News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by ggm on Thursday April 02, 2020 @10:22PM (#22765837)
Wise words a former cell biology aware PhD said to me once: a cell is at a scale where van der Waals forces means 'water' isn't behaving like you think and the 'liquid' of a cell is possibly more like a matrix than a fluid. Those high school cell models are very misleading. He basically said macro scale intuition was useless for what it means to pierce the cell wall, as an example. What does "pierce" even mean?
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by ramraj07 on Friday April 03, 2020 @01:34AM (#22766555)
Want to point out that this still slightly depends on what cell you are talking about - a mammalian cell is a thousand times larger than a bacterial cell, which in turn is a hundred or thousand times larger than a virus. An apt comparison is if you were a cell in your body, a bacteria is at best the size of a pea and a virus the size of an ant. Viruses are so small that you can sometimes just crystallize them to study their structure with crystallography as if the entire thing is a single molecule.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by titzer on Thursday April 02, 2020 @10:34PM (#22765891)
Agree! I found (https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/watch-the-...) to be pretty mind-blowing.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by Balgair on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:48AM (#22766364)
Some other good ones:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Hk9jct2ozY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_zD3NxSsD8

The GP is right in that our intuitions aren't cutting it down at the bottom.

All these animations tend to edit out the water molecules so that the audience can understand better. The proteins aren't colored blobs at all. At these scales you'd clearly see individual atoms instead of blobs. But watching a bunch of really detailed atomic ball-stick models would be confusing. And not only are the H2Os battering everything like TIE fighters in the Hoth asteroid field [0], there are ions in there too (Na, K, Cl, etc) that really effect the cell. The membranes are also edited, as many cells are porcupined with receptors like an over crowded wave pool [1]. In addition to the water/saline being edited out, most of the other proteins, vesicles, and interior membranes are also gone for the sake of clarity. There is nearly no free 'space' in the cell, think of a really crammed subway car [2], with the air being like the water/saline. But only much much tighter.

The cell is more like a frantically efficient liquidy crystaly thingy than a wonky wobbly blobby poofed-up juice box. And each one is utterly deeply profoundly fascinating.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_DnrceDEI8

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zg-GHmvtIeI

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xG-meaGqg-M

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by twic on Friday April 03, 2020 @05:45AM (#22767637)
I think David Goodsell's beautiful paintings, in his book Machinery of Life, were the first serious attempt to depict how crammed a cell is (page down past the pictures of individual molecules to get the the cell cross-sections):

https://ccsb.scripps.edu/goodsell/machinery-of-life-reducedi...

Here's an interview with him, explaining and showing his process:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0rPXTJzpLE

Here's his recent painting of a coronavirus protease:

https://pdb101.rcsb.org/motm/242

The other thing missing from those videos is any indication of how random these processes are. At one point, an actin filament assembles by having monomers fly directly at the tip and stack neatly together. It's not like that. In reality, there are all sorts of molecules just randomly moshing around, and occasionally, an actin monomer will bump into the tip of the filament and stick, because it has a binding site. But sometimes one will bump into the tip and not stick! Sometimes, the tip of the filament will fall off! The growth is purely statistical: monomers are more likely to stick than to fall off, and more likely to stick than some random unrelated protein is to stick.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by johnohara on Thursday April 02, 2020 @11:53PM (#22766187)
Pity I only get 1 upvote. I'd triple-click if I could.

This animation enables one to visualize a single SARS-CoV-2 virion binding with the ACE2 enzyme, entering the host cell, and replicating 4-5 new virions.

One SARS-CoV-2 virion is 125 nanometers wide. By the time it shows up on a CT scan we are talking many, many billions.

It's seems impossible anyone could test positive and still be asymptomatic.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by usrusr on Friday April 03, 2020 @03:47AM (#22767068)
> It's seems impossible anyone could test positive and still be asymptomatic.

Why? Most symptoms are part of the body's response switching into overdrive and not a direct consequence of cells getting subverted into virion farms. If the immune system wins without resorting to state of emergency measures like a fever you won't notice, but in the meantime there is a phase of viral replication in the throat.

With SARS-Cov-2 there is even the pattern that detection drops already in the throat of patients that still have a pneumonia raging in their lung (probably because the throat, as a battlefield in this war, somehow favors the immune system more than the lung?), so it's not even a subset/superset relation between symptoms and positive throat PCR, it's a partial overlap.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by johnohara on Friday April 03, 2020 @11:54AM (#22770511)
Seems impossible but from observation obviously is not.

