News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:43PM (#22852685)
>Almost by definition "rent" is simply extracting value from the productive economy through ownership.

What? Do you define any profit margin as such? Housing rent is not the same thing as the term 'economic rent'. Housing is as much a liability as an asset. There is risk with owning it. Rent payments are compensation for said risk. All profit is just compensation for risk.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by barrkel on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:52PM (#22852731)
Profit is not compensation for risk. Risk is a limiting factor in chasing after profits, sure, but you can take unprofitable risks, and if you have a particularly privileged position or information, you can make a profit with little to no risk. Hugh Grosvenor, 7th Duke of Westminster doesn't exactly take a lot of risk for his rents.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:03PM (#22852797)
My point isn't that "all profit that ever occurs in this universe happens only because an equivalent level of risk was assumed". This isn't thermodynamics.

My point is that profit as a concept exists because without it, there would be no reason to assume risk in the first place. Therefore, profit is compensation for risk.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by barrkel on Monday April 13, 2020 @02:01PM (#22858226)
Under an ideal, efficient free market, profit exists to be squeezed out of existence. Profit incentivizes more supply, so that existing producers have their profit margin squeezed to zero.

The mentality that you seem to have is more like a moral justification, or excuse, for profit. "X took risks, and got rewards, and it is therefore good and right", to paraphrase. But there's no direct causation between taking a risk and getting a reward; in fact many rewards come from being well connected, having the right background, skin colour, social bearing and milieu, and many other structural advantages, and taking risks without these advantages leads to big fat losses.

Reducing the justification for profit to risk is a massive apology for the inequality in society which stems from far more than mere intolerance for risk. I don't think there's much difference in risk tolerance of young men right across the income distribution spectrum; you see it in boy racers, in the jousting on a Saturday night, in thrill seekers, in criminals, in all sorts. But only a few have the privileged position to be able to put significant capital at risk for reward, rather than their own bodies. Saying that it's justified that people profit from this, because of "risk", is just wrong, it's blinkered in a way which benefits the luckiest in our society.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by effie on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:10PM (#22862432)
The idea about "all profit is due to risk" is a little one-dimensional. People/groups of people can profit for many reasons. For example, owner of a company can profit by selling or even bankrupting his company. There is often little to no risk connected to that. On the other hand, if somebody else takes on some substantial risk and invests in a company, he may not profit at all - if the owner makes it bankrupt.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by pxue on Monday April 13, 2020 @12:00AM (#22853065)
I’m not sure your last part is completely true. All parts of land development and land owning must be securely insured. there are hoops to jump through.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by johnchristopher on Monday April 13, 2020 @03:33AM (#22853852)
> Profit is not compensation for risk.

That's not really how the entrepreneur thing is framed.

But isn't it a moral position then ?

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by barrkel on Monday April 13, 2020 @02:11PM (#22858332)
I believe the concept of risk as a justification for profit is a moral justification, yes; a faulty, unbalanced one, one that, if widely believed, enables the perpetuation of structural inequalities. A lot of people are incentivized to encourage other people to believe it.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by EvenThisAcronym on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:01AM (#22855442)
> Profit is not compensation for risk.

Yes it is. The primary reason anyone takes on risk is because there is profit in it.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by barrkel on Monday April 13, 2020 @01:48PM (#22858078)
You have it backwards. You make it sound like we want people to take risks, and therefore we make it profitable.

Risk is a limiting factor on chasing profit. The risk isn't the other side of a coin with profit. There are lots of different limiting factors on chasing profit; more supply may simply be unavailable, there may be barriers to entry, natural monopolies, regulation, etc. Risk (capital and human time) is one among many.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by peacefulhat on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:50PM (#22852717)
Then should rents go up? It is now much riskier to be a landlord, risk that is going uncompensated...
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by gruez on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:51PM (#22852725)
Theoretically yes, although the demand curve also comes into play. In a parallel universe where the risks of a pandemic/lockdown was known and taken seriously, you would definitely expect rents to be higher.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:09PM (#22852834)
Basically yes, but there are more things at play. For instance, if evictions are not being processed right now (or if there are very strong squatting laws in normal times) this distorts the price discovery of the market. Actual demand will have dropped, but the resulting free supply cannot also come online because people will be living rent free. You can't rent out a unit with someone living in it.

Please note that this isn't to say tenant laws are a mistake, but they do raise the price of rent for everyone.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by texasbigdata on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:47PM (#22861433)
I think you're confusing the risk of buying an asset with the day to day reality of operating in.

In the current environment, asset value decreases and certain costs (prices charged) have decreased as the supply chain adapts to try to maintain break even volume.

Maybe it's different across the board.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by newshorts on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:46PM (#22853007)
Not really, you have to take into account a renter’s ability to pay. There’s an upper limit to what people can afford to spend on housing. Risk dictates a low percentage of the overall factor in pricing.
[dead]
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by dang on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:04PM (#22852804)
Would you please stop using HN for political battle? You've been doing it a lot, and it's not what this site is for.

