Re:Principle of Least Astonishment
by xeeeeeeeeeeenu on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:22PM
(#22798466)
Perl 5.32 will support this syntax: https://perldoc.pl/5.31.10/perldelta#Chained-comparisons-cap...
Works beautifully in Common Lisp. Of course, it is not mainstream.
? (< 0 1 2)
T
? (< 0 -1 2)
NIL
In Clojure:
user=> (< 0 1 2)
true
And user=> (< 0 -1 2)
falseIt's a big ask, to have a binary operator and ternary operator that use the same symbol.
It's honestly some fairly trivial AST-twiddling to support that feature. the compiler can simply detect cases where the left-hand-side of a comparison is /also/ a comparison and change the AST to make it two comparisons combined with an AND statement.
That said I find comparison chaining rather confusing and unexpected so I make a point of avoiding its use. Typing it out as two comparisons hardly saves any effort in any case.
To be fair, is there any mainstream language other than Python where that expression makes sense at all?
And even Python had to make explicit, syntactical support for it, and IMO it's a pretty non-obvious language hack. I mean, there's an invisible AND in there, that's pretty astonishing to me at least :-)