News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Experience Economy by presidentender on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:18PM (#2280532)
Technological progress has always been inherently deflationary.

Remember, the vast majority of the world's people used to work directly in food production as a matter of necessity. Technology has allowed most of us to get off the farm, and pursue other activities.

Whereas a day's work once bought a day's food and not much more, a human worker (using the machines that serve him) is now able to produce a huge surplus of wealth. This means that there's time for leisure, and that our leisure can be much more enjoyable than our grandparents'.

The tragedy of this seems to be that we're running out of stuff for people to do. A dystopian version of the future this could lead to is recounted in 'Manna,' by Marshall Brain: http://www.marshallbrain.com/manna1.htm

For my part, I'm hopeful. I believe that our current plight is the same sort of growing pains we've experienced in the past. The invention of the automobile made it tough to find work shoeing horses, for instance, or manufacturing buggy whips. Just because we don't need to spend our time making stuff any more doesn't mean we won't be able to find other ways to occupy our time.

Re:The Experience Economy by calvinfroedge on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:27PM (#2280567)
I think people will HAVE to work, for some very hard years, on achieving sustainability. Only then will we truly be on autopilot, and will humanity be able to focus its time on other things. Until then, all we're doing is tricking ourselves into thinking life will keep getting easier. Major conflict over resources is coming...
Re:The Experience Economy by danenania on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:53PM (#2280667)
While it's true that we have a lot of work to do, conflict is unpleasant and expensive and people on the whole have a strong interest in avoiding it. Unfortunately, war mongers tend to spend other people's money, so they don't bear the costs; we need to stop supplying them and/or make them pay. If we can manage this, I think our adaptability and ability to cooperate can win out.
Re:The Experience Economy by dublinclontarf on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:57PM (#2281000)
>The tragedy of this seems to be that we're running out of stuff for people to do.

I'm sorry but this is just wrong. There is no end to human want and desire. As long as there is this want there will be plenty of stuff for people to do.

Re:The Experience Economy by moultano on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:49PM (#2281242)
If the people who have wants aren't the same people who have money, it doesn't matter whether their wants are endless or not.
Re:The Experience Economy by nowarninglabel on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:39PM (#2281463)
I'd side note that estimates are still 1 billion people work in agriculture (ref: grain.org/world bank) and many more are in the transportation, processing, and selling of said agricultural products. The vast majority of these people still only earn enough or little more than enough for a day's food (not a huge surplus of wealth). Furthermore, lack of capital (lack of machines as you will) is still prevalent in many industrialized countries, even in the U.S. Disclaimer: I work for Kiva now, so my perspective is skewed to focus on this group of the world.
Re:The Experience Economy by VladRussian on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:20PM (#2281375)
>The tragedy of this seems to be that we're running out of stuff for people to do.

There is a lot to do for humans. Just look at the problems in any area of science. Not all people are qualified to work there though. This is why instead of whining about disappearing of menial labor jobs, we should be working toward [what would be at least a start] making K16 a basic level of education instead of K12. A thousand year ago reading and writing would made one a basically educated person (for the rest of his/her 30 year long life). In 19th century K8 was enough (and the average lifespan ~45), in 20th for the most of the part - K12 (and the average lifespan is ~70 at the end of the century). The body of knowledge is growing, we live longer, so it is natural to learn more and apply the more advanced knowledge and skills for longer period of the active adult productive life.

Re:The Experience Economy by nostrademons on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:25PM (#2282277)
I'd fix K-12 before we make K-16 the default. You could easily learn fit the amount of material in a K-16 education into 12 years if those 12 years weren't just a matter of putting in time without any real focus on learning the material. Let's improve quality of education before increasing quantity.
Re:The Experience Economy by VladRussian on Thursday March 03, 2011 @02:46PM (#2285461)
>You could easily learn fit the amount of material in a K-16 education into 12 years

>Let's improve quality of education before increasing quantity.

nice sound bites. Complete rubbish. The whole amount of K-12 material is comparable in size with amount of material consumed in just one, max 2, years of college. But it doesn't work in the opposite way. I graduated from a top math and physics high school where students were selected from half of the country. The amount of additional material what we were able to consume during the high school pales in comparison with amount of material we consumed later at the University. The brains is still not there at this age. Hormones already are :)

Re:The Experience Economy by rimantas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:43PM (#2281981)
Average lifespan was very scewed because of high children mortality. If you survivied first few years chabces were pretty good that you'd live longer than average life expectancy told.
Re:The Experience Economy by olalonde on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @09:48PM (#2282518)
> or manufacturing buggy whips

This reminded me of Other People's Money speech by Danny DeVito: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfL7STmWZ1c

Re:The Experience Economy by calvinfroedge on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @01:29PM (#2280577)
And thanks for the link, btw = )
Re:The Experience Economy by zohebv on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:02PM (#2281558)
While technological progress can be deflationary I have to strongly disagree that work is disappearing. I don't think we are ever going to run out of work.