Comorbidity is the issue with SARS-CoV-2. It is interesting that some patients testing positive report losing the sense of taste and/or smell while others report digestive problems prior to the onset of acute respiratory problems or even sore throat.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by waterhouse on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:43AM (#22766352)
I note that the virus depicted in the animation is HIV. How much of the lifecycle is different from HIV to SARS-CoV-2? One thing I noted is that it said the inserted viral DNA might remain dormant for years; surely that part is HIV-specific? (Or do we really bear viral infections for years after recovery, and—I presume—rely on the continued presence of antibodies to quash the remaining DNA?)
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by mardifoufs on Friday April 03, 2020 @04:19AM (#22767209)
That part is mostly specific to retroviruses and DNA viruses. Retroviruses are special because even though they are RNA based they can "translate" their RNA into dna once inside the cell and embed that DNA into the cell's genome. That translation in itself is remarkable since it's the opposite of the normal DNA to RNA "translation" we see in almost every organism, hence the "retro".

DNA based viruses don't have that unique mechanism but the result is conceptually the same: you get a virus that is extremely hard to completely cure/remove due to it being present in some of your own DNA. Herpes is a DNA based virus and that's why you can't ever be fully cured from it.

That's also why retroviruses like HIV can only be suppressed. It's also why antiretroviral drugs try to inhibit the replication phases of the virus, which makes managing the disease possible but can't remove the virus itself. Still, a cocktail of those inhibitors is an amazingly powerful treatment against AIDS and leads to HIV becoming basically dorment in the body.

A ribovirus (which is what coronaviruses are) is RNA based but it doesn't embed itself into our genome. It never translates it's RNA and since RNA is fundamentally less stable of a molecule than DNA, you get really high mutation rates. That "instability" is caused by the lack of a built in error checking mechanism in RNA. Those random mutations are part of why Influenza is hard to build immunity against. But it's also why RNA based viruses are generally either too virulent and mortal to allow for effective spread, or rapidly evolve towards less lethal forms.

Keep in mind that I've generalized a lot and that there are a lot of exceptions and outliers when it comes to viruses. For example, Hepatitis C is a ribovirus but it has a special protection mechanism that protects it's core genetic material from mutations even if it's RNA based.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by nullc on Friday April 03, 2020 @04:43AM (#22767341)
> It never translates it's RNA and since RNA is fundamentally less stable of a molecule than DNA, you get really high mutation rates. That "instability" is caused by the lack of a built in error checking mechanism in RNA.

The coronovirues have a proofreader mechanism, which is interesting.

And influenza has more potent evolved countercountermeasures than just high mutation rates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antigenic_shift

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by mardifoufs on Friday April 03, 2020 @05:30AM (#22767566)
Yep! That's what really makes influenza special, as I said the mutation rates are only part of why Influenza viruses rapidly change. Their ability to cross between species by combining easily with other types of influenza viruses are the key to their incredible variability

One of the distinguishing trait of CoVs are their special RNA replication/transcription mechanisms that results in less errors, which is really important considering the large size of their genomes compared to other RNA based viruses. Though, and correct me if I'm wrong, aren't they still extremely less stable than DNA viruses? Which is why only short/medium term immunity is usually possible? I don't know a lot about the synthesis of coronavirus RNA but it looks super interesting

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by nullc on Friday April 03, 2020 @09:00AM (#22768733)
> Though, and correct me if I'm wrong, aren't they still extremely less stable than DNA viruses?

That's correct. Worse, the proofreader doesn't have to protect all parts equally...

> Which is why only short/medium term immunity is usually possible?

No. For some viruses active immunity just doesn't last particularly long for reasons we don't understand (or at least it was described as not understood in every paper I've seen on the subject). For some viruses you can be reinfected months later with exactly the same virus. This is the case for several cold causing viruses.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by randlet on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:00AM (#22766213)
Amazing. The mind boggles at how complex this is and the fact that humans have the tools to discover and understand the process. Thank you very much for sharing!
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by airstrike on Thursday April 02, 2020 @10:47PM (#22765944)
Thanks for sharing this link. Saw this video once and was COMPLETELY blown away but didn't know where it was from.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by iosjunkie on Thursday April 02, 2020 @11:11PM (#22766024)
Thanks for sharing. The lifecycle was much more sophisticated than I assumed.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by usrusr on Friday April 03, 2020 @03:20AM (#22766954)
Un-narrated version, for those who were taken by the music: https://vimeo.com/260291601
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by pedroguitarm4n on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:01AM (#22766224)
That was brilliant -- be sure to watch it with the sound on. the ominous music makes the experience even better
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by JshWright on Thursday April 02, 2020 @10:33PM (#22765884)
I'd highly recommend the YouTube channel "Journey to the Microcosmos" for videos that do a great job of improving that intuition.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by chadcmulligan on Friday April 03, 2020 @01:27AM (#22766528)
I picked up a microscope last year - they were on sale, and one of those things I'd always wanted to have a play with. I remember having a look with them in school and never seeing much and it seemed very hard.

