News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by WhyNotHugo on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:29AM (#22887949)
Surprisingly, severance is also mandatory in Argentina and many other "under development" countries.

I'm absolutely amazed at how people in the US are so against severance being mandatory.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by mathattack on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:26AM (#22888651)
The theory of weaker led on severance is:

1 - If you make it too hard to let people go, companies will be less willing to hire. (You’ve added a cost to the employee)

2 - If you make the cost of severance too high, it will kill companies that might otherwise have a chance to squeak through.

There are plenty of good arguments on the other side (companies offloading social costs to the govt, etc) but these two are consistent with economic theory on labor supply and demand.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by tarsinge on Thursday April 16, 2020 @11:22AM (#22890318)
I must admit that as a small business owner in France unfortunately I am unwilling to hire because it's so hard to let people go, so putting the weight only on companies is maybe not the answer.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by jazzyk on Thursday April 16, 2020 @10:55AM (#22889987)
Yeah, but because it is o easy to fire, some companies (especially startups which just got some VC money) over-hire and then are forced to let people go.

This creates a never-ending hamster-wheel of hiring-firing - not good for the employee and not good for the company.

Also, if paying 1 month of severance is too much for a company, then perhaps it is not run well and should be allowed to fail?

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by devin on Thursday April 16, 2020 @12:48PM (#22891233)
Too reductive on your last comment. I want to agree with you, but the world is complex. Money doesn't grow on trees, and there's only so much that even a well run business can do. Particularly in the early stages of a company.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by gigatexal on Thursday April 16, 2020 @12:30PM (#22891025)
I agree. There has to be a balance. Companies need to be able to let people go who are hurting the company overall. The balance comes in in making it expensive enough that they won’t go firing people without cause as it now being expensive means it has to be worth it to do so.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by neuronic on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:51AM (#22888832)
Yea, economic theories that all assume that consumers are rational actors. Thank you, next.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by have_you on Thursday April 16, 2020 @10:24AM (#22889661)
>>Thank you, next.

So have you run a business where you had to hire employees?

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by tinyhouse on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:54AM (#22888130)
I'm not very familiar with the topic. But my current and previous US companies both provide decent severance to let go employees. They do it mostly to ensure employees don't talk or try to sue. I assume most good companies in the US follow.

It's also important that people can get unemployment benefits for at least 6 months after losing their job. I'm not sure how that works in the US. I'm guessing it changes per state like everything else in the US.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by doctorwhat on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:32AM (#22887964)
Americans are amazing like that. "Free healthcare? That's communism!!!"
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by neuronic on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:53AM (#22888837)
Can we stop calling this free healthcare? It's not free.

It's just vastly better organized in a way that (largely) protects consumers from capitalism where it doesn't belong.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by kofejnik on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:37AM (#22887987)
interesting... what if mandatory severance and other (supposedly) nice things are the reason those countries are underdeveloped?
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by CraigJPerry on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:51AM (#22888096)
Seems unlikely to find a mono-causal relationship in something as complex as a national economy.

It’s interesting though, how would you go about establishing a proof?

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by omginternets on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:15AM (#22888257)
What if most developed nations had mandatory severance and these other nice things?

Hint: they do.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by pjc50 on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:00AM (#22888503)
The less-developed countries have generally been that way since their independence from colonialism.

The argument that the regulatory burden on small businesses can be bad for economic growth does have some real validity - the great work on this is Hernando De Soto's The Other Path on Peru. However, that's an argument for making the tradeoff in an informed way and exempting small businesses (something the EU is extremely bad at!), while being against severance pay in its entirety is just a profit-before-humans talking point.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by fakedang on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:52AM (#22888101)
I wouldn't mind a stance which promotes human welfare over economic growth.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by brigandish on Thursday April 16, 2020 @09:30AM (#22889130)
Since economic growth tends to go hand in hand with better access to health services and greater social freedom, it does.

I always enjoy Hans Rosling going through the stats, if you’ve time it’s well worth it https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by zwirbl on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:47AM (#22888067)
those countries like Germany, Austria, etc?
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by eitland on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:52AM (#22888105)
Let's add Norway and probably Sweden as well to that list.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by neffy on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:23AM (#22888631)
And Iceland, which is as free-wheeling a capitalistic state as anyone could want under the hood.

Making employers responsible for severance pay is a way of aligning costs with information asymmetry, and also trying to make employers at least a little sensitive to the impact their whims can have on real people's lives.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by tcard on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:59AM (#22888152)
Other things equal, if companies need to pay severance, employees get paid less each month, because companies need to take into account expected severance costs in their total labor costs and there's less money left for other benefits.

So all employees effectively pay for layoffs, which goes against you if you're not the one that gets laid off.

(I am very much in favor of mandatory severance and generally other kinds of safety nets.)

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by altacc on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:42AM (#22888395)
Having done budgeting for hiring employees in the UK, for small and medium sized companies, the factors that went into calculating staff costs never included any severance or redundancy factors. Paying redundancy is relatively rare, so doesn't need allocated funding until you're in that process.

When you're employing people you're not already thinking about their future exit. You hire based on your growth, so you're usually optimistic about the future and thinking about employees being long term. If not you hire contractors, who you can lay off easily.