In fact, more "primitive" societies had far lesser work to do - "studies show that hunter-gatherers need only work about twenty hours a week in order to survive and may devote the rest of their time to leisure", though there are criticisms about the measurement.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Original_affluent_society

Compare this to our modern technology driven society. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_time#United_States

Also - "The Kapauku people of Papua think it is bad luck to work two consecutive days. The !Kung Bushmen work just two-and-a-half days per week, rarely more than six hours per day.[30] The work week in Samoa is approximately 30 hours,[31] and though average annual Samoan cash income is relatively low, by some measures, the Samoan standard of living is quite good."

Re:The Experience Economy by billswift on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:32PM (#2281677)
If you want to talk about "survival", you can easily survive comfortably, much more comfortably than hunter-gatherers, today on even less work. Buying lots of junk and traveling are not needed for comfortable survival, if you want them, buy them, but don't confuse them with even comfortable survival.
Re:The Experience Economy by zohebv on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @07:14PM (#2282081)
No, we are not talking about "survival". If an alien were to observe that of the 3 tribes one spent 50 hrs working, the other 30 hrs and 20 hrs respectively, he will conclude that it is the tribes working 50 hrs that have a tough time surviving. The other tribes weren't hanging on for dear life, otherwise they would have worked much harder. They have plenty to eat and hence plenty of leisure time.

Also, I dispute that buying lots of junk is unnecessary for a decent life in industrialized societies. We are socially competitive animals and if someone were to just focus on "survival", he would end up being a social outcast pretty soon and his mating prospects would have shrunk considerably. Being lazy and having low-income is a pejorative description in industrialized tribes. But Western society has such huge income gaps that no matter where you are in the income spectrum, it looks like there are thousands of people above you living the good life, right up until Bill Gates.

In contrast, in a hunter-gatherer society, the most accomplished guy might be the chief and the competitive pressure on each tribal is much lower. Hence, the possibility of a 20 hour work week.

TLDR, I dispute that technological advances will reduce work. As long as there are huge income gaps, we will have people relentlessly working long hours every day to obtain a better position in society. It is an instinct built into our genes.

Re:The Experience Economy by nostrademons on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @08:21PM (#2282268)
Grandparent's point is that you haven't held everything constant.

Hunter-gatherer types don't have a home. If you are willing to go homeless, you can live for $15-20/day in most cities. That's less than 20-30 hours of work/week in most places.

Hunter-gatherer bands also have a total mating pool measured in the half dozens. If you restrict yourself to fellow homeless people, you're likely to meet a similar number of women, all of whom have roughly the same social standing. The problem is not that there are no mates available, it's that there are no mates that you want available.

Your point that people tend to measure themselves relative to people around them is true but orthogonal. If you hold living standards constant, you can achieve them with a lot less work today than you could at hunter-gatherer tech levels. It's only because living standards are not constant that people have a tough time earning a living.

Re:The Experience Economy by olalonde on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @10:07PM (#2282592)
Actually, in Quebec (not sure about other provinces and the US), you can live comfortably (if we compare with hunter-gatherers) without working at all through welfare.
Re:The Experience Economy by zach on Thursday March 03, 2011 @01:36AM (#2283110)
And then you can spend far more than twenty hours a week hunting and gathering in online games. Plus ça change...
Re:The Experience Economy by mitcheme on Thursday March 03, 2011 @03:06AM (#2283265)
It would be so much more useful to hold happiness or quality of life constant instead. I really don't think it's a meaningful improvement to have ten times as much material wealth if that goes along with a fifteenfold increase in the amount of material wealth you think you "need", especially if that goes along with increased workload, stress, responsibility, etc., and decreased leisure time, time with family, health, etc. To most westerners it seems obvious that a nice house and your pick of hundreds of mates will make you happier, but that's just because it's how we grew up. If we packed it up and tried to go hunter-gatherer tomorrow, we would fail miserably and be miserable doing it -- but that's what exactly happens when hunter-gatherer societies and agricultural societies suddenly go western. Either way it takes several generations to adjust, so the fact that you wouldn't feel comfortable living as a hunter-gatherer, now that you've already been raised in this culture, doesn't have anything at all to do with which lifestyle is better. Even your "objective" measurement made a value judgment that meshes with industrial, not hunter-gatherer, societies. Of course an industrial society will do better by industrial standards.

