Sample collection and accessioning (accessioning is unpacking test tubes one by one and aliquoting them into plates in the lab) is definitely going to require a lot of manpower. I'm hopeful that patients "self swabbing" can help alleviate some of the manpower needs. (Self-swabs are not allowed currently under FDA guidance).
Is self-swabbing allowed there because it's for research purpose, not clinical purpose? The program does tell users whether they test positive though.
The FDA has recently made clear that no at-home self-collection tests are allowed (for now): https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/emergency-situations-med...
The Seattle Flu Study wasn't allowed to communicate back to patients but "By Feb. 25, Dr. Chu and her colleagues could not bear to wait any longer. They began performing coronavirus tests, without government approval. What came back confirmed their worst fear. They quickly had a positive test from a local teenager with no recent travel history." https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/10/us/coronavirus-testing-de...
I'm glad to hear they're allowed to do the SCAN study!
I think rightfully so. I was on a government video conference where a doctor showed the current CDC testing procedure, which involves stick a swab in the nose all the way to the back of the throat. They explained that the further the sample is taken from the lungs the less accurate it is.
If it turns out that it's already spread to most everybody lock downs are just a way to create more homelessness. If it turns out that the only people with the antibodies are the ones in the hospitals we need martial law.
We can disagree on whether a lockdown causes the least amount of societal distress compared to some of the other options, we can argue on when we would personally chose to enact lockdown. We could even try and work out what it would take to prevent people losing their homes and dying. $2000/month UBI seems like it might help.
But seriously, doing anything at all is wrong? And the only right response is to do nothing? No ordering more PPE, no preparing for a surge, no rebalancing shifts so the contagion doesn't take out the police force/navy/healthcare workers/etc?
Saying that any possible response is wrong seems like pretending the problem will go away if we pretend it doesn't exist. Which is really hard to do while people are dying.
What they had at the time were models (which predicted asymptomatic cases) and information on how it looks like in countries that did not done measures soon enough. Even as China lied and made their numbers smaller then the were, enough was known publically and even more by secret services.
Turning this around, if we multiply confirmed deaths by 264, that gives us an estimate of how many cases there are. So, for example, with UK's death count of 6159 this means about 2.4% of the population is infected. Furthermore, on the Diamond Princess only 20% of the people onboard caught the virus under poorly quarantined conditions. So, to extrapolate even further, this would imply that over 12% of the UK population has already been exposed to SARS-CoV-2. This means that the UK should peak at about 50k deaths, without any protective measures.
In 2018, the UK had 50k deaths due to flu in excess of normal flu deaths.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/11/30/winter-deaths-hi...
Furthermore you are focusing on a tiny portion of available data instead of all that is available.
Given that New York State has 4,000+ deaths your "model" would indicate that 1MM residents have COVID-19? So if it rips through the remaining 19MM residents in the course of a few weeks the result will only be 80k deaths? And of course the healthcare system won't break down?
Also you said that the Diamond Princess only had a 20% infection rate but the Greg Mortimer is reporting a 60% infection rate. Seems like you've got a lot of facts wrong on the first pass, IDK.
According to my model NYC should only have a max of 13.5k deaths, without any mitigation.
Based on the Greg Mortimer stat, this bumps up to 41k for NYC.
Even the idea of 41k at this point beggars belief, they are already well over capacity with some mitigation and the bodies are literally piling up.
I find it hard to wrap my head around the logic here.
South Korea has tested a tiny fraction of their total population, because the testing is largely targeted via contact tracing.
Not 50,000.
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
So my calculation shows cov2 is about twice as bad as a strong flu, with no preventative measures. If we hit the 20k or less with preventative measures that the Imperial model predicts, this will be on par with regular flu season.
At any rate, much less than the 200k+ deaths originally predicted by the Imperial model and that pushed the UK to lockdown.
I was part of a volunteer team that tested 3400 people on Friday/Saturday in Santa Clara country for COVID-19 antibodies [1]. It took a team of 100+ volunteers 10 hours / day just to collect samples.
Stanford, for example, has plenty of automated testing capacity, and even reagents. IMHO, the limiting factors are not that we need new tests, but rather we need (1) lighter regulations (2) funding to buy supplies and (3) massive manpower to scale-up drive through testing
[1] https://www.stanforddaily.com/2020/04/04/stanford-researcher...