News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Experience Economy by nostrademons on Thursday March 03, 2011 @05:28AM (#2283501)
Happiness is constant. That's the whole point of all the research into the hedonic treadmill. Good or bad things in your life can make you feel happy for a short period of time, but eventually we return to our set point, which is largely determined by genetics.

Given that you're fucked over by your genes and can't actually make yourself happier, why not live your life based on maximizing your standard of living? At least that way, you can look back and say "Well, even if all those things I'm stressing out about happened, I lost my job and my family and had to go homeless, and no girls would talk to me, I'd still be better off than a hunter-gatherer."

It's not that achieving a higher standard of living makes you happier, it's that achieving a higher standard of living and believing that standard of living is the key to happiness lets you look back and see by an "objective" measure that you're doing better than you were before, and that makes you happy.

Re:The Experience Economy by mitcheme on Friday March 04, 2011 @01:41PM (#2289221)
As far as I'm aware, the hedonic treadmill is a culture-bound theory. Has anyone actually done serious research about it outside of the 'developed' world? Also, by my understanding, it doesn't state that long-term lifestyle changes won't make you happier, just that our happiness levels stabilize quickly after sudden changes.

Genetics may be one factor, but relative differences in wealth is another huge factor that I know has been observed extensively outside of dominant western culture. In HG societies, there are almost no differences in wealth. Everyone considers themselves pretty well-off because there are very few things (or experiences) in their world that they could want but not have.

And even by the objective standard, a HG is better off than someone in the industrial world who has no job, family, home, or love prospects. An average HG has meaningful work, a large and close family, a mate, and considers their entire territory to be their family's "home". It isn't a miserable or unfulfilling life at all. The only way you could come to the conclusion that you're still better off is if you held really stereotypical and inaccurate views of how HGs live. Which leads like things like groups of us deciding that we have a moral obligation to nose in on what few HG societies still exist and bestow the gifts of technology and capitalism on them, so that they can live in slums for the rest of their lives and the lives of most of their descendants. Which doesn't exactly make them happy, because they go from being the richest people in their society to the very bottom of the ladder in ours.

I'm not going to live my life maximizing my standard of living because money and wealth aren't the same thing. Call it fulfillment instead of happiness if it makes you feel better, but having the biggest pile of money isn't the way to get there.