Being a hunter-gatherer born in a stable hunter-gatherer society is not at all the same as being a homeless person in the industrialized world. For the most part hunter-gatherers in a hunter-gatherer society aren't ostracized or looked down on by everyone they know, criminalized/shamed for living (finding "acceptable" opportunities to sleep, eat, piss, etc, are much more difficult for a homeless person), or surrounded by messages that a person's worth is measured by whether they own the right things. Being able to comfortably meet biological needs, having meaningful social connections, retaining dignity and self-respect -- these things mean a lot.'N!ai, the Story of a !Kung Woman' is an interesting documentary about a woman whose life took a dramatic turn for the worse after the introduction of western culture, even though she probably ended up being the richest person in her tribe.

AFAICT more technology has nearly always led to us taking up different kinds of work to fill up that time, not more leisure. When modern household appliances were introduced, the result was higher standards for housekeeping. Women in the 70's spent slightly more time doing housework than women in the 20's did despite all the new "conveniences". Were houses in the 20's disgustingly filthy? No. Did the increase in cleanliness make society as a whole happier or better off? I doubt it. If anything, I suspect the obsession with cleanliness has just contributed to increased rates in allergies, weaker immune systems, etc. Technically, access to these appliances are considered a standard of living increase, but all it really did was make us pickier about what an "acceptable" living is. Now people who can't afford those conveniences have to work harder to keep up or be shamed by others for having a "dirty" house.

People comparing themselves to others is very relevant, because those comparisons have a huge impact on happiness and quality of life, and it is generally assumed that a higher standard of living correlates with those things. (If you disagree, can you explain why having a higher standard of living is a good thing? Why is it rising? Why do we even care about it?) If that's a wrong assumption it needs to be challenged because from what I can tell it's basically a cornerstone of western civilization right now.

Re:The Experience Economy by nostrademons on Thursday March 03, 2011 @05:28AM (#2283501)
Happiness is constant. That's the whole point of all the research into the hedonic treadmill. Good or bad things in your life can make you feel happy for a short period of time, but eventually we return to our set point, which is largely determined by genetics.

Given that you're fucked over by your genes and can't actually make yourself happier, why not live your life based on maximizing your standard of living? At least that way, you can look back and say "Well, even if all those things I'm stressing out about happened, I lost my job and my family and had to go homeless, and no girls would talk to me, I'd still be better off than a hunter-gatherer."

It's not that achieving a higher standard of living makes you happier, it's that achieving a higher standard of living and believing that standard of living is the key to happiness lets you look back and see by an "objective" measure that you're doing better than you were before, and that makes you happy.

Re:The Experience Economy by mitcheme on Friday March 04, 2011 @01:41PM (#2289221)
As far as I'm aware, the hedonic treadmill is a culture-bound theory. Has anyone actually done serious research about it outside of the 'developed' world? Also, by my understanding, it doesn't state that long-term lifestyle changes won't make you happier, just that our happiness levels stabilize quickly after sudden changes.

Genetics may be one factor, but relative differences in wealth is another huge factor that I know has been observed extensively outside of dominant western culture. In HG societies, there are almost no differences in wealth. Everyone considers themselves pretty well-off because there are very few things (or experiences) in their world that they could want but not have.

And even by the objective standard, a HG is better off than someone in the industrial world who has no job, family, home, or love prospects. An average HG has meaningful work, a large and close family, a mate, and considers their entire territory to be their family's "home". It isn't a miserable or unfulfilling life at all. The only way you could come to the conclusion that you're still better off is if you held really stereotypical and inaccurate views of how HGs live. Which leads like things like groups of us deciding that we have a moral obligation to nose in on what few HG societies still exist and bestow the gifts of technology and capitalism on them, so that they can live in slums for the rest of their lives and the lives of most of their descendants. Which doesn't exactly make them happy, because they go from being the richest people in their society to the very bottom of the ladder in ours.

I'm not going to live my life maximizing my standard of living because money and wealth aren't the same thing. Call it fulfillment instead of happiness if it makes you feel better, but having the biggest pile of money isn't the way to get there.