I don't think this is the strongest argument they could have made. To me, the strongest counterargument is that the large insertion (4 amino acids; 12 nucleotides) is statistically unlikely. Even highly efficient laboratory selection systems don't produce those kinds of mutations very often.
Maybe you could do it by passing the virus between pangolins or bats over and over again, but that would be an immense amount of work.
Is it possible? Sure. Likely? No. The parsimonious answer is that it's been circulating in nature.
"More scientific data could swing the balance of evidence to favor one hypothesis over another. Obtaining related viral sequences from animal sources would be the most definitive way of revealing viral origins. For example, a future observation of an intermediate or fully formed polybasic cleavage site in a SARS-CoV-2-like virus from animals would lend even further support to the natural-selection hypotheses."
So far I have only seen innuendo and the weakest sort of circumstantial evidence, but if someone can produce something stronger I'd be willing to consider it.
Part of the argument for natural evolution is that there are mutations that most likely occured in a human host as they indicated adaption to an immune response.
My personal theory is that an individual infected with this unknown virus that was going around came into contact with the bat originated coronavirus in Wuhan (which may or may not have originated in the lab). RNA was exchanged and a novel variation emerged that was now both highly contagious and deadly. But I am not an epidemiologist.
An additional important point is that there's a middle scenario where a natural virus being studies could have been accidentally mutated and accidentally released. This might be all but impossible to distinguish between origin in the wild.
I'd guess intentional manufacture as very unlikely, but sloppy lab practices as not likely but much more likely than that.
I don't think it's very interesting if it was a naturally or artificially selected virus. The more interesting question is was the infected specimen a research subject or not.
Also, if it was somehow proven that the virus did come from a Chinese lab, what does that mean? Will the world hold China liable for this mess? That seems unlikely to me, rather I assume it would come down to “big stick diplomacy” and China carries a pretty big stick. But is there any precedent for a disease being leaked from a lab and the lab being held responsible for the consequences?
Likely but not in a military invasion type of way. No one wants a nuclear exchange with China and most other military option are unproductive for everyone involved. My guess is that individuals will be allowed to make financial claims against China for decades to come. Chinese assets around the world will be seized as necessary to pay off the claims. Logistics systems will be reconfigured to avoid China, further harming their economy. But it will be a long process because everyone is dependent on China for something or the other. The leadership of China could try to be defiant but they are going to have plenty of internal conflict to deal with so they'll be distracted on both ends. Nothing about this is going to be easy or over quickly.
That being said: what would happen if it were?
Again: nothing. Only the bottom feeders among conspiracy nuts are alleging intent here, and there's neither a legal nor a moral framework to hold states accountable for errors of negligence. We'd hopefully get a mea culpa from China, but don't hold your breath. Welcome to the community of lesser countries. There are thousands of Iraqis still waiting for a "sorry, my bad" for their brother's wedding being bombed.
This narrative is only being discussed because someone is looking for scapegoat. Realistically, it doesn't even matter. The Federal Government is supposed to protect citizens from threads irregardless of their origin. They were first warned by China itself on January 3rd. Two weeks later, the outbreak and resulting shutdown was public knowledge. Its genesis is completely irrelevant for anything that happened after New Year's.
Why necessarily Chinese? There are people that like to hypothesize that perhaps this was a misjudged attempt at biowarfare against China.
On the other hand, unless they are experimenting with humans, current technology simply doesn't allow us to produce a virus that is not fatal to many other animals but human.
It is not really a viable theory, unless the ground is that the Chinese biologist are way ahead of us in understanding the DNA, which is quite frankly extremely unlikely as a tiny bit of that would be a nature-worthy paper.
The paper then concludes that SARS-COV-2 must be a result of natural selection. While I think this is possible, they ignore the possibility that the virus is a result of artificial selection. If a laboratory were studying how SARS-COV-2 could pass to humans, they might serially pass the virus between mammals (like pangolins) in order to artificially select for mutations.
That is, in fact, exactly what previous scientists did in a 2012 experiment with bird flu. They wanted to make it transmissible between mammals, so they serially passed genetically modified bird flu between ferrets until it was. I wrote this up on my blog:https://get21stnight.com/2020/04/14/why-do-some-viruses-cros... . The result of this is that bird flu acquired previously unknown mutations in order to pass between mammals.
I'm not saying this is what happened, and there are some key differences (i.e. in the bird flu experiment, scientists had to start off with a genetically modified virus). Still, I disagree that we can definitively conclude this was a result of natural selection.