All you have to do is go to a pond or creek scoop out some weeds, dirt and water and stick it in a jar and there is hours of exploration in front of you. Once you start looking its like seeing an evolutionary world in front of you, everythings eating each other and trying to not be eaten. If you're thinking of getting a telescope (I had one), think of a microscope they open up a new world, its incredibly easy to see things - I thought it would be a lot more work.

Probably there's so many on line resources now to - this guy is a great start - microbe hunter https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDpKY8-oz5PWlBPNzNsbLug

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by nikofeyn on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:04PM (#22770644)
one of my greatest confusions of "life" is why there is this need to consume or feed off of or battle against other life. what is the purpose of this drive? why is it like this? i suspect the answer lies in thermodybamics and/or information theory, but it would be amazing to understand the reason behind life's battles for survival.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by jvanderbot on Friday April 03, 2020 @11:13PM (#22775942)
My friend built a house. I wanted a house. It was easier to take the lumber from his house than cut down trees and mine iron for nails. Eating another is no different. Different life evolves to take a niche item (like grass or minerals) and turn it into something useful to them (muscle and fat) that is also useful to others.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by nikofeyn on Saturday April 04, 2020 @04:24AM (#22776968)
i don't think that analogy holds up because it seems to ignore that there are other methods of obtaining energy.

and your last statement isn't getting to why. it's just what happens.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by jvanderbot on Sunday April 05, 2020 @01:04AM (#22783841)
Are there really that many other ways? Photosynthesis, sure, but that doesn't seem to produce much and doesnt allow much "liveliness".

Anyway... The 'why' is trivial-seeming to me. Once one organism can consume ready-made nutrients from another organism for less energy cost than producing, it will, or it will be out competed by others who do. So carnivores exist everywhere. Even deer happily eat baby birds that they come across, and rabbits eat their own.

Almost Tragedy of the Commons?

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by grawprog on Saturday April 04, 2020 @01:40PM (#22779933)
Because the amount of energy that is available increases the further down the food chain you go. Photosynthesis provides a small amount of energy, hence why plants and plantlike organisms tend to be either totally stationary or don't move much on their own.

Organisms that consume plants are capable of more complex behaviour and growth because the amount of energy and nutrients etc. is greater that they receive by conauming things that photosynthesize.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by leetcrew on Saturday April 04, 2020 @10:01AM (#22778253)
the analogy seems fine to me, if a bit anthropocentric.

every living organism has some way of perpetuating itself, either by growing indefinitely or by making copies of itself. there's no reason "why", other than that organisms that can't do this get filtered out very early in the game. this implies having some sort of "strategy" for traveling up the energy gradient.

short of somehow evolving the biological capability to fuse/split atoms, all the usable energy on earth comes from the sun. so the first link in the chain has to be something like photosynthesis, where you collect and store energy directly from the sun (ie, "building a house"). but in doing this, you change the gradient, creating an opportunity for other organisms take your stored energy for themselves. in some sense, it's much "easier" for a rabbit to eat a plant in one minute than it was for the plant to collect all that energy over its entire life. there's only so much solar radiation per square meter, which limits a plants energy budget. a rabbit can eat many plants in a day, effectively multiplying the area of the solar radiation it can capture (and spend on acquiring even more). but then the rabbit creates an opportunity for a predator to harvest its stored energy and the cycle continues...

it seems like you're maybe asking "why can't all life just cooperate"? this would probably look like a planet full of plants (or a similar lifeform at a different scale). the problem is that this leaves a huge opening for the first "defector"; it's an unstable equilibrium. life does not evolve to leave opportunities on the table.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by martythemaniak on Friday April 03, 2020 @02:38PM (#22772652)
Look into "dissipative structures", which are indeed closely linked to thermodynamics.