Part of this is that you can't just fire people without good cause and without following a process. There are probationary periods to allow the hire to be let go if they don't work out in the first 6 months or so, but after that you're into a long "managing them out of the business" process that may or may not end up with a pay off.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by hhmc on Thursday April 16, 2020 @11:43AM (#22890547)
> but after that you're into a long "managing them out of the business" process that may or may not end up with a pay off.

I'm sure you already know, but in the UK you can be fired for any non-protected reason within the first 2 years of employment. I think UK companies are typically less cavalier than their US counterparts when it comes to firing, but in the frist 2 years, the employee protections are similar to US at-will states.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by blaser-waffle on Thursday April 16, 2020 @09:29AM (#22889121)
> When you're employing people you're not already thinking about their future exit. You hire based on your growth, so you're usually optimistic about the future and thinking about employees being long term. If not you hire contractors, who you can lay off easily.

+1 for the contractors thing. If there is already an expiration date for these people, then make them a contractor or reach out to a staffing firm.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by hnhg on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:06AM (#22888193)
This forgets the high likelihood that the amount that would have been paid as severance goes to the pockets of the owners and leadership. The market pays what the employees are worth, not what is left over after costs.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by onedognight on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:12AM (#22888231)
> So all employees effectively pay for layoffs, which goes against you if you're not the one that gets laid off.

Or you could say that the company needs to save the profit generated by your position until it equals your anticipated severance before paying dividends from that profit. So it’s still a drag on profits, but it has nothing to do with other employees.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by ratww on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:17AM (#22888269)
> So all employees effectively pay for layoffs, which goes against you if you're not the one that gets laid off.

Sounds like a very acceptable compromise. I'm happy to chip in. I'm also happy that I pay taxes for universal healthcare so that I can take advantage of that when I'm in a disadvantaged position, but that's me.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by GarrisonPrime on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:35AM (#22887976)
Argentina and Germany are hardly in rosy positions at the moment.

“I like free money” is hardly a good argument to support statements like “it just makes sense”.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by NicoJuicy on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:07AM (#22888205)
> Argentina and Germany are hardly in rosy positions at the moment.

That's not an argument also, Germany is actually doing very well for everyone ( civilians, business, healthcare, innovation, ...)

They are almost launching their contact-tracing app, while the poor, that need it, in the US get 1200$ in the next 3-6 months, lol.

The rich get 1.700.000 $ though, that's "normal". Good job! /s

Perhaps you were talking about the federal state saying that states have to look for their own medical supplies? That's nice

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by bryanrasmussen on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:49AM (#22888080)
what country is in a rosy position at the moment? and what is that country's worker's rights position?
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by sneak on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:36AM (#22887982)
It’s a violation of consent. Consent can be withdrawn at any time, with no further obligations or liability. That’s key in a free society.

Employment is a transaction, like any other. Doing some business yesterday is no guarantee of business tomorrow.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by omginternets on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:53AM (#22888118)
By that logic, all contracts are violations of consent.

You'll forgive us for not being convinced by your argument.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by sneak on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:57AM (#22888144)
I’m not sure I follow that logic. Written, signed contracts where the agreeing parties are not being coerced is presently our gold standard for opt-in consent.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by omginternets on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:02AM (#22888171)
>Written, signed contracts where the agreeing parties are not being coerced is presently our gold standard for opt-in consent.

Except that you can't later withdraw your consent. You said that was "a violation of consent".

Which is it?

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by sneak on Thursday April 16, 2020 @10:46AM (#22889887)
Ahh, I see what you were saying now.

Employment contracts in the US (if they exist at all and aren’t simply an implicit agreement, so-called “at will” in most states) don’t generally provide for severance. Almost every one I’ve ever read allows for either party to opt out at any time without penalty, or explicitly states what the remaining liabilities would be in the instance that one of the parties did end the transaction.

If you don’t have a written, signed contract, you cannot assume future consent to perpetuating or extending a transaction. There wasn’t any explicit future-consent.

The existence of a written, signed contract changes that.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by lvoudour on Thursday April 16, 2020 @07:43AM (#22888402)
> Consent can be withdrawn at any time, with no further obligations or liability. That’s key in a free society.

I'm sorry but there's plenty of both liabilities and obligations in the event of early termination. Have a look at your telco contract if you don't believe me

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by pjc50 on Thursday April 16, 2020 @08:02AM (#22888522)
.. but that doesn't exempt the parties from performing obligations! You can't, say, order a meal at a restaurant and then "withdraw your consent" from paying for it.

This is just a bad-faith attempt at using the language for sexual and interpersonal consent to pretend that businesses and workers are on an equal footing and have no obligations to their staff.

Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by Scarblac on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:50AM (#22888093)
Employees are in a much weaker position than companies, they are not in an equal position so consent doesn't come into the equation, as far as I'm concerned.
Re:Ask HN: Who Is Firing? by sneak on Thursday April 16, 2020 @06:54AM (#22888128)
Yes, that’s the common argument for it (which of course does not address the violation of consent issue). I was simply replying to WhyNotHugo’s amazement and trying to clarify why many people feel the way that they do.