News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by mikece on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:33AM (#22854896)
Voluntary compliance for public health today; mandatory compliance by government edict tomorrow -- or we flag your account and you're prohibited from buying anything. And what if I chose to stop using a smart phone and just use a flip phone that doesn't have Bluetooth? Am I a de facto enemy of public health (or just public enemy)?

Anyone else see this as a MASSIVE slippery slope with too much potential for exploitation?

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by IAmEveryone on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:02AM (#22855051)
"Slippery Slope" is a logical fallacy. It's right there alongside "appeal to authority" and "confirmation bias", to name two examples people somehow tend to remember far easier. It's a fallacy because it applies to everything: "Now, they're just requiring cars to emit less CO2[0]. Next, they'll prohibit breathing!"

This program goes out of its way to achieve provable anonymity. That is, in fact, the only reason Google and Apple are needs to implement this. Google Maps has actual location data, with similar precision at least in cities. That data has been there for sliding/skating governments to grab for years now. It's on servers, where it's easier to get to than data on your phone, legally. And location data is far more valuable than "X and Y came within 5 minutes at least once in the three days beginning April 15th".

If all that doesn't convince, rest assured it will convince the public. As would anything, really, because they already see this pretty clearly. With that in mind, consider that going to the barricades for privacy now means certain failure on this issue, and possibly lasting repetitional damage for the cause.

[0]: One wishes...

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by cosmodisk on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:43AM (#22854939)
I absolutely do so. Because of the current virus situation, there will be many shady laws and practices passed with a simple excuse.

https://amp.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/fhkcw8/what_are_...

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:15AM (#22855131)
In the US at least, I think you just argued exactly how the slippery slope isn't a slippery slope. The US government is never going to spring for getting every American a smartphone.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by drivingmenuts on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:52AM (#22855810)
The government requires auto insurance for every driver without paying a cent. They just make it mandatory and leave you to figure out how to pay for it.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:13AM (#22855987)
America almost had a Constitutional crisis over whether making people who don't have health insurance pay more taxes is allowed. I don't think the Fed will have the authority to mandate purchase of a particular class of phone when another class does the job just as well.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by DagAgren on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:54AM (#22855005)
This system goes to quite some lengths to preserve privacy.

If you are going to attack it, you need to actually address what it does and explain why you don't think that is sufficient.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by FartyMcFarter on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:04AM (#22855064)
The authors of DP-3T have already explained the privacy holes in their scheme. It's in the trade-offs section of the paper; eavesdroppers, savvy hackers and governments can identify and track infected users (to varying extents) without much trouble.

A tech-savvy person could drive by your house and find out your IDs for that day. If you reveal them later on (as you would if infected), that person would know you're infected. In small towns a single person could in practice publish a database of all infected households.

A government can install Bluetooth receivers throughout a city and find out where an infected user passed by.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by Aeolun on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:06AM (#22855079)
Installing bluetooth receivers throughout a city is only feasible if you plan to use it for way more than just coronapatient tracking.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by taborj on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:21AM (#22855574)
I think that was the point. This is useful for coronavirus patient tacking, yes, but it's also useful for people tracking in general, and malcontent (whomever defines that) tracking in particular.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by DagAgren on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:34AM (#22855680)
But it's not. There are far better ways to do that, if that is the path you're going down. This is specifically designed to make that kind of thing much harder.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by mikece on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:09AM (#22855092)
It will compliment CCTV quite nicely... and since the former can do biometric identification then cross referencing that ID# 04d07402e5a502fb7ae0a7847853f1ac5d2a280729901a29738fb3b017135934 is really Bob Smith who lives at 1234 Main Street will be easy enough.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by rfoo on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:25AM (#22855209)
I recommend actually reading the specification before imagine how to abuse it. There is no fixed, per-user ID being broadcast.

Or if you don't want to, a tl;dr is:

1. Your phone broadcasts a message via BLE every X milliseconds with a "random" ID. The ID is only predictable with a secret key which never leaves user device before "voluntarily revealing" (I agree this can be shaddy). The "random" ID is rotated every Y minutes.