In short, energy gradients (ie, on hydrothermal vents) can cause matter to organize itself into structures that more efficiently dissipate this energy. You can see how the creation of this structure would in turn enable the creation of a new kind of structure that lives on top of that.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissipative_system

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqPGOhXoprU

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by effie on Friday April 03, 2020 @05:53PM (#22774303)
There are competing processes in nature even without life (in the usual sense of the word) - atomic nucleus fission/fusion, light absorption/emission, crystal nucleation vs. decay, molecule synthesis vs molecule decay - each process operating towards getting more ground. Life fighting (or helping) other life can be looked upon as a more complex variant of the same process dynamics: one set of atoms and processes interacting with other set of atoms and processes, sometimes this looks like cooperation, sometimes like a battle.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by cowboysauce on Friday April 03, 2020 @01:33PM (#22771918)
Actually game theory is probably the better place to look. Though the concept of natural selection already tends to cover the big picture. Organisms need resources to reproduce. Those that can obtain more resources (or use what they have more efficiently) reproduce more and eventually drown out those who cannot reproduce as much. Taking from another organism (whether by hunting, parasitism, etc) is just one way of obtaining more resources.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by chadcmulligan on Friday April 03, 2020 @07:57PM (#22775056)
Thats probably the thing I learnt looking through the microscope, or was perhaps made obvious. Life at that level is just chemical gradients and finding bio mass to procreate, so things that don't do this don't procreate and die, the winners are the ones that are the best at this. The asking why is a human thing and is so many layers on this elementary life we can afford to ask these questions, but I don't think life can exist without competition, at least not organic life that has evolved. Maybe we'll make a more pure sort of life that doesn't need competition to grow but not sure about that.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by nojvek on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:09AM (#22766257)
https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCBbnbBWJtwsf0jLGUwX5Q3g

^ here is the link. Pretty great animation. Thanks for the recommendation.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by computerphage on Saturday April 04, 2020 @09:11PM (#22782921)
To be clear, it's not an animation, it's video captured from a microscope.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by dekhn on Friday April 03, 2020 @03:31PM (#22773153)
The classic intro to this is "Life at Low Reynolds Number", https://science.curie.fr/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Purcell_...

Another interesting thing: cells are packed so tightly (not just a bag of water) that proteins grind against each other and against their ligands, increasing the "activity" (even the free energy of ATP hydrolysis isn't the standard 7.3kcal/mol.

Yes, macro-scale intuition isn't great (although people pierce cell walls with tiny needles all the time), but if you spend enough time looking at cells under a microscope, you start to build an intuition about cell and molecule behavior.

Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by Terr_ on Thursday April 02, 2020 @11:50PM (#22766176)
Also, on that scale individual molecules are bouncing around inside the cell faster than you can run or bike. It is a metaphorical froth of seething sliding movement.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by codekilla on Friday April 03, 2020 @12:00AM (#22766214)
I think this was first written about at length in the book ‘Soft Machines’, which is a really good critique of some of the nanotechnology thinking at the time. I highly recommend the book.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by garmaine on Friday April 03, 2020 @05:42AM (#22767622)
Actually it was a terrible critique of nanotechnology, which doesn’t try to make things the same way as biology. But a good overview of the funkiness which comes part and parcel with life’s microbiology.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by codekilla on Friday April 03, 2020 @11:02AM (#22769870)
Not sure which field of bionanotechnology (I assume you meant bionanotechnology ) you work in, but for the one I work in, the metaphor of biology and computer science is extremely intertwined—like very explicitly. Circuits, computation, the whole nine yards. If you’re talking about graphene or something that is an entirely different field. I can’t see how this book was a terrible critique of bionanotechnology—or at least an excellent discussion of the hardships faced.
Re:What's a virus, anyway? The bare-bones basics by garmaine on Friday April 03, 2020 @03:18PM (#22773044)
I did not mean bionanotechnology, and neither did Smalley. He offered that as a critique against Drexlar’s diamondoid molecular manufacturing, in a successful political coup to claim the billions in research dollars that were promised as part of the National Nanotechnology Initiative.

Because of Richard Smalley that money went towards material science and chemical research instead of the molecular manufacturing it was promised for. Even though, as you point out, in terms of fact the critique only applied to life-like bionanotechnology.

The history of this is laid out pretty well—with a surprisingly minimal amount of sour grapes—in Drexler‘s book Radical Abundance.