0 < -1 < 2
To be fair, is there any mainstream language other than Python where that expression makes sense at all?
And even Python had to make explicit, syntactical support for it, and IMO it's a pretty non-obvious language hack. I mean, there's an invisible AND in there, that's pretty astonishing to me at least :-)
Re:Principle of Least Astonishment
by xeeeeeeeeeeenu on Monday April 06, 2020 @06:22PM
(#22798466)
Perl 5.32 will support this syntax: https://perldoc.pl/5.31.10/perldelta#Chained-comparisons-cap...
Works beautifully in Common Lisp. Of course, it is not mainstream.
? (< 0 1 2)
T
? (< 0 -1 2)
NIL
In Clojure:
user=> (< 0 1 2)
true
And user=> (< 0 -1 2)
falseIt's a big ask, to have a binary operator and ternary operator that use the same symbol.
It's honestly some fairly trivial AST-twiddling to support that feature. the compiler can simply detect cases where the left-hand-side of a comparison is /also/ a comparison and change the AST to make it two comparisons combined with an AND statement.
That said I find comparison chaining rather confusing and unexpected so I make a point of avoiding its use. Typing it out as two comparisons hardly saves any effort in any case.
I know, but it isn't a very useful feature, so why bother?
Re:Principle of Least Astonishment
by geerlingguy on Monday April 06, 2020 @03:19PM
(#22796884)
Reminds me of https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/talks/wat
Javascript is convenient for many use cases, but it definitely violates POLA on many levels, in many situations!
And it does in C as well!
So does this mean that JS does satisfy the principle of least astonishment for an experienced c-coder (something important when it was developed in the early 2000s)?
In what language (other than a RPN based language like Lisp) would this expect to return something meaningful?
The coercion rules were a big surprise to me when I first started to work in JS. Sometimes codes were obvious but the underlying interpretation is a surprise call.