2. The secret key will be rotated daily. The user device only reveals last 14 keys if user voluntarily do so.

3. Note that every BLE advertisement already contains a hardware address and your phone does this regularly. Guess how they mitigate this privacy issue? Rotating the hardware address every Y minutes. So no additional entropy being leaked here, unless you have the user's secret key.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by DagAgren on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:24AM (#22855205)
But are any of those at all realistic attack scenarios?

A government can do much more with less effort using other means. And it's hard to see the value of making that kind of attack as an individual.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by joekrill on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:03AM (#22855056)
_This_ particular version of the system does, yes. But the next iteration may slightly weaken the privacy for some "legitimate" reason. And the next version slightly more. Then just a bit more. All for seemingly legitimate reasons. That's the slippery slope.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by DagAgren on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:25AM (#22855211)
Why not just ask telecom companies for all their data? Quicker, stealthier and much easier.

There is not NEED to use this scheme in such a convoluted way. There are far better ways to spy, and the way to protect against it is through politics and laws.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:31AM (#22855659)
Exactly. People worrying about what their smartphones could be leaking via a convoluted point-to-point aggregation process while every telephone conversation and email is routed through dozens of third-party machines with unaccountable auditing going on.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:18AM (#22855165)
That's not a very impressive slippery slope if we've just concluded that the first step of it is horizontal.

If this system goes to some lengths to preserve privacy, slippery slope argument doesn't really apply.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by taborj on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:22AM (#22855592)
That's a false sense of security. Change often starts with a lateral move, but one closer to the slope being acceptable.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:33AM (#22855668)
Great. Then we should keep an eye out for the actual thing that's down the slope. Forgoing useful technologies because a slope exists is like refusing to mine coal because the uranium nearby could some day be used to build atomic bombs.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by drivingmenuts on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:55AM (#22855831)
Neither of your example minerals are particularly healthy for humans, nor can they be made so without extreme efforts.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by shadowgovt on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:14AM (#22855997)
But we can agree there's a world of difference. There isn't a massive international storage and handling agreement for coal and its waste products, and no country has ever been preemptively bombed over mining too much coal.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by mikece on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:07AM (#22855083)
"OMG! We know ID 04d07402e5a502fb7ae0a7847853f1ac5d2a280729901a29738fb3b017135934 is infected and not quarantining but we have no idea who they are! If only this system weren't built for security we could save the elderly! Won't someone please think of grandma?"

You really think that won't be the predicate for abandoning security and anonymity?

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by rfoo on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:14AM (#22855118)
But wait, with this system the infected ones have to voluntarily reveal their ID, otherwise nobody knows what their ID are. So how is "We know ID .... is infected but we have no idea who they are" possible?

edit: and no, the observable "ID" is not fixed, so you can't link two unknown IDs.

Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:40AM (#22854922)
This was my first thought. Feels like an NSA goal, to build a web of association for everyone in the country.
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by mikece on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:56AM (#22855013)
That's what makes no sense at all: the CIA and NSA have been running social network graph systems for years; they know who talks to whom and what the social circles are. The only thing this does is answer who gets within proximity of another... something the NSA and others can probably do already with pervasive video surveillance and biometric identification. This project seems like a massive overreach and I won't be taking part, even if it means pulling the SIM from my iPhone and using a flip phone until sanity returns (or for the rest of my life).
Re:How Apple And Google Are Going To Enable Contact Tracing by taborj on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:08AM (#22855935)
I have several wrenches in my toolbox. But if someone is going to give me a new one, I'm gonna accept it.

That's the same idea here; sure, maybe the CIA and NSA already have the capability. But what's the harm in having it twice? There's actually benefits from the aspect of checking one against the other, not to mention one may reveal something the other doesn't.

I'm not saying this is what will happen. I'm simply saying that power seeks more power.