I didn't know is that apparently Venus has almost no plain oxygen.

Mars, on the other hand, doesn't have much nitrogen. Perhaps that's attributable to the relative lightness of N2, which would be more prone to float off into space than the somewhat heavier CO2.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by cryptonector on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:57PM (#22894435)
Venus has no plain oxygen because oxygen is reactive. It probably requires life to break apart CO2 and cast off the O2 into the atmosphere. Certainly it required life to do that on Earth.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by three_seagrass on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:23PM (#22894604)
Pretty much. Earth's reducing, oxygenating atmosphere is an anomaly that did not exist before stromataliths.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stromatolite#cite_ref-PiP_15-1

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by gnulinux on Thursday April 16, 2020 @05:50PM (#22893925)
Earth atmosphere is 0.04% CO2. Why does Earth have such little CO2? Is maybe used by life on early Earth?
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by mattkrause on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:36PM (#22894285)
I’m pretty sure we still have plants, though I admittedly haven’t been out of the house much.

A lot of carbon was also captured during the aptly-named Carboniferous Period 360-300 million years ago. Woody plants had just evolved, but microbes that could break them down had not. Thus, coal. An earlier drop in sea levels also caused carbonate (as in limestone, dolomite, and iron ores) to precipitate out. The combination of these effects pushed oxygen levels about 50% above present, allowing very large animals to evolve.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by saagarjha on Friday April 17, 2020 @04:47AM (#22897305)
> Woody plants had just evolved, but microbes that could break them down had not. Thus, coal.

Does this mean we’ll never have coal again?

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by mattkrause on Friday April 17, 2020 @10:46AM (#22899374)
It's not totally impossible for coal to still form, but the conditions are far, far less favorable: microbes get everywhere and the woody plants have a lot less lignin now than they used to, which also makes them easier to decompose. So, yeah, we're pretty got what we got.

Interestingly, this has happened once before. There's a "coal gap" from about 250-230 million years ago during which little-to-no coal was formed in most places. I'm not sure if anyone is sure why; this is right at the time of the P-Tr extinction, so a lot was happening. One theory is that the ligninaceous plants went extinct or other conditions were much less conductive to coal formation.

(FYI: Not a paleontologist or anything like--just a scientist who liked dinos as a kid and remembered some keywords!)

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by anticensor on Wednesday April 22, 2020 @01:47PM (#22948219)
We will, but the balance is much more against coal now. We will have it consumed before it is replaced.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by rozab on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:35PM (#22894278)
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by cryptonector on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:56PM (#22894424)
Yes. Earth used to have a lot more CO2. Then photosynthesis in the oceans created an oxygen crisis.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by chrisco255 on Friday April 17, 2020 @12:08AM (#22896109)
"The cyanobacteria producing the oxygen caused the event which enabled the subsequent development of multicellular forms." Seems like it was ultimately a win.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by dredmorbius on Thursday April 16, 2020 @10:27PM (#22895662)
And Global Cooling, as both methane and CO2 (both potent greenhouse gasses) were reduced out of the atmosphere.

The resulting glaciation extended across the entire planet, was kilometers deep, and lasted 100s of millions of years.

All because blue-green algae.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huronian_glaciation

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by perl4ever on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:14PM (#22894109)
Is that a rhetorical question?

I assume it's something to do with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limestone

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by croddin on Thursday April 16, 2020 @05:36PM (#22893826)
I think it is due the magnetosphere shielding from solar wind. Earth has a strong magnetosphere, while neither mars or venus do. For titan, wikipedia says "Titan spends 95% of its time within Saturn's magnetosphere, which may help shield it from the solar wind.", not sure about Triton and Pluto but they are much further from the sun so that probably helps solar wind not strip away as much nitrogen.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by T-hawk on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:31PM (#22894657)
It's not a pattern of ratio or composition, it's a pattern of the quantity of each individual component. The individual quantities then constitute the composition.

For CO2, the pattern is temperature. Titan, Triton, Pluto are well below CO2's freezing point so it stays on the surface as ice instead of atmosphere. At these temperatures, nitrogen is the heaviest abundant molecule that remains gaseous, followed by methane. If you're warm enough for gaseous CO2, you have it. The only exception is Earth and that's because plant life absorbed it and emitted O2 instead.

For nitrogen, methane, argon, the pattern is mass. Only Venus and Earth have enough mass to hold on to those, compared to heavier CO2. Venus and Earth have similar quantities of those. Venus's excess of CO2 comes from temperature high enough to evaporate carbon and oxygen from rock compounds.

Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by saberdancer on Friday April 17, 2020 @05:12AM (#22897425)
Titan has enough mass to keep a decent nitrogen based atmosphere as well. It is probably closest to Earth with the exception that methane is a water analogue on Titan.
Re:Could the Earth be an evaporated gas giant planet? by Rooster61 on Thursday April 16, 2020 @05:38PM (#22893840)
A relative lack of effect from the solar wind, either through magnetic shielding (Earth, Titan) or sheer distance from the Sun (Triton, Pluto).

Mars and Venus are both in the inner Solar System, and both have very weak magnetic fields.