Also, while I have you, would you please stop creating accounts for every few comments you post? We ban accounts that do that as well. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

You needn't use your real name, of course, but for HN to be a community, users need some identity for others to relate to. Otherwise we may as well have no usernames and no community, and that would be a different kind of forum. https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by effhn on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:08PM (#22852827)
Stop suppressing uncomfortable opinions.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:22PM (#22852914)
There's discourse between differing opinions and then there's spamming and rule breaking. One is encouraged. The other is something we could all do with less of.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by dang on Monday April 13, 2020 @01:51AM (#22853483)
I have no problem with that opinion.

It's possible to express one's opinions thoughtfully and substantively, and as part of a wider pattern of using the site (i.e. not being on HN primarily for political battle). In other words, it's possible to follow the site guidelines. Plenty of users do that, on all sides of these issues. They don't run into problems with moderation.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:01PM (#22852785)
I don't mean to be pithy, but rents are established by supply and demand, not by an analysis of who's at fault or a decision about whether some particular landlord needs more money.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by negzero7 on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:08PM (#22852833)
This would be poor planning on the renter first. The obligation is on the renter to pay for the service (housing) they are using. The banks expect the mortgage holder to pay for borrowing money. If the renter can't pay they shouldn't get to stay. If the borrower can't pay they will lose the property. If the owner can't pay the taxes, they also lose the property.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:52PM (#22852733)
Price (in essentially all cases, particularly for commodity goods like housing) is based on supply and demand, not on the individual financial situation of the person selling the product.

If demand for housing climbs noticeably, rates will follow, and vice versa (if supply of housing climbs, rates will plummet)

The reason profit exists is that risk must be assumed to earn it.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by deelowe on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:23AM (#22856612)
It can't go up. And, as a result, many landlords will lose their businesses. This is why it's a "risk." The risk of being a landlord is playing out right now and, as a result, many could stand to lose their business.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by jahaja on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:58PM (#22852765)
Surely the risk motive for profit includes what's happening now?
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by Spooky23 on Sunday April 12, 2020 @10:51PM (#22852723)
Lol. Not at any scale. Once you own about a dozen units the principal risk is not getting over your head in debt.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:04PM (#22852806)
Have you talked to many landlords that own a dozen units? It's my understanding that owning so many units is hard, requiring you to either work full time or hire a property management company, and you incur a serious risk of massive costs from misbehaving tenants.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by Spooky23 on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:18PM (#22852892)
Hard, sure you have to actually do something and hire people.

It’s a pretty basic business. Watch the money going out, manage the tenants coming in.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by SpicyLemonZest on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:35PM (#22852972)
You're right that it's not an uncharacteristically complicated business, but all businesses are hard! The idea that business owners sit there sipping whiskey, living an unburdened life like an aristocrat, is almost always false.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by mercer on Monday April 13, 2020 @06:29AM (#22854568)
It can still be an unreasonably comfortable life provided by, proportionally, little effort and, disproportionately, sizeably negative consequences for much of society.

I personally know way too many permutations of 'landlords' to feel comfortable judging them all in a similar way, but I'm still inclined to judge most of them negatively and harshly. Because in most cases, it's just so obvious how their owning and 'rentier' status is not a consequence of 'fairness' or even 'fair competition'.

My landlord got what he had because of his age. Most of my rentier friends have what they have because they inherited it. I'm okay with my landlord because he's disabled in some way and scraping by, but it's still weird that I pay for his entire mortgage + more just because he bought a house at the right time. I'd prefer a situation where I can choose to support him rather than feel, weirdly, as part of the precariat that he can kick out whenever he can benefit more from others paying his mortgage and more of his monthly expenses.

The only reason why he can't and won't do this is that legally there's a limit to how much rent he can ask me.

Anyways, point being, there's something fundamentally iffy about the fact that every single 'rentier' I know acquired this status through nepotism or timing, and not via whatever meritocratic measure one could conjure up.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by AjithAntony on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:15PM (#22861230)
What planet do you live on? San Francisco? Maybe you can get lucky and accidentally buy a house in a place that becomes the next silicon valley like your landlord.

In the real world, there are thousands of landlords that are just regular people and regular businesses that are not royalty. You can live anywhere you like.

Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by nradov on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:14PM (#22852875)
Every landlord who owns more than few units is fully aware of those realities.
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by missedthecue on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:00PM (#22852780)
So someone that purchased their units sans debt has no reason to charge rent?
Re:31% Can’t Pay the Rent: ‘It’s Only Going to Get Worse’ by pmorici on Sunday April 12, 2020 @11:48PM (#22853017)
Even without debt to service there is are still property taxes to pay and the opportunity cost compared to investing that capital in something else like 30- year treasury bonds that pay ~1%